- 1 - ! "#$ %$&!$!$ '(!) ! " !! #$% & !! #$% ' !! # #$% Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !! # #$% ( )" ! &&* &&! ! +" ! ! ! &, - # ! !!$#!!# &&, !! %'&%% - # ." ! & ! ! &, ! ! ! ! ! /" 0 ! ! ! - 3 - 1( ) 1( )" 23 4356567839 6: .3;793 526: 7<95 :33=68> ;7??7@68> 93?63;: !" # $$%&'(!$$!)*+ ))* # #%, +)-.-- !/ # #0 / 1+2 %3+# + 4 5# , 6 & 4 5# , 7 & +:3 7; 523 4356567839 6: 52+5 239 2<:.+8A # +9<56:7<8A+44+ A3/3+:3A"@+:6::<3A@652+><B+?6 265+:439!79C#D068!79C 76893:43/57;?+8A68 E 7&, 57 +8 3F5385 7; +/93: '$ ><85+: :65<+53A +5 - 4 - 27A34+??6B6??+>36A+9+?<=+8A6:596/5.368>>9+853A 68 !6?3 7 #$#, A+53A %',$% +: 439 883F<93#497A</3A+?78>@96543565678 ' 2+54<9:<+855752379A397;523+2:6?A+9523 8+C3 7; 2<:.+8A 7; 523 4356567839 +: 523 7@839 +8A 47::3::678 68 /<?56B+5678 7; 523 :+6A ?+8A ;97C &%% 57 &%%,#% @26/2 6: 497A</3A +5 883F<93# 2+5 @6527<5 49679 8756/3 52393 6: +8 3859E C+A3 68 /7?<C8 7 7; 93/79A: 7;96>25 @652 93;3938/3 57 756;6/+5678 7!!$# !!# A+53A &&, 3853968> 523 8+C3 7; D!793:5 34+95C3850 .+:3A 78 523 79A39 4+::3A .E 523 34<5E 7CC6::67839 A+53A %'&%% 78 523 C3C7 :<.C6553A .E+2:6?A+968!6?3 7%$&%%,#%23/74E7; 4395+6868> 57 523 ?+8A ;97C &%%# 57 &%&&#&' 93;?3/568>5233859E68/7?<C8 7 2+568B63@7;A3+527;2392<:.+8A#+9<56523 8+C3 7; 523 4356567839 6: A<?E C<5+53A B6A3 7# &&%&'#& +8A 385393A 6857 68 523 93B38<3 93/79A 68 - 5 - 7?<C8 7:, +8A & 7; 523 ;79 523 E3+9 &%&'#& 2+5 68 B63@ 7; 385963: 68 7?<C8 7 7; 523 3853968>5238+C37;D!793:534+95C38504356567839C+A3 + 93493:385+5678 57 523 93:478A385 7#34<5E 7CC6::67839 :33=68> 57 ;<986:2 523 /74E 7; 756;6/+5678 +8A 523 79A39 A+53A %'&%% 7@3B39 93:478A385 7#34<5E 7CC6::67839 6::<3A 38A79:3C385 /+??68> <478 523 4356567839 57 ;6?3 + ;93:2 +44?6/+5678 497B6A68> A35+6?:@65293>+9A57!6?3 <C.39+8A752394+956/<?+9: //79A68>?E 523 4356567839 +4497+/23A 57 93:478A385 7'#34<5E !793:5 78:39B+579 7; !793:5 :33=68> ;79 ;<986:268> 7; 83/3::+9E 93/79A: 93?+568> 57 756;6/+5678 93;3993A 57 68 7?<C8 7 7; 523 3:478A385 7' ;<986:23A + /74E 7; 523 756;6/+5678 6::<3A<8A393/5678*7;523EA39+.+A!793:5/5 7& 7; ' !+:?6 93;?3/568> 523 .7<8A+963: 57 523 93:39B3A ;793:5+:8756;63A - 6 - * 356567839 .368> +>>963B3A 7; 523 385963: 68 7?<C8 7 7; 523 4395+6868> 57 523 ?+8A 7; 4356567839 68 E 7&, C+A3 4<9:<+85 523 79A39 A+53A %'&%% 4+::3A .E 523 93:478A385 7G34<5E 7CC6::67839 .+:3A 78 523 :+6A 8756;6/+5678 7!!$# !!# A+53A &&, 3853968> 523 8+C3 7; D!793:5 34+95C3850 @6527<5 +8E49679 8756/3 57 523 4356567839 6: .3;793526:7<95 3+983A/7<8:3?;795234356567839:<.C65:52+5 523 497/3:: +A7453A .E 523 93:478A385#<52796563: 6: /7859+9E 57 523 497B6:678: 7; 523 )+98+5+=+ !793:5 /5 ,*' H239368+;539 93;3993A 57 +: D523 /5 ,*'0 ;79 .93B65EI 43/6;6/+??E 93;39968> 57 3/5678 7; 523 /5 ,*' 23 /78538A: 52+5 6; 523 93:478A385#<52796563: C793 4+956/<?+9?E 523 !793:5 34+95C385 68538A 57 593+5 523 ?+8A: 68/?<A68> 523 ?+8A .368> /?+6C3A .E 523 4356567839+:+93:39B3;793:5523E+9393J<693A576::<3+ 8756;6/+56786852+593>+9A+8A78?E5238523E/+8/?+6C523 ?+8A57.3523;793:5?+8A - 7 - $ 3;<95239:<.C65:@238+AC6553A?E523:<.K3/5 ?+8A 2+: .338 >9+853A 68 ;+B7<9 7; 523 4356567839 .E 6::<68> :+><B+?6 /265 68 !79C 7 +8A 523 :+C3 875 2+B68> .338 @652A9+@8 79 /+8/3??3A .E 523 93:478A385 # 93B38<3 +<52796563:2+8A68> 7B39 7; 523 :+6A?+8A57 523 !793:5 34+95C385 @6527<5 ;7??7@68> A<3 497/3:: 7; ?+@ +8A /78:3J<385?E A3/?6868> 57 38539 523 8+C3: 7; 523 4356567839 68 523 93B38<3 93/79A: 6: +9.659+9E <893+:78+.?3+8A93J<693:57.368539;393A@652 , 8:<447957;26:/785385678:2393?63:<478523 79A39: 4+::3A .E 523 7#79A68+53 .38/2 7; 526: 7<95 68 7&%'&,&%&' A+53A &'%,&%& H I +: @3?? +: <478523K<A>C3857;5236B6:67838/27;526:7<9568 7&%%%&,&%& A+53A %&%&& H I+8A:<.C65:52+5@6527<5+A23938/3 57 523 497B6:678: 7; 523 /5 ,*' C793 4+956/<?+9?E 3/5678523937;52393:478A385#<52796563:/+8875A38E - 8 - 52343565678390:96>255738K7E2394974395E68539C:7;523 >9+85+?93+AEC+A36823926:;+B7<938/323:33=:;79 +??7@68>7;523@96543565678 % 6 ?3+983A AA65678+? 7B398C385 AB7/+53@26?393;39968>5752393/79A:;6?3A:<.C65:52+5 523 ?+8A68J<3:56782+A.3382+8A3A 7B39 57523!793:5 34+95C38568523E3+9,@26?3523>9+8568J<3:5678 2+: .338 4<947953A?E C+A3 68 ;+B7<9 7; 523 2<:.+8A 7; 523435656783968523E3+9,$% 875239@79A:23:<.C65:52+5523>9+85C+A3 68;+B7<97;5234356567839@+::<.:3J<38557523A+5378 @26/2 ?+8A 2+A .338 2+8A3A 7B39 57 523 !793:5 34+95C3857@3B39:68/352393B38<3385963:@393875 C+A3 68 526: 93>+9A 52393 6: +8 39979 68 6::<68> 523 :+><B+?6/26568;+B7<97;52343565678393+?:7:<.C65: 52+5 523 :<.K3/5 ?+8A 2+: .338 68/?<A3A 68 523 ?6:5 7; DA33C3A ;793:50 4<9:<+85 57 523 A693/5678 6::<3A .E 523 781.?3 <493C3 7<95 7; 8A6+ B6A3 65: 79A39 A+53A - 9 - &&,,* 4+::3A 68 6B6? 965 3565678 7&%& 7; ,, 3:<.C65:52+5+K7685:<9B3E2+:.338/78A</53A6852+5 523 ?+8A .368> /?+6C3A .E 523 4356567839 2+: .338 6A3856;63A+:?+8A;+??68>@65268523A33C3A;793:5+93+3 ;<95239 :<.C65: 52+5 52393 2+: .338 87 +>96/<?5<9+? +/56B6563:3;+69?E:<.C65:52+5527<>2523:+><B+?6/265 2+:.3386::<3A87497/33A68>:57@652A9+@7993B7=3523 :+6A :+><B+?6 /265: 2+: .338 68656+53A .E 523 93:478A385# <52796563: 3 +?:7 :<.C65: 52+5 523 93:478A385# <52796563:@6???77=685752349749635E7975239@6:37;523 >9+85 79A39: +8A +?:7 @7<?A ?77= 6857 523 C+8839 7; 2+8A68> 7B39523:<.K3/5 ?+8A: 57523!793:534+95C385 +8A 523 /7C4?6+8/3 6; +8E 57 523 497B6:678: 7; 523 /5 ,*'@7<?A.3:596/5?E+A2393A57+;539+;;79A68>:<;;6/6385 744795<865E57523435656783938/323:33=:;79A6:47:+? 7;52343565678@65283/3::+9EA693/567868526:93>+9A & <.C6::6786:5+=387893/79A ' 3+9A39<:3A52393/79A: - 10 - 23936:87A6:4<53@652523;+/552+5523?+8A68 E 7&, C3+:<968> +/93: '$ ><85+: :65<+53A +5 27A34+??6 B6??+>3 6A+9 +?<= +8A 6:596/5 2+B68> .338 >9+853A68;+B7<97;523435656783923936:+?:787A6:4<53 7B39523;+/552+55234356567839@+:6::<3A@652:+><B+?6 /26568!79C 778%',$%68:5+857@3B398+C3 7; 523 2<:.+8A 7; 523 4356567839 2+:.338 385393A 68 523 93B38<3 93/79A: +: 7@839 +8A 47::3::79 +: :338 523 A7/<C385: 497A</3A +5 883F<93# :3963: 23 8+C3 7; 523 4356567839 2+: +?:7 .338 C<5+53A 6857 +: :338 +5 883F<93# 2393:478A385G<52796563:78523752392+8A +93A3/?6868>57/78:6A3952393J<3:57;435656783957A3?353 523 385963: C+A3 68 523 93B38<3 93/79A: 93;?3/568> 523 8+C37;!793:534+95C385 * 39<:+?7;52393/79A:;<9523993B3+?52+552393 2+: .338 87 8756;6/+5678 6::<3A .E 523 93:478A385# <52796563:68/?<A68>.E523!793:534+95C385A3/?+968> - 11 - 93:39B68>523 ?+8A .3?78>68>57 5234356567839 365239+: + +?<= !793:5 79 6:596/5 !793:5 79 523 3:39B3A !793:5 +: 523/+:3C+E.3 23>9+85C+A3+8A523:+><B+?6/2656::<3A68 ;+B7<97;52343565678396:+?:7+AC6553A?E:<.:6:568>3B38 56?? 57A+E 23 :5+?3C+53 27@3B39 6: /78568<68> +: +//79A68>5752393:478A385G5+53/395+68?+8A:68/?<A68> 523 ?+8A .368> /?+6C3A .E 523 4356567839 2+: .338 /78:6A393A +: DA33C3A ;793:50 7@3B39 87 4+956/<?+9: 2+B3.338;<986:23A68526:93>+9A $ 8 523 ?6>25 7; 523 +;793:+6A ;+/5: +8A 523 :<.C6::678:C+A3.E523?3+983A/7<8:3?;795234+9563: 526: @965 43565678 6: @652 523 ;7??7@68> A693/5678: " 23 4356567839 :2+?? C+=3 + ;93:2 93493:385+5678 +?78> @652 +?? A7/<C385: K<:56;E68> 239 /?+6C 7B39 523 4974395E 57 93:478A385 7#23 34<5E 7CC6::67839 - 12 - 6A+9@65268'%A+E:;97C523A+537;93/3645 7;/3956;63A/74E7;526:79A39 &" 3:478A385 7#2334<5E7CC6::67839 6A+9+;539>6B68>:<;;6/6385744795<865E57523 4356567839 +: @3?? +: 34<5E 78:39B+579 7; !793:5<.#6B6:6786A+9@276:93:478A385 7' 239368 :2+?? 4+:: +4497496+53 79A39: C793 4+956/<?+9?E A3539C6868> 523 8+5<93 7; 523 ?+8A +8A +?:7 @652 93>+9A 57 523 >9+85 C+A368;+B7<97;5234356567839 '" 23 3F39/6:3 +: A693/53A +.7B3 :2+?? .3 <8A395+=38+8A/7C4?353A@65268+43967A7; * C7852: ;97C 523 A+53 7; 523 4356567839 :<.C65568>23993493:385+5678+:+.7B3 " 56:C+A3/?3+952+5:68/352343565678392+: .3386847::3::6787;523?+8A68539C:7;523 >9+85 79A39 :68/3 523 E3+9 ,$% 239 - 13 - 47::3::678 :2+?? 875 .3 A6:5<9.3A 56?? 523 79A39:+:A693/53A+.7B3+934+::3A !*( '$!$) & )