- 1 - !" # $ $ ""% & ' ( ! "#$%&'$ ! ! !(% #$()'% & " #$()' * &+ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !'%!'! ! " * * ,& * " * " '%')!'!' * #- ,!'( * " . $ . /012 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 34/ 0<</55063 062 5/016/27896:/5;811/:<862/638& ! /=6>0>>1=/?/2@A34/B92>C/630620D012=6 8,!'( 203/2 '%')!'!' @A 5/016/2 225 /6=81 =?=5 92>/ E =B0A0<91 34/ </3=3=86/1 =: @/;81/ 34=: 8913 =6 0<</05 ://F=6> /64067/C/63 8; 34/ 78C</6:03=86 - 3 - & 4/ 70:/ 8; 34/ </3=3=86/10<</55063 =: 3403 86 !',!'$ 03 0@893 '&' 4/ D0: 310?/5=6> 0: 0 <=55=86 1=2/1 86 34/ C83817A75/ @/01=6> 8#!(#!),! 062=<</1@/01=6>8#!(#,))70C/;18C4=62:=2/ 062 20:4/2 38 34/ C83817A75/ 1/:953=6> =6 34/ </3=3=86/1 ;055=6>28D6062:9:30=6=6>0719:4=6B91A384=:5/;301C / D0: 02C=33/2 38 :4D=6= 8:<=305 850<91 062 402 962/1D/63 341// :91>/1=/: 062 4/ @/=6> 0>/2 0@893 &% A/01: D81F=6> 0: 7885=/ /016=6> :$'''# </1 C8634 40: :9;;/1/2 </1C06/63 2=:0@=5=3A 062 0: :974 02/G903/ 78C</6:03=86C0A@/0D012/2384=C 4/1/:<862/638062!@/=6>34/8D6/10: </134/=6:91067/<85=7A062 @88F34/1/:<862/638& @/=6> =6:91067/ 78C<06A D/1/ =::9/2 D=34 34/ 683=7/ 4/1/:<862/638&0586/0<</01/2@/;81/34/1=@9605 4/ 1/:<862/63 8 062 ! D/1/ <507/2 /H#<013/ 4/ 1/:<862/63 8& =6 =3: D1=33/6 :303/C/63 7863/62/2 3403 34/077=2/63D0:6838607789638;34/6/>5=>/67/8;34/ 21=?/18;34/=<</106234/1/:<862/638402@1/074/2 - 4 - 34/7862=3=86:8;34/<85=7A06234/1/;81/=3=:6835=0@5/38 <0A 34/ 78C</6:03=86 3 D0: 7863/62/2 3403 34/ 78C</6:03=86750=C/2=:4=>45A/H81@=3063=C0>=601A062 963/60@5/ 062 34/ 0>/ =678C/ 062 8779<03=86 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1D0:2/6=/2@A=3 $ 6 34/ @0:=: 8; 34/ 0@8?/ 7863/63=86: 34/ 0<<18<1=03/ =::9/: D/1/ ;10C/2 @A 34/ 1=@9605 062 34/ </3=3=86/1D0:/H0C=6/20:"4/287381D480::/::/2 2=:0@=5=3AD0:/H0C=6/20:"!H38,D/1/C01F/2 86 @/405; 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1 4/ 1/:<862/63 8& 2=2 683 02297/06A/?=2/67/ ) ;3/1 4/01=6> @834 :=2/: 34/ 1=@9605 0D012/2 78C</6:03=86962/1?01=89:4/02:0:@/58D+ 58 /02: C8963 0=6062:9;;/1=6>: :''''# ! /2=705/H</6:/: :$'''''# & 8::8;=678C/29/38;9673=8605 <4A:=7052=:0@=5=3A :!)'''# *8820626891=:4C/63 :$'''# $ 33/620637401>/: :$'''# ) 86?/A067/7401>/: :$'''# , 8::8;0C/6=3=/:062;9391/ 9640<<=6/:: :''''# )*+ ,--. - 5 - , /=6>0>>1=/?/2@A34/G90639C34/</3=3=86/1 =:@/;81/34=:8913=60<</05 ( 4/5/016/27896:/50<</01=6>;8134/</3=3=86/1 D8952 :9@C=3 3403 34/ "! =6 4=: 3/:3=C86A 40: :303/2 340334/</3=3=86/140::9:30=6/234/2=:0@=5=3A8;0@893!$ 38 !(I @93 34/ 1=@9605 40: 0::/::/2 34/ ;9673=8605 2=:0@=5=3A03'I3=::9@C=33/2340334/</3=3=86/1@/=6> 0 7885=/ 4=: 5/;3 4062 40: :9;;/1/2 20C0>/ 1/:953=6> =6 2/<5/3=86 8; 4=: ;9673=8605 0@=5=3=/: 38 /016 4=: 5=?/5=4882 /:9@C=3340334/78C</6:03=860D012/2@A34/1=@9605 962/1 34/1/C0=6=6> 4/02: =: 05:8 86 34/ 58D/1 :=2/ 062 34/1/;81/01/#0::/::C/63@/C02/ % /1 786310 5/016/2 7896:/5 0<</01=6> ;81 34/ 1/:<862/63 8& D8952 :9@C=3 3403 34/ 1=@9605 40: 0::/::/2 34/ 2=:0@=5=3A =6 0 <18</1 D0A 062 34/1/ =: 68 6//2 ;81 06A /64067/C/63 4/ 2/;/62: 34/ =C<9>6/2 B92>C/63062://F2=:C=::058;34/0<</05 ' 4/ ;073 3403 34/ </3=3=86/1 D0: 0 <=55=86 1=2/1 8634/C83817A75/062=3D0:4=3@A34/=<</15811A8D6/2 - 6 - @A1/:<862/638!=6:91/2@A1/:<862/638&=:683=6 2=:<93/3=:D813438683/3403:=67/34/</3=3=86/1D0:0 <=55=86 1=2/1 4/ =: 03 5=@/13A 38 >8 0>0=6:3 06A86/ 8; 34/ 3813 ;/0:81 062 0: :974 4=: 750=C 0>0=6:3 34/ 1/:<862/63 68&706683@/3916/228D6 701/;95</19:058;34/0?0=50@5/1/7812:D8952 :48D340334/</3=3=86/1402:9:30=6/2:/?/1/719:4=6B91A 38 34/ 5/;3 9<</1 5=C@ D=34 2/>508?=6> 8; 34/ 9<</1 5=C@ :F=64/1/D/1/0@10:=86:8634/5/;3F6//06234/-#10A :48D/2;107391/8;34/9560:3A58=2 <187/::74=<;107391/ 8; 34/ :70<48=2 @86/ 062 310</J=9C D=34 34/ 2/>58?=6> =6B91=/:4/2=:7401>/:9CC01AD89522=:758:/340334/1/ D/1/341//:91>/1=/:D=34D89622/@1=2/C/63062>10;3=6> 8;34/:F=64/</3=3=86/1D0:=6<03=/63;18C!',!', 38 ')'%!', 4=: 586> =6<03=/63 31/03C/63 =: 06 =62=703=86 8; 34/ 60391/ 8; 34/ =6B91=/: :9:30=6/2 062 34/ 31/03C/63>=?/6384=C ! "!=64=:3/:3=C86A0:D/550:=634/2=:0@=5=3A 7/13=;=703/ =::9/2 @A 4=C03 H) :0A 3403 34/106>/8; - 7 - C8?/C/63: 8; 34/ D1=:3 B8=63 062 /5@8D B8=63 40?/ 1/:31=73=86: 6 4=: 8<=6=86 34/ 2=:0@=5=3A 38 34/ 5/;3 D1=:3 B8=63 =: $I 5/;3 /5@8D B8=63 =: ,$I 062 38 34/ 4062 78C<86/63 =: 0@893 $I 53=C03/5A 4/ 78C/: 38 34/ 786759:=86 3403 34/ 38305 </17/630>/ 8; 2=:0@=5=3A =6 34/ 406278C<86/63=:(I06234038;34/01C78C<86/63=: !'I0620::97434/1/=:!$38!(I2=:0@=5=3A3834/5/;3 9<</1 5=C@ 4/ 2=:0@=5=3A 7/13=;=703/ /50@8103/5A C/63=86 34/C066/1=6D4=7434/0::/::C/63=:C02/@A"!3 >=?/: 06 8?/1055 <=7391/ 8; 34/ 2=:0@=5=3A :9;;/1/2 @A 34/ </3=3=86/1 "4/6 D/ B9H30<8:/ 34/ <4A:=705 2=:0@=5=3A 0::/::/2 @A 34/ "! D4=74 =: 03 !$ 38 !(I D=34 34/ 0?8703=86 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1 3403 4/ D0: 0 7885=/ 062 3403 4/D0:0>/2&,A/01:0334/3=C/8;34/077=2/633706 :0;/5A@/:0=2340334/;9673=86052=:0@=5=3A8;34/</3=3=86/1 =:7/130=65A683'I0:0::/::/2@A34/1=@9605634/ 786:=2/1/28<=6=868;34=:891334/;9673=86052=:0@=5=3A=: 0::/::/2 03 I 4/ </3=3=86/1 40: 683 <18297/2 06A C03/1=05 38 :48D 4=: =678C/ 4/1/;81/ 34/ 683=8605 =678C/ 40: 38 @/ 028<3/2 4/ >9=2/5=6/: =::9/2 @A 34/ - 8 - >9=2/5=6/: =::9/2 @A 34/ 016030F0 303/ />05 /1?=7/: 93481=3A<1/:71=@/34/683=8605=678C/8; :'!$#;81 34/ A/01 !'$ 6 9C<3//6 69C@/1 8; B92>C/63: 34=: 8913 40: 4/52 3403 34/:/ >9=2/5=6/: 01/ =6 786:86067/ D=3434/D0>/:;=H/2962/1 =6=C9C"0>/:73 & /67/34/58::8;;9391/=678C/8607789638; 34/2=:0@=5=3A=:70579503/20: :'!$'#H!H$HI K,/. 86:/G9/635A 4852=6> 50=2 9< </1=82 0: :=H C8634: 34/ </3=3=86/1 =: /63=35/2 ;81 0 :9C 8; ,-. 962/134=:4/02 $ 4/1=@960540:0D012/20:9C8; :''''# 962/1 34/ 4/02 8; <0=6 062 :9;;/1=6>: 062 34/ :0C/ 1/G9=1/:38@//64067/238,. ) 4/1=@960540:0D012/20:9C8; :$'''# 962/1 34/ 4/02 8; ;882 062 6891=:4C/63 033/62063 062 786?/A067/7401>/:34/:0C/1/G9=1/:38@//64067/238 ,. - 9 - , 4/1=@960540:0D012/20:9C8; :''''# 38D012:34/58::8;0C/6=3=/:=65=;/06234/:0C/1/G9=1/: 38@//64067/238,. ( 4/</3=3=86/1=:05:8/63=35/2;8178C</6:03=86 962/134/4/028;2=:;=>9103=86=60:9C8;,. % /67/ 34/ </3=3=86/1 =: /63=35/2 ;81 0 38305 78C</6:03=86 8; ,/0/. 962/1 34/ ;8558D=6> 4/02:# + 1*2, 345) *6*721289 ):17;845*+ 345) *6*721289 ):;,47) 0=6062:9;;/1=6>: :''''# :''''# ! /2=705/H</6:/: :$'''''# :$'''''# & 8::8;=678C/29/ 38;9673=8605<4A:=705 2=:0@=5=3A :!)'''# :!$(&''# *882062 6891=:4C/63 33/620637401>/: 86?/A067/7401>/: :$'''# :''''# $ 8::8;0C/6=3=/: 062;9391/ 9640<<=6/:: :''''# :&$'''# ) =:;=>9103=86 ## :!$'''# 8305 :(%(&''# 1,,D012/2@A34/1=@9605 :))'''# 64067/C/63 :!&,&''# - 10 - !' /67/34/;8558D=6> = 4/0<</05=:0558D/2=6<013 == 4/ =C<9>6/2 B92>C/63 062 0D012 <0::/2 @A 34/ 1=@9605 =: C82=;=/2 @A 0D012=6> 0 :9C 8; ,. =6 022=3=86 38 D403 40: @//6 0D012/2 @A 34/1=@960538>/34/1D=34=63/1/:303)I <0 ;18C 34/ 203/ 8; </3=3=86 3=55 =3: 1/05=J03=86 === /:<862/63 8!#6:91067/ 8C<06A =: 2=1/73/2 38 2/<8:=3 34/ /63=1/ 78C</6:03=86 0C8963 D=34=6 0 </1=82 8; :=HD//F:;18C34/203/8;34=:812/1 =? /:38;34/812/1<0::/2@A34/1=@9605 1/C0=696053/1/2 2# % $ ' $ =:3858