- 1 - !" #"$ %$!" &" ' ( )&" ' ( !! "# $ % & ## ' !! ! ## &## ( !! ( &## ( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !! "# $ ) * !+(% # ) !!' ) ) # !' !!! # , !!! ( ) & ) #) ,) )( !! "# $ % & ## ' !! ! ## &## !! ( &## !! ## - 3 - !! "# $ ) * !+( # % # ) !!' ) ) # !' !!! # , ! ( ) & ) #) , # )# -. # /& &# $# /& &# % 012 #3212145 4!6 !!! 17 8193: ;< 2=3 :3835:>52 4 733?15@ A0><30 24 BC>7= 2=3 40:30 :>23: !' !!!A>773:45 4 15 4!!! ( 012 #3212145 4!6!(!!! 17 8193: ;< 2=3 :3835:>52 4( 733?15@ A0><30 24 BC>7= 2=3 40:30 :>23: !' !!! A>773:45 4 15 4 ! (42=2=37C127>03 A35:15@ 45 2=3 8193 48 1D19 &C:@3 3D>:C0@> >1E=C0 17201E2 - 4 - ! 0135?>237=>99>;>:193>053:E4C5739840 2=3 A321214530 7C;F127 2=>2 037A45:352 4 GA9>152188 =>7 8193:7C1278407A3E181EA30840F>5E3482=3E4520>E2>993@3: 24 =>D3 ;335 3H3EC23: ;< 2=3 42=30 037A45:3527 >5: 15 2=3 A9>152 > 7A3E181E >D30F352 17 F>:3 2=>2 2=3 7C12 7E=3:C93A04A302<17749:158>D4C0482=3A321214530;<2=3 401@15>9D35:40>5:?54I15@8C99<I3992=3A9>152188=>7542 74C@=2>5<039138733?15@840E>5E399>2145482=37>93:33:7 3H3EC23: 15 8>D4C0 48 2=3 A321214530 2 17 7C;F1223: 2=>2 7C127 >03 840 7A3E181E A30840F>5E3 48 2=3 E4520>E2 =3 A321214530:3835:>52 4 8193: > I012235 72>23F352 :35<15@2=3>D30F3527F>:3152=3A9>152=3201>94C02 03E40:3: 2=3 3D1:35E3 48 2=3 A9>152188 >5: 15 2=3 E0477 3H>F15>21452=3A3212145307A3E181E>99<AC2>BC372145I12= 03@>0:242=33H3EC2145482=37>93:33:715=308>D4C0>5: 2=303>8230>5>AA91E>2145840>F35:F352482=3A9>152I>7 8193:733?15@ >::12145>9 A93>:15@ >5: >5 >::12145>9A0><30 24732>71:32=37>93:33:73H3EC23:;<2=3401@15>94I530 158>D4C0482=3A321214530 - 5 - ( 2 17 8C02=30 7C;F1223: 2=>2 2=3 201>9 4C02 I12=4C2 >AA03E1>215@ 2=3 8>E2 2=>2 2=303 17 >5 3540F4C7 :39><1581915@2=3>AA91E>2145840>9742=>212=>7;3358193: E4FF35E3F352482=3201>9>994I15@7CE=>5>AA91E>21457 452=3@04C5:2=>21217> F172>?3482=3E4C5739 I=1E= 17 1FA30F1771;93 2 17 8C02=30 7C;F1223: 2=>2 2=3 >AA91E>2145 733?15@ 840 >F35:F352 I>7 542 F4D3: I=35 2=3401@15>9:3835:>52I>7>91D3>5:>8230=30:3>2=7CE= >AA91E>21457>03F4D3:459<24=>0>772=3A321214530I=417 2=3;45>81:3AC0E=>73035E3=3733?724>994I2=3I012 A32121457;<732215@>71:32=31FAC@53:40:307 #30 E4520> 01 7=4? C9>@3 93>053: E4C5739 >AA3>015@ 840 037A45:352 4 GA9>152188 7C;F127 2=>2 2=303 17 > F172>?3 45 2=3 A>02 48 2=3 E4C5739 I=4 17 03A03735215@ 2=3 037A45:352 4 GA9>152188 152=37C127I=1E==>7;33503E40:3:;<2=3201>94C02>5: >994I3: 2=3 >AA91E>2145 ;< 1FA4715@ E472 2 17 7C;F1223: 2=>2 2=3 A037352 >F35:F352 74C@=2 I4C9: 542 >9230 2=3 5>2C03 48 A04E33:15@7 ;32I335 2=3 A>02137 =35E3 54 - 6 - A03JC:1E3 I4C9: ;3 E>C73: 24 2=3 A321214530 35E3 =3 733?724:17F1772=3I012A32121457 =>D3 =3>0: 2=3 >0@CF3527 48 2=3 93>053: E4C5739 840 2=3 A321214530 93>053: E4C5739 840 2=3 037A45:352 4 >5: F321EC94C79< A30C73: 2=3 F>2301>9 >D>19>;934503E40: 6 =3 037A45:352 4 GA9>152188 =>7 8193: 2=3 7C12 840 7A3E181E A30840F>5E3 48 2=3 E4520>E2 >@>1572 453 >7>FF> E9>1F15@ 2=>2 2=3 7>1: >7>FF> =>7 3H3EC23: >5 C503@172303: >@033F352 48 7>93 :>23: ( !6 15 037A3E2482=37C127E=3:C93A04A302<0383003:15;42=2=3 7C127 :F1223:9< 15121>99< 2=3 7C12 I>7 8193: 840 7A3E181E A30840F>5E3 48 2=3 E4520>E2 :>23: ( !6 >5: 459< >8230 2=3 E4FF35E3F352 48 2=3 201>9 2=3 >AA91E>21457 15 47 >5: >03 F4D3: 733?15@ 840 >F35:F352 48 2=3A9>152452=3@04C5:2=>2;<15>:D30235E32=3A9>152188 E4C9: 542 733? 2=3 039138 48 732215@ >71:3 2=3 7>93 :33:7 3H3EC23:158>D4C0482=3A037352A321214530;<2=3401@15>9 D35:40 - 7 - ' :F1223:9< 15 A>0>G 48 2=3 A9>152 > 7A3E181E >D30F352 17 F>:3 2=>2 2=3 A321214530 =>7 AC0E=>73: 2=3 A04A302< 15 BC372145 804F 2=3 401@15>9 D35:40 4I3D30 2=3 037A45:352 4 GA9>152188 E4C9: 542 733? 2=3 039138 48 732215@ >71:3 2=3 7>93 :33:7 15 2=3 7C12 I=35 12 I>7 401@15>99<8193:=3201>94C022>?15@5423482=38>E22=>2 733?15@A0><30152=3>AA91E>214517>515>:D302352F172>?3 48 2=3 E4C5739 >5: 2=3 A>02< E>5542 ;3 >994I3: 24 7C8830 :C3247CE=>F172>?3=>7>994I3:2=3>AA91E>2145 >F482=3E4571:303:D13I2=>22=3201>94C02 I>7 JC721813: 15 >994I15@ 2=3 >AA91E>21457 840 2=3 71FA93 03>7452=>212172=3037A45:352 4 A9>152188I=4=>724 A04D32=3E>73;384032=3201>94C02;>73:452=3A93>:15@ >5: 93@>99< >EE3A2>;93 3D1:35E3 5 2=3 A9>152 =3 =>7 7A3E181E>99< A93>:3: 2=>2 2=3 7C12 7E=3:C93 A04A302137 >03 749:158>D4C0482=3A321214530=30315>5:733?15@>A0><30 24732>71:37CE=7>93:33:7I4C9:542E>C73>5<A03JC:1E3 40 >9230 2=3 E9>1F 48 2=3 A9>152188 59377 7CE= >5 >F35:F3521774C@=2>5:>994I3:2=3A9>152188I4C9:542 - 8 - ;3>;9324E9>1F>5<039138>774C@=2152=37C128407A3E181E A30840F>5E348E4520>E2=3A01F>0<AC0A47348>994I15@ >5>F35:F3521724357C032=>22=3E4C02E>5:3230F153 2=303>9BC37214515E45204D307<;32I3352=3A>02137 K 5 D13I 48 2=3 7>F3 >F 48 2=3 E4571:303: D13I 2=>2 2=3 201>9 4C02 I>7 JC721813: 15 >994I15@ 2=3 >AA91E>2145 4I3D30 2=17 4C02 E>5542 9473 71@=2 48 2=3 8>E22=>212172=39>A73452=3A>02482=3037A45:352 4 G A9>152188 15 F4D15@ 2=3 >AA91E>2145 ;39>23:9< 2=>2 24 >8230 2=3 E4FF35E3F352 48 201>9 35E3 2=3 >AA91E>2145 17 03BC103:24;3>994I3:;<7>::915@2=3E472487G 15 3>E= 48 2=3 7C127 35E3 A04E33: 24 A>77 2=3 84994I15@ 1% # 4!6 !!!>5: # 4!6!(!!! >03 11% =3 >F35:3: A9>152 8193: ;< 2=3 037A45:352 4 17 >EE3A23: 7C;J3E2 24 2=3 037A45:352 - 9 - 4 GA9>152188 A><15@ E472 48 7G 24 2=3 A3212145307GA9>1521887153>E=482=37C127 111% =3 A321214530 >5: 42=30 :3835:>527 >03 A30F1223:2481932=3I01223572>23F352I12=15> A3014:4884C0I33?7 1D% =3 201>9 4C02 17 :103E23: 24 03@C9>23 127 A04E33:15@745E32=3I01223572>23F352178193: D% =3 201>9 4C02 17 03BC3723: 24 :17A473 48 2=3 7C12>73>09<>7A4771;932>?15@5423482=38>E2 2=>27C1217482=3<3>0! ( D1% 440:3024E4727 *( &%$!"' $ 172 4 9 4!! #