Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46680 (KAR)
IFFCO TOKIO GEN. INS. CO. LTD v. ROOPALI AND ORS
MFA/200412/2021 · 2025-01-30
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46680 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46680 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$
"
"
%
&
! "
"
"
"
#
$%&! '
# #$
$ # ( #
"
$ %%(! (# $) %&(
"
# #
#
$
"
$ %%(! "
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*#$#
$) %&(! ! "
$
")
" )"
$) %&( '
#
$ !+ , %
$
"
! "
"
)
!-
--
"
"
"
$ ) )
$) $)
"
)
#
"
"
(&%
#
" #
"
'%
&
$
"). " )"
- 3 -
$)
#
" /
# '
#
$
! "
"
"
" #
$
%&
$ -
#
"
$ %%(! (# $) %&(
! "# &
# $
"
$ %%(! " *#
$) %&( '
# #$ + , !%
$
"
! "
"
" #$
#
"
)
!-
--
#
"
$) )
"
$)
- 4 -
"
"
") $
"
"0#
) )"
"
"0#
) )"
#123454611789:;1<=74>13:5375?56775:17 !- @5AA17 23
B-- 89 :;1 623C2@5D 132B6 2E2D )=741 537 :;1 B>>2AA2B316 =3716 :;1 >@DB911A B>@13A5:2B3 C: $2<595@=65 FB6 A;B6: GB>>2AA2B316.:;1@1:2:2B3162A81FB61:;2AB=6:23 B 537 :;1 3A=653C1 B>@539 2A 23 B
B6:;1A5H1BFCB3E13213C1:;1@56:21A?B=D7 81 61F16617 :B 5A @16 :;126 653H234 81FB61 :;1 B>>2AA2B316
! ;1 F5C:=5D >5:62I BF :;1 C5A1 2A :;5: :;1 71C15A17 5;571E ?;B ?5A :;1 F5:;16 BF :;1 @1:2:2B316 ?5A531>@DB911BF61A@B3713:B%26535D5E571B3 >B3:;D9 ?541A BF A&% ?B6H234 5A 5 62E16 B3
- 5 -
;15E94BB7ADB6698156234B%%(!35772:2B3 :B :;1 A5D569 ;1 ?5A 5DAB 81234 @527 5 752D9 85:5 BF A% 3 & 5A @16 :;1 23A:6=C:2B3A BF :;1 1>@DB916 61A@B3713: B :;1 71C15A17 5;571E :BBH :;1 A527 DB669 DB5717 ?2:; #545AA1 :B "2@@56542 52@6295 =456 5C:B69 23C1 2: ?5A D5:1 324;:
58B=: @> :;1 1C=62:9 =567 727 3B: 5DDB?
:;1 DB669 :B 13:16 :;1 @61>2A1A BF :;1 F5C:B69 537 =3DB57
;161FB61 :;1 DB669 ?5A @56H17 5: :;1 45:1 537 B3 31I: 759>B63234:;11C=62:9=5675?5H1317:;1762E16FB6 =3DB57234 BF :;1 4BB7A 23:B :;1 F5C:B69 ;1 71C15A17 5;571E 4B: =@ 537 5F:16 F232A;234 >B63234 58D=:2B3A ?;2D1;1?5A:BA:56::;1E1;2CD1A=FF16175>5AA2E1;156:
5::5CH 537 CBDD5@A17 537 7217 ;1 1C=62:9 =567 537 A1E165D B:;16A 45:;1617 537 23FB6>17 :;1 B?316 BF :;1 DB6695375DAB:;1<=62A72C:2B35D@BD2C1 C5A1C5>1:B 81 6142A:1617 23 B 537 :;1 8B79 BF :;1 71C15A17 5;571E ?5A A=8<1C:17 :B @BA: >B6:1> ;1 @BA: >B6:1> 61@B6: ?;2C; 2A 5:
I- 72ACDBA1A :;5: :;1 71C15A17 5;571E 7217 7=1 :B :;1 >9BC56725D 23F56C:2B3
- 6 -
"156:5::5CH ;161FB61:;1@1:2:2B316?;B;5@@13A:B 81 :;1 75=4;:16 BF :;1 71C15A17 5@@6B5C;17 :;1 B>>2AA2B316CB3:137234:;5::;171C15A175;571E?5A 72AC;564234;2A7=:21A5A5762E16=3716:;11>@DB9>13:BF 61A@B3713:B537:;1715:;;57:5H13@D5C17=6234:;1 CB=6A1 537 562A234 B=: BF :;1 1>@DB9>13: BF 61A@B3713: B537:;1612A57261C:31I=A81:?113:;11>@DB9>13: 537:;1715:;BF5;571E
3 A16E2C1 BF 3B:2C1 61A@B3713: BA 537 ! 5@@15617 537 F2D17 :;126 ?62::13 A:5:1>13:A 1A@B3713:
B%2653 5DE571 ?;B 2A :;1 B?316 BF :;1 E1;2CD1 57>2::17:;5:;12A:;11>@DB9165AB375:1BF:;123C2713:
537 :;1 E1;2CD1 ?5A 23A=617 89 61A@B3713: B 537 :;1 @BD2C9 ?5A E5D27 F6B>! :B - "15DAB 57>2::17 :;5: :;1 71C15A17 5;571E ?5A ;2A 1>@DB911 ;1 ;57 @BAA1AA17 5 E5D27 762E234 D2C13C1 537 ;1 ;5A 4B:
A=8A2A:234 CB3:65C: BF 2371>32:9 ?2:; 61A@B3713: B 5DAB ?;B 2A ;2A @61E2B=A @=6C;5A16 ;161FB61 23 C5A1 5 D2582D2:9 562A1A :;1 A5>1 ;5A :B 81 F5A:1317 =@B3
- 7 -
61A@B3713:B"15DAB57>2::17:;5:71C15A175;571E ?5A:;1762E16B3:;1A527E1;2CD1537;1;5781135AH17 :B 4B :B "2@@5642 52@6295 =456 5C:B69 FB6 71D2E16234 #545AA1DB57
& 1A@B3713: B!%3A=653C1 B>@539 713217 :;1 61D5:2B3A;2@ BF :;1 1>@DB911 537 1>@DB916 81:?113 71C15A17 5;571E 537 61A@B3713: B : 5DAB 713217 :;5::;1715:;BF:;171C15A175;571E?5A7=623453723 :;1CB=6A1BF:;11>@DB9>13::?5ACB3:13717:;5::;1 @BD2C9?5A23FB6C1F6B>!:B-8=:2: 2AA=8<1C::B:16>A537CB372:2B3A ;16181234E2BD5:2B3BF :;1 :16>A 537 CB372:2B3A BF :;1 @BD2C9 2: AB=4;: FB6 58ABDE2342:AD2582D2:9
3:;185A2ABF:;158BE1CB3:13:2B3AD156317 B>>2AA2B316F65>17:;1FBDDB?2342AA=1A
! - 8 -
"
#
#
$ %""& %'()*
! *
!+ ,
! '
!-
-
;1 @1:2:2B316 ?5A 1I5>2317 5A 537 :?B B:;16?2:31AA1A?1611I5>23175AA537! IA:B ?161 >56H17 23 :;126 1E2713C1 ;1 BFF2C25D BF 61A@B3713: B!%3A=653C1 B>@539 ?5A 1I5>2317 5A 537 53 BFF2C16 BF :;1 ?5A 1I5>2317 5A IA :B ?161>56H17231E2713C1
( F:16;1562348B:;:;1A271A:;1B>>2AA2B316 53A?1617 2AA=1 BA :B !
23 :;1 5FF26>5:2E1 ;1D7 :;1 ?541A BF 71C15A17 5;571E 5: A- @> 537 71:16>2317 :;1 CB>@13A5:2B3 5: A!&% 537 7261C:17 61A@B3713: B!%3A=653C1 B>@539 :B @59 :;1 A5>1
- 9 -
#1234544621E1789:;1A5>1:;1@1:2:2B3165A ?1DD5A61A@B3713:B!56181FB61:;2AB=6:
;1564=>13:ABFD156317CB=3A1D5@@156234FB6 :;1 @1:2:2B316 537 :;1 D156317 CB=3A1D FB6 61A@B3713: B!%3A=653C1B>@539561;1567
156317 CB=3A1D FB6 :;1 @1:2:2B316 ?;B 2A :;1 5@@1DD53: 23 B A=8>2:A :;5: :;1 B>>2AA2B316 A;B=D7 ;5E1 CB3A271617 :;1 ?541A BF :;1 71C15A17 5;571E 5: A(% @> 5A @16 :;1 3B:2F2C5:2B3 2AA=17 89 :;1 13:65D BE163>13: =3716 1C:2B3#BF:;1
>@DB911AB>@13A5:2B3C: ;161 ?5A3B615AB3FB6:;1B>>2AA2B316:B617=C1:;1?541A :B A-% ?;13 :;1 1>@DB916 BF :;1 71C15A17 ;57 57>2::17 :;5: ;1 ?5A @59234 5 A=> BF A&% @>
;161FB61:B:;5:1I:13:;1@659AFB6>B72F2C5:2B3BF:;1 2>@=4317<=74>13:
16 CB3:65 D156317 CB=3A1D 5@@156234 FB6 61A@B3713:B!%3A=653C1B>@539?;B2A:;15@@1DD53: 23BA=8>2:A:;5::;1@16>2:2AA=17:B
- 10 -
:;1E1;2CD12AA:53723423:;135>1BFB31#5A5E565<537 :;1A527@16>2:?5AA=661371617:B:;1 B3! 537 :;161FB61 5A B3 :;1 75:1 BF 23C2713: :;161 ?5A 3B E5D27 @16>2: 3 :;2A 614567 ;1 61D21A B3
I ! 537 :;1 :1A:2>B39BF "2AA1CB37CB3:13:2B32A:;5::;1612A 3BA=C;61D5:2B3A;2@BF:;11>@DB9165371>@DB911?;2C;
;5A 8113 @6BE17 : 2A 5DD1417 :;5: :;1 @1:2:2B316 537 61A@B3713: B 561 CBDD=7234 ?2:; 15C; B:;16 :B >5H1 =3D5?F=D4523537:;161FB6123:;158A13C1BF5E5D27@6BBF 614567234 :;1 61D5:2B3A;2@ :;1 A5>1 2A 3B: @6BE17 ;1 :;267 CB3:13:2B3 652A17 89 :;1 D156317 CB=3A1D FB6 :;1 3A=653C1B>@5392A:;5::;1612A3B31I=A81:?113:;1 C5=A1BF715:;537:;11>@DB9>13:"161D21AB31C:2B3 !BF:;1
>@DB911AB>@13A5:2B3C::BCB3:137:;5::;1 C5=A5DCB331C:2B381:?113715:;7=1:B;156:5::5CH537 :;11>@DB9>13:2A3B:1A:58D2A;17:2ACB3:13717:;5:23 :;158A13C1BFA=C;31I=A812341A:58D2A;17715:;7=1:B ;156:5::5CHC533B:81:16>175A5CC2713:5DAB5A:B86234 :;1A5>1?2:;23:;15>82:BF5>B:B6E1;2CD1@BD2C92AA=17 89:;13A=653C1B>@539 ;131I:CB3:13:2B3652A1789
- 11 -
:;1D156317CB=3A1D5@@156234FB6:;13A=653C1B>@539 2A :;5: 61A@B3713: B 81234 :;1 @61E2B=A B?316 :;1 @BD2C9?5AA:53723423;2A35>1537:;161812343B@BD2C9 23F5EB=6BF61A@B3713:B:;1B>>2AA2B316?5A16617 23 F5A:13234 :;1 D2582D2:9 B3 61A@B3713: B!%3A=653C1 B>@539537:;161FB61:;12>@=4317<=74>13:2A85723 D5? ! : 2A 3B:2C17 :;5: :;B=4; :;1 @61A13: 5@@15DA ?161 57>2::17 DB34 85CH B3 3B A=8A:53:25D J=1A:2B3BFD5??5AF65>1789:;2AB=6:
F:16 ;156234 :;1 A=8>2AA2B3A 5A 58BE1 :;1 FBDDB?234 A=8A:53:25D J=1A:2B3A BF D5? ?B=D7 562A1 FB6 CB3A27165:2B3
;1:;16 :;1 D156317 B>>2AA2B316 ?5A <=A:2F217 23 ;BD7234 :;5: :;161 1I2A:A 5 31I=A 81:?113:;1715:;BF71C15A175;571E7=1:B ;156:5::5CH537;2A1>@DB9>13:K
15:;16 :;1 B>>2AA2B316 ?5A <=A:2F217 23 617=C234 :;1 ?541A :B A- @> 71A@2:1 :;126 81234 5 3B:2F2C5:2B3 =3716 1C:2B3 #
- 12 -
BF :;1
>@DB911A B>@13A5:2B3 C: 71CD56234 :;1?541A:B81 A(%@>K
!
15:;16 :;1 B>>2AA2B316 ?5A <=A:2F217 23 F5A:13234 :;1 D2582D2:9 B3 61A@B3713: B!% 3A=653C1B>@53989BE16DBBH234:;1@BD2C95:
I 1I:65C: 5:
I 537 :;1 @16>2: 5:
I !K
& ( ;2A B=6: ;57 53 BCC5A2B3 :B 715D ?2:; 5 A2>2D56 C26C=>A:53C1 23 :;1 C5A1 BF
!"#"$ % % &
' F:16 1I5>23234 E562B=A 71C2A2B3A 23EBDE17 23 :;1 >5::16 :;2A B=6:C5>1:B:;1CB3CD=A2B3:;5:?;13:;1B>>2AA2B316 ;57 CB>1 :B :;1 CB3CD=A2B3 :;5: :;1 71C15A17 A=FF1617 ;156: 5::5CH 7=6234 :;1 CB=6A1 BF :;1 1>@DB9>13: :;161 C533B: 81 539 7B=8: :;5: 2: 7B1A 3B: 5>B=3: :B :;1 J=1A:2B3 BF D5? : 2A ?B6:; :B 3B:1 :;5: :;1 D156317 B>>2AA2B316 ;5A C5:14B62C5DD9 CB>1 :B :;1 CB3CD=A2B3 :;5::;1611I2A:A531I=A81:?113:;1C5=A1BF715:;537 :;11>@DB9>13:8E2B=AD92:2A5J=1A:2B3BFF5C:
E13
- 13 -
:;13 :;1 D156317 CB=3A1D 5@@156234 FB6 :;1 3A=653C1 B>@53923A2A:A:;5::;1A527)*++,-81;1567
:2A@16:2313::B3B:1:;5:23:;1<=74>13:BF :;1@1IB=6:23:;1C5A1BF()( * +,() 23@565465@;A537!2:?5AB8A16E175A81DB? .-
, / /
/
0
#
/
#
/
#
/
/
/
%
%
/
& +
0
0 # 1 +2 34( 0 ((5 67 +2((* (8 .+
/
/ /
/
/
1 -(
- 14 -
/
9
,
/
# +
/
,
,
:
/,
/
;
<
/ /
<
/ /
#
= / /
<
> 9#
#
# /
< ; /
#
/
//-
- 15 -
- 3 B:;16 ?B67A 2: 2A 1AA13:25D :;5: :B 1A:58D2A; :;131I=A81:?113:;1;156:5::5CH537:;11>@DB9>13: :;161A;B=D7815D23H234F5C:B6:2A@16:2313::B3B:1:;5:
2: 2A >13:2B317 23 @565 ! BF :;1 @1:2:2B3 :;5: ?;13 :;1 71C15A17762E16?5A58B=::BA:56::;1DB669CBDD5@A17537 7217:2A5DAB>13:2B317:;5:;1;57CB>1:B:;145:1A BF:;1A=456F5C:B69B3:;1@61E2B=A324;:#=::;1612A 3B1E2713C1:BA;B?5A:BFB6?;5:72A:53C1;1;57762E13 :;1E1;2CD1B3:;1@61E2B=A759 ;2A5A@1C:2A3B:1D2C2:17 1E13 23 :;1 C6BAA% 1I5>235:2B3 BF B6 89 61A@B3713: B!%3A=653C1 B>@539 ;16189 2: A;B?A :;5::;1E1;2CD1812345;15E94BB7AE1;2CD12:?5A762E13 89:;171C15A17:2DD:;145:1ABF:;1F5C:B695:58B=: @>23:;1324;: ;1CB>@D523:>13:2B3A:;5:;1C5>1:B :;145:1ABF:;1F5C:B695:@>8E2B=AD9;1;57 762E13 :;1 E1;2CD1 :2DD D5:1 324;: B3 :;1 @61E2B=A 759
;161FB612:2A1E2713::;5::;171C15A175;571EAD1@:23 :;1E1;2CD12:A1DF53723:;1>B63234;1?5A5?5H131789 :;14=567:B4B23A271:;1F5C:B69537=3DB57:;1#545AA1 4BB7A ;2A ?B=D7 A;B?
:;5: 7=6234 :;1 CB=6A1 BF :;1
- 16 -
1>@DB9>13: ;1 ;57 762E13 :;1 E1;2CD1 819B37 :;1 @16>2AA28D1 ;B=6A :;5: :BB :2DD 58B=: @> 23 :;1 324;: ;2A2:A1DFA;B?A:;5::;161?5A5A:61AA537A:6523 FB6;2>
( 3 :;1 C6BAA%1I5>235:2B3 BF 2: 2A 1D2C2:17 :;5: :;1 71C15A17 5;571E ;57 ;156: 61D5:17 2AA=1A FB6 AB>1:2>1 537 :;5: ;1 ?5A 23 :;1 @6BF1AA2B3 BF 762E234 A23C1>B61:;53&9156A3:;1@61E2B=ABCC5A2B3A5DAB ;1;57CB>@D52317BFF;156:8=63234?;2C;2A2372C5:2E1BF ;156:72A15A1 ;161FB612:2A1E2713::;5::;1;156:5::5CH C53E169?1DD81CB331C:17:B;2A@6BF1AA2B3BF762E234
: 2A ?B6:; :B 3B:1 :;5: :;1 <=74>13: BF :;2A B=6: 23 :;1 C5A1 BF ). /0 *
1(2C5:14B62C5DD9D59A7B?3:;5::;1762E234<B8 2A =37B=8:17D9 :13A2B3234 <B8 @56:2C=D56D9 :B CB@1 ?2:;
:;1 @61A13: 759 :65FF2C 537 B:;16 :;234A 537 A:61AA 2A 23EBDE1723:;1<B8
2 ( 5635:5H5&! - 17 -
3 :;5: E21? BF :;1 >5::16 :;1 D156317 B>>2AA2B316 ;5E234 CB>1 :B :;1 CB3CD=A2B3 :;5: :;161 1I2A:A 5 31I=A 81:?113 :;1 C5=A1 BF 715:; 537 :;1 1>@DB9>13:2:812345J=1A:2B3BFF5C:C533B:8113:1617 23:B 537 5A A=C; :;1 CB3:13:2B3 BF :;1 3A=653C1 B>@5392A3B:A=A:52358D123D5? ( B>234 :B :;1 J=1A:2B3 BF 617=C234 :;1 ?541A :B A-% @> 89 :;1 B>>2AA2B316 2: 2A 3117D1AA :B A59 :;5: ?;13 :;161 2A 5 3B:2F2C5:2B3=37161C:2B3#BF:;1
C:2:?5A3B:
?2:;23 :;1 7B>523 BF :;1 B>>2AA2B316 :B 617=C1 :;1 A5>181DB?:;1A5275>B=3:3F5C::;161?5A3BA=C;
1E2713C1 ?;2C; ?B=D7 A;B? :;5: :;1 71C15A17 ?5A @527 B3D9 A-%@>
;1 @6BE2A2B3A BF 1C:2B3 # BF
>@DB911A B>@13A5:2B3C:D597B?3:;5::;113:65DBE163>13:
>59 3B:2F9 F6B> :2>1 :B :2>1 ?541A FB6 :;1 @=6@BA1 BF C5DC=D5:2B3 BF :;1 CB>@13A5:2B3 7>2::17D9 :;1 13:65D BE163>13: ;5A 3B:2F217 :;1 ?541A 5: A(% @16
- 18 -
>B3:; FB6 :;1 @=6@BA1 BF 1C:2B3 BF :;1
>@DB911A B>@13A5:2B3C:"13C1:;1D156317B>>2AA2B316CB=D7 3B: ;5E1 617=C17 :;1 ?541A :B A-% @16 >B3:;
;161FB61:;2AJ=1A:2B3BFD5?2A53A?16175CCB67234D9
! ( 156317 CB=3A1D 5@@156234 FB6 61A@B3713:B!%3A=653C1B>@539CB3:137A:;5::;161 2A 72AC61@53C9 23 :;1 @16>2: 537 :;1 @BD2C9 ;1 @16=A5DBF:;1@BD2C9@6B7=C175:
I ?B=D7A;B?:;5:2:
?5A 2AA=17 23 :;1 35>1 BF 2653 BH=D 5DE571 21 61A@B3713:BB?;161:;2A@BD2C9>13:2B3:;135>1BF 61A@B3713: B : ?5A E5D27 F6B> ! :B - ;1 71C15A17 5;571E 7217 B3 &
;161FB61 :;1 @BD2C9 2AA=17 23 :;1 35>1 BF 61A@B3713: B26535DE571?5A23FB6C1537E5D27
BF565A:;16142A:1617B?316BF:;1E1;2CD12A CB3C16317 53 BFF2C16 BF :;1 ;5A @6B7=C17 G#.
142A:16 1I:65C: BF :;1 E1;2CD1 5:
I ;2A 7BC=>13:
A;B?A :;5: :;1 E1;2CD1 A:537A 23 :;1 35>1 BF 2653 5DE571 21 61A@B3713: B F6B> & 62B6 :B
- 19 -
& 2: ?5A A:537234 23 :;1 35>1 BF B31 =65 ;>57=D2>532?;B2A3B311DA1:;5361A@B3713:B
;161FB61 5A B3 :;1 75:1 BF 23C2713: :;1 E1;2CD1 ?5A 6142A:1617 23 :;1 35>1 BF 61A@B3713: B ;16123 3 5772:2B3:B:;5::;1?62::13A:5:1>13:BF61A@B3713:B A:5:1A :;5: ;1 ;57 53 2371>32:9 54611>13: ?2:; :;1 156D216 B?316 537 B3 :;5: 85A2A :;1 D2582D2:9 ?5A :5H13 BE1689;2> ;161FB61:;1612A3B72AC61@53C92361A@1C: BF:;135>1BF:;16142A:1617B?31623:;161CB67A5DAB
& ;1 :;267 5A@1C: 652A17 89 :;1 D156317 CB=3A1D FB6 61A@B3713: B! % 3A=653C1 B>@539 2A :;5: :;1 @16>2:?;2C;2A5:
I !>13:2B3A:;5:G 1>56HA 16>2:
=6613716 FB6 53C1DD5:2B3 B3 %%!. ;161FB61 2: 2AA=8>2::17:;5::;1@16>2:?5A3B:E5D275375AA=C;:;1 B?316;5A:B81>571D258D1:B@59:;1CB>@13A5:2B3
: 2A @16:2313: :B 3B:1 :;5: :;1 @16>2:
@56:2C=D56A ?161 @6B7=C17 89 ?;B ?5A A=>>B317 5: :;1 23A:53C1 BF 61A@B3713: B!%3A=653C1 B>@539 D5=A1B23
I !A;B?A:;5::;1@16>2:?5AE5D27F6B>
- 20 -
&!:B!&( ;161>56HA23D5=A1B&5A 61@6B7=C17 7B3B:>5H15>1532345A:B?;1:;16 :;1 @16>2: ;BD716 ?5A 5AH17 :B A=6613716 :;1 @16>2: FB6 C53C1DD5:2B3B6:;5:2:?5AA=661371617FB6C53C1DD5:2B3B3 ! B6 ?;1:;16 2: ?5A C53C1DD17 B3 ! ;161FB612:?5A31C1AA569FB661A@B3713:B!%3A=653C1 B>@539 :B 1D2C2: 537 CD562F9 :;1 A5>1 F6B> ?;B ?5A 1I5>2317 5: 2:A 23A:53C1 3 :;1 :1A:2>B39 BF % # 53<=35:; ;1 ;5A 3B: A:5:17 539:;234 58B=: :;1 C53C1DD5:2B33:;1B:;16;537;1A:5:1A:;5::;1@16>2:
?5A 23 :;1 35>1 BF B31 #5A5E565< 5C;5@@5 537 2: ?5A E5D27F6B>&!:B!&("15DABA:5:1A:;5:
1E13 :;1 F2:31AA ?5A 5DAB E5D27 ;161FB61 ?;13 :;1 >153234 BF D5=A1 B& 23
I ! 2A 3B: 1D2C2:17 F6B> :;1 >B=:;BF ?;13;1?5A23:;1?2:31AA8BI5375DAB ?;13 C5:14B62C5DD9 A:5:1A:;5::;1@16>2:?5AE5D27 81:?113&!:B!&(2:C533B:81A527:;5:
:;1 @16>2: ?5A C53C1DD17 3716 :;1A1 C26C=>A:53C1A @B23:B!652A1758BE12A53A?161723:;15FF26>5:2E1
- 21 -
- 3 E21?
BF :;1 58BE1 72AC=AA2B3 :;1 ?541A BF :;1 71C15A17 81234 ;1D7 5: A(% @16 >B3:; :;1 CB>@13A5:2B32AC5DC=D5:175A A(I&LI!-- M A&&(%35772:2B3:B:;5::;1@1:2:2B3162A5DAB 13:2:D17FB65A=>BF A&%:B?567AF=3165D1I@13A1A
;=A:;1@1:2:2B3162A13:2:D17FB65:B:5DCB>@13A5:2B3BF A(%
( ;161FB61 :;1 5@@15D F2D17 89 :;1 @1:2:2B316 23 B71A16E1A:B815DDB?17 23@56:537 :;1 5@@15D F2D17 89 :;1 3A=653C1 B>@539 23 B8123471EB27 BF539 >162:A 71A16E1A :B 8172A>2AA17
"13C1:;1FBDDB?234
2 B F2D17 89 :;1 @1:2:2B316 2A 2
/ 537
B F2D17 89 :;1 3A=653C1 B>@5392A
- 22 -
22
;1 <=74>13: 537 5?567 @5AA17 89 :;1 D156317B>>2AA2B3162A>B72F217 222
;1 @1:2:2B3165@@1DD53: 23
B 2A 13:2:D17 FB6 5 :B:5D CB>@13A5:2B3 BF A(% 5DB34 ?2:; 23:161A:5:L@5F6B>:;175:1BF1I@269 BF ! 759AF6B> :;1 75:1 BF :;1 23C2713: :2DD 2:A615D2N5:2B3 2E 1A: BF :;1 B6716 @5AA17 89 :;1 D156317 B>>2AA2B31661>523A=35D:1617 E 3 E21? BF 72A@BA5D BF :;1 >523 5@@15DA @13723423:16DBC=:B695@@D2C5:2B3A2F5397B 3B:A=6E2E1FB6CB3A27165:2B3
7% . " /
"
# 2A:B DB --