- 1 - ! "#"$ %&# # ' ( ) ! "#$ % "%# "& " ' " "(%% ""%"" ) "%"" " "" Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - &* + ) " ! , %)- # "")"%%$ %" " & " * % % " % " % %$."""" " # # * %" ( " $ . " "" '* " " ' # "" )) &* %" ("$."""*& " % )'')' " ) " % % " % &' " % # " # %" (" % /0 " " " " 1,, 23 4356567839 2:; <2:==38>3? %79@ 7 :8? ;A35<2 4934:93? 68 93;43<5 7B C7 &' :8? &' 7B9686D:;:9:?:>6D6==:>3232:;:=;7<2:==38>3? 523 79?39 4:;;3? EC 523 93;478?385 7' ?:53? '* 68 :443:= 7 # "" )) &* :; - 3 - F3== :; 523 79?39 ?:53? 4:;;3? EC 523 93;478?385 7 68 93D6;678 7 # * 234356567839<78538?;52:5=:8?E3:968>C7 &' 7B 9686D:; :9:?:>6 D6==:>3 :=:EG9:>6 :=GA: :8? ?6;596<5 @3:;G93? ' :<93; & >G85:; :8? E3=78>3? 57 92:D:9G 7 96;28::F:93;7=?:<93;>G85:; 579:A:;2<2:8?68539@;7B:;:=3?:53?'&G5 7B523:B793;:6?3H53857B:<93;>G85:;:83H53857B :<93;F:;<78D3953?B97@:>96<G=5G9:=57878:>96<G=5G9:= G;3 68 539@; 7B :8 7BB6<6:= @3@79:8?G@ E3:968> 7 # " &* ?:53? )* 23 <78D3953? :<93; 7B =:8? F:; ;7=? 57 7G52398 HC>38 7@4:8C 96D:53 6@653? ;G9D3C ;A35<2 68 %79@ F:; 4934:93? :; 523 4356567839 ?3;693? 57 4G9<2:;3 523 93@:6868> 4795678 7B ' :<93; >G85:; F26<2 ;23 4G9<2:;3?68539@;7B:;:=3?33??:53?' ' 356567839<78538?;52:593;478?3857)6;;G3?: 8756<3?:53?*B79/:5A:=27?607B=:8?E3:968> - 4 - C 7 &' 7B 9686D:; :9:?:>6 D6==:>3 5 F:; ;5:53? 523936852:552393F:;:?6BB3938<3E35F3385233H53857B =:8? @3856783? 68 523 4:2:86 :8? :<5G:= 47;;3;;678 :8? 52393B793?693<53?:==4:9563;57E3493;38578* E3B793 523 93;478?385 7) :=78> F652 83<3;;:9C ?7<G@385; 23 4356567839 <=:6@3? 52:5 5297G>2 523 ;:6? 8756<3 F:; 93<36D3? EC 239 ;23 38?79;3? 78 523 8756<3 52:5 ;23 F7G=? 875 E3 68 57F8 78 * :8?F7G=? 935G98 E:<A :B539 : F33A 79 B79586>25 783523=3;; 4356567839 ;GE@6553? 239 7EI3<5678; 57 523 93;478?385 7)23 <78538?; 52:5 F6527G5 <78;6?3968> 523 <=:6@7B 5234356567839:;F3==:;239?7<G@385;93;478?3857) 6;;G3?:B93;2%79@7:8?;A35<26893;43<57B =:8? E3:968> ;G9D3C 7 &' :8? &' %33=68> :>>963D3? EC 523 ;:6? 79?39 ;23 B6=3? :8 :443:= G8?39 3<5678)!:$7B523 <5&)E3B79352393;478?385 7'2393;478?3857'93I3<53?523:443:=68539@; 7B :8 79?39 ?:53? '* 2393:B539 523 4356567839 B6=3?:93D6;67843565678G8?393<5678&7B523 :98:5:A: :8?3D38G3<5&)E3B79352393;478?385723 - 5 - 93D6;678 43565678 F:; :=;7 ?6;@6;;3? 68 539@; 7B :8 79?39 ?:53?368>:>>963D3?EC523;:6?79?39;523 43565678396;E3B793526;7G95 ) 3:983? <7G8;3= B79 523 4356567839 <78538?; 52:5 523 4974395C 52:5 F:; 4G9<2:;3? EC 523 4356567839 F:; 3:9=639 ;G9D3C3? :8? 523 E7G8?:963; 7B ' :<93 >G85:; F:;?G=C@:9A3?:8?:;A35<268%79@7F:;6;;G3? 3 52393B793 <78538?; 52:5 F26=3 <78?G<568> : /:5A:= 27?6065F:;68<G@E385G478523;G9D3C7BB6<39;572:D3 D396B63?%79@7:8?523565=3?33?7B5234356567839 3 <78538?; 52:5 :; : 93;G=5 7B 523 /:5A:= 27?60 523 93;478?3857)2:;=:6?7G5:97:?52:59G8;5297G>2523 4974395C 7B 523 4356567839 :8? 523 E7G8?:963; 7B 523 4974395C :93 :=;7 :=5393? %G9523923 <78538?; 52:5 F26=3 523 4974395C 7B 4356567839 F:; ;JG:93 ;2:43? 68 523 ;A35<2 EG5 65 2:; 87F E3<7@3 :8 7?? ;2:43? ;653 68 %79@ :8? 27?6 ;A35<2 2G; 23 <78538?; 52:5 523 79?39 4:;;3? EC 523 93;478?385 7) 523 <78;3JG385 - 6 - ;A35<227?6:8?:;;6>868>C7&' :8?&' :93 =6:E=357E3;35:58:G>25 3:983? ??65678:= 7D398@385 ?D7<:53 <78538?3? 52:5 523 /:5A:= 27?60 6; E:;3? 78 523 :<5G:= 47;;3;;678 7B 523 4:9563; :8? 52393B793 52393 6; 875268> F978>6852393;478?3857)?9:F68>G4:;A35<2:;439 523 :<5G:= 27=?68> 7B 523 4:9563; 3 <78538?; 52:5 6B 523 4356567839 ?3;693; 57 93<7D39 523 4974395C ;23 6; 38565=3? 57 ?7 ;7 68 :<<79?:8<3 F652 =:F EC :4497:<268> 523 <7@435385 6D6= 7G95 3 BG95239 <78538?; 52:5 523 97:? B7G8? 68 523 /:5A:= 27?60 ;A35<2 F:; :=93:?C :;42:=53? EC 523 GE=6< 79A; "34:95@385 :8? 52393B793 523 4356567839<:8875=:C<=:6@5752397:?:;656;D3;53?68523 5:537D398@385 & 2:D3<78;6?393?523;GE@6;;678;7B523=3:983? <7G8;3= B79 523 4356567839 :8? =3:983? ??65678:= 7D398@385 ?D7<:53 B79 93;478?385 7; 57 ) 3;478?385 7 527G>2 ;39D3? F652 523 8756<3 7B 523 - 7 - F965 43565678 2:; 875 :443:93? 2393B793 526; 7G95 ?6? 8752:D3523E383B657B26;;GE@6;;678; * 23 4356567839 2:? 4G9<2:;3? ' :<93; >G85:; 7B=:8?68C7&':8?5234974395C;74G9<2:;3?F:; 6?3856B63? EC 523 ;G9D3C79 EC 6;;G68> %79@ 7 2393B793 B79 :== 49:<56<:= 4G947;3; F26=3 4934:968> : 27?6:8?:;;6>868>83F;G9D3C8G@E39;5787578=C523 4974395C 7B 523 4356567839 EG5 :=;7 57 523 4974395C 7B 75239;523;A35<268%79@72:?57E3<78;6?393? :8?93;43<53?5:443:9; B97@523 ?7<G@385; 4=:<3? 78 93<79?52:5 5234974395C4G9<2:;3?EC 5234356567839F:; :=@7;5;JG:93;2:43?:8?93;3@E=3?:JG:?96=:539:=F652 5233:;5F3;5=38>527852387952398;6?3E6>>3952:8523 ;7G52398 ;6?3 8 523 ;7G52398 ;6?3 7B 526; 4974395C :<93; F:; 523 <78D3953? =:8? ;7=? 57 7G52398 7HC>38 7@4:8C 96D:53 6@653? 23 93;478?385 7 F27 4G947953?=C 2:? 4G9<2:;3? ;7@3 4974395C =C68> 78 523 F3;5398;6?37B5234974395C7B5234356567839;7G>25B79: 27?6 E6BG9<:5678 7B 26; 4974395C <<79?68>=C ;534; F393 - 8 - 68656:53?B79E6BG9<:56787BC7&'23;A35<24934:93? EC52393;478?3857);27F;52:55234974395C4G9<2:;3? EC 523 4356567839 :8? 6?3856B63? 68 B79@ 7 F:; 875 ;G9D3C3?:8?523E7G8?:963;F3938754934:93?:;439523 %79@;A35<2:8?523;:=3?33?7B5234356567839 23 497<3?G93 B79 E6BG9<:5678 7B 93D38G3 ;G9D3C 8G@E39; 4:956<G=:9=C 68 @:5539; 7B ?3539@68:5678 7B E7G8?:963;7B=:8?;B79@68>:4:957B;G9D3C8G@E39;79: 27=?68> 6; ?3B683? G8?39 3<5678 ) 7B 523 :98:5:A: :8?3D38G3<5F26<293:?;:;B7==7F; ! " # $ % & ! ' () & - 9 - * # ' + 23 <7993;478?68> 9G=3; G8?39 523 :98:5:A: :8? 3D38G3 G=3; && :93 G=3 7; ' )F26<293:?:;B7==7F; , - - - $. ( / , # * ! 0 1 & ( & 1 2 3 4& * $ % % & & ! / 2 * & & 1 1 * ' $ & - 10 - $ 5 & $ , 5 & & 1 2 1 ,( 6 1 ,7 ' *$ $ ' 1 2) $ 1 2 $ 1 2 ,( 1 0 % & ' 8 8 ' 1 2 ) ! 1 2 ' ,/0 ' 1, - 11 - ,( * % & ' ,2 *% ! 1 2 1 ) & ! & ,, % % ) # # + 44:9385=C 523 27?6 7B 523 =:8? 4G9<2:;3? EC 52393;478?38576;B6H3?:;497D6?3?G8?39G=3!$ F6527G5<7@4=C68>523497<3?G93493;<96E3?G8?39G=3 !$!'$!)$:8?!$:8?F6527G568JG6968>6857523?6;4G53 :; 497D6?3? G8?39 G=3 :8? ' 5 52393B793 :443:9;52:552393;478?38572:?:997>:53?5726@;3=B 52347F397B:6D6=7G9568:=53968>523E7G8?:963;7B523 - 12 - 4974395C F26<2 6; 4G9<2:;3? EC 523 4356567839 23 93;478?385 7) E368> : ;G9D3C 7BB6<39 2:; 57 <78?G<5 523 ;G9D3C :8? B6H 523 E7G8?:963; E:;3? G478 523 565=3 ?33?; 7B 523 4:9563; :8? E:;3? G478 3:9=639 ;G9D3C ?7<G@385; B 68 523 3D385 7B :8C 38<97:<2@385 7B :8C 4974395C 523 ;G9D3C :G527965C 6; E7G8? 57 @385678 523 ;:@3 68 523 ;G9D3C ?7<G@385 :8? 93=3>:53 523 4:9563; E3B7935236D6=7G9526;?73;87568:8CF:C3@47F39 523;G9D3C:G527965C57593:5523;G9D3C497<33?68>;:;: <6D6= ?6;4G53 57 93>G=:96K3 :8C @6;5:A3; 68 523 93;43<56D3 ;:=3?33?;7B5234:9563;79:8C:<5;7B38<97:<2@385EC :8C 4:9563; 23 93;478?385 7; :8? ' 2:D3 <=3:9=C >=7;;3? 7D39 526; BG8?:@385:= B:<5 23C 2:D3 B:6=3? 57 8756<352:552393;478?3857)2:;<93:53?:8G8F:853? =656>:5678E35F3385234356567839:8?52393;478?3857 EC :=53968> 523 E7G8?:963; 7B 523 4974395C 4G9<2:;3? EC 523 4356567839 :8? 523 93;478?385 7 2393B793 523 6@4G>83?%79@7:8?523;G9D3C;A35<24934:93?EC 52393;478?385E3B793:;;6>868>C7&' :8?&' 7B 9686D:; :9:?:>6#6==:>3 ?3;39D3; 57E3 JG:;23? 23 - 13 - @:5539 ?3;39D3; 57 E3 93@6553? E:<A 57 523 93;478?385 7)F27;2:==<78?G<5:;G9D3C:8?B6H523E7G8?:963;7B 523 4974395C 4G9<2:;3? EC 523 4356567839 :8? 523 93;478?3857E:;3?785236993;43<56D3565=3?33?;:; F3==:;93;43<56D3%79@752:5F393:4:957B523 ;:=3?33?;3H3<G53?6852369B:D79 38<3523F965435656786;236@4G>83? 79?394:;;3?EC52393;478?3857):8?6@4G>83?%79@ 7 6;;G3? EC 93;478?385 7 :8? 523 ;A35<2 E6BG9<:568>C7&' :8?&' 7B9686D:;:9:?:>6 #6==:>3 6; ;35 :;6?3 23 <:;3 6; 93@6553? E:<A 57 523 93;478?385 7) F27 ;2:== <78;6?39 523 <:;3 7B 523 4356567839 :8? 523 93;478?385 7 E:;3? 78 52369 93;43<56D3;:=3?33?;:8?%79@7F26<2:934:957B 52369;:=3?33?; 8 D63F 7B 523 :B793;:6? 79?39 79?39 4:;;3? EC 523 93;478?385 7' ?:53? '* 68 :443:= 7 # "" )) &* :; F3== :; 523 79?39 ?:53? 4:;;3?EC52393;478?38576893D6;6787 - 14 - # * :93 :=;7 JG:;23? 23 93;478?3857)6;?693<53?573H43?653523<78;6?39:5678 7B523?6;4G5368523@:8839497D6?3?G8?39G=357 7B :98:5:A::8?3D38G3G=3;&&:8?3<5678) 7B523 :98:5:A::8?3D38G3<5&)F65268:43967? 7B;6H@7852;B97@523?:537B93<36457B<3956B63?<74C7B 526;79?39 *( '#) # , 6;57=7'