Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46585 (KAR)
SMT. LAXMI @ DISH MALLAMMA. v. SMT. BASAMMA NAGAPPA
CRP/200028/2025 · 2025-04-01
Anant Ramanath Hegde
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46585 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46585 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "
#$%!$
&&! '
&&! !"
# " $
% "
&&
"'
()
! # "
*
! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!"
# "
! !! !"
# " $
& & & " +, * ,*,* -& . .& & %' . & " )*,* /
!"
# " $
% "
&&
"'
- 3 -
()
! # "
*
!*
!"
# "
! !*
!"
# " $
& & & " +, * ,*,* -& . .& & %' . & " )*,* /
"
&
" "
0. - 4 -
%0. '
12324256567839:29:6368;7<5987:=2:=952=* ,*,* 68 7 )*,* 78 512 >6?2 7> 512 :68@649? 6A6? .<=;2" 96@1<: 23478=285 7 B2>7:2 5163 7<:5 193 >6?2= 7 )*,* " 322C68; :2?62> 7> 68D<8@5678 68 :2342@5 7> 98 6EE7A29B?2 4:742:5F B29:68; <:A2F 7*!G9/* 68 273<;<: 7B?6 7> 96@1<: 59?<C9 12 4?96856>> 9?37 37<;15 9 =6:2@5678 57 512 :2A28<2 9<517:65623 57 :2@56>F 512 :2A28<2 :2@7:=342:596868;575123<654:742:5FBF=2?2568;51289E27> =2>28=985398=57:2357:216389E2
* 12 =2>28=9853 @7852352= 512 3<65 98= >6?2= 5H7 944?6@956783" 782 <8=2: :=2: <?2 %9' 7> 512 7=2 7> 6A6?:7@2=<:2%>7:317:5I7=2'98=987512:<8=2::=2:
<?2 %='7>7=212>6:354:9F2:H9357:2D2@55124?968578 5124:2E6325195"512:26387@9<327>9@567857>6?25123<65
! 1232@78=4:9F2:63785124:2E63251955123<6563 56E2 B9::2= 12 5:69? 7<:5 :2D2@52= B751 512 944?6@956783 28@2" 5H7 :2A63678 425656783 9:2 >6?2=" 93396?68; 512 396=
- 5 -
@7EE78 7:=2: 49332= 78 944?6@956783 >6?2= <8=2: :=2: <?2 %9'98=<8=2::=2: <?2 %='7>7=2
29:82=@7<832?:622:231<=619?"94429:68;78 B219?>7>512425656782:3H7<?=@78528=5195"5124?96856>>6812: 4?9685193@78528=2=5195"29:?62:"5124:742:5FH9349:5656782= B25H228 512 4?96856>> 98= =2>28=9853 98= 512 4?96856>>-3 89E2 H932852:2=685124:742:5F:2@7:=3368@2*,,!98=512:29>52:
685124?96856532?>5124?96856>>19335952=5195"68512F29:*, ( 512 =2>28=9853 ;75 512 4:742:5623 49:5656782= 9E78;
512E32?A23 98= 4<:3<985 57 512 39E2" 512:2 H93 9 E<595678 2852:68; 512 89E2 7> 512 =2>28=9853 68 512 4:742:5F :2@7:=3 17<;1 512 4?96856>> 193 9332:52= 5195 512 89E2 7> 512 =2>28=98539:22852:2=685124:742:5F:2@7:=3"BF=2?2568;512 89E2 7> 512 4?96856>> H6517<5 512:2 B268; 98F :6;15" 565?2 98= 6852:235 98= H6517<5 8756@2 57 512 4?96856>> 12 4?9685 9A2:E2853H7<?=@?29:?F2359B?6315195512=2>28=98537*98= ! 9:2 68 512 4733233678 7> 512 4:742:5F 98= 93 3<@1" 512 3<65 H6517<5:2?62>7>=2@?9:956787>565?263B9::2=<8=2:?9H8=2: 51232@6:@<E3598@23"6563<:;2=5195"5123<6563B9::2=<8=2: ?9H
- 6 -
5639?37<:;2=5195"5123<656356E2B9::2=78512 ;:7<8= 5195" 68 512 F29: *, ( 512 89E2 7> 512 =2>28=985 63 2852:2=685124:742:5F:2@7:=398=5123<65317<?=19A2B228 >6?2= H65168 51:22 F29:3 >:7E 512 =952 7> @2:56>6@95678 7> E<595678285:F1<3"12H7<?=<:;251955125:69?7<:52::2= 6817?=68;5195512944?6@9567839:2875E96859689B?2
( 1637<:5193@7836=2:2=512@7852856783:9632=68 5129:98=42:<32=512:2@7:=3
) =E6552=?F" 512 3<65 63 782 >7: 68D<8@5678 H12:268 5124?96856>>63322C68;68D<8@56789;96835512=2>28=985378512 4:2E632 5195 512 4?96856>> 63 356??
68 4733233678 7> 512 4:742:5F =234652512E<595678B268;2852:2=6851289E27>=2>28=9853 7*98=!68512F29:*, (H6517<58756@2575124?96856>>12 32@78=4:9F2:6357=2?25251289E237>512=2>28=985368512 4:742:5F:2@7:=3
5 63 >7:51@7E68; >:7E 512 9A2:E2853 E9=2 68 512 4?9685 5195" 512 4?96856>> 68656952= 4:7@22=68;3 B2>7:2 512 336359857EE6336782:785124:2E632519568512F29:*, (" 512 89E23 7> 512 =2>28=9853 9:2 2852:2= 68 512 4:742:5F :2@7:=3H6517<5512:2B268;98F8756@2575124?96856>>98=6563
- 7 -
9?37 >7:51@7E68; 5195 512 E9552: H93 9;65952= B2>7:2 512 :2A28<2 9<517:65623 78 5H7 7@@936783 98= 87H 512 24<5F 7EE6336782:193>689??F49332=987:=2:H651987B32:A95678 5195 512 285:623 319?? @78568<2 3<BD2@5 57 512 :23<?5 7> 512 428=68; 3<65 68 7 )*,* 163 B268; 512 47365678" 5163 7<:5637>512A62H5195"5123<65>7:68D<8@5678@98875B2396= 57 B2 56E2 B9::2= B2@9<32 7> 512 4?96856>> 9??2;23 5195 512 4?96856>>63356??6847332336787>5124:742:5F98=512285:62363 E9=2685124:742:5F:2@7:=68512F29:*, (H6517<58756@257 5124?96856>>12=634<52B2>7:2512336359857EE6336782:63 :9632=68512F29:*,*,98=5123<6563>6?2=68 512F29:*,* 98= 93 >9: 93 512 3<65 >7: 68D<8@5678 63 @78@2:82= 65 63 9 :2@<::68; @9<32 7> 9@5678 98= 512:2 63 87 ?6E6595678 93 3<@1 1<3 512 @785285678 5195 512 3<65 63 56E2 B9::2= @98875 B2 9@@2452=
+ 3>9:93512@7852856785195"5123<65H6517<5:2?62> 7>=2@?9:956787>565?263875E96859689B?263@78@2:82="656357 B28756@2=5195"5124?96859A2:E2853H7<?=68=6@9525195"512 4?96856>>639332:568;47332336787A2:5123<653@12=<?24:742:5F" =234652512285:623B268;E9=26851289E27>512=2>28=9853 7 57!124?96856>>193@783635285?FE96859682=93598=5195
- 8 -
512 4?96856>>-3 89E2 63 =2?252= 68 512 4:742:5F :2@7:=3 H6517<5 512 8756@2 57 512 =2>28=9853 163 B268; 512 47365678" 512 4?96856>> 63875<8=2:7B?6;9567857322C9:2?62>7>=2@?9:95678 12512:93<6563E96859689B?2>7:H9857>:2?62>7>=2@?9:95678 68512?6;157>5124?29=68;3685124?968519357B2=2@6=2=95 51256E27>5:69?124?9685@98875B2:2D2@52=9551251:2317?= 78 512 4:2E632 5195 512 3<65 63 875 E96859689B?2 >7: H985 7> =2@?9:956787>565?2 56357B28756@2=51955124?9685=723875 =63@?7325122J63528@27>98F:2;6352:2=565?2=22=6851289E2 7> 512 =2>28=9853 57 H16@1 512 4?96856>> 63 9 49:5F 163 B268;
512 47365678" 5163 7<:5 63 7> 512 4:6E9/>9@62 A62H 5195 512 @78528567851955123<6563875E96859689B?2>7:H9857>:2?62>7> =2@?9:9567819357B2:2D2@52="955163359;212512:512:2?62> 7>=2@?9:9567863:2K<6:2=7:87519357B2=2@6=2=9551256E2 7>>689?=634739?9>52:5125:69?"68512>9@537>5163@932
, 5 63 H2?? 3255?2= 47365678 7> ?9H 5195" H128 512 7<:5 @7836=2:3 512 944?6@95678 <8=2: :=2: <?2 7>
"5127<:519357;7BF5129A2:E285E9=2685124?9685 9?782124:9F2:E9=2685124?968563>7:68D<8@567868:2342@5 7> 98 6EE7A29B?2 4:742:5F 78 512 4:2E632 5195 512:2 63 98 6852:>2:28@2 78 9@@7<85 7> 98 285:F 68 512 :2@7:= 7> :6;153
- 9 -
2:2?F B2@9<32 782 328528@2 68 512 4?9685 =63@?7323 5195 512 4:742:562319A2B22849:5656782=B25H228512=2>28=98537 57!"512396=328528@2@98875B2:29=68637?956785739F5195 512 :2E96868; 9A2:E2853 68 512 4?9685 9332:568; 5195 512 4?96856>> 63 4733233678 >7: 512 4:742:5F 63 =6?<52= 7: 8<??6>62= 12329:2512E9552:357B2@7836=2:2=9551256E27>5125:69?
8=2: 51232 @6:@<E3598@23" 5163 7<:5 =723 875 19A2 98F:29378 57 6852:>2:2H651 512 6E4<;82= 7:=2:49332= BF5125:69?7<:528@2"5124256567839:2
* 563><:512:E9=2@?29:51955127B32:A956783E9=2 6851637:=2:9:278?F@78>682=57512E2:657>512944?6@956783 <8=2: :=2: <?2 7> 512 7=2 75168; 68 5163 7:=2:
H7<?= B2 @7835:<2= 93 19A68; 2J4:2332= 98F 7468678 78 512 E2:6537>512@?96E7>26512:7>51249:5623
!(
'$ ) %
6357 ?7*