- 1 - ! "#!$ #$ %&'%()*+ %)) , ! "# $ ## % & # # ## & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ' ()' "# $ #&* &% # & ) & # # # ''' & & ## # '' ' # & + $# + % ,-./ 01 -203 4,-.5,/ 67859,4 -::,-.35; <7. 1=, :,131375,. 4,-.5,/ # <7. 1=, .,9:75/,51 7 -5/ .3 =-1, 4,-.5,/ 67859,4 -::,-.35; <7. 1=, /,(<-617 670:4-35-51 .,9:75/,51 7 - 3 - =39 .,>39375 :,131375 39 <34,/ ?31= 1=, <7447?35; :.-@,. !! "# " $%& '!!( )) * + " $ ,# -. # + " - / "0 =,<-61935A.3,<?=36=-.,8107915,6,99-.@<7. /39:79-47<1=,.,>39375:,131375-.,-985/,. 670:4-351 6-0,17 A, 47/;,/ ?31=805-A-/ #7436, A@ 1=, .,9:75/,51 7(3.3B- 6751,5/35; 1=-1 =,.9,4< -5/ =,. =89A-5/ =3>-:81.- 3.-/-. ?,., ,C35; 781 1=,3. 43>,43=77/ A@ 67743, ?7.C -5/ 1=,@ =->, 1=.,, 6=34/.,5 A@ 5-0, 5B-5,@- ,,.,9= D ,/ #.-C-9= -5/ =-;@-9=.,, =,@ =-/ - /39:81, ?31= .,;-./ 17 - 1-34,/ .77< =789, ?31= 1=,3. 678935 A.71=,.9 5 ''' .3 -53C 7 =3>-.-0 :36C,/ 8: - E8-..,4 ?31= .,;-./ 17 1=, 30:.7:,. /391.3A81375 7< 1=, 4-5/ <1,. - ?=34, ?3<, 7< .3 -53C >3931,/ 1=, =789, 7< 1=, 670:4-35-51 -475; ?31= =,. 9759 - 4 - .39=5--5/3B-@C80-.-5/=,.=89A-5/-5/:36C,/8:1=, E8-..,4 ?31= 1=, <-034@ 0,0A,.9 ,. A.71=,.(35(4-? A@ 5-0,-443C-.B851.3,/17:-63<@1=,E8-..,4A@9-@35;1=-131 39 - 899-.- <,913>-4 /-@ -5/ 1=,@ 9=784/ 571 E8-..,4 ?31= ,-6=71=,.-5/-/>39,/1=,017;7-?-@<.701=,=789,1 1=-1 B85618., 1=, 9,675/ 975 7< 1=, 670:4-35-51 5-0,4@ ,,.,9= D ,/ #.-C-9= ?-9 931135; 5,-. 1=, 781,. /77. 7< 1=,=789,-5/1=,-6689,/ 7(=-C851-4-:844,/1=,=-5/9 7< ,,.,9= -5/ 1=.7?5 -?-@ =30 75 - 9175, ,. 6=34/.,5 .39=5--5/3B-@-C80-.C36C,/1=,9757<1=,670:4-35-51 11=-1B85618.,1=,=89A-5/7<1=,-6689,/ 7(-53C174/ 1=, 71=,.9 1=-1 1=, 0,0A,.9 7< 1=, <-034@ 7< 1=, 670:4-35-519=784/571A,4,<1-475,-5/35913;-1,/71=,.917 1-C,-?-@1=,43<,7<,,.,9=D,/#.-C-9= =,A.71=,.(35( 4-?7<1=,670:4-35-51-443C-.B858564,7<1=,670:4-35-51 #85/-43C -5/ A.71=,. 7< 1=, 670:4-35-51 >35-9= 1.3,/ 17 :-63<@1=,E8-..,4-11=-1B85618.,9757<1=,-6689,/ 7( .39=5-177C-C53<,-5/-99-841,/=,.@785;,.A.71=,. ,6-89, 7< 1=, -99-841 -5/ 1=.7?35; -?-@ 1=, 9,675/975 7< 1=, 670:4-35-51 A,6-0, 85675963789 -5/ =, - 5 - ?-9 1-C,5 17 1=, 7>,.50,51 79:31-4 <7. 1.,-10,51 =, 7617.9 ?=7 ,2-035,/ 1=, 9,675/ 975 7< 1=, 670:4-35-51 /,64-.,/1=-1=,395707., -9,/ 75 1=, 670:4-351 1=, #7436, =->, .,;391,.,/ 1=, 6-9, 35 .30, 7! ' <7. 1=, 7<<,56,9 :8539=-A4,85/,.,613759''F-5/'.,-/ ?31=,613757<#-5/35>,913;-1,/1=,0-11,.-5/<34,/ 6=-.;,(9=,,1 F =,:,131375,.9=,.,35<34,/-5-::436-13759,,C35; /396=-.;, 75 1=, ;.785/ 1=-1 1=, /,-1= 7< ,,.,9=D ,/ #.-C-9=177C970,?=,.,,49,-5/357./,.17=->,-58::,. =-5/ 35 1=, 63>34 /39:81, - <-49, 6.3035-4 6-9, =-9 A,,5 <7391,/ -;-3591 1=, :,131375,. =, -::436-1375 9,,C35; /396=-.;,?-97::79,/A@1=,:.79,681375A@<3435;/,1-34,/ 7AB,613759 G ,-.5,/ 1.3-4 8/;, -<1,. =,-.35; 1=, :-.13,9 /390399,/1=,-::436-13759,,C35;/396=-.;,7<1=,:,131375,.9 <.70 1=, 6.3035-4 6-9, ,35; -;;.3,>,/ A@ 1=, 9-0, 1=, :,131375,.9-.,A,<7.,1=3978.1351=39.,>39375:,131375 - 6 - ) ,-.5,/67859,4<7.1=,.,>39375:,131375,.901 -203 >,=,0,514@ 6751,5/,/ 1=-1 75 -667851 7< - 63>34 /39:81,-075;1=,:,131375,.9-5/1=,670:4-35-51:-.1@-5 855-18.-4/,-1=7<1=,9,675/9757<1=,670:4-35-51?=36= =-97668..,/,49,?=,.,=-9A,,50-/,-9-177417<7391- <-49,6.3035-46-9,-;-35911=,:,131375,.9=,.,35357./,.17 1-C, 8::,. =-5/ 35 1=, :,5/35; 63>34 /39:81, 9 986= 1=, :,131375,.9-.,35576,51?=36==-9A,,53;57.,/A@1=,1.3-4 8/;,?=34,/39039935;1=,-::436-13759,,C35;/396=-.;,-5/ 1=89978;=1<7.-447?1=,.,>39375:,131375 ! ,-./ 1=, 4,-.5,/ 67859,4 -::,-.35; <7. 1=, :,131375,.94,-.5,/# 7-5/ .3=-1,4,-.5,/ 67859,4-::,-.35;<7.1=,.,9:75/,51 7 ' =,@ ?784/ <8.1=,. 6751,5/ 1=-1 1=, /,<,56, 7< 35576,56, 39 17 A, ,91-A439=,/ /8.35; 1=, 1.3-4 -<1,. 1=, :.79,681375:4-6,91=,67;,51,>3/,56,75.,67./ =,@ ?784/ -497 6751,5/ 1=-1 1=, 6=-.;,(9=,,1 0-1,.3-49351=,<7.07<:79107.1,0.,:7.1-5/91-1,0,519 7<?315,99,935648/35;1=,35B8.,/?315,99?=739-@785;,. - 7 - A.71=,. 7< 1=, 670:4-35-51 ?784/ A, 98<<363,51 ,578;= 17 :.76,,/?31=1=,6.3035-46-9,A@<.-035;5,6,99-.@6=-.;,9 -5/1=,.,<7.,978;=1<7./390399-47<1=,.,>39375:,131375 ->35; =,-./ 1=, -.;80,519 <.70 A71= 93/,9 :,.89,/ 1=, 0-1,.3-49 75 .,67./ 0,136847894@ 5 986= :,.89-4 7< 1=, 0-1,.3-4 31 39 6.@91-4 64,-. 1=-1 1=,., 39 57 4799 7< 130, 35 -::.7-6=35; 1=, :7436, A@ 1=, 670:4-35-51 =, 3563/,51 9-3/ 17 =->, 7668..,/ 75 1=, 899-.- &,913>-4 /-@31=-<785/=7:,1=-11=,9,675/9757<670:4-35-51 ?784/A,-43>,1=,670:4-35-51.89=,/171=,=79:31-4-<1,. 1=, 3563/,51 -475; ?31= -443C-.B85 -5/ 71=,.9 =, 7617.9 -17>,.50,5179:31-4,2-035,/1=,@785;A7@,,.,9=D ,/#.-C-9=-5/<785/1=-1=,=-/A.,-1=,/=394-91-43114, ?=34,-;7 ->35; 57136,/ 1=, 9-0, 1=, 3563/,51 ?-9 -497 .,:7.1,/171=,B8.39/36-1375-4:7436,1=.78;=-0,/3674,;-4 6-9, .,:7.1 =, :7436, 300,/3-1,4@ -..3>,/ -5/ 177C 1=, 91-1,0,517<1=,670:4-35-51-5/1=,5.,;391,.,/1=,6-9, =, 9,E8,56, 7< ,>,519 1=89 ?784/ 64,-.4@ 35/36-1, 1=-1 - 8 - =-./4@1=,.,?-9-5@967:,<7.1=,670:4-35-5117677C8:- <-49, 6-9, -;-3591 1=, :,131375,.9 =,.,35 35 7./,. 17 1-C, - 8::,.=-5/351=,:,5/35;63>34:.76,,/35;9 , 31 ?=-1 31 0-@ 1 39 <7. 1=, 1.3-4 78.1 17 67593/,. 1=,9, -9:,619 /8.35; 1=, 1.3-4 =, :.30-(<-63, 0-1,.3-49 35 1=, <7.0 7< :79107.1,0 .,:7.1 7< ,,.,9= D ,/#.-C-9=35B8.@6,.13<36-1,7<A.71=,.7<1=,670:4-35-51 A,35;1=,:-.17<1=,6=-.;,(9=,,10-1,.3-49-:-.1<.709:71 0-=-H-. -5/ 71=,. 0-1,.3-49 75 .,67./ ?784/ :.30-(<-63, 0-C,781-6-9,<7.<.-035;7<1=,6=-.;,9-5/:.76,,/35; ?31=1=,1.3-4-;-35911=,:,131375,.9 =,;.785/98.;,/351=,.,>39375:,131375-.,35 1=, 5-18., 7< /,<,56, ?=36= 6-5571 A, 67593/,.,/ A@ 1=39 78.1-11=3991-;,A@=74/35;-03531.3-4-9=74/35;-0353 1.3-4 39 /,:.,6-1,/ 35 1=, 0-11,. 7< 1=39 5-18., 1=.78;= 6-1,5-7< 8/;0,5197<1=,75IA4,:,278.1 F 8<<36, 17 9-@ 1=-1 1=, 0-1,.3-4 75 .,67./ ?784/ A, 98<<363,51 ,578;= 17 :.76,,/ -;-3591 1=, :,131375,.9 <7. 1=,-44,;,/7<<,56,9-5/3139<7.1=,:.79,68137517,91-A439= - 9 - 1=, 6-9, A@ :4-635; 67;,51 ,>3/,56, 75 .,67./ -5/ :,131375,.9?344=->,1=,3.6=-56,17:818:1=,3.6-9,351=, <7.0 7< 6.799(,2-035-1375 17 1=, :.79,681375 ?315,99 -5/ -497 17 :4-6, 986= 71=,. 0-1,.3-4 ?=36= -., <->78.-A4, 17 1=,0351=,1.3-4 G 5>3,?7<1=,-A7>,/396899375/390399-47<1=, -::436-1375 9,,C35; /396=-.;, A@ 1=, 4,-.5,/ 1.3-4 8/;, 39 B891-5/ :.7:,. ?=36= .,E83.,9 57 351,.<,.,56, 1=-1 177 35 1=, 43031,/ 967:, 7< .,>39375-4 B8.39/361375 667./35;4@ 1=, <7447?35;7./,. $3% =,,>39375:,131375390,.314,99-5/39 =,.,A@/390399,/ $33% 1 39 0-/, 64,-. 1=-1 1=, 7A9,.>-13759 0-/,A@1=3978.1/8.35;1=,678.9,7<1=397./,. 9=-44 571 -<<,61 1=, .3;=19 7< 1=, :-.13,9 35 1=, :,5/35;1.3-43575,?-@7.1=,71=,. -* %$) ! 391 74 7 #