- 1 - !"#$ %#&## # '(')*+( '** , !" #$ %& # & $ ' & !" && ' "( &&) !* !" # &$ %& # &' + ' $ Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ' !*, ' & # $ ! * ' #$ & & & ( " # & ! " $ & ' ' ' '' & *(#$-!*#$ '"*# *-**(- "- '&$!- '& " & ' . #& . $ /0123456 05121234 27 82956 :; 1<5 /==>756 ?<3 27 /@56 ;5/A7 >465A 5=1234 ! * 38 </A/12;/ /@/A2B >A/B7<//4<21/"*755B24@@A/4138A5@>9/A:/2924/ 05=2/9 /75#& $ 3( " /A2724@ 3>1 38 A2C5 3! " 38 /4D2 &392=5 1/1234 271 /2=<>A 83A 38854=50>427</:95>465A5=12347*(#$-!/465=1234 *#$ 38 </A/12;/ ;/;/ /4<21/ "* /46 5=12347 ! /46-38&A315=123438<296A548A3C5E>/9 8854=57" #& =1$ - 3 - <50A375=>1234.7=/75271</134>45" /1 /00A3E2C/159; !*" 0C 1<5 D2=12C /995@56 13 :5 /46 / </98 ;5/A7 396 ?/7 >49/?8>99; B264/0056 :; 1<5 051212345A 1 27 8>A1<5A /995@56 1</1 1<5 051212345A A505/1569;</683A=58>975E>/92415A=3>A75?21<1<5D2=12C =347121>124@ /@@A/D/156 05451A/12D5 75E>/9 /77/>91 3475F>5419; / =A2C5 ?/7 A5@2715A56 /@/2471 1<5 051212345A83A38854=570>427</:95>465A5=1234*(#$38 1<5</A/12;/;/;//4<21/"* * <5 95/A456 =3>4759 83A 1<5 051212345A A585AA56 131<5D2=12C.771/15C5417C/65>465A5=1234-381<5 A2C24/9&A3=56>A5365#A&$/465=1234-!381<5 A&A5=3A656:583A51<505=2/9>6@5137>:C211</1 1<5051212345A</7:5548/9759;2C092=/156/46</7:55424 =>7136; 724=5 >45 - " <5 =3>4759 /A@>56 1</1 C562=/9 5D2654=5 7>@@5717 1<5 D2=12C 27 :51?554 - /46 ( ;5/A7 396 /46 ?/7 =/0/:95 38 >465A71/4624@ 1<5 =3475F>54=5738<5A/=123471?/78>A1<5A=341546561</1 1<5 D2=12C D39>41/A29; /==3C0/4256 1<5 051212345A 13 - 4 - /4@/93A5 =341A/62=124@ 1<5 B264/0024@ /995@/1234 585AA24@131<5C562=/9A503A1?<2=<A503A1569;2462=/157 4372@4738A5=54175E>/9/=12D21;1<5=3>4759/A@>561<27 =/717 63>:1 34 1<5 D5A/=21; 38 1<5 C/24 /995@/12347 <5A583A51<5=3>475973>@<113:/9/4=51<5@A/D21;381<5 =</A@57?21<1<5051212345A.7A2@<11392:5A1;5C0</72G24@ 1</11<5051212345A27431A5F>2A5683A8>A1<5A24D5712@/1234 /7 1<5 4D5712@/124@ 882=5A </7 /9A5/6; 82956 / =</A@5 7<551A5465A24@=34124>5624=/A=5A/1234>445=577/A; ! &5A=341A/1<595/A456 2@<3>A13D5A4C541 &95/65A 71A34@9; 3003756 1<5 05121234 5C0</72G24@ 1<5 <5243>7 4/1>A5 38 1<5 38854=5 ?<2=< 27 0>427</:95 >465A 1<5"*/461<5&A315=123438<296A548A3C5E>/9 8854=57 #& $ =1 " <5 3D5A4C541 &95/65A 7>:C21156 1</1 1<5 D2=12C.7 71/15C541 A5=3A656 >465A 5=1234-!381<5A&=95/A9;657=A2:571<5051212345A.7 /=12347651/2924@ <3?<59>A561<5D2=12C?21</0A3C275 38C/AA2/@58A3C/;3>4@/@5/461<524=26541734>45 "/46>45"24=9>624@75E>/92415A=3>A75/46 - 5 - 7>:75F>5411<A5/17<53D5A4C541&95/65A/A@>561</1 1<5 D2=12C.7 71/1>7 /7 / C243A A5465A7 1<5 F>571234 38 =347541 95@/99; 2AA595D/41 >465A 1<5 & =1 /46 1<5 75D5A21;381<538854=57?/AA/417=34124>56=>7136; <5 95/A456 =3>4759 /005/A24@ 83A 1<5 75=346 A570346541 =3C09/24/41 /630156 / 72C29/A 71/4=5 =34154624@1</11<575D5A21;381<538854=57627541219571<5 051212345A /==>7568A3C75=>A24@A5@>9/A:/29 - /D24@ <5/A6 1<5 =3>4759 34 A5=3A6 1<5 83993?24@03241/A275783A=347265A/1234 H<51<5A 1<5 051212345A ?<3 27 43? =</A@5 7<55156 83A 38854=57 0>427</:95 >465A 5=12347 *(#$ -! /46 *#$ 38 1<5 </A/12;/ ;/;/ /4<21/ "* /46 5=12347 ! /46 - 38 1<5 &A315=123438<296A548A3C5E>/9 8854=57=1 "#& =1$275412195613A5@>9/A:/29IH - 6 - ( 5=3A67 A5D5/9 1</1 1<5 24D5712@/1234 27 =3C09515 =9375A 5E/C24/1234 38 1<5 D2=12C.7 71/15C541 >465A 5=1234 -! 38 1<5 A& 2462=/157 7<5 ?/7 24 / A59/12347<20?21<1<5/==>756/@56;5/A7<5C562=/9 5D2654=5A59256>034:;1<50A375=>1234A5D5/971<5D2=12C 27/@56:51?554-/46(;5/A7?<29531<5A63=>C5417 7>@@5717<5?/7;5/A7/46C341<7396341<56/1538 1<5 /995@56 24=26541 91<3>@< 1<5 051212345A 27 43? =</A@57<5515683A38854=57=3D5A56>465A1<5& =1 1<27 3>A1 =/4431 2@43A5 1</1 1<5 /==>756 27 / ;3>4@ 3885465A /@56 ;5/A7 24D39D56 24 / & =/75 =34=5A424@ /C243A D2=12C <5 6585475 /1 1<27 J>4=1>A5 <2@<92@<17 1<5 D2=12C.7 5=1234 -! 71/15C541 ?<2=< /=B43?956@57/0A23AA59/12347<20/46<5AD39>41/A;1A/D59 13/4@/93A5<5C562=/9A503A10/A1381<5=</A@57<551 C/15A2/9 A503A1569; 7<3?7 43 72@47 38 A5=541 75E>/9 /=12D21; 3?5D5A 1<5 @A/D21; 38 1<5 /995@/12347 C>71 :5 7>:71/412/156:;1<50A375=>12346>A24@/8>998956@561A2/9 ?<5A5 1<5 :>A654 27 34 1<5 0A375=>1234 13 0A3D5 1<5 - 7 - /==>756.7 @>291 5/A24@ 24 C246 1<5 /==>756.7 /@5 <27 65154123424J>62=2/9=>7136;724=5>45-"/461<5 A59/12D59; 7C/99 /@5 @/0 :51?554 1<5 D2=12C @2A9 /46 1<5 /==>7561<273>A127381<5D25?1</1?<54=2A=>C71/4=57 7>@@571 / =3C095E /63957=541 A59/12347<20 1<5 051212345A C/; :5 549/A@56 34 :/29 <295 1<5 D2=12C.7 /=B43?956@C541 38 / H93D5 /88/2AH 27 95@/99; 2AA595D/41 /1 1<2771/@51<5/=1>/9/@5381<5D2=12C?<51<5A;5/A7 /46C341<7:51?554-13(;5/A73A/:3D5(;5/A7 C>71 :5 0A2C/A29; 6515AC2456 6>A24@ / 8>998956@56 1A2/9 ?<5A55D2654=5=/4:515715624651/29 1 1<5 :/29 71/@5 1<27 3>A1 C>71 :/9/4=5 1<5 /995@/12347 38 38854=57 >465A 1<5 & =1 ?21< 1<5 051212345A.7 8>46/C541/9 A2@<1 13 05A734/9 92:5A1; >465A A12=95381<5347121>123438462//=B43?956@24@1</1 @>29127349;571/:927<56/815A/8>998956@561A2/9C03724@ 71A24@541 =346212347 13 0A5D541 892@<1 A27B 3A ?214577 1/C05A24@?299547>A51<52415@A21;381<51A2/90A3=577/46 =/>75 43 75A23>7 0A5J>62=5 13 1<5 0A375=>1234 3A 1<5 - 8 - D2=12C34D5A759;=34124>5665154123424J>62=2/9=>7136; /1 / 15465A /@5 =3>96 75D5A59; 2C0/=1 1<5 /==>756 / =A>=2/9 /705=1 1</1 =/4431 :5 2@43A56 2D54 1</1 1<5 =</A@57<551</7:55482956/461<5051212345A27:3>4613 8/=5 1A2/9 1<27 3>A1 82467 21 /00A30A2/15 13 549/A@5 1<5 051212345A 34 :/29 7>:J5=1 13 71A24@541 =346212347 /46 / =95/A 62A5=1234 1</1 <5 ?299 431 =341/=1 3A 2412C26/15 1<5 D2=12C==3A624@9;1<50324183A=347265A/123427/47?5A56 241<5K , '3A1<583A5@324@A5/73471<273>A10/77571<5 83993?24@ 2$<50512123427 22$<5051212345A2762A5=15613:5549/A@5634:/2924 05=2/9 /75 #& $ 3 ( " /A2724@ 3>1 38 A2C5 3 ! " 38 /4D2 &392=5 1/1234 271 /2=<>A 83A 38854=57 0>427</:95 >465A 5=12347 *(#$ -! /46 *#$ 38 1<5 </A/12;/ ;/;/ /4<21/ "* /46 - 9 - 5=12347!/46-381<5&A315=123438<296A548A3C5E>/9 8854=57=1"#& =1$054624@341<5829538 669 271A2=1 /46 5772347 >6@5 /2=<>A 7>:J5=1 13 1<5 83993?24@=346212347 /$ <5 051212345A 7</99 5E5=>15 / 05A734/9 :346 83A/7>C387""""" ?21<1?37>A5125783A 1<5 92B5 7>C 13 1<5 7/1278/=1234 38 1<5 J>A2762=1234/93>A1+ :$ <5 051212345A 7</99 /005/A A5@>9/A9; 34 /99 <5/A24@ 6/157 :583A5 1<5 A2/9 3>A1 >49577 <27 /005/A/4=5275E5C015683AD/926A5/7347:;1<5 3>A1+ =$ <5 051212345A 7</99 431 62A5=19; 3A 2462A5=19; 1<A5/154 3A 1/C05A ?21< 1<5 0A375=>1234 ?21457757+ 6$ <5 051212345A 7</99 431 24D39D5 24 72C29/A 38854=57241<58>1>A5+ - 10 - 5$ <5 051212345A 7</99 431 95/D5 1<5 J>A2762=1234 381<5A2/93>A1?21<3>121705AC277234>41291<5 =/75A5@2715A56/@/2471<2C276270375638+ 8$ <5 051212345A 7</99 431 =341/=1 1<5 D2=12C 521<5A 15950<342=/99; 3A 0<;72=/99; ?<295 1<5 1A2/9 27054624@=347265A/12344;7>=</115C017</99 :5D25?5675A23>79;/467</99:51<57395@A3>46 83A=/4=59924@1<5:/29 -+ '##* & 271393