Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46677 (KAR)
SHANTAYYA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/200952/2025 · 2025-04-03
Chillakur Sumalatha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46677 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46677 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "# $ %$ &
!"#
"#
!"#
$ %
&
'
''
!"#
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
'' !"#
(
'' )###
" '
*
!#
+
!"#
$ % ',&
'
- ' '
'
#(#
'
' ( #(
+
.' +
' '
'
- 3 -
/
%
/
&
0123 24 5167894:; 19461<5 9012:03 =>8:?09 @>2 <50 A24< B0<4<4>:02? 1? A099 1? 9012:03 334<4>:19 >C02:60:< 3C>=1<0 A5> 20B20?0:<? 20?B>:30:< >? 1:3
00D4:; <50 >82< <> E81?5 <50 >2302 <51< 4? 20:30203 7F <50 >82< >@ 4?<24=< 1:3 0??4>:? 83;0 4312 4: >( #( 31<03 #(# <50 B20?0:< A24<B0<4<4>:4?@4903 ( 50@9>A>@0C0:<?4:<50?87G0=<1BB0191201? 8:302 4& 50 B0<4<4>:02? B20@02203 1: 1BB019 8:302 0=<4>: " >@ <50 1:3 =E84?4<4>: =< !H" =51990:;4:; <501A123>@<501:3=E84?4<4>:2478:19519D4 44& 50 B0<4<4>:02? 343 :>< B1F <50 20E84203 >82< @00 50 61<<02A1?704:; B>?<03 @2>6<460 <> <460 @>2
- 4 -
50124:;1:3 <509012:03 3C>=1<0 @>2<50B0<4<4>:02? A1? <1D4:;<460 444& 5061<<02A1?50123>:<50?430>@20?B>:30:< >?( <> >: ## 012:03 =>8:?09 @>2 <50 A24< B0<4<4>:02? 1BB0991:<? ?>8;5< <460 0C0: >: <51< 31F <1<4:;<51<16B90>BB>2<8:4<FA1?192013FB2>C4303<50 >82< B>?<03 <50 61<<02 @>2 G83;60:< <> #"#"# >A0C02 94702<F A1? ;21:<03 <> <50 B0<4<4>:02? <> @490 A24<<0:12;860:<?1:3B1F30@4=4<>82<@00 4C& 50 >2302 31<03 ## 7F A54=5 <50 61<<02A1?B>?<03@>2G83;60:<<>#"#"#A4<594702<F <><50B0<4<4>:02? 1BB0991:<?<>@490A24<<0:12;860:<?1:3 B1F30@4=4<>82<@00A1?=51990:;0370@>20<54?>82<7F @494:;1A24<B0<4<4>:C430>##H # C& 54?>82<34?B>?03>@<50?143A24<B0<4<4>:>:
#"#(# B0264<<4:; <50 B0<4<4>:02? 1BB0991:<? <> B1F 30@4=4<>82< @00>A0C02<50B0<4<4>:02? A0203420=<03 <>B1F<50>82<@00A4<54:1B024>3>@>:0A00D@2>6<50
- 5 -
31<0 >@ <50 >2302 50F A020 19?> B0264<<03 <> 13320?? >21912;860:<? " 012:03=>8:?09@>2<50B0<4<4>:02??8764<?<51< <50 B0<4<4>:02? B143 <50 >82< @00 1:3 ?>8;5< <460 <> 12;80 <50 61<<02 78< <460 A1? :>< 1==>2303 @>2 13C1:=4:;12;860:<?1:3<50>82<B>?<03<5061<<02@>2 G83;60:<<>#"#"#1:31;;240C037F<50?160<50 B20?0:<A24<B0<4<4>:4?@4903
? B02 <50 >2302 >@ <54? >82< 4: >##H # <50 B0<4<4>:02? A020 8:302 >794;1<4>: <> B1F <50 30@4=4< >82< @00 A4<54: 1 B024>3 >@ >:0A00D@2>6<5031<0>@<50?143>230250>2302A1? 20:30203>:#"#(#5020@>20<50B0<4<4>:02??5>893 51C0 30B>?4<03 <50 30@4=4< >82< @00 >: >2 70@>20 #(#>A0C02061:321@<@>230B>?4<>@>82< @00 A1? <1D0: >: ##(## 58? 4< 4? =9012 <51< <50 B0<4<4>:02? 51C0 :>< B143 <50 30@4=4< >82< @00 A4<54: <50 <460 ;21:<03 7F <54? >82< 50 46B8;:03 >2302 20C019? <51< <50 BB0991<0 >82< 0IB20??03 4<? C40A <51< <5>8;5
- 6 -
>82<@00A1?:><B143A4<54:<50<460;21:<031:3<5>8;5 4< 51? :> 18<5>24<F <> ;> 70F>:3 <50 >2302 >@ <50 4;5 >82<>@12:1<1D1F0<<>;4C01:>BB>2<8:4<F<50>82< @00B1434?1==0B<035046B8;:03>230219?>20C019?<51< 9012:03=>8:?09@>2<50A24<B0<4<4>:02?1;14:B21F03<460 @>213C1:=4:;12;860:<?>A0C02<5061<<02A1?D0B< 1?4301:3A1?1;14:=199031<(B6<>@1=494<1<0<50 B0<4<4>:02? <> 13C1:=0 12;860:<? >A0C02 9012:03 =>8:?09 @>2 <50 A24< B0<4<4>:02? @4903 1 606> <51< 0:4>2 >8:?0951?<>12;80<5061<<02
IB20??4:;4<?C40A<51< <50>82<3>0?:><@4:31:F;2>8:3<>0I<0:3@82<502<460 <50 61<<02 A1? B>?<03 @>2 G83;60:< <> #"#"# ;21:<4:;94702<F<><50B0<4<4>:02?<>@490A24<<0:12;860:<? 7F !#(# : <54? 31F 9012:03 =>8:?09 @>2 <50 A24< B0<4<4>:02?
?8764<? <51< A24<<0: 12;860:<? 120 :>< @4903 51< B20C0:<03 <50 B0<4<4>:02? <> @490 <50 A24<<0:
12;860:<? 4? :>< ?<1<03 4D0A4?0 A51< B20C0:<03 <50 9012:03=>8:?09@>2<501BB0991:<?<>61D054??8764??4>:
70@>20<50>82<>:01=51:30C02F>BB>2<8:4<F;21:<034? :><=9124@403<901?<A50:<54?>82<;21:<03>BB>2<8:4<F
- 7 -
<><50B0<4<4>:02?<>12;80<50=1?0A54=54?0C430:<@2>6 <50>2302?4:>##H #<50B0<4<4>:02??5>893 51C0 <1D0: ?<0B? <> ?8764< <5042 =>:<0:<4>:? 50 B0<4<4>:02?343:><3>?>2>??:0;94;0:=0>:B12<>@<50 B0<4<4>:02? 4: B82?84:; <50 61<<02 =1::>< 70 =>:3>:03 <460 1:3 1;14: 58? <50 A24< B0<4<4>: 17?>98<09F 91=D? 6024<? >A0C02 <> ;4C0 @142 >BB>2<8:4<F <> <50 B0<4<4>:02? <> 61D0 <5042 ?8764??4>: 4: <50 @>26 >@ 12;860:<? <54? >82< =>:?4302? 30?421790 <> ;4C0 >:0 6>20>BB>2<8:4<F ) 5020@>20 <50 A24< B0<4<4>: 4? 34?B>?03 >@ A4<5 <50@>99>A4:;
4& 50 B0<4<4>:02? 120 B0264<<03 <> @490 <5042 A24<<0:12;860:<?7F#-#"# 44& 50>82<>@4?<24=<1:30??4>:?83;04312 4?3420=<03<>20=04C0<50A24<<0:12;860:<?4@ 1:F@49037F<50:1:3<50201@<02<>B2>:>8:=0 <50G83;60:<A4<54:201?>:1790<460
- 8 -
444& : <50 94;5< >@ ;2>?? :0;94;0:=0 >: <50 B12< >@ <50B0<4<4>:02?4:B82?84:;<5061<<021:31?4< 4? @>8:3 <51< <50 B0<4<4>:02? 51C0 :>< >:9F A1?<03<50<460>@<50BB0991<0>82<78<19?> <50 4;5 >82< 7F @494:; <A> A24< B0<4<4>:? B0264??4>: <> @490 <50 A24<<0: 12;860:<? 4? 1==>2303>:B1F60:<>@=>?<?>@?#### .<> <50 4?<24=< 0;19 02C4=0? 8<5>24<F 4312 :9F >: B2>38=4:; ?8@@4=40:< B2>>@ 20;1234:;
B1F60:< >@ =>?<? <50 A24<<0: 12;860:<? 4@ 1:F@4903700:<02<14:03 4C& 0;4?<2F <> =>668:4=1<0 <50 >2302 <> <50 =>:=02:03>82<4660341<09F
'(
%) $ & #
4?<>9>#