- 1 - !!" !#$ % "&"'""! ""'' ($!) * ! " # # $%&%' ( ) * Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! # $+ $&&'# ,, $%&%' ## $%&%' ( ) "' #) ** # # +)*# # ' # # # & ' # -+&%%, $ ". -% $. # # / - 3 - &! 012304 5673-08 962 :;0 1<<08813:- =- <20-03: 012304 5673-0896220-<63403:6=-1>-03: 012480123045673-08962:;01<<08813:- ;=- 1<<018 =-9=804 1?1=3-: :;0 @74?A03: 134 1B124 41:04&<1--04=3 6' >C:;0 44=:=6318 03=62 =D=8 74?0 134 1=5;72 30 1?121@ -63 69 21<<1 1::131-;0::C 1?04 1>67: % C012- A0: B=:; 13 155=403: 63 % 134 4=04 =- B=90 417?;:02 134 A6:;02 9=804 581=A <0:=:=63 581=A=3? 56A<03-1:=63 69 -% $ B=:; =3:020-: ;0 2=>7318 563-=402=3? :;0 0D=40350 63 205624 ?213:04 56A<03-1:=63 69 -+&%%, $ B=:; =3:020-: 1: ". <02 1337A 926A :;0 41:0 69 <0:=:=63 :=88 2018=E1:=63 ' ??2=0D04 >C :;0 -1=4 62402 :;=- 1<<018 =- 9=804 -00F=3?03;1350A03:=3B;=5;=:=-563:03404:;1::;01A673:- ?213:0473402:;06:;02;014-1206386B02-=40;040501-04 B1-0123=3?-% $<02A63:;>7::;02=>7318;1-:1F03 - 4 - ;=- =356A0 1- -% $ <02 A63:; 0350 20G70-:04 962 03;1350A03:69:;056A<03-1:=63 %;67?;:;0<0:=:=6302-$581=A13:-;1D0-:1:04:;1::;0 40501-04B1-0123=3?-% $<02A63:;>C46=3?<2=D1:0 -02D=5013418-6-:1:04:;1:;0=-:;06B30269:;0;6:08>7: :;0C;1D036:9=80413C<266969;=-=356A0;040501-04A0: B=:; 13 155=403: =3 :;0 C012 - <02 :;0 ?7=408=30- 69 1231:1F1:1:00?1802D=50- 7:;62=:C;=-36:=6318=356A0=- :6>0:1F031--+% $<02A63:;0B1-1?04%C012- 134:;0A78:=<8=02=-"6'.=-:6>014404:6B124-97:720 <26-<05:-1-<02:;0@74?A03:69:;063/>807<20A0672:=3 :;0 51-0 69 134 630 :;=24 =- :6 >0 40475:04 :6B124- <02-6318 0H<03-0- 1- <02 :;0 ?7=408=30- 69 :;0 63/>80 7<20A0 672: =3 :;0 51-0 69 ;7-:;086--6940<034035C56A0- :6-'"' $)+%I'.$ 24HH"* 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 - 5 - "#72:;021-<02:;0?7=408=30-69:;063J>807<20A0 672: =3 :;0 51-0 69 ! "# "$ %134=3 :;0 51-0 69 & ! ' ( ) ' * :;0 9=2-: <0:=:=6302 =- 03:=:804 962 -'' $ :6B124- 86-- 69 -<67-18 563-62:=7A :;0 -05634 <0:=:=6302 =- 03:=:804 962 -'' $ :6B124-<1203:18563-62:=7A134:;=24<0:=:=6302=-03:=:804962 -'' $ :6B124- 9=8=18 563-62:=7A ;7- - $ =- ?213:04 :6B124- 86-- 69 563-62:=7A - $ =- 1B12404 73402 563D03:=6318 ;014- 1- <02 :;0 ?7=408=30- 69 63/>80 7<20A0672:=3:;051-069 + ;0 2=>7318 ?213:04 -+"% $:6B124-A04=5180H<03-0-134:;=-672:3004- 36=3:029020350B=:;:;0-1A03188:;0581=A13:-12003:=:804 962:;056A<03-1:=6369-&"""% $B=:;=3:020-:1:".<02 1337A1-1?1=3-:-+&%%, $1B12404>C:;02=>7318 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 5 (2017) 16 SCC 680 - 6 - +;01B1246956A<03-1:=63<1--04>C:;02=>7318=- A64=9=041-73402 014- A673:=3- 6--690<034035C '"' $ 6--6963-62:=7A $ 6B124-563D03:=6318;014- $ '6B124-A04=5180H<03-0- +"% $ 6:18 &"""%+ &3:;020-78::;096886B=3?62402=-<1--04 )=* <<018=-1886B04=3<12: )==* ;0 581=A13:- 120 03:=:804 962 :;0 :6:18 56A<03-1:=6369-&"""% $B=:;=3:020-:1:".<1926A :;041:069<0:=:=63:=88:;041:0692018=E1:=63 )===* ;0 20-<63403:$3-721350 56A<13C =- 4=205:04 :6 40<6-=::;0 19620-1=4 56A<03-1:=63 1A673: B=:;=3 630 A63:; 926A:;041:069:;=-62402 )=D* 3-75;40<6-=::;0:;=24<0:=:=6302$A6:;0269:;0 40501-04=-03:=:804962- $B=:;=3:020-:134-;0=- <02A=::04 :6 B=:;421B :;0 03:=20 1A673: 1863? B=:; =3:020-: 1552704 63 =:K -% $ =- :6 >0 F0<: =3 :;0 31A0 69 -05634<0:=:=6302=39=H0440<6-=:=313C31:=6318=E04>13F:=88 - 7 - -;0 1::1=3- :;0 1?0 69 A1@62=:C 134 :;0 9=2-: <0:=:=6302 =- <02A=::04 :6 B=:;421B =3:020-: 1552704 63 =: 6350 =3 :B6 A63:;- :6 A00: 67: :;0 41C :6 41C 3050--=:=0-K 134 :;0 9=2-: <0:=:=6302 =- <02A=::04 :6 B=:;421B :;0 >181350 1A673: 1863? B=:;=3:020-:155270463=: ,-+ ('""!) &! =-:686&&