Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46679 (KAR)
MAHALAXMI v. THE KARNATAKA PUBLIC SERVCICE COMMISSION
WP/201012/2025 · 2025-04-04
Chillakur Sumalatha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46679 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46679 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$ % & '
! "
#
$ %
$
"
%
&'(((
# $
&'(((
! ")$ %
® Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
' * #
#
#
#
#
#
$
$ #
#
+)
" +)%
,-./.01-2/-34-.5,-.2,/,206.76328,59:6 .,;.,8,2<8088:39-2,8:9-.05,-.2,/76328,562.,76./ =6.<:,9.0<;,<0<062,.-89,55-8.0.3;-8->-. -<059:6 .,;.,8,2<8.0):38-.,5,-.2,/76328,5=6..,8;62/,2< 68-2/
,,102> - 9.0< 6= 4-2/-438 /0.,7<02> -.2-<-1-
3?507 ,.@07, 644088062 <6 -5569 <:, ;,<0<062,.<6-;;,-.=6.<:,4-02,A-402-<0626=.63;
;68<89:07:-.,87:,/35,/<6?,:,5/=.64(B ( <6
- 3 -
C(B ( -< -5-?3.->0 /3, <6 :,. 4,/07-5 762/0<062 <:089.0<;,<0<06208=05,/
,-.2,/76328,5=6.<:,;,<0<062,.83?40<8<:-< <:, -.2-<-1- 3?507 ,.@07, 644088062 0883,/ 26<0=07-<06202<:,D,-. ( B02@0<02>-;;507-<0628=6.=05502> 3;@-.0638.63;-2/;68<8:,;,<0<062,.83?40<<,/ :,.-;;507-<0628;,.<:,.,7.30<4,2<;.67,887-2/0/-<,8 :-@, <6 =0.8< 75,-. <:, ;.,50402-.D ,A-402-<062 <6 ?, ,50>0?5,=6.<:,4-02,A-402-<062:,;,<0<062,.-;;,-.,/ =6.<:,;.,50402-.D,A-402-<062-2/>6<,50>0?050<D<69.0<, <:, 4-02 ,A-402-<062 :, ;,<0<062,. 02 <:, 4,-2<04, ?,7-4, ;.,>2-2< 69 8:, 08 02 :,. -/@-27,/ 8<->, 6= ;.,>2-27D :, -.2-<-1-
3?507 ,.@07, 644088062 87:,/35,/ <:, 4-02 ,A-402-<062 =6. .63; ;68<8 =.64 (B ( <6C(B ( </,80>2-<,/<:,,A-402-<062 7,2<,.8 -< ,2>-53.3 -2/ :-.9-/ 625D 69,@,. <:, ;,<0<062,. 08 .,80/,2< 6= -5-?3.->0 :, 08 <-102> <.,-<4,2< -< -5-?3.->0 -2/ 67<6.8 -/@08,/ :,. 26< <6 <-1, <.-@,5 :, ;,<0<062,.E8 :,-5<: 9635/ ?, -< .081 02
- 4 -
7-8,<:,;,<0<062,.<-1,83;<.-@,5=6.9.0<02>,A-402-<062 :38 :-@02> 26 6<:,. >6 8:, :-8 =05,/ <:, ;.,8,2< 9.0< ;,<0<062 8,,102> <6 -776446/-<, :,. <6 9.0<, <:, ,A-402-<062-<-5-?3.->0 B ,-.2,/ 76328,5 9:6 08 .,;.,8,2<02> <:, .,8;62/,2<8 83?40<8 <:-< ,A-402-<0628 9055 ?, 762/37<,/ 90<: 8<.07< 8,73.0<D -2/ 32/,. 7-4,.-8 83.@,055-27, :, -.2-<-1-
3?507 ,.@07, 644088062 4-/, -55 -..-2>,4,2<8=6.762/37<02><:,,A-402-<062-<<:,70<0,8 6=,2>-53.3-2/:-.9-/27-8,<:,;,<0<062,.02<,2/8 <6 9.0<, <:, ,A-402-<062 8:, :-8 <6 -<<,2/ <:, -556<<,/ 7,2<,. -2/ -;;,-. =6. <:, ,A-402-<062 #6. <:, 762@,20,27, 6= - 802>5, 7-2/0/-<, -.2-<-1-
3?507 ,.@07, 644088062 7-226< <-1, 3; :,7<07 ,A,.708, 6= 762/37<02> <:, ,A-402-<062 -< -5-?3.->0 -2/ <:,.,=6., <:,9.0<;,<0<0620850-?5,<6?,/084088,/
2/08;3<,/5D -562> 90<: <:, .,7.30<4,2< 26<0=07-<0622687:,/35,08;.6@0/,/>0@02><:,/-<,86=<:, ;.,50402-.D ,A-402-<062 -2/ <:, 4-02 ,A-402-<062 69
- 5 -
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
3. 7632<.D 08 8;,2/02> 7.6.,8 6= .3;,,8 =6. 762/37<02>,5,7<0628-2/?D,,5,7<06280=.,F30.,/3,<6 5-716=;5-2202>-2/@08062;3?507462,D08=.,F3,2<5D;3< <69-8<,3<:,.,08-7-8,9:,.,<-<,83?40<8?,=6., <:08 63.< <:-< 0< 7-226< 8;,2/ 462,D <6 762/37< ,A-402-<062=6.-/,8,.@02>7-2/0/-<,:,4-1,.86=<:,
- 6 -
628<0<3<062 76280/,.02> <:, =-7< <:-< 964,2 .,F30., 8;,70-5 <.,-<4,2< :-@, ,2@08->,/ 32/,. -.< 6= <:, 628<0<3<0627,.<-02;.0@05,>,8,A75380@,5D=6.964,2
D .<075, B 6= <:, 628<0<3<062 6= 2/0- <:, <-<, 08 ;.,@,2<,/ =.64 /,2D02> ,F3-50<D ?,=6., 5-9 6.
,F3-5 ;.6<,7<062 6= 5-98 90<:02 <:, <,..0<6.D 6= 2/0- .<075, "% 6= <:, 628<0<3<062 6= 2/0- ,4;69,.8 <:, <-<,<64-1,8;,70-5;.6@080628=6.964,2-2/7:05/.,2 .<075, ' 6= <:, 628<0<3<062 6= 2/0- 8<-<,8 <:-< <:,., 8:-55 ?, ,F3-50<D 6=6;;6.<320<D=6. -55 70<0G,28 02 4-<<,.8 .,5-<02><6,4;56D4,2<6.-;;602<4,2<<6-2D6==07,32/,. <:,<-<,.<075,C9:07:0802
-.<$6=<:,628<0<3<062 6= 2/0- ,2@08->,8 <:-< <:, <-<, 8:-55 /0.,7< 0<8 ;6507D <69-./88,73.02>0<870<0G,284,2-2/964,2,F3-55D<:, .0>:< <6 -2 -/,F3-<, 4,-28 6= 50@,50:66/ :,8, 8-53<-.D ;.6@0806287-226<?,6@,.5661,/,20-56=6;;6.<320<D<6 <:, ;,<0<062,. 7,.<-025D -4632< <6 @065-<062 6= :,. =32/-4,2<-5.0>:<8>3-.-2<,,/32/,..<075,8B-2/ '6=<:,628<0<3<0626=2/0-
- 7 -
C :, ;,<0<062,. 08 26< .,F3,8<02> <:, 63.< <6 ;,.40<:,.<69.0<,,A-402-<062-<-;5-7,9:,.,<:,.,-., 26 ;3?507 6==07,8 26 ,5,7<.070<D 83;;5D 6. 9:,., 7-4,.-87-226<?,-..-2>,/:,.,<:,.,082,7,880<D<6 -..-2>,7-4,.-8<:,D-.,?,02>-..-2>,/044,/0-<,5D <6 ;.6<,7< 5-9 -2/ 6./,. -2/ 80<3-<0628 -501, :,.,=6., <:0863.<086=<:,@0,9<:-<<:,<-<,7-226</,2D<-102> .,8;6280?050<D <6 762/37< ,A-402-<062 <6 <:, ;,<0<062,. -< <:, 70<D 9:,., 8:, 8<-D8 02 <:, 50>:< 6= <:, H38<0=0-?5, >.632/88:,;.6H,7<,/ ( 2 26.4-5 70.7348<-27,8 7-2/0/-<,8 -., .,F30.,/ <6 -<<,2/ <:, ;5-7, 9:,., <:, ,A-204-<0628 -., 87:,/35,/<6?,:,5/69,@,.02<:,7-8,62:-2/<:, ;,<0<062,.0826<02-;680<062<6<.-@,5,0<:,.<6:-.9-/6. <6,2>-53.3-55<:,9-D=.64-5-?3.->0:,.,=6.,<:08 63.< 08 6= <:, @0,9 <:-< - /0.,7<062 -8 863>:< =6. 08 .,F30.,/ <6 ?, 0883,/ <6 <:, -.2-<-1-
3?507 ,.@07, 644088062<6762/37<<:,,A-402-<062=6.<:,;,<0<062,. - 8 -
-< -5-?3.->0 :08 9.0< ;,<0<062 08 <:,.,=6., /08;68,/ 6== 90<:<:,=6556902>
9.0< 6= 4-2/-438 08 0883,/ /0.,7<02> .,8;62/,2<8 <6762/37<<:,,A-402-<062<6<:,;,<0<062,.-2D9:,.,-< -5-?3.->0-8;,.<:,0.7:607,-2/762@,20,27, :,7,2<.,6=,A-402-<062-<-5-?3.->0?,02<04-<,/ <6<:,;,<0<062,.?D(C(B (
()
&* % ' $
08<656