- 1 - ! "#" $ %&# "' %&# # $$( ) * ! " # $ ! ! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % $ $ %! ! & '( ) * + , -!$!# . " -!$!# . & -!$!# - 3 - ' ,, -!$!# ) *", + /// , , , %#0# " #%# , , ,"' + , 1 , , , 2 %#0# " #%# , " 3" 3"" - 4 - #& * 3"+ 45 675859: 7;: 665<= 4<8 >559 ?;=5@ >A :45 =<9@ BC9578 D<==;9E ;9 FG58:;B9 :45 B7@57 @<:5@ %#0# 6<885@ ;9 B#%# C4575>A :45 =5<795@;9E=5"G@E54<@@;8H;885@:457;:5:;:;B9?;=5@ >A:4565:;:;B9578 456<7:;58<7575?5775@:B<8657:45;77<9I8;9 :45C7;:67BD55@;9E8 45 65:;:;B9578 4<@ ?;=5@ B#%# 855I;9E?B7;88G<9D5B?<C7;:;9:459<:G75B?H<9@<HG8 :B@;75D::457586B9@59:G:4B7;:;58:B75:<;9:459<H5B? 65:;:;B9578;975865D:B?=<9@;9G7J5AB!:B:455K:59: B? ## <D75 $ EG9:<8 B? <9@;IBB7 ;==<E5 <=<>G7<E; ;8:7;D: B7 ;9 :45 <=:579<:;J5 :B @;75D: :45 7586B9@59: G:4B7;:;58 :B ;9;:;<:5 <DFG;8;:;B9 67BD55@;9E8 :<I;9E 9B:5 B?:45LG@EH59:B?;J;=BG7:<9@8GD4<DFG;8;:;B9:B>5 :<I59 ;9 :57H8 B? ;E4: :B ,<;7 BH6598<:;B9 <9@ - 5 - 7<986<759DA ;9 <9@ DFG;8;:;B9 54<>;=;:<:;B9 <9@ 585::=5H59: D: # <9@ 6<A DBH6598<:;B9 C;:4 <== 8:<:G:B7A>595?;:8 : ;8 :45 D<85 B? 65:;:;B9578 :4<: :45A <75 :45 BC9578 B? =<9@ ;9 G7J5A B! H5<8G7;9E $ <D758 $ EG9:<8 B? <9@;IBB7 ;==<E5 <=<>G7<E; ;8:7;D: : ;8 ?G7:457D<85B?65:;:;B9578:4<::45:<:5?B7:456G76B85B? DB98:7GD:;B9B?L<;=E<7@594<@;88G5@<9B:;?;D<:;B9G9@57 5D:;B9 *+B?:45<9@DFG;8;:;B9D:$0 C;:475865D: :B<95K:59:B?%<D758#EG9:<8:;88G>H;::5@:4<: 8G??;D;59DA B? DBH6598<:;B9 C<8 :<I59 G6 ;9 75?5759D5 67BD55@;9E8;9B#0#$ ! :;88G>H;::5@:4<::45<DFG;8;:;B967BD55@;9E8 C575 ;9;:;<:5@ ;9 :45 A5<7 0% <9@ 8G>85FG59:=A <9 5K:59: B? ## <D75 $ EG9:<8 B? =<9@ C<8 75:<;95@ >A :45H;9:458<H58G7J5A9GH>57875E<7@88GD4=<9@ B $%00 C<8 ?;=5@ <E<;98: :45 7586B9@59: :<:5 855I;9E:4575=;5?B?H<9@<:B7A;9LG9D:;B9C4;D4D<H5:B >5@5D755@ - 6 - : ;8 8G>H;::5@ :4<: <9 5K:59: B? ## <D75 $ EG9:<8 4<8 <=8B >559 G:;=;M5@ :4BGE4 9B: <DFG;75@ <9@ <DDB7@;9E=A:45C7;:65:;:;B9D<H5:B>5?;=5@855I;9E?B7 :4575=;5?<88BGE4:?B7 % : ;8 8G>H;::5@ :4<: :45 =5<795@ ;9E=5 "G@E5 4<8 @;8H;885@ :45 C7;: 65:;:;B9 C4;=5 B>857J;9E :4<: <DFG;8;:;B9B?=<9@?B759:7<="<;=C;:475865D::B%<D758 #EG9:<8<9@:4BGE4B>857J5@:4<:##<D75$EG9:<8 4<@>559G:;=;M5@?B7:456G76B85B?G=><7E<&"5C<7E;<;9 B<@@;@9B:;88G5<9A@;75D:;B9:B8<?5EG<7@:4567B657:A 7;E4:8;9:458<;@5K:59:B?##<D75$EG9:<8EE7;5J5@ >A8GD4B7@57:45675859:<665<=4<8>559?;=5@ $ : ;8 :B >5 9B:;D5@ :4<: <@H;::5@=A C4<: C<8 <DFG;75@ >A J;7:G5 B? 9B:;?;D<:;B9 G9@57 5D:;B9 *+ ?B7 :45 6G76B85 B? 59:7<= 7;8B9 C<8 B9=A <9 5K:59: B? % <D758#EG9:<8C;:475865D::BC4;D4:4575;89B@;86G:5 BC5J57 :45 FG58:;B9 ;8 <8 75E<7@8 :B 75H<;9;9E ## <D75$EG9:<8 45<DFG;8;:;B967BD55@;9E8 C575;9:45 A5<7 0% ?B7 <9 5K:59: B? % <D758 # EG9:<8 9 :45 - 7 - A5<700 B $%00D<H5:B>5?;=5@<9@:458<;@ 8G;: D<H5 :B >5 @5D755@ C;:4 75865D: :B ## <D75 $ EG9:<875:<;95@>A:45=<9@BC957C;:4<?G7:457@;75D:;B9 :B <DFG;75 ## <D75 $ EG9:<8 ;9 G7J5A B! B? <9@;IBB7 ;==<E5 <=<>G7<E; ;8:7;D: ;9 <DDB7@<9D5 C;:4 :45 67BJ;8;B98 B? <9@ DFG;8;:;B9 D: $0 GD4 67BD55@;9E89B:4<J;9E>559;9;:;<:5@:4565:;:;B9578C575 DB98:7<;95@:B?;=5:457;:5:;:;B9 0 45=5<795@;9E=5"G@E54<89B:;D5@:455K:59: B?<DFG;8;:;B9>5;9E%<D758#EG9:<8<9@:4<:75H<;9;9E =<9@B?##<D75$EG9:<84<8>559G:;=;M5@?B77B<@<9@ 75DB7@8:<9@8;9:459<H5B?:45BJ579H59: BC5J57< ?G7:457?;9@;9EBGE4::B4<J5>55975DB7@5@75E<7@;9E:45 DB9:59:;B9:4<:=<9@G:;=;M5@?B7:457B<@4<8>559G:;=;M5@ C;:4BG:<DFG;8;:;B9 98GD4E7BG9@:45B7@57;9:45C7;: 67BD55@;9E875FG;758;9:57?5759D5 # G7;9E :45 659@59DA B? 675859: 67BD55@;9E8 :45 BG7: 4<@ @;75D:5@ DB9@GD:;9E B? 8G7J5A <8 657 :45 B7@57 6<885@ B9 # G>85FG59:=A ;: <665<78 - 8 - :4<:8G7J5A4<8>559DB9@GD:5@<9@:45=5<795@@@;:;B9<= BJ579H59: @JBD<:5 4<8 ?;=5@ < H5HB <=B9EC;:4 @BDGH59:8 B9 # <9@ 67B@GD5@ DB6A B? :45 8I5:D4 @<:5@ # 657G8<= B? :45 8I5:D4 C;:4 5K6=<9<:;B9 CBG=@ >5 B? 75=5J<9D5 <9@ :45 8<H5 ;8 7567B@GD5@4575;9>5=BC& !"#$%&'()#* +! ,-./.,-001211113432411213 $5 . ! 678 "9: ! ; <= 1222431213#*>) ?7@ABC. 1. %& # D+ , C #* *C . . $ABEC $ F ) DBC. G;H$ABE I $ABE J J J J A J J 1K1K 23 22 213 1K23 - 9 - 0. LM N B #N MC C O P OEQ +BRS0 L; 0'%T R20RS0#* *C. .U@. . $ABEKVJWB@. .0$ABEVXJY3 ZBX[Y2 ZI(W 101VJWG;H$ABE1S2VJWO$ %& 8' BC. 3. *C. .ULMN B#NMC C1S2VJW O$ %& 8' #\A \C] "C $ABE K VJW O$7 U V. . @^ 1W[C_* #;HECI!C](C BC. @ %& CI) 7C`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