Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 46603 (KAR)

PRADEEP S/O PRABHU v. VIJAY SHETTY AND ANR

MFA/200331/2022 · 2025-01-28

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#" $ # # %%& ' ( ) ! " # $ % ! & $& '(! ) ! ! $ *$ ! !! $ ! " # $ + , - !*% LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.01 15:22:10 - 0800 - 2 - $+ + !-#!% + $ * $ + &$ * ( ! $ ! & $ $ + $ - * '. ! *!. $ + $ &$* $ / $&$& # # / $&$& % 012345673615893:;63<45=6739:>>3:;?6@85;A512 123 >:;1?37 123 B:113; ?7 1:C36 => 85; 8?6:9 <?7>57:9 125=@2?1?779:13<85;<B?77?56 2?7 :>>3:9 ?7 <?;3413< :@:?671 123 D=<@B361 :6< :E:;< ?6 $ 5 ! >:773< A0 93:;63< 36?5; ?F?9 &=<@3 :6< <<9 $ 2:9C? #23;3?6:813; ;383;;3<15:7G123;?A=6:9H85;725;1% <:13<( ! 0 123 ?B>=@63< D=<@B361 :6< :E:;< 123 ;?A=6:9 2:7 :995E3< 123 49:?B >31?1?56 ?6 >:;1 :6< :E:;<3< : 7=B 58 7 - :7 45B>367:1?56 :6< <?;3413< ;37>56<361 57! :6< 123;3?6 15 <3>57?1 123 - 3 - 7:B3 @@;?3F3< A0 123 7:?< D=<@B361 :6< :E:;< 123 >31?1?563;?7A385;312?75=;1 23 >31?1?563; B31 E?12 : ;5:< 1;:88?4 :44?<361 56 - ( !- E2?93 23 E:7 >;5433<?6@ 56 B515;40493 A3:;?6@ 5- , :6< E236 23 :6< 1E5 5123;7 E3;3 E:?1?6@ 85; 123A=7 63:; :6@:B372E:;:B::6 : 4:; A3:;?6@ 5$' 4:B3 ?6 2?@2 7>33< :6< 63@9?@361 B:663; :6< <:723< 123 >31?1?563; :6< 23 7=71:?63< @;?3F5=7 ?6D=;?37 23 1E5 5123;7 E3;3 :975 ?6D=;3<:6<1230<?3<9:13;23>31?1?563;456136<3<12:1 23 E:7 :@3< 03:;7 E:7 : 71=<361 :6< =73< 15 <5 C?;:6:A=7?63773:;6?6@7! >3;B5612:6<<=315 123 :44?<361:9 ?6D=;?37 23 2:7 7=883;3< >3;B:6361 <?7:A?9?10 :6< :7 7=42 23 B:0 A3 :E:;<3< :<3I=:13 45B>367:1?56 25=@2 ;37>56<361 57! :6< :>>3:;3< A385;3 123 ;?A=6:9 E;?1136 71:13B361 E:7 8?93< 5690 A0 ;37>56<361 567=;:643 5B>:60 456136<?6@ 12:1 123 45B>367:1?56 49:?B3< ?7 2?@290 3J5;A?1:61 :6< 123 13;B7 - 4 - :6< 456<?1?567 58 123 >59?40 E3;3 F?59:13< A0 123 <;?F3; :6<5E63;581234:;:6<:97512:1123;3E:74561;?A=15;0 63@9?@3643 56 123 >:;1 58 123 >31?1?563; 7 7=42 23 >;:03<85;<?7B?77:95812349:?B>31?1?56 6 123 A:7?7 58 123 :A5F3 >93:<?6@7 123 ;?A=6:98;:B3<634377:;0?77=3785;?174567?<3;:1?5623 >31?1?563; E:7 3J:B?63< :7 *! :6< J7! 15 ' E3;3 B:;C3< 63E?16377E:73J:B?63<:7*!56A32:9858 ;37>56<3617 :6< J! E:7 B:;C3< 813; 23:;?6@ 123 :;@=B3617 A0 A512 123 7?<37 123 ;?A=6:9 2:7 :E:;<3< 123 45B>367:1?56 58 7 - 15 123 >31?1?563; 259<?6@12:1123?645B358123>31?1?563;?77 >3; B5612 :6< 123 <?7:A?9?10 ?7 :1 !. :6< <?;3413< ;37>56<36157!:6<15>:012345B>367:1?56:B5=61 =6<3;<?883;36123:<7:7A395E :?6:6<7=883;?6@7 7! $3<?4:93J>36737 7 56F30:643 :1136<:61 42:;@37 ) 65=;?72B361 7 577 58 8=1=;3 3:;6?6@ 4:>:4?10 56 :445=6158>3;B:6361<?7:A?9?1?37 7! 51:9 7 - - 5 - ( @@;?3F3<A01237:?<D=<@B361:6<:E:;< 123 >31?1?563; ?7 A385;3 12?7 5=;1 733C?6@ 362:643B361 456136<?6@12:1123I=:61=B5845B>367:1?56:E:;<3<A0 123;?A=6:9?75612395E3;7?<3 - 3:;< 123 :;@=B3617 A0 123 93:;63< 45=6739 :>>3:;?6@ 85; 123 :>>399:61 :6< 93:;63< 45=6739 85; ;37>56<3615 3:;63< 45=6739 :>>3:;?6@ 85; 123 :>>399:61>31?1?563;E5=9<456136<12:1123;?A=6:98:?93< 15 :77377 :>>;5>;?:13 <?7:A?9?10 125=@2 * 2:< 71:13< 12:1123;3?7.<?7:A?9?101512395E3;9?BA56:445=6158 8;:41=;3 58 1?A?: :6< 123 ;?A=6:9 :975 8:?93< 15 4567?<3; :>>;5>;?:13 651?56:9 ?645B3 :6< :7 7=42 123 45B>367:1?56633<715A3;3:773773<A012?75=;1 ' 3; 4561;: 93:;63< 45=6739 :>>3:;?6@ 85; ;37>56<361 567=;:643 5B>:60 456136<7 12:1 123 45B>367:1?56 :E:;<3< A0 123 ;?A=6:9 ?7 >;5>3; :6< 45;;341:6<123;3?765633<85;362:643B361581237:B3 - 6 - ! 23 8:41 12:1 123 >31?1?563; E:7 :@3< :A5=1 03:;7:11231?B358:44?<361?7651?6<?7>=1325=@2 123>31?1?563;456136<712:123E:7<5?6@C?;:6:A=7?6377 :956@E?12>=;7=?6@2?771=<?37 65<54=B361:;03F?<3643 ?7 :F:?9:A93 15 >;5F3 123 ?645B3 58 123 >31?1?563; 23 @=?<39?637 ?77=3< A0 123 :;6:1:C: 1:13 3@:9 3;F?437 =125;?10?6;37>34158123731193B3615812349:?B7:;?7?6@ 5=158123B515;F32?493:44?<3617A385;31235C<:9:12 >;374;?A37123651?56:9?645B3587! >B85;123 03:; !- 6 =B>1336 6=BA3; 58 4:737 12?7 5=;1 2:7 239< 12:1 123 7:?< @=?<39?637 ?77=3< A0 123 :;3 ?6 @363;:9 45685;B?10 E?12 123 E:@37 8?J3< =6<3; 123 $?6?B=B*:@374123;385;3 123651?56:9?645B358123 :>>399:61 ?7 239< 15 A3 7! >B 23;385;3 123 45B>367:1?56 =6<3; 123 23:< 58 9577 58 8=1=;3 ?645B3 ?7 4:94=9:13<:77! J!J!J!.K7 - A0:<5>1?6@123B=91?>9?3;58! !! 5673I=36190 A0 259<?6@ 12:1 123 >31?1?563; 45=9<651;37=B32?765;B:9:41?F?1?37:193:7185;:>3;?5< - 7 - 58 1E5 B56127 23 ?7 361?193< 85; : 7=B 58 7 =6<3;12323:<58957758?645B3<=;?6@9:?<=>>3;?5< ! 23 ;?A=6:9 2:7 651 :E:;<3< :60 45B>367:1?56=6<3;12323:<58957758:B36?1?37?69?83 567?<3;?6@123:@358123>31?1?563;:6<1236:1=;358123 ?6D=;?37 ?1 ?7 D=71 :6< >;5>3; 15 :E:;< : 7=B 58 7 =6<3;12?723:< ! 23 45B>367:1?56 :E:;<3< A0 123 ;?A=6:9 :1 7! =6<3;12323:<58>:?6:6<7=883;?6@:>>3:;7 15A35612395E3;7?<3 7?643123>31?1?563;2:<7=883;3< 45B>5=6< 45BB?6=13< 8;:41=;3 58 1?A?: :6< 23 2:< 15 =6<3;@57=;@3;?37<=;?6@1231;3:1B36123;385;3 :7=B 587 ?7:E:;<3<=6<3;12?723:< ! 567?<3;?6@ 123 >3;?5< 58 ?6>:1?361 1;3:1B361 123 45B>367:1?56 =6<3; 123 23:< 58 456F30:643 :1136<:61 42:;@37 :6< 65=;?72B361 ?7 :975 ?64;3:73< 15 7! - 8 - ! 23 45B>367:1?56 :E:;<3< A0 123 ;?A=6:9 =6<3;123;3B:?6?6@23:<7?7>;5>3;:6<<5376514:9985; :60?613;83;3643A012?75=;1 !( 3643 123:>>399:61?7361?193<85;123B5<?8?3< 45B>367:1?56=6<3;<?883;36123:<7:7A395E :?6:6<7=883;?6@ 7 $3<?4:93J>36737 7 56F30:643 :1136<:61 42:;@37 ) 65=;?72B361 7! 57758?645B3<=;?6@9:?<=>>3;?5< 7 577588=1=;33:;6?6@7 7 - 57758:B36?1?37?69?83 7 51:9 377:E:;<3<A0;?A=6:9 62:643B361 7 ! 7 - *+ 2=7 123 :>>399:61 ?7 361?193< 85; 362:643< 45B>367:1?56 58 7 - ' E?12 ?613;371 :6< 123;385;3 123 :>>3:9 <373;F37 15 A3 :995E3< ?6 >:;1 3643 12385995E?6@ #?% 23:>>3:9?7:995E3<?6>:;1 #??% 23 ?B>=@63< D=<@B361 :6< :E:;< >:773< A0 123 ;?A=6:9 ?7 B5<?8?3< A0 :E:;<?6@ : - 9 - 7=B 58 *+ ?6 :<<?1?56 15 E2:1 2:7 A336 :E:;<3< A0 123 ;?A=6:9 15@3123; E?12 ?613;371 :1 (. >: 8;5B 123 <:13 58 >31?1?561?99?17;3:9?L:1?56 #???% 37>56<361 5 67=;:643 5B>:60 ?7 <?;3413< 15 <3>57?1 123 361?;3 45B>367:1?56 :B5=61E?12?6:>3;?5<587?JE33C78;5B123 <:135812?75;<3; #?F% 371 58 123 5;<3; >:773< A0 123 ;?A=6:9 ;3B:?67=6:913;3< < & # ( # ?715!95!