- 1 - ! " # $$ %$& ' !" # $%&%'( ) ! (* # $%&%'% ) !% # $%+%'% Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $%&%'( ! # $%&%'( ( * # $%&%'( % " # $%&%'( )% ,$- + (" # )+ . $%%' - %/ + - ''- . )+'))'( . &")') . '*'")') . 0 .- - 3 - %))'' - -. # - - . 1 . # 1 . 23 456789:3; <349:; 56635= >? 723 @:<@443<<A@= 6=58:78AA< B29 5C3 5<<58=8:D 723 49:4@CC3:7 E@;DF3:7< C3:;3C3; >? >972 723 9@C7< >3=9B ;573; )+'))'( 65<<3; >? ;;= 3:89C 8G8= .@;D3 @=>5CD5 8: 9&")') 5:; ;573; '*'")') 65<<3; >? C8:4865= 8G8=.@;D3 5:; .- 9@C7 @=>5CD58: 9%))'' B2925G3;34=8:3;79DC5:7;8<4C3789:5C?C3=83A9A<6348A84 63CA9CF5:435:;25G39C;3C3;C3A@:;9A35C:3<7F9:3?9A <)")'''$B872A@7@C38:73C3<757723C5739A+H65 ) -9C 723 <5I3 9A 49:G3:83:43 723 65C783< 5C3 C3A3CC3;795<63C7238CC5:I>3A9C3723C85=9@C7 - 4 - ! -547<=35;8:D7972345<35C35<@:;3C <@87 8: 9%))'' B5< 8:<787@73; >? 723 6=58:78AA< <33I8:D <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 9A 5 C3D8<73C3; 5DC33F3:79A<5=3;573;*')''+236=58:78AA<5==3D3; 7257 723 2@<>5:; 9A ;3A3:;5:7 9) :5F3=? 3G5:5<8;;5665 25; 3J34@73; 723 5DC33F3:7 A9C =3D5= :343<<87?5:;25;C3438G3;5:5;G5:43<5=349:<8;3C5789: 9A <)")'''$ 449C;8:D 79 723 6=58:78AA< ;3<6873 C363573; C3K@3<7< >? 723 =3D5= 238C< 9A 723 9C8D8:5= 5DC33F3:7 29=;3C @:;5665 723 =3D5= 238C< 9A 3G5:5<8;;5665 A58=3; 79 3J34@73 723 <5=3 ;33; 49F63==8:D723F79A8=37236C3<3:7<@87 ( 23 ;3A3:;5:7< 49:73<73; 723 <@87 >? <3C89@<=? ;8<6@78:D 723 5==3D3; 5DC33F3:7 9A <5=3 3A3:;5:7 9 A8=3;5:8:;8G8;@5=BC8773:<7573F3:7/;3A3:;5:79<)79+ A8=3;5E98:7BC8773:<7573F3:7/5:;;3A3:;5:79"<8<73C 9A 3G5:5<8;;5665A8=3;5F3F95;9678:D723<7573F3:7 9A ;3A3:;5:7 9 23 49:<8<73:7 ;3A3:43 B5< 7257 723 - 5 - <@87 6C963C7? 8< E98:7 A5F8=? 5:43<7C5= 6C963C7? 23 ;3A3:;5:7<;3:83;7233J34@789:9A7235DC33F3:75:;723 C343867 9A <)")'''$ 23? A@C723C 49:73:;3; 7257 :9 =3D5= 9C A5F8=? :343<<87? 3J8<73; 5:; 723C3A9C3 3G5:5<8;;5665 25; :38723C 5@729C87? :9C 49F63==8:D C35<9: 79 5=83:573 723 5:43<7C5= 6C963C7? 8< =94@< 79 3J34@73 723 5==3D3; 5DC33F3:7 9A <5=3 B5< <6348A845==? K@3<789:3; % 23C85=9@C75A73CAC5F8:D8<<@3<63CF8773; >972<8;3<795;;@439C5=5:;;94@F3:75C?3G8;3:43: 566C3485789: 9A 723 F573C85= 9: C349C; 723 C85= 9@C7 5:<B3C3; <<@3 9< 5:; ) 8: 723 5AA8CF578G3 29=;8:D 7257 723 6=58:78AA< 25; 6C9G3; 723 3J34@789: 9A 723 5DC33F3:7 ;573; *')''+ 5< B3== 5< 7238C C35;8:3<< 5:; B8==8:D:3<< 9B3G3C B28=3 49:<8;3C8:D 723 ;8<4C3789:5C?C3=83A9A<6348A8463CA9CF5:437239@C723=; 7257723<@876C963C7?>38:DE98:7A5F8=?5:43<7C5=6C963C7? 7236=58:78AA<B3C3:973:787=3;79<@423K@875>=3C3=83A23 <@87B5<723C3A9C365C7=?;34C33;>?;8C3478:DC3A@:;9A723 - 6 - 5;G5:4349:<8;3C5789:B28=37236C8:4865=C3=83A9A<6348A84 63CA9CF5:43B5<;34=8:3; + DDC83G3; >? 723 E@;DF3:7 5:; ;34C33 723 6=58:78AA<6C3A3CC3; 9&")')23663==5739@C7 9: C3$566C3485789: 9A 723 3G8;3:43 49:4@CC3; 7257 723 3J34@789: 9A 723 5DC33F3:7 5:; 723 6=58:78AA<L C35;8:3<< 5:; B8==8:D:3<< <799; 6C9G3; 9:3723=3<< 723 663==573 9@C76C9433;3;9:5;8AA3C3:76C3F8<35:;9><3CG3;7257 DC5:78:D 723 =5CD3C C3=83A 9A <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 57 728< <75D3 B9@=; <3C89@<=? 6C3E@;843 723 C8D27< 9A 723 ;3A3:;5:7< : 728< C35<9:8:D 723 56635= 45F3 79 >3 ;8<F8<<3; " 28< 9@C7 >? 9C;3C ;573; '%'))'% 5;F8773; 723 56635= 5:; A9CF@=573; 723 A9==9B8:D <@><75:785=K@3<789:9A=5B - 7 - ! " # $ # # %& ()*()+),-.,/0)/(012-3,/()104 & : 5 <@87 A9C <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 723 9@C7L< 8:K@8C?8<:5CC9B=?758=9C3;797B9A5437< 8B23723C723 6=58:78AA< 25G3 3<75>=8<23; ;@3 3J34@789: 9A 723 <@87 5DC33F3:75:; 88B23723C723?25G36C9G3;49:78:@9@< C35;8:3<< 5:; B8==8:D:3<< 79 63CA9CF 7238C 65C7 9A 723 49:7C547 5< C3K@8C3; @:;3C 34789: + 4 9A 723 6348A84 3=83A47*+!23@=78F573DC5:79C;3:85=9A723;34C33 C3<7<9:5E@;8489@<3J3C48<39A;8<4C3789:/29B3G3C<@42 ;8<4C3789: F@<7 >3 3J3C48<3; 9: =3D5==? C3=3G5:7 49:<8;3C5789:<23C85=9@C7;34=8:3;723C3=83A<9=3=?9: 723DC9@:;7257723<@876C963C7?8<E98:7A5F8=?5:43<7C5= - 8 - 6C963C7? 257 566C9542 8< 63CG3C<3 65=65>=? 3CC9:39@< 5:;49:7C5C?79723<377=3;69<8789:9A=5B * 363573;=?728<9@C725<23=;72578:5<@87A9C <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 723 49:73<7 8< 6C8F5C8=? 8:73C <3 723 5DC33F3:7$29=;3C 5:; 723 3J34@75:7/ 723 49F6378:D 4=58F< 9A :9:$5=83:578:D 4965C43:3C< 5C3 :97 5;E@;84573; B8728:<@42 6C9433;8:D<23 9@C7 F@<749:A8:3 87<3=A 79 723 6C99A 9A 723 5DC33F3:7 5:; 723 6=58:78AAL< C35;8:3<< 5:;B8==8:D:3<< 3A@<5=9A723=5CD3CC3=83A45:9:=?>38: 5449C;5:43B872723F5:;5739A 34789:)'9A723 6348A84 3=83A 47 5< 566=845>=3 83 @69: =3D5==? <@<758:5>=3 DC9@:;<<@425<49F65C578G325C;<286@:A58C5;G5:75D3 9C9723CC349D:8M3;3K@875>=349:<8;3C5789:<;@=?6=35;3; 5:; 6C9G3; ><3:7 729<3 A9@:;5789:< 5 F3C3 =5>3= 9A N5:43<7C5= 6C963C7?O 45::97 ;3A357 5: 9723CB8<3 G5=8; 4=58FA9C<6348A8463CA9CF5:43 ' 78<8:4@F>3:7@69:5;3A3:;5:7B29<33I<723 9@C7L< ;8<4C3789: @:;3C 34789: )' 79 <6348A845==? 6=35; 5:; =35; 3G8;3:43 9: 49F65C578G3 25C;<286 9C 9723C - 9 - 3K@875>=3>5C< 6348A8463CA9CF5:4345::97>3C3A@<3;>? C3<9C779 34789:)'8:7235><3:439A<@426=35;8:D<5:; 6C99A:7236C3<3:745<3723C38<:973G3:5B28<63C8: 723 BC8773: <7573F3:7< 5>9@7 49F65C578G3 25C;<286 @:A9C3<33:;37C8F3:79C;8<6C969C789:5736C3E@;84379723 ;3A3:;5:7< 23 C85= 9@C7 723C3A9C3 25; :9 9445<89: :9C 5:? =3D5= >5<8< 79 B38D2 25C;<286/ 8:;33; 87 ;8; :97 5;G3C77972573:K@8C?6C348<3=?>345@<3:9<@426=35B5< C58<3; 3A@<5= 9A <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 B8729@7 723 C3K@8<873 6=35;8:D< 5:; 3G8;3:785C? <@><7C57@F 8< =3D5==? 8F63CF8<<8>=3 23 C85= 9@C7 25< ;34=8:3; <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 <9=3=? >345@<3 723 6C963C7? 8< ;3<4C8>3; 5< 5:43<7C5= 257 C35<9:8:D 8< @:<@<758:5>=3 : 5 <@87 A9C <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 723 9@C7 5;E@;84573< 723 5DC33F3:7$29=;3CL<C8D27>?566=?8:D7236C8:486=3<@:;3C 34789: + 4 5:; >? 73<78:D 723 5DC33F3:7L< G5=8;87? 3:A9C435>8=87? 5:; 723 6=58:78AA<L 49:;@47 A 723 3K@8783< =35:8:A5G9@C9A7236=58:78AA<723;34C33F@<7A9==9B23 - 10 - F3C35:43<7C5=425C5473C9A7236C963C7?8<:97>?87<3=A5 ;3A3:<379<6348A8463CA9CF5:435<>37B33:7235DC33F3:7 29=;3C 5:; 723 3J34@75:7 23 C8D27< 9A :9:$5=83:578:D 4965C43:3C<8A5:?5C3:977C83;B8728:<@42<@87/723?F5? B9CI 9@7 7238C 8:;363:;3:7 C3F3;83< 8: 5 6C963C=? 8:<787@73;65C78789:9C;34=5C579C?54789:8F35:;5D58: 728< 9@C7 25< C3A@<3; 79 63CF87 :9:$5=83:578:D F3F>3C< 79 ;3A357 5 <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 4=58F 9: 723 >5C3 6=35 72577236C963C7?8<E98:7A5F8=?5:43<7C5=6C963C7?97257 3J73:7 723 C85= 9@C7L< 49:7C5C? G83B <@AA3C< AC9F 63CG3C<87?5:;B5CC5:7<8:73CA3C3:43 ) @C:8:D79723-8C<7663==5739@C7L<C35<9:8:D 728<9@C7A8:;<7257723663==5739@C7A3==8:793CC9C>? 3J5F8:8:D N25C;<286O B23: :9 8<<@3 9: 7257 698:7 B5< AC5F3;5:;:9A9@:;5789:5=6=35;8:D<3J8<73;7:9<75D3 ;8; 723 ;3A3:;5:7< 49:73:; 7257 DC5:7 9A <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43B9@=;8:A=8478CC365C5>=3=9<<@69:723F7257 49@=; :97>3 49F63:<573; 8: F9:3? 9C 72573:A9C43F3:7 B9@=; 963C573 B872 ;8<6C969C789:573 <3G3C87? : 723 - 11 - 5><3:43 9A 5 <6348A84 6=35 5:; 5: 8<<@3 9: 49F65C578G3 25C;<286 723 663==573 9@C7 49@=; :97 25G3 8:G9I3; 34789: )' 79 ;3:? 723 ;34C33 7< 566C9542 5F9@:7< 79 7C5G3==8:D >3?9:; 723 6=35;8:D< 5:; 8<<@3< 5:; 8< 723C3A9C3=3D5==?8:A8CF ! :5:?3G3:73G3:9:7236=359A25C;<286723 ;3A3:;5:7<L9B:;94@F3:7< 349C;<9A 8D27<F5CI3;5< J<+ 5:; " <29B 7257 723 A5F8=? 9B:< 9723C =5:;< >3<8;3< 723 <@87 6C963C7? 23 ;3A3:;5:7<L C3>@775= 3G8;3:43 72@< @:;3CF8:3< 5:? <@DD3<789: 9A ;8<6C969C789:573 25C;<286 9C39G3C 8A 5 ;34C33 A9C <6348A8463CA9CF5:438<;C5B:72349:G3?5:43B8==8:=5B 5>8;3 723 9@749F3 9A 5:? 65C78789: 6C9433;8:D< 5:; 963C573797233J73:79A7235=83:9CL<7C5:<A3C5>=38:73C3<7 B872 566C96C8573 3K@8783< 79 >3 B9CI3; 9@7 >? 723 49F6373:79@C78:72365C78789:<@87 ( 7 8< 5=<9 6=543; 9: C349C; >? =35C:3; 49@:<3= A9C 723 C3<69:;3:7<;3A3:;5:7< 7257 ;3A3:;5:7 9" <8<73C 9A 3G5:5<8;;5665 25< 8:<787@73; 5 65C78789:<@87 - 12 - B2842 <75:;< ;34C33; G3: <9 DC5:7 9A <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 23C38: B8== >3 <@>E347 79 5:; 963C573 49:<8<73:7=? B872 723 6C3=8F8:5C? ;34C33 8: 723 65C78789: <@87/ 723 49:G3?5:43 <25== 65<< <@42 C8D27 787=3 5:; 8:73C3<75<7235=83:9C49@=;G5=8;=?49:G3?=35G8:D8:7547 723C8D27<9A:9:$5=83:578:DF3F>3C<7925G37238C<25C3< 45CG3;9@78:729<36C9433;8:D<23-8C<7663==5739@C7 723C3A9C33CC3;8:8:G9I8:DN49F65C578G325C;<286O8:723 733729A 5><3:76=35;8:D<5:; 8<<@3< 7<C3A@<5=79 DC5:7 723=5CD3CC3=83A9:7257DC9@:;8<63CG3C<35:;49:7C5C?79 <377=3;=5B5:;45::97>3<@<758:3; % 69: 5 49F6C323:<8G3 C3$566C58<5= 9A 723 A8:;8:D< 9A >972 723 9@C7< >3=9B 5:; 5: 3J5F8:5789: 9A 723 =3D5= 6C8:486=3< D9G3C:8:D <@87< A9C <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 728< 9@C7 8< 49:<7C58:3; 79 29=; 7257 723 E@;DF3:7<9A723C85=9@C75<B3==5<723-8C<7663==573 9@C7 <@AA3C AC9F <3C89@< =3D5= 8:A8CF8783< 5F9@:78:D 79 63CG3C<87? - 13 - + 23 C85= 9@C7 ;3<6873 25G8:D 4573D9C845==? C349C;3;A8:;8:D<8:A5G9@C9A7236=58:78AA<9:7234C@485= 8<<@3< :5F3=? ;@3 3J34@789: 9A 723 5DC33F3:7 9A <5=3 ;573; *')''+ 5:; 723 6=58:78AA<L C35;8:3<< 5:; B8==8:D:3<< 6C9433;3; 79 ;3:? 723 C3=83A 9A <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 9: 5: @:73:5>=3 DC9@:; 7257 723 <@87 6C963C7? 8< E98:7 A5F8=? 5:43<7C5= 6C963C7? 28< 566C9542 C3A=347<5A@:;5F3:75=F8<566=845789:9A=5B " 23 C85= 9@C7 A58=3; 79 566C348573 7257 723 :57@C3 9A 723 6C963C7? 9C 723 49F6378:D 4=58F< 9A :9:$ 5=83:578:D4965C43:3C<5C3B29==?8CC3=3G5:749:<8;3C5789:< 8:5<@87A9C<6348A8463CA9CF5:43>37B33:7235DC33F3:7$ 29=;3C 5:; 723 3J34@75:7 23 C85= 9@C7 7C5G3==3; A5C >3?9:; 723 63CF8<<8>=3 <4963 9A <4C@78:? @:;3C 34789:< + 4 5:; )' 9A 723 6348A84 3=83A 47 9 6=35 9A 49F65C578G3 25C;<286 9C 3K@87? B5< C58<3; 8: 723 BC8773: <7573F3:7< :9C 5:? 8<<@3 AC5F3; 37 723 C85= 9@C7 ;34=8:3;C3=83A9:5:3J7C5:39@<5:;=3D5==?8F63CF8<<8>=3 DC9@:;28<;3G85789:AC9F723<377=3;6C969<8789:9A=5B - 14 - 25< C3:;3C3; 723 A8:;8:D :97 F3C3=? 3CC9:39@< >@7 63CG3C<3 5< 87 49F6=373=? 8D:9C3< >8:;8:D 6C343;3:7< B284229=;7257:9:$5=83:578:DF3F>3C<F5?6@C<@37238C C8D27<9:=?8:5:8:;363:;3:765C78789:54789: & 23 -8C<7 663==573 9@C7 729@D2 49:4@CC8:D 7257 3J34@789: 9A 723 5DC33F3:7 5:; 723 6=58:78AA<L C35;8:3<< 5:; B8==8:D:3<< <799; 6C9G3; ;8<F8<<3; 723 56635= 9: 5 B29==? :3B DC9@:; 5==3D3; 25C;<286 79 723 ;3A3:;5:7< 8A <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 B3C3 79 >3 DC5:73; 28< C35<9:8:D 8< 3K@5==? @:<@<758:5>=3 5:; 3J28>87< 63CG3C<87?9:F@=786=349@:7< 8 .,3)53 $130*()+, 23 ;3A3:;5:7< :3G3C 6=35;3; 49F65C578G3 25C;<286 9C 5:? ;8<6C969C789:573 6C3E@;843 8: 7238C BC8773: <7573F3:7< : 723 5><3:43 9A 6=35;8:D< :9 A9@:;5789: 3J8<73; A9C 723 663==573 9@C7 79 3J5F8:3 25C;<286 @:;3C 34789: )' 9A 723 6348A84 3=83A47 - 15 - 88 .,3)53,,-3 98<<@3C3D5C;8:D25C;<286B5< AC5F3;>?723C85=9@C723663==5739@C749@=; :9725G3G3:7@C3;8:795:5C359@7<8;3723<49639A 7236=35;8:D<5:;8<<@3< 888 )/6067 8(*3)53 G3: 5<<@F8:D 25C;<286 49@=; >3 3J5F8:3; 723 ;3A3:;5:7<L 9B: ;94@F3:7< J< + 5:; " 3<75>=8<2 7257 723 A5F8=? 9B:< <@><75:785= 6C963C783< 565C7 AC9F 723 <@87 6C963C7? 28< 3G8;3:43 :3D573< 5:? 7239C? 9A 25C;<286 37 723 663==573 9@C7 429<3 79 C3=? 9: 5: @:A9@:;3; 5<<@F6789:8D:9C8:DC3=3G5:73G8;3:439:C349C; 8G (,63+06* 3//13* 04 23 -8C<7 663==573 9@C79G3C=99I3;7236C8:486=3725725C;<286F@<7>3 6=35;3; 6C9G3; 5:; <29B: 79 25G3 >33: @:A9C3<335>=35772378F39A49:7C5479:39A723<3 A9@:;5789:5=C3K@8C3F3:7<B3C3<578<A83; * 23-8C<7663==5739@C7L<A8:;8:D8<723C3A9C3 63CG3C<3 5< 87 C3<7< 9: 49:E347@C3 8< @:<@669C73; >? - 16 - 6=35;8:D< 9C 3G8;3:43 5:; 8< ;8C347=? 49:7C5C? 79 >8:;8:D =3D5=6C8:486=3< )' 2363CG3C<87?8:723A8:;8:D<9A>9727239@C7< >3=9BD93<79723G3C?C9979A7238CC3<63478G3E@;DF3:7< 972 9@C7< 8D:9C3; 723 5;F8773; 5:; 6C9G3; A547@5= F57C8J 7C5G3==3; >3?9:; 7238C E@C8<;84789:5= =8F87< C3=83; @69: =3D5==? 8F63CF8<<8>=3 49:<8;3C5789:< 5:; A58=3; 79 566=?723<377=3;6C8:486=3<D9G3C:8:D723DC5:79A<6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 28< 25< C3<@=73; 8: F8<45CC85D3 9A E@<7843 B5CC5:78:D8:73CA3C3:43>?728<9@C7@:;3C 34789:''9A ) 23 <@><75:785= K@3<789: 9A =5B AC5F3; >? 728< 9@C7 723C3A9C3 <75:;< 5:<B3C3; 8: 723 P 8: A5G9@C9A7236=58:78AA<5:;5D58:<7723;3A3:;5:7< )) -9C 723 A9C3D98:D C35<9:< 728< 9@C7 6C9433;< 7965<<723A9==9B8:D - 17 - 23 3D@=5C 349:;6635=8< 23 <@87 8: 9%))'' 8< ;34C33; A9C <6348A84 63CA9CF5:43 23 6=58:78AA< <25== ;369<87 723 >5=5:43 <5=3 49:<8;3C5789: >3A9C3 723 C85= 9@C7 B8728: <8J + B33I< AC9F 723 ;573 9A C3438679A543C78A83;496?9A728<E@;DF3:7 3A3:;5:7 9< 79 + <25== 3J34@73 5 C3D8<73C3; <5=3 ;33; 8: A5G9@C 9A 723 6=58:78AA< @69: C343867 9A 723 >5=5:43 <5=3 49:<8;3C5789: B8728: 7B9 ) F9:72< AC9F 723 ;573 9A <@42 ;369<87:978439A;369<87>3A9C37239@C7>3=9B : ;3A5@=7 9A 3J34@789: >? 723 ;3A3:;5:7< B8728:7235A9C3<58;63C89;7236=58:78AA<<25==>3 57 =8>3C7? 79 <33I 3J34@789: 9A 723 ;34C33/ 723 C85= 9@C7 <25== 723C3@69: 45@<3 723 <5=3 ;33; 79>33J34@73;8:5449C;5:43B872=5B - 18 - 7 8< 4=5C8A83; 7257 723 49:G3?5:43 5:; 87< 8:48;3:7< <25== 5>8;3 >? 5:; >3 <@>E347 79 723 C8D27< 9A :9:$5=83:578:D A5F8=? F3F>3C< 5< ;373CF8:3; 8: 723 65C78789: 6C9433;8:D< 5:; <25== 963C573 79 723 3J73:7 9A 723 5=83:9CL< 7C5:<A3C5>=38:73C3<7B8723K@8783<79>35;E@<73; >?72349F6373:79@C7 C5B;34C335449C;8:D=? *9 % & # . 8<79 ! =9