Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46686 (KAR)
RAGUNATH S/O SADASHIV NARAYANKAR v. MAHARASHTRA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION
MFA/200392/2023 · 2025-02-18
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46686 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46686 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""
#
$
$ %%&
' ( )
! "
"
"#$%&''%
"
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%& %"
! ''$'%
%()'%( ! %)&%''#
*
+
! ,! ! $ ,! ! "
-./0 12- 3-./4-0 56748-3 .99-./:4; <6/ 12- .99-33.41.4012-3-./4-056748-3<6/12-/-89640-41
-:4; .;;/:-=-0 >? 12- @7.417A 6< 56A9-48.1:64 .B./0-0 :4 6%()'%( >? 12- 3-./4-0 003 -4:6/ :=:3 !70;- .40 -A>-/
.3.>7/.;: 2-/-:4.<1-/ /-<-//-0 16 .8 C12- /:>74.3* <6/ >/-=:1?" 12- 9-1:1:64-/ :8 >-<6/- 12:8 67/1 8--D:4; -42.45-A-416<56A9-48.1:64
- 3 -
&
2- <.517.3 A.1/:E 6< 12- 5.8- B2:52 :8 461 :4 0:8971- >-1B--4 12- 9./1:-8 :8 12.1 64 ')'% B2:3- 12- 9-1:1:64-/ B.8 ;6:4; 64 2:8 5661? 12- >78 >-./:4; 6%$ () 6B4-0 >? 12- /-89640-41 5633:0-0 B:12 12- 1B6 B2--3-/ 6< 12- 9-1:1:64-/ 07- 16 B2:5212-9-1:1:64-/<-3306B4.408781.:4-0:4F7/:-8 2- 9-1:1:64-/ 2.0 8781.:4-0 </.517/- 6< 12- 799-/ -40 6< 12- /:;211:>:..40<-B612-/A:46/:4F7/:-8 2-/-<6/-2-<:3-0 .53.:A9-1:1:64>-<6/-12- /:>74.3 $
2- /:>74.36>8-/=:4;12.1.52./;-82--1B.8 <:3-0 .;.:481 12- 0/:=-/ 6< 12- >78 6B4-0 >? 12- /-89640-412-3012.112-/-B.84-;3:;-45-6412-9./16< 12-0/:=-/ 6< 12- >78 .40 12-/-<6/- <.81-4-0 12- 3:.>:3:1? 6412-/-89640-41169.?12-56A9-48.1:64 2:8.89-51:8 4610:8971-0 ) -./4-0 56748-3 .99-./:4; <6/ 12- 9-1:1:64-/ B673087>A:112.112-@7.417A6<56A9-48.1:64.B./0-0 >?12- /:>74.3:86412-36B-/8:0--96:41867112.112- 0:8.>:3:1? 81.1-0 >? 16 12- -E1-41 6< &G 2.8 461
- 4 -
>--49/69-/3?.88-88-0>?12- /:>74.3.4012-9-1:1:64-/ B.8 . 2-39-/ :4 . 81./ 261-3 .1 74- .40 A6=-A-41 B.8 9./1 6< 2:8 F6> .8 . 2-39-/ .40 .8 8752 12- <7451:64.3 0:8.>:3:1? 6< 12- 9-1:1:64-/ B.8 461 .99/-5:.1-0 >? 12-
/:>74.3 1 :8 87>A:11-0 12.1 12- 9-1:1:64-/ B.8 -./4:4; 8)'''#9-/A6412.40B.8.;-0$?-./8.112-1:A- 6< .55:0-41 .40 12-/-<6/- .0-@7.1- 56A9-48.1:64 >- .B./0-0162:A H -/ 5641/. 3-./4-0 56748-3 .99-./:4; <6/ 12- /-89640-410-<-40812-:A97;4-0F70;A-41>?87>A:11:4; 12.1 12- 0:8.>:3:1? 81.1-0 >? 2.8 >--4 /:;213? .88-88-0 >? 12- /:>74.3 .1 IG 2-/-<6/- 2- 87>A:18 12.1 12-/- :8 46 4--0 <6/ -42.45-A-41 6< 12- 56A9-48.1:64.A6741
2-/-56/08/-=-.312.112-9-1:1:64-/53.:A816 >- . 2-39-/ :4 . 81./ 261-3 .1 74- .40 2- B.8 -./4:4;
8)'''# 9-/ A6412 267;2 12- <.51 12.1 2- B.8 B6/D:4; :4 74- .8 . 2-39-/ 5.4461 >- 0:8971-0 12- 9-1:1:64-/ 56730 2.=- 9/6075-0 0657A-41./? -=:0-45- 16
- 5 -
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
.1 IG 2-/- :8 46 0:85788:64 :4 12- :A97;4-0 F70;A-41 .8 16 26B 12- 0:8.>:3:1? 6< IG :8 .88-88-0 5./-<73 9-/78.3 6< 12- .=65.1:646<12-9-1:1:64-/12.12-B.8.2-39-/:4.81./ 261-3 .1 74- .40 12.1 2- B.8 .;-0 $?-./8 12- :4F7/? 87<<-/-0 >? 2:A :- </.517/- 6< 799-/ -40 6< /:;21 1:>:. 0-<:4:1-3?.<<-5182:89-/<6/A.45- 2-/-<6/-12-<:40:4;6< 12- /:>74.3 12.1 12-/- :8 . <7451:64.3 0:8.>:3:1? 6< IG
- 6 -
2.=:4; 46 F781:<:5.1:64 :1 B6730 >- 9/69-/ 16 .88-88 12- 0:8.>:3:1?<7451:64.30:8.>:3:1?.1%'G ( 4 12.1 =:-B 6< 12- A.11-/ 12- 56A9-48.1:64 740-/ 12- 2-.0 6< 3688 6< <717/- :456A- :8 .88-88-0 .8 8%')'E%E%IE%'GJ8%$''>?.0691:4;12- A731:93.?-/6<%I %' 648-@7-413? 12- 56A9-48.1:64 740-/ 12- 2-.0 6< 3688 6< :456A- 07/:4; 3.:0 79 9-/:60 2.8 16 >- 5648:0-/-0 <6/ . 9-/:60 6< 12/-- A64128 .40 .8 8752 . 87A6<8&')'#:8.B./0-0740-/12-8.:02-.0 %% 2- /:>74.32.8.B./0-0.87A6<8&)'''# 740-/12-2-.06<9.:4.4087<<-/:4;B2:52.99-./816>- 6412-36B-/8:0-.40:8-42.45-0168$''''# % 2- 9-1:1:64-/ B.8 .4 :49.1:-41 <6/ . 9-/:60 6< %$0.?8.40-=-412-412- /:>74.32.8.B./0-0.87A6< 8$(''#740-/12-2-.06<<660.40-E1/.467/:82A-41 .40A-0:5.3.11-40.41B2:52.99-./816>-6412-36B-/ 8:0-.40:8-42.45-0168%)'''#
- 7 -
%& 2-9-1:1:64-/2.8.386>--4.B./0-0.87A6< 8I''' 740-/ 12- 2-.0 6< 564=-?.45- .40 12- 8.A-:8 -42.45-0168%''''# %$ 2- /:>74.32.8.B./0-0.87A6<8I'''# 740-/12-2-.06<36886<.A-4:1:-8:43:<- 2-9-1:1:64-/ 2.816<.5-12->/7416<12-</.517/-6</:;211:>:.<6/12- /-81 6< 12- 3:<- 2-/-<6/- 12- 56A9-48.1:64 740-/ 12- 2-.0 6< 3688 6< .A-4:1:-8 :4 3:<- :8 -42.45-0 16 8&''''# %) 2- 56A9-48.1:64 .B./0-0 >? 12- /:>74.3 740-/ 12- 2-.0 6< A-0:5.3 -E9-48-8 16 12- 174- 6< 8(&$''# 06-8 461 5.33 <6/ .4? :41-/<-/-45- >? 12:8 67/1 %H -45-12-.99-33.41:8-41:13-0<6/12-A60:<:-0 56A9-48.1:64740-/0:<<-/-412-.08.8>-36B
- 8 -
.:4.4087<<-/:4; 8$''''# -0:5.3-E9-48-8 8(&$''# 660-E1/.467/:82A-41.40A-0:5.3 .11-40.41 8%)'''# 64=-?.45- 8%''''# 6886<:456A-07/:4;3.:0799-/:60 8&')'# 6886<<717/--./4:4;8 8%$''# 6886<.A-4:1:-8 8&''''#
61.3 -88.B./0-0>? /:>74.3 42.45-A-41 8$$'))'# 8&$H(''# *#
278 12- .99-33.41 :8 -41:13-0 <6/ -42.45-0 56A9-48.1:646<8(&H)'#B:12:41-/-81 % 2-/-<6/-12-.99-.30-8-/=-816>-.336B-0:4 9./1-45-12-<6336B:4;
:"
2-.99-.3:8.336B-0:49./1 ::"
2- :A97;4-0 F70;A-41 .40 .B./0 9.88-0 >? 12- /:>74.3 :8 A60:<:-0 >? .B./0:4; . 87A6<*#:4.00:1:6416B2.12.8 >--4.B./0-0>?12- /:>74.316;-12-/B:12 :41-/-81.1HG9.</6A12-0.1-6<9-1:1:64 1:33 :18 /-.3:K.1:64 -E5370:4; 12- :41-/-81 <6/
- 9 -
12- 0-3.?-0 9-/:60 6< %I 0.?8 :4 <:3:4; 12- .99-.3 :::"
2- /-89640-41#6/96/.1:64 :8 0:/-51-0 16 0-968:1 12- -41:/- 56A9-48.1:64 .A6741 B:12:4.9-/:606<8:EB--D8</6A12-0.1-6< 12:86/0-/ :=" -81 6< 12- 6/0-/ 9.88-0 >?
12- /:>74.3 /-A.:4874.31-/-0
0# &
$ ( $
:81 6%3 6(