- 1 - ! ""#" $"% & ! " # $ ! %&!'! ! %& ! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %&!'! %& " # ( $ ( ( )* ( *'*'& ( ( & '+ ( (( ( ( , ! #, $ -./ 011203 ./ 4567 8-2 9:;<72=8 0=; ;2>522 ;082; *'*'& 10//2; ?@ 8-2 2=.65 .A.3 :;<2 08 2B05<. #-252.=048255242552;860/C8-25.036:58D465?52A.8@$.= 6& '+;./7.//.=<8-2/:.84651058.8.6= - 3 - -2130.=8.44/>30.78-088-2@0528-2>-.3;52=64 6=22230770-2<2=2036<@4:5=./-2;?@8-2130.=8.44/ ./0/:=;25 ! >>65;.=< 86 8-2 130.=8.44/ 6=2 0;.<2110 B0/ 8-2 15616/.8:/ 0=; 030770 B0/ -./ B.42 -2 130.=8.44/ >30.7 8-08 8-2 15616/.8:/ 0;.<2110 -0; 8B6 ;0:<-825/ 0=; 6=2 /6= 2230770 8-2 130.=8.44/D 768-25 ./ /0.; 86 ?28-24.5/8;0:<-82564/0.;0;.<2110E-0==07708-2 /2>6=; ;0:<-825 ./ =68 70;2 0 1058@ 86 8-2 /:.8 0/ /-2 Neelamma (Dead) Chennamma (Dead) Basavaraj (Deft.No.1) Karanamma (D-2) Sharnamma (Ptft) Malamma (D-3) Chandamma (D-4) shantamma (P-2) Gadigeppa Bankur (Dead) Malamma (Wife /Dead) - 4 - ;.2; .//:232// 0=; 0/0A0509 8-2 6=3@ /6= 64 0;.<2110 -0/0550@2;0/;242=;0=86-2130.=8.44/-0A20550@2; 8-2;0:<-825/642230770.28-2/./825/64130.=8.44/0/ ;242=;0=86/86 0/8-2@52152/2=8.=<8-2?50=>-64 2230770 -2 130.=8.44/ >30.7 8-08 8-252 ./ =6 1058.8.6= 04825 8-2 ;208- 64 0;.<2110 030770 0=; 2230770 //:>-8-2@>30.78-088-2/0.;1561258.2/0528-296.=8 407.3@ 1561258.2/ 0=; >30.72; 8- /-052 .= 8-2 /:.8 />-2;:321561258.2/ -2 ;242=;0=8/ >6=82/82; 8-2 /:.8 0=; >30.7 8-08 2230770 ./ =68 8-2 ;0:<-825 64 0;.<2110 -2 ;242=;0=8/ 866F 0 /12>.4.> /80=; 8-08 2230770 ./ 8-2 ;0:<-825 64 0F0110 G 0=;2110 0=; :30770 -:/ 8-2@150@2;465;./7.//03648-2/:.8 * 0/2;6=8-21320;.=</8-25.036:5845072; 8-246336B.=< - 5 - ! "#$ % & + 4825 0=03@/.=< 8-2 2A.;2=>2 32; ?24652 .8 8-2 5.03 6:58 -0/ >6=>3:;2; 8-08 8-2 130.=8.44/ -0A2 =68 2/80?3./-2; 8-2 52308.6=/-.1 64 2230770 0/ ;0:<-825 64 15616/.8:/ 0;.<2110 6=/2H:2=83@ 8-2 5.03 6:58 -0/ ;./7.//2;8-2/:.8 - 6 - & <<5.2A2;?@8-2/0.;9:;<72=80=;;2>5228-2 130.=8.44/052?246528-./6:58.=011203 ) 205=2; >6:=/23 011205.=< 465 8-2 0112330=8/ 130.=8.44/B6:3;50./28-246336B.=<>6=82=8.6=/ 0$ -2;242=;0=8/-0A21320;2;8-082230770./ 8-2:825.=2/./82564;242=;0=860=;8-2?:5;2=/-6:3; -0A2 ?22= >0/8 6= 8-2 ;242=;0=8/ 86 156A2 8-2 /0.; >6=82=8.6= ?$ -2 130.=8.44/ -0A2 156;:>2; 8-2 <2=2036<.>03 8522 .//:2;?@ 8-2 .330<2>>6:=80=86B2A25 8-25.03 6:58 ?5:/-2; 0/.;2 8-2 /0.; ;6>:72=8 6= 8-2 1527./2 8-088-2/0.;;6>:72=8;62/=68>6=80.=.=465708.6=0/86 6=B-6/252H:2/88-2/0.;<2=2036<.>038522./4:5=./-2; >$ -2 5.03 6:58 -0/ 7./>6=/85:2; 8-2 6503 0=; ;6>:72=805@2A.;2=>232;?@8-21058.2/0=;2556=26:/3@ ;./7.//2;8-2/:.8 ' 205=2;>6:=/23011205.=<4658-252/16=;2=8/ B6:3; >6=82=; 8-08 -:30770 B0/ 8-2 768-25 64 - 7 - 2230770 0=; /-2 B0/ ?65= 4567 8-2 7055.0<2 64 -:30770 B.8- 0F0110 4825 8-2 ;208- 64 0F0110 -:30770 /80582; 3.A.=< B.8- -25 /./825 -.A03.=<0770 0=; 30825 -:30770 7055.2; 0;.<2110 (567 8-2 /0.; 7055.0<2 -:30770 -0; 0 ;0:<-825 ?@ =072 -0==07700=;6= 0/0A05098-2;242=;0=86 8 ./ 8-2 4:58-25 :5<2; 8-08 8-2 >30.7 8-08 2230770 ./ 8-2 /./825 64 0/0A0509 >0==68 ?2 0>>2182; 4567 8-2 0<2 72=8.6=2; .= 8-2 >0:/2 8.832 64 8-2 130.=8 B-252.= 130.=8.44 -050=0770 B-6 ./ 8-2 ;0:<-825 64 2230770B0/0<2;@205/B-2=8-2/:.8B0/4.32;0=; ;242=;0=8 6 0/0A0509 B0/ 0<2; ' @205/ 4 0/0A0509 B0/ ' @205/ 0=; 130.=8.44 -050?=0770 8-2 ;0:<-8252230770B0/0<2;@205/8-2=.8>0==68?2 /0.;8-088-22230770./8-2/./82564 0/0A050988-2 76/82230770>0=?2>6=/.;252;0/8-2:825.=2/./82564 0/0A0509 0/ 768-25 -:30770 <0A2 ?.58- 86 2230770 4567 0F0110-254.5/8-:/?0=;0=;-:30770<0A2?.58- 86 0/0A05094567-25/2>6=;7055.0<2860;.<2110 - 8 - 24255.=< 86 8-2/2 >.5>:7/80=>2/ .8 ./ :5<2; 8-088-2130.=8.44/>30.78-082230770./8-2;0:<-82564 0;.<2110./=682/80?3./-2; !(6336B.=<16.=805./2465>6=/.;2508.6= I -28-250112330=8/2/80?3./-8-088-2@052 8-2;2>2;2=8/640;.<2110JK -./ 6:58 -0/ >6=/.;252; 8-2 >6=82=8.6=/ 50./2;088-2 050=;125:/2;8-252>65;/ -252308.6=/-.164;242=;0=860/8-2/6=64 15616/.8:/0;.<21100=; 030770./0;7.882;8./=68 .= ;./1:82 8-08 -0==0770 B0/ 8-2 ;0:<-825 64 0;.<21100=; 0307700=;/-2;.2;.//:232//-26=3@ H:2/8.6= 8-08 52H:.52/ 86 ?2 0=/B252; ./ B-28-25 2230770 8-2 768-25 64 8-2 130.=8.44/ 0=; ;242=;0=8 6/!0=; ./8-2;0:<-825640;.<211065;0:<-825 64 0F0110G 0=;2110K * -2 5.03 6:58 -0/ =68 >6=/.;252; 8-2 ;6>:72=82; 08 L/ + 0=; & B-.>- 052 8-2 - 9 - <2=2036<.>03 8522/ .//:2; ?@ .330<2 >>6:=80=8 =;630 / 405 0/ L + ./ >6=>25=2; 8-2 6:58 -0/ >6=>3:;2; 8-088-2/0.;;6>:72=8;62/=68?2058-2.<=08:52648-2 .330<2>>6:=80=8=;6300=;L &8-6:<-.8?205/8-2 /.<=08:52648-2.330<2>>6:=80=8=;6308-25.036:58 -0/ ;2>3.=2; 86 366F .=86 8-./ 0=; ;6>:72=8 6= 8-2 1527./2 0/ 86 6= B-6/2 .=/80=>2 8-2 /0.; ;6>:72=8 ./ .//:2;./=684658->67.=< + -./ 6:58 -0/ >6=/.;252; L + 0/ B233 0/ L & L + 1:51658/ 86 ?2 8-2 >258.4.2; >61@ 64 8-2 <2=2036<.>03 8522 .//:2; ?@ 8-2 .330<2 >>6:=80=8 =6;630 8 ?205/ 8-2 /.<=08:52 64 0/-.3;05 -.8801:5 B-6 -0/ .//:2; 8-2 >258.4.2; >61@ 6B2A25 .8 ;62/ =68 ?205 8-2 /.<=08:52 64 .330<2 >>6:=80=8 =;630 8;62/ =682A2=/0@8-088-2/0.;;6>:72=8.//.<=2;?@.330<2 >>6:=80=8=;630 &/4050/L &./>6=>25=2;.8./=68.>2;8-08 8-2/0.;;6>:72=852A203/8-2=0726422307700/8-2 ;0:<-825 64 0;.<2110 0=; :30770 -./ ;6>:72=8 - 10 - 8-6:<- /.<=2; ?@ .330<2 >>6:=80=8 =;630 6= B-6/2 .=/80=>2.8B0/.//:2;./=68/12>.4.2;.=8-2/0.;;6>:72=8 0=;8-././8-26?/25A08.6=70;2?@8-25.036:58-./ 6:58;62/=684.=;0=@25565.=8-2/0.;6?/25A08.6== B-08 ?0/./ 8-2 /0.; ;6>:72=8 ./ .//:2; 0=; B-6/2 2A.;2=>2./523.2;6=86.//:28-2/0.;;6>:72=8./03/6=68 4658->67.=< ) -./ 6:58 ./ 64 8-2 A.2B 8-08 8-2 /0.; ;6>:72=8/ 08 L/ + 0=; & 052 =68 <66; 2=6:<- 86 852080/2A.;2=>286-63;8-082230770 ./8-2;0:<-825 640;.<21100=;:30770 ' 8 ./ 03/6 5232A0=8 86 =682 8-08 2L>218 130.=8.44 6=668-25125/6=./2L07.=2;86156A28-2>0/2648-2 130.=8.44/ 25@ .=8252/8.=<3@ ;242=;0=8 6 B-6 ./ 8-2 /./82564130.=8.446/0=;-0/?22=2L07.=2;0/ -2/:116582;8-2>0/264;242=;0=860=;/-2/8082/ 8-082230770./8-2;0:<-82564 0F01100=;:30770 252A.;2=>20//:72/.716580=>2.=8-2/2=/20/.8./8-2 2A.;2=>2<.A2=?@8-2125/6=0<0.=/8-256B=.=8252/84 - 11 - /-2 -0; /:116582; 8-2 >0/2 64 8-2 130.=8.44/ /-2 B6:3; -0A2/2>:52;/-052036=<B.8-8-2130.=8.44/6B2A25/-2 -0/=68>-6/2=86/:116588-2>0/2648-2130.=8.44/;2/1.82 8-2 /0.; /808272=8 <62/ 0<0.=/8 -25 6B= .=8252/8 0B 0//:72/ 7652 .716580=>2 86 8-2 2A.;2=>2 64 /:>- 125/6=/B-670F20/808272=80<0.=/88-2.56B=.=8252/8 -./ ./ 6=2 0/12>8 B-.>- -0/ 86 ?2 >6=/.;252; B-.32 >6=/.;25.=<8-25.A03>30.7/64?68-8-21058.2/ = 0;;.8.6= 86 2A.;2=>2 64 -0=;0770 6=2 125/6= 4567 8-2 /0.; A.330<2 B-252 ;242=;0=8 6 ./ 52/.;.=<./03/62L07.=2;0=;-2-0/<.A2=2A.;2=>2868-2 2442>88-082230770./8-2;0:<-82564 0F01100=;8-2 /0.; 0F0110;.2;0=;30825:307707055.2;0;.<2110 8./03/6>672.=2A.;2=>28-08:30770D/7055.0<2B0/ 12546572; ?@ -.A03.=<0770 B-6 ./ 8-2 /./825 64 :30770 8 ./ 03/6 5232A0=8 86 =682 8-08 B-6 ./ 2L07.=2;86/:?/80=8.0828-2>30.78-082230770./8-2 ;0:<-825 64 0;.<2110 -0/ 1320;2; .<=650=>2 86 8-2 - 12 - H:2/8.6=/ 1:8 86 -.7 .= 8-2 >56//%2L07.=08.6= 8 8-2 /072 8.72 .8 ./ 03/6 5232A0=8 86 =682 8-08 -2 -0/ =68 ;2=.2;8-2/:<<2/8.6=/?0/2;6=8-2;242=>250./2;?@8-2 ;242=;0=8.=8-2B5.882=/808272=8=8-268-25-0=;-2 -0/ 1320;2; .<=650=>2 6= 8-2 ;242=>2 50./2; ;242=;0=8 =;258-2>.5>:7/80=>2/8-25.036:58-0/>672868-2 >6=>3:/.6= 8-08 8-2 130.=8.44/ -0A2 =68 32; 2A.;2=>2 86 /:116588-2.5>0/2 ! -6:<- 8-2 3205=2; >6:=/23 011205.=< 465 8-2 0112330=8/B6:3;>6=82=;8-088-2;242=;0=8/05252H:.52; 862/80?3./-8-2.5;242=>28-./6:58./648-2A.2B8-088-2 6=:/64 156A.=<8-2;242=>2 B6:3;05./26=3@ .=>0/2 8-2 130.=8.44/ B6:3; -0A2 ;./>-05<2; 8-2.5 ?:5;2= B-.>- ./ .=.8.033@>0/86=8-2130.=8.44/?0/2;6=8-2.5>30.78-088-2.5 768-25%2230770./8-2;0:<-825640;.<2110.=>28-2 130.=8.44/ -0A2 =68 2/80?3./-2; 8-08 2230770 ./ 8-2 ;0:<-825 64 0;.<2110 0//:7.=< 8-08 8-252 ./ 301/2 6= 8-21058648-2;242=;0=8/862/80?3./-8-2.5;242=>28-08 2230770 ./ 8-2 ;0:<-825 64 0F0110 ;62/ =68 >672 86 - 13 - 8-2 52/>:2 64 8-2 130.=8.44/ 86 -63; 8-08 2230770 ./ 8-2 ;0:<-825640;.<2110 (658-20465272=8.6=2;520/6=/8-./6:58./64 8-2A.2B8-08=6<56:=;./70;26:886.=8254252B.8-8-2 9:;<72=8 0=; ;2>522 10//2; ?@ 8-2 5.03 6:58 >>65;.=<3@8-2011203./;./7.//2; '$ # % ! ./8636