Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 46690 (KAR)

SHARADABAI W/O SANGAPPA BADIGER v. THE BRANCH MANAGER AND ANR

MFA/200695/2022 · 2025-02-25

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " " ##$ % & ' ! " ! # $ %"& '())) $ * !!" + "$ Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !" " ,% " ! !" ! " ! ! - )#).$)$ !,( $) ( #)$$)$ ! " /! " !0 " ! 1!! %" 1!! 2345 672 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 672 3>>2883963956728234925:;<9=28A;467242=>;95296= $ 2?9@ 3@@4?2B25 CD 672 E<5@F296 395 3G345 53625 )#).$)$ >3==25 ?9 ! ;,( $) ( CD 672 8234925 55?6?;938 ?=64?:6 395 2==?;9= <5@2 395 !2FC24!'-?E3D3><437242?93A62442A244256;3= / 0A;4C42B?6D42=>;95296; 67242?9 ;G924 ;A672643:6;4?=C2A;4267?=;<46?93>>238 - 3 - % 72 A3:6<38 F364?H ;A 672 :3=2 ?= 6736 ;9 $)($) 672 52:23=25 3B? G7; G3= 3@25 3C;<6 . D234= G;4I?9@ 3= 3 :;;8?2 G3= 3C;<6 6; C;345 3 43:6;4 43?824 C234?9@ ;'$# ' #'#( 672 54?B24 ;A672643:6;4=<55298DF;B25672B27?:82A;4G345?97?@7 =>225 395 ?9 3 92@8?@296 F39924 42=<86?9@ ?9 A388 ;A 672 52:23=25 ;9 672 4;35 395 =<=63?9?9@ A3638 ?9E<4?2= 395 52367 72 >26?6?;924= 342 672 >34296= ;A 672 52:23=25 72D :;9629525 6736 672 3::?5296 ;::<4425 5<2 6; 672 92@8?@29:2 ;9 672 >346 ;A 672 54?B24 ;A 672 643:6;4 7242A;42672;G924395?9=<424;A672B27?:823428?3C82 6;>3D672:;F>29=36?;9 72 >26?6?;9 G3= ;>>;=25 CD 42=>;95296 ; ;9 672 @4;<95 6736 67242 G3= 9; =<:7 92@8?@29:2 ;9 672 >346;A67254?B24;A672643:6;46G3=:;96295256736672 :;F>29=36?;9:83?F25?=7?@78D2H;4C?6396?F3@?934D395 <96293C8239538=;529?256723@2?9:;F2395;::<>36?;9 ;A 672 52:23=25 72 G4?6629 =6362F296 ;A 42=>;95296 ; 5;2=9;6F296?;9672F39924?9G7?:76723::?5296 - 4 - ;::<4425 6 G3= :;9629525 6736 672 B27?:82 G3= ?9=<425 G?67 42=>;95296 ;$ 7242A;42 39D :;F>29=36?;9 6736 F3D C2 3G34525 73= 6; C2 A3=62925 <>;9 42=>;95296 ;$ 2=>;95296 ;$'9=<439:2 ;F>39D ?9 ?6= G4?6629 =6362F296 :;9629525 6736 67;<@7 672 643:6;4' 643?824<9?6G3=:;B2425<9524672?9=<439:2>;8?:D?==<25 CD ?6 67242 G3= B?;836?;9 ;A 672 624F= 395 :;95?6?;9= ;A 672 >;8?:D 6 G3= :;9629525 6736 672 52:23=25 3B? G3= 39 <93<67;4?=25 >3==29@24 ?882@388D 643B28?9@ ;9 672 643:6;429@?9239567242A;42672>;8?:D73B?9@:;B2425672 4?=I ;A ;98D 672 54?B24 ;A 672 B27?:82 67242 C2?9@ 3 >4;7?C?6?;9 <9524 42@<836?;9 ;$# ;A 672 !;6;4 27?:82 2@<836?;9=?6?=9;68?3C826;>3D672:;F>29=36?;96;672 >26?6?;924 6 G3= :;9629525 6736 672 =236?9@ :3>3:?6D ;A 672 643:6;4 G3= ;98D ;92 ?2 672 54?B24 ;98D 395 2H:2>6 67254?B249;;92G3=388;G256;643B28;967229@?92;A 672 643:6;4 72 52:23=25 G3= 643B288?9@ ;9 672 =3?5 643:6;4 29@?92 6 G3= :;9629525 6736 672 :;96296?;9 ;A - 5 - 672>26?6?;924=?6=28AG;<8542=<86?93C=;8B?9@6728?3C?8?6D ;A 42=>;95296 ;$'9=<439:2 ;F>39D ?6 G3= 38=; :;9629525 6736 672 :;F>29=36?;9 :83?F25 ?= 7?@78D 2H;4C?6396 ?F3@?934D 395 <96293C82 6 529?25 672 3@2 ?9:;F2395;::<>36?;9;A67252:23=25>346A4;F6736?6 G3=38=;:;9629525673667254?B24;A672643:6;4G3=9;6 73B?9@3B38?554?B?9@8?:29=2366726?F2;A6723::?5296 ( 9 672 C3=?= ;A 672 4?B38 :;96296?;9= 672 A;88;G?9@?==<2=395355?6?;938?==<2=G242A43F25CD672 4?C<938 ! "" #$ %& ! ' $ ( ! '!)&*%+(,% -+%+ $ !! $ ! . / - 6 - " $ $/ " 0 / 1 / *22 3)*4 ) ) 5 6 /7 , 26?6?;924;$G3=2H3F?9253= 395;92 2D2G?692== G3= 2H3F?925 3= $ H= 6; ( G242 F34I25 ;9 672?4 C2738A 9 672 ;6724 7395 42=>;95296 ;$2H3F?925672;AA?:?38;A6723= 395?6=;G9 ;AA?:?38 3= $ H= 6; % G242 F34I25 ?9 672?4 2B?529:2 # A624 7234?9@ 672 34@<F296= CD C;67 =?52= 672 4?C<938 7285 6736 672 3::?5296 ;::<4425 G7?82 672 52:23=25 G3= 643B28?9@ ;9 672643:6;4 395428D?9@ ;9 672 E<5@F296;A672?B?=?;929:7;A67?=;<46?9672:3=2;A - 7 - CD ;C=24B?9@ 6736 42@<836?;9 ;$# >4;7?C?625 39D ;6724 >24=;9 A4;F 643B28?9@;9672643:6;45?=F?==25672>26?6?;93=3@3?9=6 42=>;95296 ;$'9=<439:2 ;F>39D 395 A3=62925 672 8?3C?8?6D;942=>;95296; ';G924;A672B27?:82 67242 C2?9@ 9; 5;:<F29634D 2B?529:2 42@345?9@ 672 ?9:;F2 ;A 672 52:23=25 672 4?C<938 7285 672 9;6?;938 ?9:;F2 36 =#))) ' >24 F;967 395 3G34525 :;F>29=36?;9 ;A =.%,))) ' <9524 5?AA24296 7235= 3= C28;G ;G345= A<6<42 8;== ;A 52>29529:D =#())) ' $ "?8?38:;9=;46?<F =)))) ' % ;G345=8;==;A=6362 = ()) ' ;G345=A<924382H>29=2= = ()) ' ;638 =.%,))) ' . 2?9@ 3@@4?2B25 CD 672 =3?5 E<5@F296 395 3G345 42=>;95296 ; ' ;G924 ;A 672 B27?:82 73= 3>>4;3:72567?=;<46?93>>238 89&::'1182,9 - 8 - ) 9 C2?9@ =24B25 G?67 672 9;6?:2 672 42=>;95296= ; J ?9=<439:2 :;F>39D 395 672 42=>;95296 ;$ :83?F396 73B2 3>>23425 67;<@7 672?4 42=>2:6?B28234925:;<9=28 6?==6362567365<4?9@>29529:D;A672>26?6?;9 672>26?6?;924; 5?257242A;42?6?=;98D672>26?6?;924 ;$G7;?=3443D253=42=>;95296;$?967?=3>>238 $ 72 4?C<938 42:;45= 73B2 C229 =2:<425 72 34@<F296=;A8234925:;<9=283>>234?9@A;4C;67=?52=342 72345 % 728234925:;<9=283>>234?9@A;46723>>288396 J ;G924 672 B27?:82 =<CF?6= 6736 672 " 395 ;6724 2B?529:2 3B3?83C82 ;9 42:;45 G;<85 :82348D =7;G 6736 672 52:23=25'3B?735@;65;G9A4;F672B27?:826;39=G24 3 936<42 :388 395 672423A624 72 G3= 3C;<6 6; C;345 672 643:6;4 36 6736 6?F2 672 54?B24 F;B25 672 B27?:82 ?9 3 92@8?@296 F39924 42=<86?9@ ?9 672 3::?5296 6 ?= :;96295256736G7296723::?5296;::<442567252:23=25 J3B?G3=9;6;9672643:6;4C<672G3=3C;<66;C;345 - 9 - 672 643:6;4 7?= G;<85 ?95?:362 6736 672 54?B24 735 9;6 :;9=29625;4388;G2567252:23=256;643B28;967229@?92 ;A672643:6;46?==<CF?66256736G72967252:23=25G3= ;9 672 4;35 672 3::?5296 73= ;::<4425 7242A;42 672 64?C<938244;92;<=8DA3=629256728?3C?8?6D;96723>>288396 ';G924;A672B27?:82 5 672 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 672 42=>;95296 ; ' ?9=<439:2 :;F>39D :;96295= 6736 672 2B?529:2 ;A 672 $ 395 672 >;8?:2 >3>24= :82348D ?95?:362673667252:23=25G3=3C;<66;C;345;9 672 29@?92 ;A 672 643:6;4 7242A;42 672 ?96296?;9 ;A 672 52:23=25G3=6;C;34567229@?92;A672;A672643:6;42 =<CF?6=67362B29>4?;46;6723::?529667252:23=25G3= 643B28?9@;9672643:6;4CD672=?52;A67254?B24G7?:7?= 9;6>24F?662596736B?2G;A672F36624672?96296?;9;A 672 52:23=25 395 672 54?B24 ;A 672 643:6;4 C2?9@ :8234 67242 ?= B?;836?;9 ;A 2@<836?;9 ;$# 7242A;42 672 4?C<938 73= 4?@768D :;F2 6; 672 :;9:8<=?;9 6736 672 ?9=<439:2:;F>39D?=9;68?3C826;>3D672:;F>29=36?;9 - 10 - 2A<46724=<CF?6=673667262=6?F;9D;A672 G;<85 :82348D ?95?:362 6736 672 =236?9@ :3>3:?6D ;A672 643:6;4?= ;98D;9229:27252A295=672423=;9?9@;A6724?C<938 395=22I=5?=F?==38;A6723>>238 234925 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 42=>;95296 ;$ >26?6?;924;$:;96295=673667252:23=25G3==6?88 =6395?9@ ;9 672 @4;<95 G729 672 3::?5296 735 ;::<4425 7242A;42 72 =<>>;46= 672 :;96296?;9 ;A 672 3>>288396 7242?9238=;=<CF?6=6736672:;F>29=36?;93G34525?= ;96728;G24=?52 ( 9 672 8?@76 ;A 672 3C;B2 =<CF?==?;9= 672 K<2=6?;9673634?=2=A;4:;9=?52436?;9?= . " " ! 6 ; " 6 " ! / , 6?=92:2==34D6;9;626736E<5@F296;A672"<88 29:7 ;A 67?= ;<46 ?9 672 :3=2 ;A - 11 - G;<85=7;G6736?A6723::?5296;::<4=G7?82672?9E<425;4 67252:23=25?=643B28?9@;967229@?92;A672643:6;46729 67242?=3:8234B?;836?;9;A672624F=395:;95?6?;9=;A672 >;8?:D 7242A;42 672 ?9=<439:2 :;F>39D ?= 9;6 8?3C82 6; >3D 672 :;F>29=36?;9 72 >;8?:D C2?9@ ?==<25 6; :;B24 ;98D;92>24=;9G7;?=67254?B247242C2?9@9;=236?9@ :3>3:?6D ;A F;42 6739 ;92 ?6 73= 6; C2 7285 6736 ?6 G3= F2396A;467254?B24967?=42@345672"<8829:7;A67?= ;<46428?25<>;9672<5@F296?9672:3=2;A 395=2B2438;6724E<5@F296=395 :3F26;672:;9:8<=?;96736?A672?9E<425;467252:23=25 G3= 643B288?9@ CD =?66?9@ ;9 672 F<5'@<345 ;4 39D ;6724 ?9=64<F296= 3663:725 6; 672 643:6;4 6729 672 ?9=<439:2 :;F>39D?=9;68?3C826;>3D672:;F>29=36?;9;G2B24 ?6 ?= 6; C2 9;625 6736 ?A 672 ?9E<425 ;4 672 52:23=25 G3= 643B288?9@ ;9 672 643?824 72 C2?9@ 3 >24=;9 G7; F3D C2 :;B2425 <9524 <82 )) ;A 672 !;6;4 27?:82= <82= 672 $ 4'& <11== %+8-9*&'=> - 12 - 9=<439:2 ;F>39D F3D 9;6 C2 296?6825 A;4 3 >4;62:6?;9 <95242:6?;9 ,;A672!;6;427?:82=:6 # ?6767?=C3:I@4;<95;A83G826<=2H3F?92672 2B?529:2;942:;45 . 72">4;5<:2536H G;<85?95?:3626736 672 :;F>83?96 G3= A?825 CD ;92 <953>>3 <825 G7; ?= 9;9228=26739672A36724;A67252:23=256?==63625?9 672 :;F>83?96 6736 672 52:23=25 ' 3B? G296 ?9 3 643:6;4 C28;9@?9@ 6; ;92 39@3>>3 35?@24 6 ?= =63625 6736 72 :3F2 6; I9;G 3C;<6 672 3::?5296 ;9 92H6 F;49?9@ 7242A;42724<=7256;672=>;6395:3F26;I9;GA4;F ;92 353=7?B3 G7; G3= 39 2D2G?692== 6736 G729 672 54?B24=6;>>25672643:6;439567252:23=25735@;92A;4 936<42 :388 395 426<4925 72 G3= 3C;<6 6; C;345 672 29@?92 ;A 672 643:6;4 672 54?B24 F;B25 672 B27?:82 ?9 3 92@8?@296 F39924 7242A;42 72 A288 5;G9 395 =<AA2425 7235?9E<4D3955?25 - 13 - $) 72 >24<=38 ;A 672 =>;6 F373L34 G7?:7 ?= 36 H% 38=; =7;G= 6736 672 643:6;4 643?824 <9?6 C234?9@ 2@;'$#'' #'#( G242 36 672 =>;6 G729 672 F373L34G3=:;95<:62572F373L3438=;=6362=6736672 3::?5296 735 ;::<4425 G729 672 52:23=25 426<4925 3A624 672 936<42 :388 395 G3= 3C;<6 6; C;345 672 643:6;4 ;G72422?6724672";4672=>;6F373L34=7;G=6736 >4?;46;=<:7?9:?529667252:23=25G3=643B28?9@;9672 29@?92;A 672 643:6;4;4 G72672472 G3= 643B28?9@ ;9 672 643?824 $ 72 3B3?83C82 2B?529:2 ;4 672 >;8?:2 >3>24= 5; 9;6 F296?;9 3= 6; G7242 72 G3= 643B288?9@ ;4 G7242 72 C;34525672643:6;46?88672=>;6;A6723::?5296 $$ $ G7; :83?F= 6736 72 ?= 39 2D2G?692== =6362= 6736 G729 72 G3= =6395?9@ 9234 672 A?285 ;A ;92 35?F39?67252:23=25G3=;96724;3539572G3=3C;<6 6;C;345672643:6;4643?824<9?6C234?9@2@;'$#'' #'#( 672 54?B24 F;B25672 B27?:82 395672 52:23=25 A288;96724;35395=<AA2425672?9E<4D - 14 - $% 9672:4;=='2H3F?936?;9?6?=28?:?625673672?= A4;F672=3F2B?883@2395727359;6@?B2939D=6362F296 C2A;42 672 >;8?:2 7242 ?= 3C=;8<628D 9; =<@@2=6?;9 6736 67252:23=25735C;34525672643:6;46?=38=;>246?9296 6; 9;62 6736672 62=6?F;9D ;A 672 $ 395 672 5; 9;6 F296?;9 39D67?9@ 3= 6; G726724 672 52:23=25 735 643B2825>4?;46;6723::?5296;967229@?92;A67243:6;4 $ 723C;B22B?529:2:82348D=7;G=673667242?= 9; =<:7 F3624?38 G7?:7 G;<85 2=63C8?=7 6736 >4?;4 6; 672 3::?529667252:23=25735643B2825;967229@?92;A672 643:6;4 736 ?= 3B3?83C82 ;98D ?= 6736 G729 3A624 672 936<42:38867252:23=25G3=3C;<66;C;345672643:6;4 6723::?5296 ;::<4425D 67?= :;<96 672 ?96296?;9 ;A 672 52:23=25 ?= :8234 C<6 672 :;95<:6 ;A 672 54?B24 ;A 672 643:6;4 G;<85 9;6 =7;G 6736 72 735 >24F?6625 672 52:23=25 6; 643B28 ;9 672 29@?92 ;A 672 643:6;4 6 ?= >;==?C82 6736 672 52:23=25 735 643B2825 ;9 672 643:6;4 >4?;46;6723::?5296A;4672643?824G3=38=;3663:7256; 672643:6;4366726?F2;A6723::?5296 - 15 - $ 9524 672=2 :?4:<F=639:2= 672 2B?529:2 3B3?83C82;942:;45?=:823467366723::?5296735;::<4425 G72967252:23=2564?256;C;345;967229@?92C<69;6 43?8249A3:667242?=9;67?9@;942:;456;=7;G673672 735 643B2825 ;9 672 29@?92 ;A 672 43:6;4 >4?;4 6; 672 3::?5296 7?= 3=>2:6 C2?9@ B24D :8234 A4;F 672 2B?529:2 395=<:72B?529:273B?9@9;6:;96435?:625A4;F39D;A672 G?692==2=?6?=5?AA?:<866;7;856736672:83?F?=7?6CD672 >4?9:?>82= 83?5 5;G9 ?9 672 :3=2 ;A 8 97242A;4267?=A3:6<38244;473=C229:;FF?6625 CD6724?C<938 $( 6 ?= 38=; >246?9296 6; 9;62 6736 ?A 672 3::?5296 735;::<4425G7?8267252:23=25G3=384235D;9C;345672 643:6;4 395 ?A 72 G3= 3662F>6?9@ 6; @26 5;G9 A4;F 672 643:6;43956723::?5296735;::<4425672>4?9:?>82=<9524 2:6?;9 2@<836?;9 ;$# G;<85 73B2 C229 F352 3>>8?:3C8229:2672:;9:8<=?;9=423:725CD6724?C<938 6736 672 ?9=<439:2 :;F>39D ?= 9;6 8?3C82 6; >3D 672 :;F>29=36?;9 3>>234= 6; C2 ?9:;442:6 72 ?96296?;9 ;A - 16 - 67282@?=836<42?=6;>4;B?52F3H?F<F:;B246;672B?:6?F= ;A 672 3::?5296 6 C2?9@ 3 C292A?:?38 82@?=836?;9 39 ?9624>42636?;9 ;A 672 3B3?83C82 F3624?38 6736 G;<85 C2 5264?F29638 6; 672 C292A?:?34?2= :399;6 C2 3::2>625 ?F?8348D G729 672 2B?529:2 ?= :8234 6736 672 52:23=25 G3= 64D?9@ 6; C;345 672 643:6;4 672 9=<439:2 ;F>39D :399;62=:3>2?6=8?3C?8?6D6;>3D672:;F>29=36?;9 $, 7242?=3C=;8<628D9;F3624?386736>4?;46;672 3::?529667252:23=25735643B2825;967229@?92;A672 643:6;429:2?6?=728567366724?C<938?=9;6E<=6?A?25?9 A3=629?9@6728?3C?8?6D;96723>>2883967242?9 $# 9 6736 B?2G ;A 672 F36624 A;4 672 3C;B2 =3?5 423=;9= 672 >;?96 43?=25 ?= 39=G2425 ?9 672 92@36?B2 29:26723>>238=<::225=::;45?9@8D672A;88;G?9@ 723>>238?=388;G25 72?F><@925E<5@F296A3=629?9@6728?3C?8?6D;9672 3>>288396';G924;A672B27?:82?==263=?52 - 17 - 72 3>>288396 J ;G924 ;A 672 B27?:82 ?= 2H;9243625 A4;F>3D?9@672:;F>29=36?;96;672>26?6?;924= 72 8?3C?8?6D ?= A3=62925 <>;9 42=>;95296 ; ' 9=<439:2;F>39D 72 9=<439:2 ;F>39D =7388 52>;=?6 672 :;F>29=36?;9 3F;<96 3= 3G34525 CD 672 4?C<938 G?67?93>24?;5;AA;<4G22I=A4;F6725362;A42:2?>6 ;A :;>D;A 67?= E<5@F296 3= >24 2:6?;9 (# %;A 672!;6;427?:82=:6 7242=6;A672;4524>3==25CD6724?C<93842F3?9 <93862425 VII. 72 3F;<96 ?952>;=?6 ?= ;452425 6; C242A<9525 6; 6723>>288396J;G924;A672B27?:82 5 ' $ " & " ?=6; 8;()