Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46544 (KAR)
HANAMANT DUNDAPPA NARALE AND ANR v. PANDURANG AND ORS
MFA/200081/2023 · 2025-03-04
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46544 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46544 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!$! !!%%&' ( )* !!%%+&' (
) *
! " #
$
%&'()
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
*
+ *
! "
$, ')*)** #
$ $ -*"# $ $
(()' ()
+) *
$
! "
#
- 3 -
*
*
%&'()
*
*
%&'()
*)
%&'()
& + **
"
#%(-*&- ! " $ ,
$, * & #
$ $ -*"# $
()
.% (()'
$$
- 4 -
/
$
"/ #
0123 4012503 6785904 2:15;151;7831 :21312 <72 1==04415>9 :5 $ 7)))')*
012503 6785904 <72 >?0 1==04415>%59821560 7@=15A :5 $7)*))?1957>98B@:>>03?:912;8@05>9
0:5; 1;;2:0C03 BA >?0 D83;@05> :5 7(()' =19903 BA %33:>:7514 05:72 :C:4 83;0 153%.:D1A1=821"<729?72>E>?02:B8514F#31>03 () >?0 =0>:>:75029 120 B0<720 >?:9 782> :5 $ 7)))')* 153 >?0 59821560 7@=15A :9 B0<720 >?:9782>:5$7)*))
* ?0 <16>814 @1>2:G 7< >?0 6190 >?1> 0@02;09 <27@>?02067239:9>?1>75)-1>1B78>*)1@ >?0 30601903%:33121A1 H19 H14I:5; 75 0G>20@0 053 7< >?0 2713 153 >?0 @7>726A640 B012:5; 7
% %() 2:3305 BA 750 8B?19? 61@0 :5 1 219? 153 50;4:;05>
- 5 -
@15502153319?03>7157>?02@7>726A640B012:5;7% '%') 153 >?0201<>02 B7>? >?0 C0?:6409 319?03 >7 :33121A1 H?020 ?0 3:03 380 >7 >?0 <1>14 :5D82:09 989>1:503 > :9 675>05303 >?1> >?0 30601903 H19 1;03 1B78> ' A0129 0125:5; 9&)))% =02 @75>? 153 >?0 =0>:>:75029 B0:5; >?0 =1205>9 7< >?0 30601903 ?1C0 479> >?0:2 975 153 >?020<720 >?0A 120 05>:>403 <72 >?0 67@=0591>:75
?0209=75305>79153B0<720>?02:B8514 H020 >?0 7H502 153 :598202 7< >?0 @7>726A640 B012:5; 7%'%')153>?0209=75305>79*153H020 >?0 2:302 153 7H502 7< >?0 @7>726A640 B012:5; 7
% %()
& 5 9=:>0 7< 902C:60 7< 57>:60 >?0 209=75305> 79*1533:357>1==012B0<720>?02:B8514>:9754A >?0209=75305>71==01203153675>09>03>?0641:@> H19 675>05303 BA 209=75305> 7 >?1> >?0 @7>726A640 B012:5; 7%'%') ?19 50C02 >786?03 >?0 30601903153>?020<7205750;4:;0560615B01>>2:B8>03>7
- 6 -
:>>H19675>05303>?1>>?050;4:;0560H1975>?0=12>7< >?0 2:302%209=75305> 7*%8B?19? 153 >?020<720 :> :9 754A>?0209=75305>79*153H?71204:1B40>7=1A>?0 67@=0591>:75 209=75305> 7 ?13 1497 675>05303 >?1> >?020 H020 C:741>:75 7< >02@9 153 6753:>:759 7< >?0 =74:6A 153 >?0 2:302 ?13 57 32:C:5; 4:60560
( 5 >?0 B19:9 7< >?0 1B7C0 675>05>:759 >?0 2:B8514<21@031==27=2:1>0:99809153>?0=0>:>:75027 H190G1@:50319153;7>@12I03G9>7'153 750H:>5099H190G1@:50319?0209=75305>93:3 57> 4013 15A 768412 0C:30560 B8> 67=A 7< >?0 =74:6A H19 @12I0319G
- <>02?012:5;B7>?>?09:309>?02:B851461@0 >7 6756489:75 >?1> 2:3029 7< B7>? >?0 @7>726A6409 675>2:B8>03 50;4:;0560 0J8144A 153 19909903 >?0 67@=0591>:75=1A1B401>9*-)))%1533:206>03>?0 209=75305> 7 >7 =1A >?0 67@=0591>:75 H:>?
4:B02>A >7
- 7 -
2067C02&)K7<>?091@0<27@>?0209=75305>79*153
' 0:5; 1;;2:0C03 BA >?0 91:3 D83;@05> >?0 =0>:>:75029 120 B0<720 >?:9 782> 900I:5; 05?1560@05> 7< >?0 67@=0591>:75 ?0 59821560 7@=15A :9 B0<720 >?:9 782>900I:5;1B974C0@05>7<:>94:1B:4:>A9:560>?06?12;0% 9?00> H19 <:403 754A 1;1:59> >?0 209=75305> 7* L 8B?19? 153 19 986? <19>05:5; &)K 4:1B:4:>A 75 >?0 209=75305>7B0<720>?02:B8514:9:5672206>
012503 6785904 1==012:5; <72 >?0 1==04415>9=0>:>:7502998B@:>9>?1>>?057>:7514:567@07< >?030601903H?7H191;031B78>(A0129@75>?9?19 57>B005=27=024A6759:30203BA>?02:B8514098B@:>9 >?1>0C05>?78;?>?030601903H191@:572>?0 :C:9:75 056? 7< >?:9 782> :5 $ 7)(')
*))
?19 ?043 >?1> >?0 @:5729 1;03 1B7C0 & A0129 ?1C0 >7 B0 6759:30203 19 1384>9 <72 >?0 =82=790 7< 199099@05> 7< 67@=0591>:75 153 :5 >?:9 20;123 >?0
- 8 -
:C:9:75056??19204:0375>?0D83;@05>7<>?075/B40 =0G782>:5>?061907<!" #$
%$
) 957>0398=215712;8@05>912013C1560375 B0?14<7<>?01==04415>%598215607@=15A
=028914 7< >?0 2:B8514 2067239 H7843 9?7H >?1> :5 >?0 67@=41:5> <:403 BA >?0 =0>:>:75029 B0<720 >?0 =74:60 :> H19 640124A @05>:7503 >?1> ?0 61@0 >7 I57H 1B78> >?0 166:305> >?278;? 750 1538 1>214 > H19 :5<72@03 >7 >?0 BA 91:3 1538 >?1> H?:40 >?0 30601903 H19 H14I:5; BA >?0 9:30 7< >?0 2713 >?0 209=75305>7*%8B?19?61@075>?0@7>726A640B012:5;
7
% %() H:>? 1 =:44:75 2:302 :5 ?:;? 9=003 153 50;4:;05>@15502153319?03>7>?0@7>726A6407<>?091:3 1538 :0 %'%') 153 >?05 319?03 >7 >?0 30601903 H?7 H19 H14I:5; 75 >?0 572>?025 9:30 7< >?0 2713?091:31538H05>>7>?09=7>153?13<7853>?1>
1 )*&)*-
- 9 -
>?0 30601903%:33121A1 ?13 98668@B03 >7 :5D82:09 66723:5;4A >?0 67@=41:5> H19 473;03 BA 153 :5C09>:;1>:75 H19 41856?03 BA >?0 =74:60 82:5; :5C09>:;1>:75>?05C09>:;1>:5;<<:602<7853>?1>>?091:3 8B?19? ?13 57 32:C:5; 4:60560 153 >?020<720 <:403 >?0 6?12;0 9?00> <72 >?0 7<<05609 =85:9?1B40 85302 06>:759 -**-**'153*)%7<15306>:75*2013H:>? '7<6>?07H5027<>?0@7>726A640H191221A03 19 1668903 7 153 ?0 H19 1440;03 7< 1447H:5; >?0 @7>726A640H?:6?H1957>:598203>7B032:C0575>?02713 BA1=02975H?7:957>?1C:5;1C14:332:C:5;4:60560153 >?020BA>?07<<05608530206>:75&(2013H:>?(153 06>:75 & 2013 H:>? ') 7< >?0 6> H020 :5C7I03 1;1:59> ?:@ ?0 5C09>:;1>:5; <<:602 3:3 57> <:53 15A 684=1B40 50;4:;0560 >7H1239 >?0 2:302 :0 1538 7< >?0 @7>726A640B012:5;7%'%')
?0=0>:>:75029675>053>?1>B7>?>?0C0?:6409 1<>02 >?0 6744:9:75 ?13 319?03 >7 >?0 30601903 ?:9 C029:759>1>03BAH?7641:@9>7B00A0H:>509937
- 10 -
57> <:53 15A 98==72> <27@ 15A 7< >?0 =74:60 =1=029 ?0 9=7>@1?1M121>G&H78439?7H>?1>>?020:913:9>1560 1B78> &) <00> <27@ >?0 =4160 H?020 >?0 C0?:640 7< 209=75305> 79 153 ?13 6744:303 H:>?
>?0 C0?:640 7< >?0 209=75305> 79* 153 153 >?0 =4160 H?020 :> ?13 319?03 >7 >?0 30601903 ?:9 H7843 9?7H >?1> B7>? >?0 C0?:6409?:>>:5;8=75>?0306019033757>;0>98==72><27@ >?0=74:60=1=029
* 0 >?1> 19 :> @1A >?0 =74:60 120 9133403 >7 :5C09>:;1>0 >?0 684=1B40 50;4:;0560 :5 >?0 @1>>02 ?0 :5C09>:;1>:5;1;056A:957>675602503H:>?>?016>:751B40 50;4:;0560 ?020<720 :> :9 >?0 16>:751B40 50;4:;0560 H?:6?:92040C15><721=0>:>:759<:4038530206>:75((7< >?06>
?0 =7:5> 57H =7903 B0<720 >?:9 782> :9 H?0>?02>?07H502153:5982027<>?0C0?:640B012:5;7 %'%')12014974:1B40>7=1A>?067@=0591>:75N
- 11 -
& >:9 90>>403=27=79:>:757<41H>?1> >?04:1B:4:>A >7=1A67@=0591>:7585302>72>12:90978>7<>?067560=> 7<16>:751B4050;4:;0560
( 516>:751B4050;4:;0560B19:6144A67@=2:907< 1#B2016?7<38>A7<61207H03>7157>?02=02975 7205>:>A B#>?038>A7<612020J8:2:5;>?0=029757205>:>A >7 0G026:90 2019751B40 6120 >7 =20C05> ?12@ 72 :5D82A>77>?029 6# >7 09>1B4:9? 16>:751B40 50;4:;0560 :> @89> B0 9?7H5>?1>>?0B2016?7<38>A618903>?0?12@72 :5D82A153 3# >?0 641:@15> @89> 1497 9?7H >?1> ?0 98<<0203 31@1;0919120984>7<B2016?7<38>A
- ?0 684=1B40 50;4:;0560 H?:6? :9 2040C15> <72 =279068>:5;1;056A67@=2:907< 1#;279972H15>75B2016?7<38>AH?:6?:9@720 902:789 153 0;20;:789 B2016? >?15 16>:751B40 50;4:;0560
- 12 -
B#206I40993:920;123<72>?091<0>A153H044B0:5;
7< 7>?029 H?:6? :9 1 ?:;?02 40C04 7< :5>05> >?15 16>:751B4050;4:;0560 6#67596:7893:920;123>7>?091<0>A153H044B0:5;
7< 7>?029 I57H:5; >?1> >?0:2 16>:759 67843 61890 ?12@ 3# 684=1B40 50;4:;0560 615 20984> :5 =85:>:C0 31@1;09H?:6?120309:;503>7=85:9?>?0H275; 3702<72>?0:2206I40991530;20;:789B0?1C:72
' >@1AB057>03>?1>>?030;2007<50;4:;0560 :5>05> 153 >?0 67590J805609 120 >?0 I0A 3:<<0205609 7< 16>:751B4050;4:;0560153684=1B4050;4:;0560684=1B40 50;4:;056020J8:209?:;?0230;2007<=277<19:>20984>9:51 =85:9?@05> >7 >?0 H275; 3702 ?020<720 :< :> :9 9?7H5 >?1> 1 =02975 <1:403 >7 0G026:90 15A 7< >?0 6120 19 @05>:7503 1B7C0 ?0 H7843 B0 4:1B40 >7 =1A >?0 67@=0591>:75
?0 67560=> 7< 16>:751B40 50;4:;0560 H19 6759:30203 BA >?0 =0G 782> :5 >?0 6190 7<
- 13 -
&' (' ( %$ $) :5 >?0 1B7C0D83;@05>1>=121;21=?7(:>H19?04319B047H
! " # $
$
%
) 5 7>?02 H7239 H?7 618903 >?0 166:305>N 153 >?0 159H02 >7 986? J809>:75 =27C:30 >?0 8409 7< 675>2:B8>72A50;4:;0560
?030C047=@05>7<41H7<:598215606756025:5;
>?0 @7>72 C0?:640 166:305>9 7C02 >?0 A0129 ?19 85302;750 3219>:6 6?15;09 7H:5; >7 >?0 209=759:B:4:>A 7< >?0 >1>0 >7 67@=0591>0 >?0 C:6>:@9 7< >?0 166:305>9
2 (1>&'
- 14 -
$27@ >?0 C:0H=7:5> 7< =27C:5; >?0 16>:751B40 50;4:;0560 H?:6? :9 09905>:14 :5 6190 7< 15A >72>8789 4:1B:4:>A :> 1==0129 >?1> >?0 20J8:20@05> H19 <:4403 BA >?0 >1>0 :5 321<>:5; >?0 7>72 0?:6409 6> <72 >?0 H723 50;4:;0560 61557H?020B0<78530:>?02:506>:75(&72((7<>?0 6> 5 7>?02 H7239:> :9754A>?0:5C74C0@05>7< >?0 C0?:640 H?:6?
:9 09905>:14 >7 :5C7I0 >?0 =27C:9:759 7< 06>:75 (( 7< >?0 6> :0H03 <27@ >?:9 15;40 :> 1==0129 >?1> :> :9 57> 50609912A <72 >?0 =0>:>:75029 >7 09>1B4:9?153=27C0>?050;4:;056075>?0=12>7<>?02:302 7< >?0 @7>726A640 B012:5; 7%'%') >?0 :5C74C0@05> 7< >?0 91:3 C0?:640 :9 98<<:6:05> $72 >?0 =82=7907<684=1B4050;4:;0560:>:950609912A>7<:5378> H?7 H19 @720 50;4:;05> 19 986? 50;4:;0560 @1I09 ?:@ 4:1B4085302>?062:@:5144:1B:4:>A
BC:7894A >?0 2:302 7< >?0 @7>726A640 B012:5; 7%'%')H1957>6?12;0%9?00>03BA>?0=74:60
5302 >?090 6:268@9>15609 0C05 >?78;? >?0 2:B8514 02203 :5 ?743:5; >?1> B7>? >?0 C0?:6409 ?1C0 675>2:B8>03
- 15 -
&)K50;4:;0560>?04:1B:4:>A7<>?0209=75305>79*153 H?:6? 12:90 78> >?0 16>:751B40 50;4:;0560 61557> B0 1B974C0367@=40>04A
* > :9 H72>? >7 57>0 >?1> >?0 50;4:;0560 75 >?0 =12> 7< >?0 209=75305> 7*%8B?19? 153 >?0 7H502 209=75305> 7 H19 640124A 75 >?0 ?:;?02 9:30 > :9 0C:305>>?1>209=75305>7;1C01585:598203C0?:640:5 >?0 ?1539 7< >?0 209=75305> 7* H?7 3:35/> ?1C0 1 32:C:5; 4:60560 ?020<720>?0 4:1B:4:>A 7< >?0 209=75305> 79* 153 :9 ?043 1> )K 153 >?1> 7< >?0 209=75305> 79153:9?0431>)K9:560?067843?1C00G026:903 6120 H?:40 75 >?0 2713 B0<720 >?0 C0?:640 7< >?0 209=75305> 79*%8B?19? 6744:303 H:>? ?:9 C0?:640 C:305>4A 19 =02 >?0 9=7> @1?1M12 166:305> B0>H005 >?0 >H7@7>726A6409?13>1I05=41601>>?0605>207<>?02713 5 >?1> C:0H >?0 1==72>:75@05> 7< 50;4:;0560 BA >?0 2:B8514:985989>1:51B40:541H153>?091@0:9@73:<:03 19)K75>?0=12>7<209=75305>79*153153)K 75B0?14<7<209=75305>79153
- 16 -
7@:5; >7 >?0 J815>8@ 7< >?0 67@=0591>:75 >?0 2:B8514 >?78;? 2:;?>4A >77I >?0 57>:7514 :567@0 1> 9)&)%:><1:403>7133<8>820=279=06>9<72>?091@0 ?020<720 1<>02 133:5; >?0 <8>820 =279=06>9 >?0 67@=0591>:75>7H123947997<30=053056A:9201990990319 ,+) O9*&)%P)&)Q")&)G)K#R G G ' G &)KS BA 30386>:5; &)K >7H1239 =0297514 0G=059097<>?030601903H?7H191B16?0472
7 >?1> 1 98@ 7< 9&))% >7H1239 <850214 0G=05909 9&))% >7H1239 >?0 4799 7< 09>1>0 153 9&)))%>7H123947997<47C01531<<06>:75:91H12303 1<>02 ;:C:5; 096141>:759 1> )K 0C02A * A0129 19 ?043 :5 >?0 6190 7< $ *+ % ) ,- (.?020<720>?0=0>:>:7502912005>:>403 <72>7>1467@=0591>:757<,
)
& ?02:B8514>?78;??1302203:5199099:5;>?0 1==72>:75@05> 7< 50;4:;0560 ?19 2:;?>4A 7230203 >?0
3 "))#*-'
- 17 -
209=75305> 7%59821560 7@=15A >7 =1A >?0 67@=0591>:75 H:>?
4:B02>A >7 2067C02 >?0 91@0 <27@ >?0 209=75305>79*153?:9:975166785>7<>?0=2:56:=40 7< 67@=79:>0 50;4:;0560 C:305>4A >?030601903 ?13 57 2740>7=41A:5>?0166:305>,?0H191=0309>2:15H14I:5; BA >?0 9:30 7< >?0 2713 $72 ?:@ :> H19 1 6190 7< 67@=79:>050;4:;0560"!- /*+
% )0# ?020<720 >?0 =0>:>:75029 120 1> 4:B02>A >7 641:@67@=0591>:75<27@15A7507<>?0>72><019729
( 9986?B7>?>?01==014930902C0>7B01447H03 :5%=12>153?0560>?0<7447H:5;
":# 7>?1==01491201447H03:5%=12>
"::# ?01==04415>9%641:@15>912005>:>403<72 67@=0591>:75 7< ,
) <27@ >?0 209=75305> 79 >7 D7:5>4A 153 90C02144A
4 ")&#-*
- 18 -
":::# ?0209=75305>791531204:1B40>7 =1A 67@=0591>:75 7< )K 153 >?0 209=75305>79*1531204:1B40>7=1A 67@=0591>:757<)K
":C# ?0 209=75305> 7%59821560 7@=15A :9 3:206>03 >7 =1A 05>:20 67@=0591>:75 >7 >?0 =0>:>:75029 H:>? 4:B02>A >7 2067C02 >?0 91@0 <27@ >?0 209=75305> 79* 153 BA 0G068>:5; >?:9D83;@05>191306200
"C# 09>7<>?072302=19903BA>?02:B8514 20;123:5; 1==72>:75@05> 153 30=79:> 20@1:58514>0203
"C:# ?0 1@785> :5 30=79:> :< 15A B0 >2159@:>>03 >7 >?0 675602503 2:B8514 <72>?H:>? - 19 -
"C::# ?00;:9>2A>79053B16I>?02067239>7 >?0675602503782>
3% &$! ( $
938 -'