Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 46606 (KAR)

SATISH @ SANTOSH v. LOKU RATHOD AND ORS

MFA/200752/2021 · 2025-01-28

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#" $# # %%&' ( ) ! " # $ "% !& &'( '"!%! ) && & '%*!+! & ), +"'+!'+ ! # LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.29 10:35:25 - 0800 - 2 - & & !() ! & # &# !"+!++ & ' (++ +!% & # - # - ./01 2113/.4.5 67 89. :;51<.08 205 2=235 /0 >(++ +!% 528.5 !"+!++ 89. ?.8/8/>0.3 /@ 6.A>3. 89/@ >;38 @..B/01 .0920C.<.08 >A 89. C><?.0@28/>0 + .23589.D.230.5C>;0@.DA>389.2??.DD208205 89.3.@?>05.08>) - 3 - +) 0*++!"89.?.8/8/>0.3=2@8324.D/012@2 ?/DD/>03/5.3>089.<>8>3C7CD.6.23/01.1>'!)'' E")2D>01=/89>0.@9=2320589.23;8/ <0/6.23/01 .1>'+*''!E!E C2<. A3>< 9/05 @/5. >A 89. <>8>3C7CD.205C>DD/5.5=/8989.8=>=9..D.3@23.@;D8 >A=9/C989.?.8/8/>0.3A.DD5>=0205@;@82/0.5A32C8;3.>A >CC/?/82D6>0./0</5D/0.3.2C9/01;?8>A>3.23<<210;< 9.<>33921. C>08;@/>0 5/AA;@. C.3.632D .5.<2 >89.3 /0:;3/.@ . =2@ @9/A8.5 8> >@?/82D 28 >D2?;3 9. ?.8/8/>0.3C>08.05@89289.=2@263/198@8;5.08205=2@ 2D@> 5>/01 213/C;D8;32D =>3B .230/01 @!++++ ' ?.3 <>089 ;. 8> 89. /0:;3/.@ @;AA.3.5 67 9/< 9. 92@ D>@8 @83.0189 /0 9/@ D/<6@ 3.@;D8/01 /0 5.?D.8.5 @83.0189 9.3.A>3.89.3./@2?.3<20.085/@26/D/878/@C>08.05.5 8928 2CC/5.08 6./01 0.1D/1.0C. >0 89. ?238 >A 89. C23 53/4.3 +" 0 @.34/C. >A 0>8/C. 89. 3.@?>05.08 >! 5/5 0>8 2??.23 9. 3.@?>05.08 >@ 205 ) =9> =.3. 89. >=0.3 205 /0@;3.3 >A 89. 4.9/CD. 2??.23.5 6.A>3. 89. - 4 - 3/6;02D 9. 3.@?>05.08 > C>08.05.5 8928 89. 0.1D/1.0C.=2@>089.?238>A89.3/5.3>A89.<>8>3C7CD. 20589289/@53/4.3925242D/553/4/01D/C.0@.@@;C9207 D/26/D/87<276.A2@8.0.5;?>089.3.@?>05.08>) +% 9. 3.@?>05.08 >) 89>;19 25</88.5 89. ?>D/C7 924/01 6..0 /@@;.5 /0 A24>;3 >A 3.@?>05.08 > 6;8/8/@C>08.05.5892889.3./@4/>D28/>0>A89.8.3<@205 C>05/8/>0@ >A 89. ?>D/C7 9.3.A>3. 89. D/26/D/87 92@ 8> 6. A2@8.0.5;?>089.3.@?>05.08>82D@>3./8.328.589. C>08.08/>0@ 8928 89. 0.1D/1.0C. =2@ >0 89. ?238 >A 89. 3/5.3>A89.<>8>3C7CD. + 9.3/6;02DA32<.589.2??3>?3/28./@@;.@205 89. ?.8/8/>0.3 =2@ .F2</0.5 #! 205 89. 5>C8>3 =9> 2@@.@@.5 9/@ 5/@26/D/87 =2@ .F2</0.5 2@ # F! 8> ! =.3. <23B.5 /0 89. .4/5.0C. 9. >AA/C/2D >A 89. 3.@?>05.08 >) =2@ .F2</0.5 2@ #! 205 20>89.3 =/80.@@ =2@ .F2</0.5 2@ # 205 F! 8> ) =.3. <23B.5/089..4/5.0C. - 5 - +( A8.39.23/0189.231;<.08@89.3/6;02DA>;05 892889.3. /@ 2 A;0C8/>02D 5/@26/D/87 >A +G 2052@@.@@/01 89. <>089D7 /0C><. >A 89. ?.8/8/>0.3 28 @%+++ ' ?.3 <>089 205 2=235.5 89. C><?.0@28/>0 >A @")%+++ ' ;05.389.A>DD>=/019.25@' D > .25@ ><?.0@28/>0 =235.5 +! 0:;37?2/0205@;AA.3/01@ @)++++ ' + .5/C2DF?.0@.@ @EE+++ ' +) >@@>A/0C><.5;.8> ?.3<20.08?97@/C2D5/@26/D/87 @!+++ ' +" &>>52050>;3/@9<.08 @)++++ ' +% 88.05208C9231.@ @++++ ' + >04.720C.C9231.@ @++++ ' +( >@@>A2<.0/8/.@205A;8;3. ;092??/0.@@ @++++ ' >82D @")%+++ ' - 6 - +* ./01 2113/.4.5 67 89. @2<. 89. ?.8/8/>0.3 /@ 6.A>3.89/@>;38 +E 9.D.230.5C>;0@.D2??.23/01A>389.?.8/8/>0.3 C>08.05@ 8928 89. ?.8/8/>0.3 92@ @;AA.3.5 632/0 /0:;37 =9/C9 92@ 3.@;D8.5 /0 ?238/2D 9.</?D.1/2 205 9. 92@ D>@8 @83.0189 /0 9/@ D/<6@ @ @;C9 89. 5/@26/D/87 2@@.@@.5 67 89. 3/6;02D /@ 0>8 C>33.C8 . ?>/08@ >;8 8928 89. # 925@828.589.5/@26/D/878>6.%+G86./0120.;3>D>1/C2D 5/@26/D/87/8@9>;D5924.6..02CC.?8.56789.3/6;02D/0 .08/3.87. 2D@> ?>/08@ >;8 8928 89. C><?.0@28/>0 ;05.3 89. >89.3 9.25@ /@ 2D@> >0 D>=.3 @/5. 9.3.A>3. 89. C><?.0@28/>06.3.2@@.@@.56789/@>;38 !+ .3 C>0832 89. D.230.5 C>;0@.D 2??.23/01 A>3 3.@?>05.08>) =>;D5@;6</8 892889. ?.8/8/>0.3 89>;19 C>08.05@89289.=2@?;3@;/019/@@8;5/.@6;89.92@0>8 @9>=0 207 <28.3/2D 8> .@826D/@9 8928 9. =2@ 20 213/C;D8;3/@8.?>/08@>;8892889.C><?.0@28/>02=235.5 6789.3/6;02D6782B/0189.5/@26/D/87>A+G/@?3>?.3 9.3./@0>0..5A>3.0920C.<.08>A89.@2<. - 7 - !! 9.A2C8892889.?.8/8/>0.3=2@21.526>;8! /@ 0>8 /0 5/@?;8. 9. ?.3;@2D >A 89. 8.@8/<>07 >A # =>;D5 @9>= 8928 9. 2@@.@@.5 89. 5/@26/D/87 205 9. A>;05 8928 ?.8/8/>0.3 925 =.2B0.@@ /0 9/@ 3/198 ;??.3 D/<6 ?3.9.0@/D.A;0C8/>0@>A89.3/1989205/@3.5;C.53.@;D8/01 /0 D28.32D ?/0C9/01 C7D/053/C2D 132@? 205 @?9.3/C2D 132@? 205 9>>B 132@? 67 %+G . 925 @828.5 8928 89.3. /@ 3.5;C8/>0 >A 89. ?>=.3 /0 89. 3/198 23< 89. .D6>= 205 @9>;D5.39.3.A>3.;D8/<28.D79.C><.@8>89.C>0CD;@/>0 892889.5/@26/D/87/@8>89..F8.08>A%+G.2D@>>?/0.5 8928 89.3. /@ =.2B0.@@ /0 89. 3/198 D>=.3 D/<6 9. ?.8/8/>0.3 =2DB@ =/89 2 12/8 =9/C9 /@ /05/C28/4. >A 9.</?D.1/2 ! C23.A;D2@@.@@<.08>A89.26>4..4/5.0C.67 #=>;D5@9>=892889.3/198;??.3D/<620589.3/198 D>=.3D/<6>A89.?.8/8/>0.392@3.5;C.58>@83.01899. A2C8 8928 89. ?.8/8/>0.3 =2DB@ =/89 89. 12/8 /@ 2D@> 20 /05/C28/4.>A</D59.</?D.1/2 - 8 - !) #9.089/@2@?.C8/@0>8@?.C/A/C2DD7?>/08.5>;8 205 3.6;88.5 67 207 C>1.08 .4/5.0C. 89. @;6</@@/>0 >A 89. D.230.5 C>;0@.D 2??.23/01 A>3 89. 3.@?>05.08 >) 892889.<288.392@8>6.3.A.33.58>89.<.5/C2D6>235/0 89/@2??.2DC200>86.2CC.?8.58/@=>3898>0>8.892889. .4/5.0C.>03.C>35@;11.@8892889.3./@</D59.</?D.1/2 >0@/5.3/0189.21.>A89.?.8/8/>0.39.92@8>@;AA.389. @2<. A>3 3.@8 >A 9/@ D/A. 8 <27 6. 83;. 8928 >4.3 89. ?.3/>5>A8/<.89.3.<276.<231/02D/<?3>4.<.08/089. C>05/8/>0 >A 89. ?.8/8/>0.3 079>= 89. 5/@26/D/87 92@ 8> C>08/0;.A>389.3.@8>A89.D/A. !" 9. 3/6;02D 2A8.3 0>8/01 8928 89.3. /@ /05/C28/>0@>A9.</?D.1/22058928#9255.?>@.58928 89.3. /@ %+G 5/@26/D/87 3.5;C.5 89. @2<. 8> +G 2@ 2 A;0C8/>02D 5/@26/D/87 0 89. C>0@/5.3.5 >?/0/>0 >A 89/@ >;38 89. 3.5;C/01 89. A;0C8/>02D 5/@26/D/87 28 +G /@ /0C>33.C8.0C.89.A;0C8/>02D5/@26/D/87/@C>0@/5.3.567 89/@>;3828)+G - 9 - !% 9. 1;/5.D/0.@ /@@;.5 67 89. A>3 @.88D.<.08 >A 5/@?;8.@ 6.A>3. >B'52D289 ?3.@C3/6.5 2 0>8/>02D /0C><. >A @(%++ ' ?.3 <>089 A>3 89. 7.23 +!" 0 ;<?8..0 0;<6.3 >A :;51<.08@ 89/@ >;38 92@ 9.D5 8928 89. 1;/5.D/0.@ /@@;.5 67 89. 23. /0 1.0.32D C>0A>3</87 =/89 89. =21.@ A/F.5 ;05.3 89. /0/<;< #21.@ C8 9.3.A>3. 89.7 23. 2CC.?826D. .0C.89.0>8/>02D/0C><.>A89.?.8/8/>0.3/@C>0@/5.3.5 28 @(%++ ' 9.3.A>3. 89. /@ C2DC;D28.52@@(%++ 'F!F)+GF!*H@"*+++ ' 6782B/012<;D8/?D/.3>A!*A>389.21.>A!7.23@ ! @2C>0@.I;.0C.9>D5/0189.D2/5;?2?.3/>5 8>6.)<>089@89.C><?.0@28/>0>A;05.389.9.25>A /@ C2DC;D28.5 2@ @(%++F)H !( 9.3/6;02D92@2=235.52@;<>A@++++ ' ;05.3 89. 9.25 >A 0 89. C>0@/5.3.5>?/0/>0>A89/@>;38/892@8>6..0920C.58> - 10 - !* 9. 3/6;02D 92@ 2=235.5 3.2@>026D. C><?.0@28/>0 2<>;08 8>=235@ 9.@2<.0..50>8 6.5/@8;36.5 !E 9.3.A>3. 89. CD2/<208 /@ .08/8D.5 A>3 8>82D .0920C.5 C><?.0@28/>0 >A @)!%++ ' ;05.3 89. A>DD>=/019.25@' D > .25@ ><?.0@28/>0 =235.5 6789/@>;38 ! 0:;37?2/0205 @;AA.3/01@ @)++++ ' .5/C2DF?.0@.@ @EE+++ ' ) >@@>A/0C><.5;.8> ?.3<20.08?97@/C2D 5/@26/D/87 @"*+++ ' " &>>5205 0>;3/@9<.08 @)++++ ' % 88.05208C9231.@ @++++ ' >04.720C.C9231.@ @++++ ' ( >@@>A2<.0/8/.@205 A;8;3.;092??/0.@@ @"++++ ' * >@@>A/0C><.5;3/01 D2/5;??.3/>5 @%++ ' >82D .@@=235.56789. 3/6;02D @("(%++ ' @")%+++ ' >82D.0920C.<.08 @)!%++ ' + .0C. 2??.2D 5.@.34.@ 8> 6. 2DD>=.5 /0 ?238 9.3.A>3.89.A>DD>=/01, - 11 - 9.2??.2D/@2DD>=.5/0?238 9. 2??.DD208 /@ .08/8D.5 A>32@;<>A @)!%++ ' /0255/8/>08>=92892@6..02=235.56789.3/6;02D 2D>01=/89/08.3.@82889.328.>AG?2A3><528. >A?.8/8/>08/DD89.528.>A5.?>@/8 .@8 >A 89. >35.3 ?2@@.5 67 89. 3/6;02D 3.1235/01 5.?>@/8.8C3.<2/0;02D8.3.5 5 ' &# ( # /@8>!D>"