Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46653 (KAR)
MALLAPPA BASANNA NAVALAGUDDA v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/200997/2025 · 2025-04-03
Chillakur Sumalatha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46653 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46653 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
# $! !% &% !'
! " ! ! #
! ! # $
% ! & '
&(
® Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
' !! & & )&
' !! *"""
& !! ! ! *"""
&!' !! #
! &+ &!! #
&! $
%!!!) !) !!!' (
!) ' & * '!&'
)&!' &! !&
" " %
' ,+(
- 3 -
! ' ) '
' ! '
""""*""""&
! &
' ) & ! ' ! & ! &
''& ' ' & '' ! ' ' ! ! ! & ! " " % ',+(&
! & ' ! )! & !- &&! ! % !- &&! !(
!./01 02 0/3456278 /9/1/82 6./07.1 .72:0 ;:57<.6 =4: />>./0< ?40:584 921.: ;:7@.0.7;. /71 0.>0.<.7?< ?4. =02? >.?2?2:7.0< 6<: 4./01 6./07.1 19:;/?. .7.0/6 02 4/<42A20/7 4.??B =4: />>./0< ?40:584921.:;:7@.0.7;. .?2?2:7.0</0.3.@:0.?42<&:50?<..A278/=02? :@ C/71/C5< 120.;?278 0.<>:71.7? :< ?: ?:
2C>6.C.7? ?4. 1.;2<2:7 ?4/? =/< ?/A.7 3B 0.<>:71.7? - 4 -
:>>.0 02<47/
0:D.;? + 0028/?2:7 192<:0B &:CC2??.. 02<47/ 4/8B/ /6 28/C 2C2?.1 :7
" " 0.8/01278 0.6./<. :@ =/?.0 @:0 20028/?2:7 >50>:<. @0:C /0/B/7>50 /C @0:C """ ?:
"*""/?""&>.01/B/71?:0.92<.?4.=/?.0 0.6./<.>:62;B?:.7<50.@/0C.0<27?.0.<? ./07.1 .72:0 ;:57<.6 =4: 0.>0.<.7?< ?4. >.?2?2:7.0< <53C2?< ?4/? ?4. >.?2?2:7.0< /0. /802;56?502<?< /71 ?4.B 4/9. 0/2<.1 /=/0 ;0:> 27 ?4.20 0.<>.;?29. /802;56?50/66/71<6:78=2?4?4.C<.9.0/6:?4.0@/0C.0< /6<: 0/2<.1 ;0:>< ':0 20028/?278 ?4.20 6/71< ?4.B <:6.6B 1.>.71 5>:7 ?4. =/?.0 =42;4 2< 3.278 0.6./<.1 @0:C /0/B/7>50 1/C
4. >>.0 02<47/
0:D.;? =/< <>.;2@2;/66B 1.<287.1 ?: /110.<< ?4. =/?.0 <;/0;2?B 2<<5.< 27 7:0?4./<?.07 12<?02;?< :@ /07/?/A/ : 12<;5<< =/?.0 12<?0235?2:7 <.02.< :@ C..?278< =.0. 4.61 3B ?4. ;:7;.07.1 /5?4:02?2.< 27;651278 C..?278< 571.0 ?4. 6./1.0<42>:@6./07.1272<?.0:@E;2<.=4:2<27+;4/08.:@ /8/6A:?. 12<?02;? /71 0.<21.7? 02<47/ >>.0 /7A
- 5 -
0:D.;? 0028/?2:7 192<:0B &:CC2??.. '27/66B :7 ;:7<21.0278 ?4. 0.F5.<?< ?4/?=.0.0.;.29.1@0:C 9/02:5< >/0?< :@ ?4. ?/?.< /71 @0:C <.9.0/6 :08/72G/?2:7< ?4. &:CC2??..4./1.13B6./07.1272<?.01.;21.1?:0.6./<. =/?.0@0:C" "?:" "
? =/< /6<: 1.;21.1 ?: 0.6./<. =/?.0 @0:C ?=: 0.<.09:20<;:C327.1""&>.01/B@0:C"""?:
"*"" !:=.9.0 ?4. 0.<>:71.7?< /032?0/026B =2?410.=?4.2C>6.C.7?/?2:7:@?4.1.;2<2:7@:00.6./<.:@ =/?.0 @0:C """ ?: "*"" '/2650. ?: 0.6./<. =/?.0/19.0<.6B/@@.;?<?4.;0:></7127;/<.?4.@/0C.0< =2667:?8.?/7BB2.61@0:C?4.;0:><?4.B;/77:?<50929. 4.0.@:0. 4/9278 7: :?4.0 8: ?4. >.?2?2:7.0< @26.1 ?4. >0.<.7? =02? >.?2?2:7 <..A278 / 120.;?2:7 ?:
?4. 0.<>:71.7?< ?: 0.6./<. ?4. =/?.0 @:0 20028/?2:7 >50>:<. @0:C/0/B/7>501/C@0:C"""?:"*""/? ""&>.01/B
./07.119:;/?..7.0/6C/A278/<53C2<<2:7 ?4/??4.&:CC2??..4./1.13B6./07.1272<?.04/<?/A.7
- 6 -
/=2<./71D5<?1.;2<2:7;:7?.71<?4/??/?.:@/07/?/A/ 4/< 8:? 458. >:>56/?2:7 /71 ?4. >02:02?B :@ ?4. :9.07C.7?2<?:>0:921.1027A278=/?.0?:?4.>5362;7 ;/<.=/?.02<0.6./<.1@:020028/?2:7>50>:<.:9.07C.7? =266 3. 36/C.1 @:0 7:? >0:921278 <5@@2;2.7? =/?.0 @:0 1027A278 >50>:<.
27 ?4. ?/?. ./07.1 19:;/?. .7.0/6 /6<: <?/?.< ?4/? ?4:584 / 1.;2<2:7 =/< ?/A.7 :7
" " @:0 0.6./<. :@ =/?.0 /? "" & @0:C
""" ?:
"*"" 4/9278 ;:7<21.0.1 ?4. <588.<?2:7< @0:C /66 2<?02;? &:CC2<<2:7.0< :27? 20.;?:0<.?;/71?/A27827?:;:7<21.0/?2:7?4.F5/7?2?B:@ =/?.0?4/?2<0.F520.1?:3.0.<.09.1@:01027A278>50>:<.< ?266 ?4. .71 :@ 57. " ?4. &:CC2??.. 57/72C:5<6B 1.;21.1?:0.6./<.=/?.027?4.;/7/63.1<:@/0/B/7>50 0.<.09:20:76B@0:C"" "?:" " * ./07.119:;/?..7.0/6<?/?.<?4/?<:@/0/< 5<. :@ =/?.0 @0:C 6/C/??2 0.<.09:20 2< ;:7;.07.1 ?4. 1.;2<2:7?/A.7:7" "=2663.@:66:=.1
- 7 -
./07.119:;/?..7.0/6/6<:<53C2?<?4/??4. 1.;2<2:70.8/01278?4.1/?.<=4.7?4.=/?.02<0.F520.1?:
3. 0.6./<.1 @:0 20028/?2:7 >50>:<. 27 ?4. ;/7/6 3.1< :@ /0/B/7>500.<.09:20=:5613.?/A.72715.;:50<. ?2<7:?2712<>5?.?4/?27?4.C..?2784.61:7
" "/1.;2<2:7=/<?/A.73B0.<.09278"& @:01027A278=/?.0?/7A@266278>50>:<.<.?;1.;2<2:7=/< /6<:?/A.7?4/??:>0:?.;?;0:><3:?420028/?2:7<;:C327.1 <4:5613./>>62.1/??4.0/?.:@""&>.01/B?=/< /6<:0.<:69.1?4/?@0:C " "?: " "/714 =2663.@:66:=.1/71@0:C"""?:"*""?=:
0.<.09:20< ;:C327.1 2. /0/B/7>50 /71 6C/??2 /C<
""&:@=/?.0=2663.0.6./<.1@:020028/?2:7>50>:<.?: >0:?.;?;0:>< # B?4.<53C2<<2:7<?4/?=.0.C/1.3B3:?4?4. ;:7?.<?278 6./07.1 ;:57<.6< 2? 2< ;6./0 ?4/? <: @/0 /< ?4. 6/71<20028/?.1571.0/0/B/7>50.<.09:20/0.;:7;.07.1 7: =/?.0 2< 0.6./<.1 /@?.0 " " :? :76B 45C/7 3.278<35?/66629278;0./?50.;/77:?<50929.=2?4:5?=/?.0
- 8 -
@:0 / 6:78.0 ?2C. /71 ?4. <:6.C7 15?B :@ ?4. ?/?. :9.07C.7? 2< ?: <.. ?4/? 1027A278 =/?.0 @/;262?B 2< >0:921.1 ;:7?275:5<6B 27 ?4. .7?20. ?/?. 4/? 1:.< 7:? C./7 ?4/? ?4. @/0C.0< <4:561 3. >5? ?: <5@@.0/7;. 4. ?/?. :9.07C.7? 2< 571.0 :3628/?2:7 ?: <?02A. / 3/6/7;. 3.?=..7 ?4. >5362; 27?.0.<? =42;4 1.C/71< <5>>6B :@ =/?.0;:7?275:5<6B/?503/7/71050/6/0./<@:01:C.<?2;
>50>:<.< /71 ?4. 1.C/71 :@ ?4. @/0C.0< @:0 <5>>6B :@ =/?.0@:0?4.;0:><
" !.0. 2< / ;/<. =4.0. 2? 2< ;6./0 30:584? :7 0.;:01 ?4/? =/?.0 2< 7:? 0.6./<.1 ?: ?4. /0./< :@ ?4. >.?2?2:7.0< /@?.0 " " )/?.0 /< >.0 ?4. 1.;2<2:7 ?/A.7 :7 " " 2< 0.F520.1 ?: 3. 0.6./<.1 @0:C
""" ?: "*"" 60./1B 727. 1/B< >/<<.1 %*" "?:" "" 3:?41/B<27;65<29.( /71:76B ?40.. 1/B< /0. 6.@? &0:>< 27 ?42< <5CC.0 <./<:7 ;/77:? <50929./71B2.61=2?4:5?=/?.03.278>0:921.1&0:></0. =2?4:5?=/?.0/<>.0?4.C/?.02/6/9/26/36.:70.;:01/71 /< >.0 ?4. <53C2<<2:7 ?4/? 2< C/1. 3B 3:?4 ?4. 6./07.1
- 9 -
;:57<.6 @0:C " " 2. <27;. C:0. ?4/7 / =..A 4/? />/0? 7: C/?.02/6 2< :7 0.;:01 ?: <4:= =4/? >0.9.7?.1?4.0.<>:71.7?/5?4:02?2.<?:>6/;.3.@:0.?4. &:CC2??..?4..E/;?<2?5/?2:7@:0?/A278/1.;2<2:7/??4. ./062.<? /><. :7 >/0? :@ ?/?. 1C272<?0/?2:7 2< .921.7? @0:C ?4. @:66:=278 :3<.09/?2:7 C.7?2:7.1 /? >/8. :@ 275?.< :@ ..?278 /?
77.E50.+ ?0/7<6/?2:7 :@ =42;4 2< /? /8.:@C/?.02/6>/>.0<
! " # $
%
? 2< =.66 </21 ?4/? 2@ /802;56?50. 8:.< =0:78 7:?4278.6<.=2664/9./;4/7;.?:8:0284?27?42<&:57?0B '/0C.0<?4.3/;A3:7.:@?4.&:57?0B<4:56120028/?.?4.20 6/71< @0:C ?4. =/?.0 829.7 3B 7/?50. /71 7:? @0:C ?4. ?./0<:@?4.20.B.< 4.0.@:0. ?42< &:50? ;:7<21.0< 1.<20/36. ?: :01.0?4.0.<>:71.7?<?:0.6./<.@:0?4=2?4=/?.0/<<:584? - 10 -
@:0 3B ?4. >.?2?2:7.0< /? ?4. 0/?. /80..1 5>:7 @0:C
"""?266"*""45<=02?>.?2?2:72<12<>:<.1 :@@=2?4?4.@:66:=278
2( =02? :@ C/71/C5< 2< 2<<5.1 120.;?278 0.<>:71.7? :< ?: ?: 0.6./<. =/?.0 @:0 20028/?2:7 >50>:<.< @0:C ?4. /0/B/7>50 1/C @0:C """ ?:
"*""/</80..15>:7 22( 4.2<<5.=2?40.8/01?:?4.=/?.00.6./<.>:62;B3. ?/A.75>2CC.12/?.6B/71<:@/0/<0.6./<.:@=/?.0 27?4.;:C2781/B<2<;:7;.07.1?4.&:CC2??..?:
;:715;? C..?278 /< ./06B /< >:<<236. >0.@.0/36B =2?427 :7. =..A /71 ?: 1.;21. 27 ;6./0 ?.0C< ?4. 1/?.< :@ 0.6./<. :@ =/?.0 /71 ?4. .E?.7? :@ =/?.0 =42;4 ;/7 3. 0.6./<.1 3/<278 :7 ?4. >0.9/26278 ;20;5C<?/7;.<
!()
& * !% ' $
2<?:6: &