Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 46728 (KAR)

THE RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANE v. MAHARUDRA S/O SHARANAPPA DUDAGI AND ANR

MFA/200860/2023 · 2025-04-04

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $ % % ##& ' ( ) !" ! # $% &%'%( ) !* ! &) ""' # &%'%( *+ ) Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , * -(,)()) ,-- )()( * * ! ! .* * % ! .* * /01233425016054789:/4;413<=74=: <)&=1>;2=?4 <@32=9 0= <,-- )()( 64450=A 2AA;04B47 89 :/4 C>7A@4=:2=72D2;772:47-(,)())89:/4;54=0<; 0B05*>7A4 2528>;A06<;1/<;:E:/4;08>=25F ) <; :/4 12G4 <6 ?<=B4=04=?4 :/4 32;:041 2;4 ;464;;47:<2134;:/40;;2=G1846<;4:/4;08>=25 /4 62?:>25 @2:;0H <6 :/4 ?214 01 :/2: <= ((%)(- :/4 34:0:0<=4; 2=7 <=4 44;41/ D4;4 ;070=A @<:<;?9?54842;0=A <&) &($$-/434:0:0<=4;D21 ;070=A:/41207@<:<;?9?54<D=4789;413<=74=: <2=7 - 3 - 0=1>;47 89 ;413<=74=: <) 842;0=A <&) &"'' ;0774=89:/4=<=44514:/2=;413<=74=: <?2@46;<@ <33<10:4 70;4?:0<= 2=7 721/47 :< :/4 @<:<;?9?54 <6 :/4 34:0:0<=4;/434:0:0<=4;1>1:20=47A;04B<>10=C>;041:</01 54A 2=7 D21 27@0::47 :< /20:2=92 >5:0 34?025:9 <130:25D/4;4/4D21:;42:476<;28<>:"72914/27 1>1:20=47 6;2?:>;41 :< /01 546: 54A ?214 ?2@4 :< 84 ;4A01:4;4789:/4C>;0170?:0<=253<50?40= ;0@4 <,' )(- 2=7>5:0@2:459?/2;A4&1/44:D21605472A20=1::/4;074;1<6 8<:/ :/4 B4/0?541 /4 34:0:0<=4; ?520@47 ?<@34=12:0<= 6;<@ :/4 <D=4; ;413<=74=: < 2=7 0=1>;4; ;413<=74=: <)<6:/4<664=70=AB4/0?54 $ =3>;1>2=?4:<:/4=<:0?4:/4;413<=74=: < :/<>A/ 23342;47 846<;4 :/4 ;08>=25 707 =<: 6054 2=9 D;0::4= 1:2:4@4=: <D4B4; ;413<=74=: <) 23342;47 2=7 60547 D;0::4= 1:2:4@4=: ?<=:4=70=A :/2: :/4;4 D21 B0<52:0<=<6:/4:4;@12=7?<=70:0<=1<6:/43<50?910=?4:/4 ;074; /27 =< 7;0B0=A 50?4=?4 2=7 251< 74=047 :/4 2A4 0=?<@4 2=7 <??>32:0<= <6 :/4 34:0:0<=4; :/4 - 4 - ?<@34=12:0<= ?520@47 D21 251< :4;@47 21 /0A/59 4H<;80:2=:2=70@2A0=2;9 % = :/4 82101 <6 :/4 28<B4 ?<=:4=:0<=1 :/4 ;08>=256;2@47:/4233;<3;02:4011>412=734:0:0<=4;D21 4H2@0=47 /0@1456 21 2=7 :/4 7<?:<; D/< 21141147 :/4 70128050:9 D21 4H2@0=47 21 ) 2=7 A<: @2;G47 H1 :< , /4 <660?025 <6 ;413<=74=: <) =1>;2=?4 <@32=9D214H2@0=4721 " 6:4; /42;0=A 8<:/ 10741 :/4 ;08>=25 /21 21141147 :/4 ?<@34=12:0<= 2: 1%'((( & 3292854 89 :/4 2334552=:&;413<=74=: <) : 251< /457 :/2: :/4 34:0:0<=4; 840=A ;074; <6 :/4 @<:<;?9?54 /27 ?<=:;08>:47 =4A50A4=?4:<:/44H:4=:<6%(I2=7211>?/:/45028050:9 <6;413<=74=: <)D21<=591)-%(( & , 40=A 2AA;04B47 89 :/4 12@4 ;413<=74=: <) =1>;2=?4 <@32=901846<;4:/01 <>;: ' /4 542;=47 ?<>=145 23342;0=A 6<; :/4 2334552=:&=1>;2=?4 <@32=9 ?<=:4=71 :/2: :/4 - 5 - ;413<=74=: <D/</0@1456D21;074;<6:/4@<:<;?9?54 D21=<:3<114110=A:/4B25077;0B0=A50?4=?42=7:/4;46<;4 :/4;401B0<52:0<=<6:/4:4;@12=7?<=70:0<=1<6:/43<50?9 2=7 21 1>?/ :/4 5028050:9 /21 :< 84 621:4=47 >3<= :/4 ;413<=74=: < - :016>;:/4;?<=:4=747:/2::/4;2:0<52077<D= 0=:/4?214<6 D<>57 ;4J>0;4 :/2: :/4 ;413<=74=: < 1/<>57 :2G4 2 7464=?4 :/2: :/4 8;42?/ <6 :/4 ?<=70:0<=1 <6 :/4 3<50?9 D21 =<: 0=:4=:0<=25 6 :/4;4 01 D0556>58;42?/<6?<=70:0<=<6:/43<50?9:/4=:/43;0=?0354 <63292=7;4?<B4;D<>57=<:8423350?28542=7:/4;46<;4 :/4 34:0:0<= 21 2A20=1: :/4 2334552=:&0=1>;2=?4 ?<@32=9 1/<>57/2B4844=701@0114789:/4;08>=25 ( 542;=47 ?<>=145 23342;0=A 6<; :/4 34:0:0<=4; ;413<=74=: < D<>57 1>8@0: :/2: /4 01 :/4 1 )(($ )-, - 6 - :/0;732;:90=;4134?:<6:/42??074=:2=7:/4;46<;4/401 4=:0:5476<;144G0=A?<@34=12:0<=6;<@:/42334552=: :0134;:0=4=::<=<:4:/2::/434:0:0<=4;840=A2 ?<=:;08>:<;:<:/4=4A50A4=?4?2==<:84:4;@47212:/0;7 32;:9 /4= :/4;4 2;4 C<0=: :<;:6421<;1 1>?/ :<;:6421<;1 ?2==<:84:/0;732;:92A20=1:42?/<:/4;:/0;732;:9012 34;1<=D/</27=<;<54:<35290=:<;:64212=?48B0<>159 :/4 34:0:0<=4; D21 2 :<;:6421<; ;2:/4; 2 C<0=: :<;:6421<; 2=7 :/4;46<;4 0: ?2==<: 84 1207 :/2: :/4 34:0:0<=4; 01 2 :/0;7 32;:9 : 01 251< ;454B2=: :< =<:4 :/2: :/4 60=70=A<6 :/4;08>=25:/2::/434:0:0<=4;/27?<=:;08>:47=4A50A4=?4 :< :/4 4H:4=: <6 %(I 0= ?<@@0110<= <6 2??074=: /21 =<: 844=2112054789:/434:0:0<=4;896050=A2=9233425 =74; :/414?0;?>@1:2=?41:/460=70=A<6:/4;08>=25212A20=1: :/4 34:0:0<=4; :/2: /4 /27 ?<=:;08>:47 =4A50A4=?4 :< :/4 4H:4=:<6%(I?2==<:840=:4;64;47D0:/ ) /4 542;=47 ?<>=145 23342;0=A 6<; :/4 ;413<=74=: <) D<>57 1>8@0: :/2: C>7A@4=: <6 :/4 0B010<= 4=?/ <6 :/01 <>;: 0= :/4 ?214 <6 - 7 - /272=<??210<= :<?<=1074;210@052;10:>2:0<=:0134;:0=4=::<=<:4:/2: 0=:/41207?214:/47;0B4;<6:/4<664=70=A5<;;9D21=<: 3<114110=A2B25077;0B0=A50?4=?4/4 <>;::<<G=<:0?4<6 :/4 62?: :/2: :/4 4=:;>1:@4=: <6 :/4 B4/0?54 :< 234;1<= D/<707=<:/2B42B25077;0B0=A50?4=?4?<@41D0:/0=:/4 3>;B04D<6:/43;0=?0354152077<D=0=:/4?214<6 1>3;2 2=7 :/4;46<;4 0: /27 621:4=47 :/4 5028050:9 >3<= :/4 0=1>;2=?4 ?<@32=9 2=7 70;4?:47 :/2: 26:4; 329@4=: <6 ?<@34=12:0<= :< :/4 34:0:0<=4;1 :/4 12@4 @2984;4?<B4;476;<@:/4<D=4;<6:/4<664=70=AB4/0?54 =:/4?214<=/2=7:/4;413<=74=: <840=A <D=4;<6:/4B4/0?54D21:/4;074;:?2==<:841207:/2: :/48;42?/<6?<=70:0<=1<6:/43<50?9D21=<:D0556>5/4 ;413<=74=: </27:2G4=>3:/4?<=:4=:0<=:/2:/4/27 4=:;>1:47 :/4 B4/0?54 :< 2 34;1<= 84504B0=A :/2: 1>?/ 34;1<= /27 2 B2507 7;0B0=A 50?4=?4 :/4= /01 8<=260741 D<>57/2B4844=2??43:47 2 <)(-') )(-? D <)("'% )(-!)%($)()$ - 8 - $ /4 <814;B2:0<= <6 :/4 0B010<= 4=?/ <6 :/01 <>;:0=32;2&(<6:/4C>7A@4=:?0:4789542;=47?<>=145 6<;:/4;413<=74=: <;427121845<D! ! "# $ % % % " % &'() % % ! % " !! *+, % % " $ % % " % % % " % !- % - " ! " " . " !" "% ! ! %- $ % % / ! % />10:014B074=::/2::/4;413<=74=: </21 620547 :< 41:28501/ :/2: /4 /27 4=:;>1:47 :/4 B4/0?54 :< 2 34;1<=D/<@/484504B47:</2B4:/47;0B0=A50?4=?4:/4 3;0=?0354 <6 329 2=7 ;4?<B4; D<>57 =<: 84 23350?2854 <;4<B4;;413<=74=: <?2==<:35427<;2;A>4:/2:2= <;74;<63292=7;4?<B4;/21:<84@2742A20=1:/01<D= 0=1>;4;/4;413<=74=: <010=?<=:;2?:>25<850A2:0<=1 - 9 - D0:/;413<=74=: <) 0=1>;2=?4?<@32=9 /4;46<;42=9 ?<=:4=:0<=/4@29:2G401<=592A20=1::/434:0:0<=4;8>: =<:2A20=1:/01<D=0=1>;4;/01 <>;:?2==<:7D455@>?/ 0=:< :/4 B0<52:0<= <6 :/4 ?<=:;2?:>25 :4;@1 2=7 ?<=70:0<=1 84:D44=:/42334552=:2=7:/4;413<=74=: < " /4 0@3>A=47 C>7A@4=: <6 :/4 ;08>=25 =<D/4;4 ;464;1 :< :/4 J>41:0<= <6 5028050:9 4H?43: 0= 32;2A;23/ <( : <814;B41 :/2: :/4 ?/2;A4&1/44: @2;G47 2: H 7< =<: @4=:0<= 2=9:/0=A 28<>: =<=& 3<114110=A:/47;0B0=A50?4=?42=7:/4;46<;40:A<412/427 :< 621:4= :/4 5028050:9 >3<= :/4 2334552=:&0=1>;2=?4 ?<@32=9:0134;:0=4=::<=<:4:/2::/4:/4<660?025 <6:/40=1>;2=?4?<@32=9/27743<147846<;4:/4;08>=25 :/2: :/4 ;413<=74=: < /27 =< 7;0B0=A 50?4=?4 : 01 =<:47 :/2: :/4 ;074; D21 1<@48<79 4514 2=7 :/4 ;413<=74=: < /27 255<D47 1>?/ ;074; :< ;074 :/4 @<:<;?9?54 =74;:/414?0;?>@1:2=?41:/4:41:0@<=9<6 :/4D211>660?04=:4=<>A/:<3;<@3::/4;413<=74=: <&<D=4;:<12928<>::/47;0B0=A50?4=?4:01;454B2=: - 10 - :< =<:4 :/2: ;413<=74=: < /27 23342;47 :/;<>A/ /01 ?<>=145 846<;4:/4 ;08>=25 /4;46<;4:/4 1054=?4 <6 :/4 ;413<=74=: <?2==<:84?<=1:;>47:<8427B2=:2A4<>1 6<;/0@1456 , =74; :/414 ?0;?>@1:2=?41 :/4 233425 1>??44714=?4:/46<55<D0=A! 0 /423342501255<D47 00 /4 5028050:9 :< 329 :/4 ?<@34=12:0<= <6 1)-%(( & 25<=A D0:/ 0=:4;41: 21 <;74;4789:/4;08>=25<=:/42334552=:01 14:210742=71>?/5028050:901621:4=47>3<= :/4 ;413<=74=: < :/4 <D=4; <6 :/4 @<:<;?9?54;413<=74=: <)/4;40= 000 /434:0:0<=212A20=1:2334552=:&=1>;2=?4 <@32=91:2=71701@01147 0B /4 2@<>=: 0= 743<10: 06 2=9 84 :;2=1@0::47:<:/4?<=?4;=47 <>;:2=7:/4 - 11 - ;08>=25 :< ;46>=7 :/4 12@4 :< :/4 2334552=:&0=1>;2=?4?<@32=9 B /4 4A01:;9 :< 14=7 82?G :/4 :;025 ?<>;: ;4?<;71:<:/4?<=?4;=47 <>;: 7 & & % ( % ! !$$ !