Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 46609 (KAR)

NAGARATNA v. SANTOSH

WP/200287/2025 · 2025-02-04

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!" #$%% &$ ' ! " #! $ ! " % $&' ( # ) ) # *+ Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - ,& + $' ) - ) ) ./ 0/1/20324 52 6 62 4./ 157/ 61 /2568 5957 ):0;/ 320 ) 520.32:8 5< =/168/ 4.5< 6:84 >.377/2;52; 4./ >688/>42/<< 61 32 680/8 034/0 $&' =? @.5>. 4./ 6:84 058/>4/0 4./ A73524511 46 A3? 0/15>54 <43BA 0:4? 61 + 3< 0:4? 320 A/2374? 62 4./ <37/ 3;8//B/24 <6:;.4 46 =/ B38C/0 =? .5B <:54 52 6 @3< 157/0 168 <A/>515> A/8168B32>/ 61 32 3;8//B/24 61 <37/ A:8A684/07? /D/>:4/0 =? 0/1/20324 52 1396:8 61 A73524511 @./8/:20/8 ./ .30 3;8//0 46 </77 4./ <:54 <>./0:7/ A86A/84? 168 3 46437 <37/ >62<50/834562 61 + 320 .30 8/>/59/0 3 <:B 61 + 3< A384 61 4./ 3;8//0 <37/ >62<50/834562 - 3 - 4 5< <434/0 4.34 4./ <:54 @3< >624/<4/0 =? 4./ 0/1/20324 @.6 0/25/0 4./ /D/>:4562 61 4./ <350 3;8//B/24 320 37<6 0/25/0 4./ /24547/B/24 61 4./ A73524511 168 4./ 8/75/1 61 <A/>515> A/8168B32>/ 3</0 62 4./</ >624/24562< 4./ 8537 6:84 183B/0 5<<:/< 320 </4+06@2 4./ >3</ 168 48537 ./ A73524511 485/0 46 B38C 4./ 3;8//B/24 61 <37/ @.5>. @3< 6AA6</0 =? 4./ 0/1/20324 62 4./ ;86:20 4.34 <:115>5/24 <43BA 0:4? @3< 264 A350 4./8/62 3< A6<</<<562 @3< 0/759/8/0 46 4./ A73524511 B:>. A8568 46 4./ /D/>:4562 61 3 <37/ 0//0 320 4./8/168/ 4./ A73524511 @3< =6:20 46 A3? 4./ <43BA 0:4? 3< A86950/0 :20/8 845>7/ /!5! 61 4./ E382343C3 43BA >4 &$% ' ./ A73524511 6AA6</0 4./ 3AA75>34562 320 >624/20/0 4.34 4./ A6<</<<562 @3< 264 0/759/8/0 :20/8 4./ 3;8//B/24 61 <37/ =:4 @3< 0/759/8/0 :20/8 3 7/3</ /D/>:4/0 =? 4./ 0/1/20324 52 1396:8 61 4./ A73524511 @.5>. @3< </A3834/7? 8/;5<4/8/0 / 4./8/168/ >624/20/0 4.34 @./2 4./ A6<</<<562 61 4./ A86A/84? @3< 264 0/759/8/0 :20/8 4./ 3;8//B/24 ./ @3< 264 =6:20 46 A3? <43BA 0:4? :20/8 - 4 - 845>7/ /!5! 61 4./ E382343C3 43BA >4 &$% ./ 8537 6:84 314/8 >62<50/852; 4./ 8/>5437< 52 4./ 3;8//B/24 ./70 4.34 A6<</<<562 @3< 264 0/759/8/0 :20/8 4./ 3;8//B/24 320 4.34 4./ A73524511 .30 A350 + 3< <43BA 0:4? 62 4./ 3;8//B/24 320 @3< =6:20 46 A3? + @.5>. @3< 4./ 0/15>54 <43BA 0:4? 320 ./2>/ 058/>4/0 .5B 46 A3? 0:4? 320 A/2374? 3B6:2452; 46 3 <:B 61 + /52; 3;;85/9/0 =? 4./ <350 680/8 4.5< A/454562 5< 157/0 ./ 7/382/0 >6:2</7 168 4./ 0/1/20324 <:=B544/0 4.34 4.6:;. A6<</<<562 @3< A:8A684/07? 0/759/8/0 46 4./ A73524511 :20/8 3 7/3</ 0//0 54 .30 46 =/ >62<48:/0 4.34 A6<</<<562 @3< 0/759/8/0 :20/8 4./ 3;8//B/24 3< 4./ 85;.4 61 3 4/2324 B/8;/0 52 4./ 3;8//B/24 61 <37/ 320 ./2>/ 54 <.6:70 =/ 0//B/0 4.34 A6<</<<562 @3< 0/759/8/0 :20/8 4./ 3;8//B/24 61 <37/ ./ 7/382/0 >6:2</7 1:84./8 52954/0 4./ 344/24562 61 4./ 6:84 46 /DA73234562 46 845>7/ /! E382343C3 43BA >4 &$% 320 >624/20/0 4.34 51 3 A6@/8 61 344682/? 5< /D/>:4/0 52 1396:8 32 3;8//B/24 .670/8 4./2 4./ <3B/ 5< - 5 - >62<48:/0 3< 0/759/852; A6<</<<562 :20/8 4./ 3;8//B/24 320 <43BA 0:4? 3< A3?3=7/ :20/8 845>7/ /!5! E382343C3 43BA >4 &$% 5< A3?3=7/ / 4./8/168/ <:=B54< 4.34 4./ <3B/ 32376;? .3< 46 =/ 3AA75/0 @./2 A6<</<<562 5< 0/759/8/0 :20/8 3 7/3</ 0//0 /D/>:4/0 A8568 46 4./ 3;8//B/24 61 <37/ ./ E382343C3 43BA >4 &$% 5< 3 15<>37 7/;5<734562 320 4.5< 6:84 >32264 <:AA7/B/24 32? 6B5<<562 52 4./ 7/;5<734562 46 A86950/ 168 32 /248? @.5>. 5< 264 A86950/0 52 4./ 43BA >4 A/8:<37 61 4./ 3;8//B/24 61 <37/ <.6@< 4.34 4./8/ @3< 3 A8568 7/3</ 3;8//B/24 /D/>:4/0 =? 4./ 0/1/20324 52 1396:8 61 4./ A73524511 52 8/<A/>4 61 4./ <:54 A86A/84? @.5>. @3< 0:7? 8/;5<4/8/0 320 A6<</<<562 61 4./ <:54 A86A/84? @3< 0/759/8/0 46 4./ A73524511 :20/8 4./ <350 7/3</ 3;8//B/24 4 5< 4./8/314/8 4.34 4./ <37/ 3;8//B/24 @3< /D/>:4/0 =? 4./ 0/1/20324 52 1396:8 61 A73524511 ./8/ 5< 26 B/24562 61 4./ 0/1/20324 .32052; 69/8 A6<</<<562 61 4./ <:54 A86A/84? 68 48/3452; 4.34 4./ A86A/84? 0/759/8/0 :20/8 4./ 7/3</ 3;8//B/24 3< - 6 - 0/759/8? 61 A6<</<<562 61 <:54 A86A/84? :20/8 4./ 3;8//B/24 61 <37/ ./8/ 5< 26 B/8;/8 61 4./ 85;.4< 61 7/<<// @54. 4.34 61 32 3;8//B/24 .670/8 /2>/ 4./ >735B 61 4./ 0/1/20324 4.34 4./ 85;.4< 61 3 7/<<// .3< B/8;/0 @54. 4./ 85;.4< 61 3 A:8>.3</8 5< :23>>/A43=7/ ./ 85;.4< 61 3 7/<<// >32 B/8;/ @./2 4./8/ 5< 3 4832<1/8 61 4./ A86A/84? 52 4./ B322/8 A86950/0 :20/8 />4562 ' 61 4./ 832<1/8 61 86A/84? >4 4 5< 3AA38/24 4.34 A6<</<<562 61 4./ <:54 A86A/84? @3< 0/759/8/0 46 4./ A73524511 264 :20/8 4./ 3;8//B/24 61 <37/ =:4 @3< :20/8 3 A8568 7/3</ 320 ./2>/ 4./ A73524511 @3< 264 8/F:58/0 46 A3? 4./ <43BA 0:4? 3< A8/<>85=/0 :20/8 845>7/ /!5! 61 4./ E382343C3 43BA >4 &$% ./ 8537 6:84 .3< 85;.47? >62<50/8/0 4./ <3B/ 320 .3< 85;.47? ./70 4.34 4./ A73524511 5< 264 753=7/ 46 A3? 4./ <43BA 0:4? 4 .6@/9/8 ./70 4.34 4./ A73524511 5< =6:20 46 A3? 0/15>54 0:4? 61 + 320 5BA6</0 A/2374? 61 4/2 45B/< 4./ 0:4? 320 058/>4/0 4./ A73524511 46 A3? + 3< 4./ 0/15>54 <43BA 0:4? 320 A/2374? ./8/168/ 4.6:;. 4./ 8537 6:84 <.6:70 264 .39/ 5BA6</0 4/2 45B/< 4./ 0:4? 3< A/2374? ?/4 4./ 5BA:;2/0 680/8 06/< 264 B/854 320 - 7 - 524/81/8/2>/ 34 4./ 52<432>/ 61 4./ 0/1/20324 52 4./ <:54 /2>/ 4./ @854 A/454562 5< () &%' % 5<4 6 & 7 6 G