- 1 - !" # "$ " % &'()&*+,'& ++ - ! "# ! # $ %& '" ( ""# ) Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * " " " " " * %&+ '" ( ") " * , + * " " ) # " * ) - * # ++& " - "" + + """"* " - * - * # +,+! " # () - *% , + - $ " * " # # * +!++ * " * * . - 3 - % (" . ) /0120304567801094"7:0:09401;067<=>:/7?7:0:094721 =704@5@@20787<=>:/7AB<@374:9;C9480C:09454<92<72 94174:74C7<5:7<+,+!049, +94:/7 ;067 9; :/7 <<0:09456 74092 0806 B<@7 54< *% 5: 50C/B2 54< 0:1 C94;0235:094 92<72 <5:7< ++& 04 2030456??7569 +94:/7;0679;:/7 <<0:09456 01:20C: 54< 7110941 B<@7 50C/B2 D/72704 :/7 ?7:0:094721 /587 =774 C9480C:7< ;92 :/7 9;;74C71 B4<72 7C:0941&+54<+!9; 4<054"74569<7(;921/92:E "F) /7 254G1 9; :/7 ?52:071 04 :/7 2056 9B2: D066 =7 C9410<727</74C7;92:/;92C94874074C7 *./012324/103/ :01:/7C5179;:/7?2917CB:094:/5:94!+5: 5=9B:&++?3D/74"51G7<:/75CCB17<?721941 51:9D/>:/7>D727:/29D04@5D5>:/7=9::67154<5619 <904@45:B27C56604;294:9;:/702/9B17=704@7425@7< => :/7 5C: 9; " :/7 5CCB17< 91 :9 ;9237< - 4 - B465D;B651173=6>D0:/5C933949=A7C::95115B6:54< 56199B:25@7:/739<71:>5115B6:7<154<!54< C5B17< 04AB2071 /7 5CCB17< 9 ?B667< :/7 15277 9; " 04 92<72 :9 9B:25@7 /72 39<71:> 74C7 5 C517 C537 :9 =7 27@01:727< 5@5041: 566 :/7 5CCB17< ?721941 =7;927 :/7 AB201<0C:09456 ?960C7 04 2037 9++ + ;:72C94<BC:04@:/704871:0@5:0941B=30::7<:/7C/52@7 1/77: 9 ?2987 :/7 C517 9; :/7 ?2917CB:094 :/7 ?2917CB:094 7H53047<&D0:47117151"1:9&54<@9:352G7<! <9CB374:1 51 H1" :9 "! 54< 5619 0<74:0;07< :/277 35:72056 9=A7C:1 51 1 :9 4 :/7 C94:252> :/7 <7;74C77H53047<:D9D0:47117151154</7 2056 9B2: 27C92<7< :/7 C9480C:094 ;92 :/7 9;;74C71 1:5:7< 1B?25 4 5??756 0: /51 =774 39<0;07< :9 :/7 7H:74::/5:5CCB17<91:9/587=7745CIB0::7<;92 :/7 9;;74C71 B4<72 7C:0941 + 54< +! 9; " 9D7872 :/7> /587 =774 C9480C:7< ;92 :/7 9;;74C71 B4<727C:0941&9; "*B2:/725CCB17< 9154</587=774C9480C:7<;92:/79;;74C7B4<72 7C:0949; "*B2:/725CCB17<91:9!54< - 5 - /587 =774 C9480C:7< ;92 :/7 9;;74C7 B4<72 7C:094 275<D0:/7C:094,9; "*B2:/725CCB17<9/51 =774C9480C:7<;92:/79;;74C7B4<727C:0949; " *B2:/72 5CCB17< 91 :9 :9 /587 5619 =774 C9480C:7<;92:/79;;74C7B4<727C:09412 D,9; " 704@ 5@@20787<=> :/7 1537 :/7 ?7:0:094721 527 =7;927:/019B2: 752< 202B4GB352 352@B4<5??5 675247< C9B4176 ;92 :/7 ?7:0:094721 54< 20 535<52 /5/5=B<<04 675247< 0@/ 9B2: 98724374: "675<72 ;92 :/7 271?94<74:J:5:7 ! :01:/71B=30110949;675247<C9B4176;92:/7?7:0:094721 :/5: :/7 AB<@374: 9; C9480C:094 54< 0:1 C94;0235:094 92<72 ?5117< => 9B2:1 =769D 527 C94:252> :9 :/7 780<74C7 94 27C92< 54< 5619 17::67< ?204C0?671 9; 65D /727;927:/7153701605=67:9=717:510<7 :01;B2:/721B=30::7<:/5::/7 4871:0@5:04@ ;;0C72/51 ;5067< :9 27C92< :/7 780<74C7 9; 04<7?74<74: D0:471171 :/9B@/ :/727 527 4B3=72 9; ?721941 ?27174: 04 54< 529B4< :/7 ?65C7 9; :/7 04C0<74: 9:/ :/7 9B2:1 /587 - 6 - C9330::7< 72292 04 5??27C05:04@ :/7 780<74C7 9; :/7 <7;74C7 C9417IB74:6> :/702 780<74C7 /587 =774 0@4927< & :01;B2:/721B=30::7<:/5:04:/7780<74C79;"154< C94:5047< 69:1 9; C94:25<0C:0941 54< 930110941 D/0C/ 52735:72056C94:25<0C:09410445:B27/9D7872=9:/:/7 9B2:1/5870@4927<04C9410<7204@:/71537 , :01;B2:/721B=30::7<:/5:04807D9;:/7C94:25<0C:92> 780<74C727@52<04@:/704AB20715667@7<:9/5871B1:5047< => :/7 80C:031 :/7 C9480C:094 9B@/: 49: :9 /587 =774 27C92<7< /B1 :/7 ;04<04@1 9; :/7 9B2:1 =769D 04 27C92<04@ :/7 C9480C:094 /587 :9 =7 17: 510<7 5G04@ 1BC/1B=30110941:/7675247<C9B4176;92:/7?7:0:094721 ?25>1:95669D:/7?7:0:094 + "72C94:25:/7675247<0@/9B2:98724374:"675<72 ;92 :/7 271?94<74: J :5:7 87/7374:6> AB1:0;07< :/7 ;04<04@19;:/79B2:1=769D0427C92<04@:/7C9480C:094 54< ;B2:/72 /7 1B=30::7< :/5: :/7 1C9?7 9; 27801094 01 872> 6030:7< 54< 5??27C05:094 9; 780<74C7 5: :/01 1:5@7 C5449: =7 @947 04:9 /727;927 51 5 ?204C0?67 ;04<04@ - 7 - 9B: :/7 72292 0; 54> C9330::7< => :/7 9B2:1 =769D :/01 9B2: /51 6030:7< AB201<0C:094 :9 =7 <756: D0:/ :/7 C94CB2274:;04<04@1CC92<04@6>:/7C94CB2274:;04<04@1 /587:9=7<756:D0:/045CC92<54C7D0:/:/765D : 01 ;B2:/72 1B=30::7< :/5: :/7 ;04<04@1 9; :/7 9B2:1 =769D527?29?7254<5??29?205:754<04:72;7274C7D0:/ :/7 150< ;04<04@1 35> 49: =7 ?29?72 /727;927 :/7 ?7:0:094 /51 :9 =7 27A7C:7< 5G04@ 1BC/ 1B=30110941 :/7 675247< 0@/ 9B2: 98724374: "675<72 ;92 :/7 271?94<74:J:5:7?25>1:9<013011:/7?7:0:094 5804@ /752< :/7 675247< C9B4176 ;92 :/7 271?7C:087 ?52:071 54< 5619 ?72B17< :/7 ;04<04@1 9; :/7 9B2:1 =769D 0: 01 47C71152> :9 /587 5 CB2192> 699G B?94 :/7 780<74C79;566:/7D0:471171 " =704@ :/7 C93?650454: 54< 5619 :/7 04AB27< /51 1:5:7< =7;927 :/7 9B2: 04 /01 780<74C7 :/5: 566 :/7 5CCB17</5875115B6:7<:/7354<C5B17<04AB2071:9/01 D0;7 194 54< /03176; 7 ?27117< :/7 9872: 5C: 9; 5115B6:D0:/;027D99<54<56199B:25@04@:/739<71:>9; /01 D0;7 5@5041: 5CCB17< 9 40:0566> /7 /51 49: - 8 - 1B??92:7< 04 271?7C: 9; 9B:25@04@ :/7 39<71:> 9; 5 D9354 /9D7872 /7 D51 :275:7< 51 /91:067 54< 1B=17IB74:6>51535::729;03?2987374:1/75<30::7< :/5:5CCB17<9?B667<:/7152779;/01D0;79D7872 /7 <0< 49: :2> :9 5::73?: :9 C9330: 25?7 9; /01 D0;7 /9B@/:/727D7271B@@71:094135<7:9/03:/5:5;5617 C517 /51 =774 ;901:7< 5@5041: :/7 5CCB17< 5: :/7 041:54C79;?960:0C56=5CG@29B4</7<7407<:/71537 "/511:5:7<04/72780<74C7:/5:5CCB17<91:9 D727176604@60IB9204:/702/9B17/7?721941D/9D727 @904@:9C941B3760IB92D727:/29D04@:/7=9::6715;:72 C941B304@ 60IB92 54< 5619 B2045:04@ 04 ;294: 9; /72 /9B17 /74 1/7 9=A7C:7< 54< 51G7< :/7 5CCB17< :9 :5G7 C527 9; 566 :/917 :/04@1 54< 5619 :96< :/73 :9 041:2BC: :/7 CB1:93721 :9 :5G7 C527 ?29?726> /5804@ /752< :/7 5<8017 9; " :/7> =7C537 ;B209B1 54< 566 :/7 5CCB17< /587 5115B6:7< /72 54< /72 /B1=54< 54< 194/7/5145225:7<:/79872:5C:9;566:/75CCB17<04 /727H53045:094%04%C/07;1B@@71:094D5135<7:9/72 :/5: :/7 5CCB17< D51 49: 176604@ 54> 60IB92 04 :/702 - 9 - /9B171/7<7407<:/7153754<1/7D5151172:08704/72 780<74C7:/5::/7>D727176604@:/760IB92 " =704@ :/7 194 9; "1 54< 5619 1:5:7< 04 /01 780<74C704C9419454C7D0:/:/5:9;"154< ! " 01 :/7 =29:/72 9; " 5619 1:5:7< :/5: 566 :/7 5CCB17< /587 IB522767< 54< 5115B6:7< /01 =29:/72 101:72%04%65D54<5619" " 1:5:7< :9 =7 :/7 D0:4711 :9 :/7 1?9:%CB3%170KB27 35/5K52 D/0C/ 01 352G7< 51 H" /9D7872 /7 /51 :B247< /91:067 4 ;5C: /7 D51 1B??917< :9 <7?917 5=9B::/7170KB279;;027D99< & "! 1:5:7< :9 =7 :/7 04<7?74<74: D0:4711 :9 :/7 04C0<74:/7/511B??92:7<:/7C5179;:/7?2917CB:09404 271?7C: 9; 9872:%5C: 9; :/7 5CCB17< 9D7872 04 /01 C2911%7H53045:094 /7 /51 5<30::7< :/5: " 54< /03176;527:/7=71:;2074<1 , "=704@:/79C:921:5:7<:9/587:275:7<1:9! 54<1B=30::7</0127?92:51?72H1":9" - 10 - + "&D51D92G04@51" 1:5:7<:9/587C94<BC:7<:/7 04871:0@5:09454<1B=30::7<:/7C/52@71/77: 4 275<04@ 9; :/7 780<74C7 9; 566 :/7 D0:471171 0: 5??7521 :/5: :/7 74:027 C517 92 04C0<74: /51 =774 27896804@529B4<176604@9;60IB92=>:/75CCB17<04:/702 /9B17 9D7872 :/7 4871:0@5:04@ ;;0C72 /51 49: 27C98727< 54> 60IB92 =9::671 492 /51 C0:7< 54> 9; :/7 CB1:93721D/9D727C941B304@:/760IB9204:/7/9B17 9;:/75CCB17< /587?72B17<:/7D9B4<C72:0;0C5:79;:/704AB27</7 9C:921:5:7<04/0127?92::/5:566:/704AB2071527103?67 0445:B27 7:/5:510:35>040:0566>:/7C93?6504:C94:5047<:/7 5872374:1 9; 9B:25@04@ :/7 39<71:> 9; D9354 B=17IB74:6> 04 :/7 780<74C7 9; " 0: /51 =774 <06B:7<54<C94;047<:9:/77H:74:9;?B6604@:/7152779; " => 5CCB17< 9 /9B@/ :/7 780<74C7 D9B6< <01C6917:/5:5CCB17<95115B6:7<"D0:/;027D99< 54< 0: /51 =774 170K7< 04 :/7 ?27174C7 9; :/7 ?54C/ D0:471171 :/7 D0:471171 /587 :B247< /91:067 54< 49: - 11 - 1B??92:7< :/7 C517 BC/ =704@ :/7 ;5C: 0: C5449: =7 150< :/5: :/7 5CCB17< 9 /5< 5115B6:7< :/7 04AB27< D0:/:/7;027D99< 4 275<04@ 9; :/7 04C94101:74C071 54< 5619 :/7 C94:25<0C:094104:/7780<74C79;:/77>7D0:471171%CB3 %04AB27< D0:471171 53 9; :/7 C9410<727< 9?04094 :/5: :/7 ;04<04@1 9; :/7 9B2:1 =769D 04 27C92<04@ :/7 C9480C:094 ;92 :/7 9;;74C71 1:5:7< 1B?25 527 B41B1:5045=67 54< :/7 ;04<04@1 527 7229479B1 /727;927:/7153701605=67:9=717:510<7 4:/760@/:9;:/79=17285:09435<75=987 ?29C77<:9 ?511:/7;9669D04@ (0) /720304567801094"7:0:09401 (00) /7 AB<@374: 9; C9480C:094 54< 92<72 94 174:74C7 <5:7< +,+! ?5117< 04 9, + => :/7 <<0:09456 74092 B<@7 54< *% 5: 50C/B2 54< :/7 AB<@374: 54< 92<72 <5:7< ++& ?5117< 04 2030456 ??756 - 12 - 9 + => :/7 <<0:09456 01:20C: 54< 7110941 B<@750C/B252717:510<7 (000) /7 ?7:0:094721 527 5CIB0::7< ;92 :/7 9;;74C7 B4<72 7C:094 & +54<+!9; " (08) 506=94<17H7CB:7<0;54>1:54<C54C7667< 5, & + $ 01:969 "