Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 46621 (KAR)

UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY v. GAJENDRA S/O ASHOK KUMAR KAJOJI AND ORS

MFA.CROB/200022/2023 · 2025-04-01

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" # $ $ % & !!" !# $% #$" ## ! # &!%# # # & !" ' % # # $ #$ # ! # &!%# (( " " # (# # # Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # " )# *# #" ! # !" ((# %*(+ ! # $ # (# # % ( " # % # # )# #" ! # %" # !" (( ' % ## , " " ## , -* " , -*# " " * # % % " * -+ " # !" % " #*#-% % - 3 - $%' & " " %# (# %*(+# # # " "(- ' % # !!" !# $% #$" ## ! # &!%# # # & !" # $ #$ # ! # &!%# (( ! # $ # (# # % ( " # % # # )# #" ! # %" # !" (( ' - 4 - " " # % " * -+ % " #!" # % # " # %# " " $ $ . " $ $ . " /012 32240/5/6 78 9:/ ;<62=/19 316 3>346 01 ?-+ 78 @/341/6 401A0B3@ /10?4 050@ <62/ 316 !3@37<4320# 639/6 *# 9:/ B/9090?1/4 0C 01 3BB/3@7/D?4/9:0C ?<49 316 9:/ 4/CB?16/19 ? 0C 7/D?4/ 9:0C?<49014?CC7;/A90?1C :/ D3A9<3@ 3CB/A9 9:39 0C 4/@/5319 D?4 9:/C/ 3BB/3@316A4?CC?7;/A90?1C34/3C7/@?>$ 3 :/B/9090?1/4>3C9435/@01201 393320A5/:0A@/ 7/34012 ?!* 9?>346C 3C353E3@831 316 >:/19:/6405/4?D9:/C3065/:0A@/64?5/9:/C3=/01 - 5 - 43C: 316 1/2@02/19 =311/4# 3 @?448 7/34012 ? )*+A3=/D4?=9:/?BB?C09/604/A90?13169:/4/ >3C 3 A?@@0C0?1 7/9>//1 9:/ 5/:0A@/C# 4/C<@9012 01 240/5?<C01;<40/C9?9:/B/9090?1/4316?9:/401=39/C?D 9:/ 393320A /9090?1/4 >3C C:0D9/6 9? 9:/ ?5/41=/19 ?CB093@# 3C353E3@831 316 9:/4/3D9/4 :/ >3CC:0D9/69?%3C:?63 ?CB093@#?@3B<4A3C/>3C 4/20C9/4/632301C99:/6405/4?D9:/ 393320A0140=/ ?*+ ?D 3C353E3@8313 ?@0A/ 9390?1 :/ ?>1/4 316 01C<4/4 ?D 9:/ 393320A 34/ 34438/6 3C 4/CB?16/19 ?C 316 316 9:39 ?D 9:/ @?448 34/ 34438/6 3C 4/CB?16/19 ?C 316 :/ B/9090?1/4 3BB4?3A:/69:/ 407<13@#A?19/160129:39:/>3C32/6 8/34C 39 9:/ 90=/ ?D 3AA06/19# >3C /341012 C# B/4 =?19: 78 6?012 7<C01/CC ?D =?70@/ B:?1/C 316 :/ :35012 C<DD/4/6 60C370@098# C?<2:9 36/F<39/A?=B/1C390?1D4?=9:/4/CB?16/19C 7 1C/450A/?D1?90A/#9:/4/CB?16/19?C316 3BB/34/6 9:4?<2: 9:/04 A?<1C/@C 316 D0@/6 >4099/1 - 6 - C939/=/19C :/ 4/CB?16/19 ?C 316 606 1?9 3BB/343163CC<A:#9:/8:35/7//1B@3A/6/GB349/ A :/ 4/CB?16/19 ? A?19/16/6 9:39 9:/ 1/2@02/1A/>3C?19:/B349?D9:/@?4486405/43169:/ 6405/4 ?D 9:/ 393320A >3C 1?9 4/CB?1C07@/ D?4 9:/ 3AA06/19 :/ 6405/4 >3C :?@6012 53@06 6405012 @0A/1A/ 3169:/4/D?4/#318@0370@098:3C9?7/D3C9/1/6<B?19:/ 4/CB?16/19? 6 :/4/CB?16/19?A?19/16/69:399:/3AA06/19 >3C6</9?9:/1/2@02/1A/?D9:/6405/4?D4/CB?16/19 ? 316 9:/4/ 7/012 1? 53@06 6405012 @0A/1A/ D?4 9:/ @?448 6405/4# 9:/ @0370@098# 0D 318# :3C 9? 7/ D3C9/1/6 <B?19:/4/CB?16/19? / 1 9:/ 73C0C ?D 9:/ 37?5/ A?19/190?1C# 9:/ 407<13@D43=/63BB4?B4039/0CC</C :/B/9090?1/4>3C /G3=01/6 3C 316 GC 9? >/4/ =34E/6 :/ ?A9?4 >:? 3CC/CC/6 9:/ 60C370@098 >3C /G3=01/6 3C :/ ?DD0A03@ ?D 9:/ 4/CB?16/19 ? >3C /G3=01/63C - 7 - D D9/4 :/34012 9:/ 342<=/19C# :/ 407<13@ :/@6 9:399:/4/CB?16/19?C31634/@037@/3163>346/6 3 A?=B/1C390?1 ?D C#(#+* <16/4 D?@@?>012 :/36C$ 301316C<DD/4012C C# ?CC ?D 3=/1090/C 316 /1;?8=/1901@0D/ C# ?CC?DD<9<4/01A?=/ C+*#+ /60A3@/GB/1C/C C*#** ( 99/16319HCA:342/C#D??6# 1?<40C:=/19 316 A?15/831A//GB/1C/C C# - ?CC ?D 01A?=/ 6<4012 B/40?6?D94/39=/19 C# ?93@ C#(#+* 2240/5/6 78 9:/ C306 ;<62=/19# 9:/ B/9090?1/4# 3C>/@@3C9:/4/CB?16/19?34/7/D?4/9:0C?<49 :/ C<7=0CC0?1C 78 @/341/6 A?<1C/@C 3BB/34012 D?4 3BB/@@319# D?4 A4?CC?7;/A9?4 316 D?4 4/CB?16/19 ? >/4/:/346?90A/9?4/CB?16/19?0C60CB/1C/6>09: ( :/ @/341/6 A?<1C/@ 3BB/34012 D?4 9:/ B/9090?1/43BB/@@319C<7=09C9:399:/A?=B/1C390?13>346/6 789:/ 407<13@0C?19:/@?>/4C06/3169:/ 407<13@:3C1?9 - 8 - 3BB4?B4039/@8A?1C06/4/69:/60C370@098 /A?19/16C9:399:/ 9:?<2:C939/69:399:/4/0C(I60C370@098#9:/ 407<13@ :3C A?1C06/4/6 9:/ 60C370@098 ?1@8 39 I :/4/D?4/# :/ C//ECD?44/3CC/CC=/19?D9:/F<319<=?D9:/A?=B/1C390?1 - :/ @/341/6 A?<1C/@ D?4 9:/ 4/CB?16/19 ? 4?CC?7;/A9?4A?19/16C9:399:/4/>/4/C/5/43@?9:/4A@30= B/9090?1C 316 9:/ 4/CB?16/19 ? :3C C390CD0/6 C/5/1 C<A: A@30=C ?D 9:/ 01=39/C ?D 9:/ 393320A 340C012 ?<9 ?D 9:/ C3063AA06/19 /C<7=09C9:399:/B/4=099/6A3B3A098?D9:/ 5/:0A@/ >3C C/5/1 3C B/4 9:/ B?@0A8 316 09 :35012 C390CD0/6 C<A: A@30=C# 0C 1?9 @037@/ 9? B38 9:/ A?=B/1C390?1 01 9:/ B4/C/19B/9090?1 0CC/A?16B4?12?D9:/342<=/190C9:39 9:/ ?460139/ /1A: ?D 9:0C ?<49 01 ?C-- 9? - ?D * 316 9:4// ?9:/4 A?11/A9/6 =399/4C >:0A: >/4/6/A06/6783A?==?1;<62=/19639/6#:3C :/@6 9:39 9:/4/ >3C 1/2@02/1A/ ?1 9:/ B349 ?D 9:/ 6405/4 ?D 9:/@?448?>1/6784/CB?16/19?3@C?9:3C6/9/4=01/6 C<A: 1/2@02/1A/ ?D 9:/ @?448 6405/4 39 (I /1A/# :/ C<7=09C 9:39 9:/ 4/CB?16/19 ?C 316 34/ 9? 7/ :/@6 - 9 - @037@/D?4C<A:A?19407<9?481/2@02/1A/ /2346012F<319<=# :/6/D/16C9:/0=B<21/6;<62=/19 * /341/6 A?<1C/@ 3BB/34012 D?4 4/CB?16/19 ? >?<@6C<7=099:399:/A?=B/1C390?13=?<196/9/4=01/678 9:/ 407<13@ 0C B4?B/4 316 A?44/A9 316 9:/4/ 0C 1? 1//6 9? /1:31A/ 9:/ C3=/ / D304@8 C<7=09C 9:39 9:0C ?<49 :3C D?<16 9:/ @0370@098 ?D 4/CB?16/19 ? 39 (I 01 9:/ A?11/A9/6=399/4C :/D04C93CB/A99?7/A?1C06/4/6789:0C?<490C 4/23460129:/F<319<=?D9:/A?=B/1C390?13=?<19 + :/9/C90=?18?D9:/>?<@660CA@?C/9:399:/ B/9090?1/4 :36 C<C9301/6 :/36 01;<48 78 >38 ?D @3A/439/6 >?<16 ?5/4 D4?19? B340/93@ 4/20?1 316 09 >3C 60321?C/6 3C @/D9 D4?193@ /G943 6<43@ :/=39?=3# :/ >3C 01B390/19 D4?= + 9? + 316 9:/ 139<4/ ?D 9:/ 94/39=/19 >3C A?1C/453905/ :/ 37?5/ D016012C 37?<9 9:/ 01;<48 34/ C<BB?49/6789:/?<16/490D0A39/39 G-3169:/:?CB093@ 4/A?46C39 GC+316 :?<2:#9:/0CA:342/<==/48 - 10 - 0C1?9B4?6<A/6#9:/37?5/6?A<=/19CC:?>9:399:/4/>3C :/3601;<48 C939/C9:399:/B/9090?1/40C:35012=024301/ :/363A:/#1/AEB301316<137@/9?73@31A/01?1/B?C090?1 D?4@?12#BC8A:?C?=390A60C9<4731A/C#7@3AE?<9?D=/=?40/C /9A ?>/5/4#9:/139<4/?D9:/9/C9CA?16<A9/678:0=D?4 BC8A:03940A60C?46/4C0C1?9D?49:A?=012 :/C939/C01 :0C9/C90=?183160C370@098/490D0A39/39 G9:399:/4/ 0C(I60C370@0989?9:/>:?@/7?68750?<C@8#9:/4/7/012 1?;<C90D0A390?1D?49:/=3167/0123?A9?4>:?6061?9 94/39 9:/ B/9090?1/4# 9:/ 407<13@:3C 93E/1 9:/ 60C370@098 39 I13A34/D<@B/4<C3@?D9:/9/C90=?18?D9:/#9:0C ?<49 0C ?D 9:/ 50/> 9:39 9:/ D<1A90?13@ 60C370@098 ?D 9:/ B/9090?1/40CI :/ 3AA06/19 >3C 01 9:/ 8/34 +# 9:/ 407<13@ A?1C06/4/69:/1?90?13@01A?=/39 C-##>:0A:6?1?9 4/F<04/318019/4D/4/1A/ :/4/D?4/#9:/A?=B/1C390?1<16/4 9:/ :/36 ?D @?CC ?D 01A?=/ ?1 3AA?<19 ?D 9:/ 60C370@098 0C - 11 - A3@A<@39/63C C-# G G I G* J C## 7836?B9012=<@90B@0/4?DK*H ?1C/F</19@8# 9:/ A?=B/1C390?1 <16/4 9:/ :/36 ?D@?CC?D01A?=/6<4012@306<BB/40?60CA3@A<@39/6D?4D?<4 =?19:C39 C-#GJ C# ?1C06/40129:/139<4/?D9:/01;<40/C31609C@?12 @3C9012 A?=B@0A390?1C# 9:/ A?=B/1C390?1 <16/4 9:/ :/36 ?D B301 316 C<DD/4012 0C /1:31A/6 9? C(# 316 9:39 ?D @?CC?D3=/1090/C01@0D/0C/1:31A/69? C# :/A?=B/1C390?1<16/49:/:/36?D399/16319HC A:342/C#D??6#A?15/831A//9A#6/C/45/69?7//1:31A/69? C(#C01A/:/>3C01B390/19D?4638C ( :/ A?=B/1C390?1 3>346/6 <16/4 9:/ :/36 ?D =/60A3@/GB/1C/C6?/C1?91//6318019/4D/4/1A/ - /1A/# 9:/ B/9090?1/4 0C /1909@/6 D?4 9?93@ C<= ?D C##**<16/4<16/4$ - 12 - @ ? /36C >346789:/ 407<13@ >346789:0C ?<49 301316C<DD/4012C C# C(# /60A3@/GB/1C/C C*#** C*#** ?CC?D01A?=/6</9? B/4=31/19 B:8C0A3@ 60C370@098 C+*#+ C## ?15/831A/# ??6# 1?<40C:=/19 316 399/16319HCA:342/C C# C(# ( ?CC ?D 3=/1090/C 01 @0D/ C# C# - ?CC?D01A?=/6<4012 @306<BB/40?6 C# C# ?93@ C#(#+* C##** /CC$>346789:/ 407<13@ C#(#+* ?93@/1:31A/=/19 C*# * ? D34 3C 9:/ 1/2@02/1A/ 316 @0370@098 34/ A?1A/41/6# 09 0C 4/@/5319 9? 1?9/ 9:39 9:0C ?<49 01 9:/ ;<62=/19 ?D ?--* 316 A?11/A9/6 =399/4C :3C?7C/45/601343*3163C7/@?>$ - 13 - ! " " ## "$ " % " & " " ' % " " " % " "" % "( ! % " ! ) - 14 - :<C# 09 >3C D?<16 9:39 9:/4/ >3C /F<3@ A?19407<9?481/2@02/1A/?19:/B349?D9:/4/CB?16/19?L 4<AE 405/4 C C<A:# 9:/ 4/CB?16/19 ? >3C 3@C? :/@6 @037@/9?B389:/A?=B/1C390?190CB/4901/199?1?9/9:39 9:/C306D016012?D9:0C?<490C1?960C9<47/6 + :/ A4?CC?7;/A9?44/CB?16/19 ? :/4/01 :3C A?19/16/6 9:39 :/ :3C C390CD0/6 C/5/1 A@30=C 340C012 ?<9 ?D 9:/ C306 3AA06/19# B/49301012 9? 9:/ 01=39/C ?D 393320A 0C A?19/190?1 >3C <B:/@6 78 9:0C ?<49 01 9:/ 37?5/ ;<62=/19 3C =38 7/ C//1 D4?= 343 * :/4/D?4/# 9:/ 4/C<@9319 /DD/A9 >?<@6 7/ 9:39 9:/ 01C<4/4C ?D 7?9: 9:/ 5/:0A@/C >0@@ 7/ @037@/ D?4 B38=/19 ?D 9:/ A?=B/1C390?1 3=?<1901/F<3@B4?B?490?1C3169:/A4?CC?7;/A9?4>?<@67/ 39 @07/498 9? 4/A?5/4 9:/ A?=B/1C390?1 B306 01 /GA/CC ?D C/5/1A3C/CD4?=9:/01C<4/64/CB?16/19? /1A/#9:/ D?@@?>012$ - 15 - 0 :/ 3BB/3@ 316 9:/ A4?CC?7;/A90?1C 34/ 3@@?>/601B349 00 :/ B/9090?1/4 0C /1909@/6 D?4 3 C<= ?D C*# 01 366090?1 9? 9:/ A?=B/1C390?1 3>346/6 78 9:/ 407<13@# 3@?12>09:019/4/C939-IB/4311<=D4?= 9:/639/?DB/9090?190@@09C6/B?C09 000 :/019/4C/1/2@02/1A/?D4/CB?16/19?C 3160C:/@639(I/3A: :/4/CB?16/19 ? :35012 C390CD0/6 C/5/1 A@30=C B/4=0CC07@/<16/49:/B?@0A8#C:3@@B38>09: @07/4989?4/A?5/49:/A?=B/1C390?13=?<19 D4?=4/CB?16/19? 05 :/ 4/CB?16/19 ? 7/012 01C<4/4 ?D 4/CB?16/19?0C@037@/9?B38(I?D9:/ /1904/ A?=B/1C390?1 3=?<19 9? 9:/ B/9090?1/4 - 16 - 5 /C9 ?D 9:/ ?46/4 B3CC/6 78 9:/ 407<13@ 4/=301<13@9/4/6 /341/6 A?<1C/@ 40 CB3@@0 0C B/4=099/6 9? D0@/ 3E3@3901?D?44/CB?16/19?#>09:01 3 >//E >09: ?D @/341/6 A?<1C/@ 40 ?:3==/6 76<@ &<38<= 6 ( $ ) $ 0C9?$@?$( $!