- 1 - ! " # # $ ! " # $%&& ' ( $%&& ) ! ! " & ! " * ! ' ! (%&%+& %&% $%&& ! ' !$$ !( Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $%&& ) ! , & *& ' && ' ! " ' * ! " " &%&+ " ' -! " " # -! " " & ./01 2./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 <=. /88.22/3<8.<9<953.0 /31 <=. 2./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 0.78531.3<53760/34.5>8/3? !.93: /::09.@.1 A? <=. B61:>.3< /31 /C/01 1/<.1 * 8/77.1 93 5&%&+ A? <=. 119<953/2 .03950 9@92 "61:. /31 " /31 /94=60;507=50<D<=. 09A63/2E<=.8.<9<953.097A.;50.<=97 - 3 - 560< 7..F93: .3=/34.>.3< 5; <=. 45>8.37/<953 ;50 1/>/:.7<5=97@.=942. =. 8.<9<953.0 453<.317 <=/< 53 $&* =. /31=97;09.317C.0.8054..193:93/ :5517@.=942. A./093: 5($ $ C=94= C/7 ?.< <5 A. 0.:97<.0.1 /31 53. 60.7= C/7 <=. 109@.0 5; <=. @.=942. ./0 (/09:611/ 53 .@/160:/"/2/=/229 /93 5/1 / >939 2500? A./093:5(%&%+&4/>.;05>.@/160:/791.93/0/7= /31 3.:29:.3< >/33.0 /31 1/7=.1 /:/937< <=. 8.<9<953.0E7 @.=942.0.762<93: 93 93B609.7 <5<=. 8.<9<953.0 /31 ;.C 5<=.0 93>/<.719.153<=.785< =.@.=942.C/7;622?1/>/:.1 4/7.C/70.:97<.0.1/:/937<<=.109@.05;>9392500?A./093: 5(%&%+& /< "/2/=/229 5294. </<953 93 09>. 5&* /31 62<9>/<.2? 4=/0:.7=..< 4/>. <5 A. ;92.1 /:/937<=9> =.85294.=/1/2757.9G.1<=.1/>/:.1@.=942. 5;<=.8.<9<953.06.<593B609.7767</93.1A?<=.8.<9<953.0 =.C/763/A2.<5:.<<=.@.=942.0.2./7.1/319<0.>/93.193 <=.467<51?5;<=.85294.;<.00.45@.0?;05><=.93B609.7 =.:5<<=.@.=942.760@.?.1A?/36<=509G.160@.?50/31 =. /77.77.1 <=. 1/>/:. <5 <=. @.=942. 5; <=. 8.<9<953.0 /< - 4 - 7* < 97 <=. 7/91 />563< <=/< <=. 8.<9<953.0 42/9>.1 93 <=. 42/9>8.<9<953 ;05> 0.78531.3< 57& /31 C=5/0.<=.5C3.0/3193760.05;>9392500?A./093:5( %&%+& * ;<.07.0@94.5;35<94.0.78531.3<5&/88./0.1 /31 453<.31.1 <=/< <=. 3.:29:.34. C/7 53 <=. 8/0< 5; <=. 109@.05;<=.@.=942.5;<=.8.<9<953.0/31<=/<=97@.=942.C/7 93760.1 C9<= 0.78531.3< 5 /31 /3? 29/A929<? <=/< >/? A. ;/7<.3.168530.78531.3<5&=/7<5A.8/91A?0.78531.3< 516.<5453<0/4<6/25A29:/<95375;<=.85294? $ .78531.3< 5 453<.31.1 <=/< <=. />563< 5; 45>8.37/<95342/9>.197=9:=2?.H50A9</3</319>/:93/0?< 0.9<.0/<.1<=. 453<.3<9537 5; 0.78531.3< 5& 75 ;/0/7 <=. 3.:29:.34.974534.03.1<97453<.31.1<=/<9<C/735<<=. 4/7. 5; 0.78531.3< 5 <=/< <=. @.=942. 5C3.1 A? 0.78531.3<5&C/735<45@.0.1A?<=.93760/34.<C/7 ;60<=.0 453<.31.1 <=/< <=. 109@.0 5; <=. @.=942. 5; <=. 8.<9<953.0C/735<=/@93:/@/291109@93:294.37./31<=/<<=. 8.<9<953.07=5621=/@./00/?.1=9793760.093<=.8.<9<953 - 5 - % 3 <=. A/797 5; 764= 453<.3<9537 <=. 09A63/2 ;0/>.1 /8805809/<. 9776.7 /31 <=. 8.<9<953.0 C/7 .H/>93.1 /7'&<=.60@.?50C/7.H/>93.1/7' H7&<5&& C.0. >/0F.1 93 .@91.34. =. 5;;949/2 5; 0.78531.3< 5 C/7.H/>93.1/7 '&/31 H7 &<5C.0.>/0F.1 ;<.0 =./093: <=. 76A>9779537 5; A5<= <=. 791.7 <=. 09A63/2 /C/01.1 / 76> 5; 7&$ 190.4<93: 0.78531.3< 57& /31 <5 8/? <=. 45>8.37/<953 />563< !.93: /::09.@.1 A? <=. 7/91 B61:>.3< <=. 8.<9<953.0 97 A.;50. <=97 560< 7..F93: 45>8.37/<953 /7 8.0 <=. 60@.?50E7 .850< ./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 <=. /88.22/3< 8.<9<953.0C562176A>9<<=/<<=.8.<9<953.0=/7805164.1<=. 60@.? .850<80.8/0.1A?'631.0 H%C=94=>.3<953 <=/<<=.1/>/:.C/7<5<=..H<.3<5; 7*/31<=. .3<90. 60@.? .850< 42./02? 7=5C <=/< <=. @.=942. C/7 1/>/:.1A.?5310.8/907/31/7764=<=. 09A63/2;/92.1<5 /C/01<=.45>8.37/<953/>563</78.0<=.60@.? .850< . 76A>9<7 <=/< <=. 3530.:97<0/<953 5; <=. @.=942. 5; <=. - 6 - 8.<9<953.0 /31 /3? 764= 5<=.0 2/463/ 53 <=. 8/0< 5; <=. 8.<9<953.0 4/335< A. / 0./753 ;50 <=. 09A63/2 <5 1.3? <=. 8/?>.3< 5; <=. 45>8.37/<953 < 97 76A>9<<.1 <=/< 632.77 /3? 3.:29:.34. 93 4/6793: <=. /4491.3< 97 /<<09A6<.1 <5 <=. 8.<9<953.0E7 @.=942. <=. 09A63/2 45621 35< =/@. A067=.1 /791.<=.60@.?50E7 .850</78.0 H%/31<=.<.7<9>53? 5;<=.' =.0.;50.=.453<.317<=/<<=. 09A63/245621 35<=/@.0.164.1<=.45>8.37/<953/>563</7/77.77.1A? <=.' + 2./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 0.78531.3<5C562176A>9<<=/<<=.@.=942.=/135@/291 8.0>9<0.:97<0/<953/7531/<.5;<=./4491.3</31<=/<<=. 8.<9<953.0 =/7 35< :5< <=. @.=942. 0.8/90.1 93 86076/34. <5 <=.760@.?453164<.1A?' =.0.;50.=.453<.317<=/< C=.3<=.@.=942.9735<?.<0.8/90.10.78531.3<59735< 29/A2. <5 8/? <=. 45>8.37/<953 />563< . /275 76A>9<7 <=/<<=.45>8.37/<953/C/01.1A?<=. 09A63/2<5<=..H<.3< 5; 7&$ 97 /1.I6/<. /31 /7 764= =. 756:=< ;50 197>977/25;<=.8.<9<953 - 7 - & =. 8.067/2 5; <=. 0.45017 C5621 1974257. <=/< /;<.0 93@.7<9:/<953 / 4=/0:.7=..< C/7 ;92.1 /:/937< <=. @.=942. 5C3.1 A? 0.78531.3< 5& /31 93760.1 A? 0.78531.3<5 =97/78.4<9735<19786<.1 =.4=/0:. 7=..</2751974257.7<=/<<=.3@.7<9:/<93:;;94.0=/1;5631 /A7526<. 3.:29:.34. 53 <=. 8/0< 5; <=. 109@.0 5; <=. @.=942. 5C3.1 A? 0.78531.3< 5& 6< 5; <=. <C5 8.07537 C=5 C.0. 93 <=. 4. @.=942. 53. 8.0753 76446>A.1 <5 93B609.7<97C50<=<535<.<=/</8.067/25;<=. /31<=. 4=/0:.7=..<C=94=/0./< H7&/31*C56211974257.<=/< <=.3.:29:.34.C/753<=.8/0<5;<=.@.=942.5C3.1A?<=. 0.78531.3<553.:29:.34.45621=/@.A..3/<<09A6<.1 <5 <=. @.=942. 5C3.1 A? <=. 8.<9<953.0 =.0.;50. <=. ;93193: 5; <=. 3@.7<9:/<93: ;;94.0 =/@93: 35< A..3 453<0/@.0<.1 <=. 0.78531.3<7 /0. 29/A2. <5 8/? <=. 45>8.37/<953 && =. 3.H< I6.7<953 <=/< /097.7 97 C=/< 97 <=. I6/3<6>5;<=.45>8.37/<953 =.8.<9<953.042/9>7<=/<<=. 1/>/:. <5 <=.@.=942. C/7 <5 <=. <63. 5; 7* /7 /77.77.1 A? ' /31 7934. <=. @.=942. C/7 3.C =/012? - 8 - /A56< >53<=7 521 /;<.0 8604=/7. <=.0. C/7 35 764= 1.80.49/<953 <=/< 45621 A. /<<09A6<.1 4450193:2? <=. ' =/7/77.77.1<=.1/>/:.<5<=..H<.3<5; 7*3 <=. <.7<9>53? 5; <=. ' 9< C/7 .2949<.1 <=/< =. 9378.4<.1 <=.@.=942./;<.0%>53<=7/317</<.1<=/<<=.@.=942.=/1/ <.>850/0? 0.:97<0/<953 . 1.39.7 <=/< =97 @/26/<953 /31 /77.77>.3<5;<=.1/>/:.97934500.4< =.0.9735<=93:93 <=.40577.H/>93/<953C=94=7=5C7<=/<<=.1/>/:.<5<=. @.=942.C/735<<5<=.<63.5; 7*A6<9<C/7;50 2.77.0 @/26. =.0.;50. <=.0. C/7 35 9>8.19>.3< ;50 <=. 09A63/2 <5 /C/01 / 76> 5; 7* /7 /77.77.1 A? ' /31 C=.3 9< 97 7=5C3 <=/< <=. @.=942. C/7 35< :5< 0.2./7.1 ;05> <=. 467<51? 5; 5294. /7 9< =/1 767</93.1 /2>57<45>82.<.1/>/:. =.<5</2@/26.5;<=.@.=942.C/7 7*/31<=.<.7<9>53?5;'4562135<=/@.A..3 19786<.1A?<=.0.78531.3<7 & =.2./03.145637.2/88./093:;50<=.0.78531.3< 5C562176A>9<<=/<<=.@.=942.5C3.1A?<=.8.<9<953.0 C/735<0.:97<.0.1/319<C/735<=/@93:/@/2910.:97<0/<953 36>A.0<97/275453<.31.1<=/<<=.@.=942.C/735<=/@93: - 9 - /3?93760/34./275 =.I6.7<953C=.<=.0<=.@.=942.5;<=. 8.<9<953.0C/7.9<=.093760.10.:97<.0.15035<9735<:593: <5/;;.4<<=.I6/3<6>5;<=.45>8.37/<953/>563< & 7 53 1/<. 5; <=. /4491.3< <=. 8.<9<953.0 =/7 76;;.0.1<=.1/>/:.<5<=.@.=942./31<=.I6.7<953C=.<=.0 9<C/70.:97<.0.15093760.15035<9735<:593:<5/;;.4<<=. 29/A929<?930.78.4<5;1/>/:.<5<=.@.=942.@.=942.C=94= =/71.;.4<793<=.;50>5;.9<=.00.:97<0/<95350;5225C93:<=. 7</<6<50? 0.I690.>.3<7 5; 2/C 4/335< A. / A53. 5; 453<.3<953C=.3<=.1/>/:.79742/9>.1A?<=.8.<9<953.0 ;/</22<=.@.=942.5;<=.8.<9<953.0=/1@952/<.1/3?5;<=. 7</<6<50? 805@979537 <=. /8805809/<. /6<=509<9.7 C=5 45621 </F. /4<953 /0. /<29A.0<? <5 939<9/<. <=. 7/>. !6< 53<=/< 4563< 0.78531.3< 57& /31 4/335< 1.3? <=.90 29/A929<? .78531.3< 5 97 634534.03.1 /A56< <=. 7</<6<50? 45>829/34.7<=/<=/1<5A.>/1.A?<=.8.<9<953.0930.78.4< 5;=97@.=942.31.0<=.7.49046>7</34.7<=.76A>9779535; <=.2./03.145637.2/88./093:;500.78531.3<5<=/<<=. @.=942.5;<=.8.<9<953.0=/13593760/34.45@.0/:.50<=/<9< C/7 35< /< /22 0.:97<.0.1 /;<.0 <=. .H890? 5; <=. <.>850/0? - 10 - 0.:97<0/<953 C922 35< =521 /3? C/<.0 31.0 <=.7. 49046>7</34.7 <=. 9>86:3.1 B61:>.3< 5; <=. 09A63/2 C=94= =/7 0.164.1 <=. 45>8.37/<953 />563< <5 7&$ 97 35< 767</93/A2. < 7=5621 =/@. /C/01.1 <=.45>8.37/<9535; 7*/7785F.3<5A?<=.' &* =. 8=5<5:0/8=7 </F.3 A? ' C=92. /77.7793: <=. 1/>/:. C=94= 97 8/0< 5; H% 1.894<7 <=/< <=. .3<90. @.=942.=/7A..3;622?1/>/:.131.0<=.7.49046>7</34.7 <=.9>86:3.1B61:>.3<0.16493:<=.45>8.37/<953/>563< <5 7&$ 97 35< 767</93/A2. 93 2/C =.0.;50. <=. /88./21.7.0@.7<5A./225C.1/31=.34.<=.;5225C93: 9 =./88./297/225C.1 99 .78531.3< 35 97 190.4<.1 <5 8/? 45>8.37/<9535; 793/119<953<5 C=/< =/7 A..3 /C/01.1 A? <=. 09A63/2 /253: C9<= 93<.0.7< /< <=. 0/<. 5; %J 8.0 - 11 - /336> ;05> <=. 1/<. 5; 8.<9<953 <922 0./29G/<953 1 % # & # ! 97<5&25 (