Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46531 (KAR)
YALLAWWA AND ORS v. SUSHANT AND ANR
MFA/200879/2022 · 2025-04-01
K Natarajan, Vijaykumar A Patil
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46531 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46531 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" ! #
$$
#
$%$
! &
'
!" # $
%&'
#%#
( # $
%'
#% "
!#
' ! !" # $
%'&
#%
#
)$ !" # $
%''
#%
#
$# *)! #
+$! & ,
+ +"$"#
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
$"# $
%
#% "
!# +)) $#
* )" &
+ $
#
" #
#
$+"$# + # )" & ,
+ # -
'
"
"
"
' # $
)"$
'
"
)"$
+
+" # )" # )" #
+
$
" + #&#&
+
+
"
+ +
(
#"
()&
'
)! " # $
%
#%#
" # $
%'
#% "
!#
' ) # $
%'
#%
#
- 3 -
$$$ # + $" #
# )" & ,
+ +"$"#
" $"# $
%
#% "
!# +)) $#
*. )" &
+ $
#
" #
#
$+"$# + # )" & ,
+
!+ # # -
'
"
"
"
' # $
)"$
"
)"$
+ # )" #
)" +
$
" + #&#' +
+
"
+ +
(
"
#$ # )"$
"
%
% /+
)" ! )
/+
)" )!"
- 4 -
$ % /+
)" ! )
01230 40565 7885796 7:5 9;645< =1: 7<>;66;1?# @;40 405 A1?65?4 1= 957:?5< A12?659 =1: 405 87:4;56# 405 67>5 7:547B5?28=1:=;?79<;681679
+1404056578857967:5=;95<CD405854;4;1?5:6 A97;>7?46#737;?64405A1>>1?E2<3>5?47?<7@7:<<745< 87665<;?167?<' CD 405 5>C5:# # ;E7D782:# =1: 601:4 F405
:;C2?79G# A07995?3;?3 405 H27?42> 1= 405 A1>85?674;1? 7@7:<5< 7?< =;I;?3 1= 405 9;7C;9;4D 1? :5681?<5?4 1 J 1@?5:1=4051==5?<;?3K50;A95CD5I1?5:74;?34059;7C;9;4D 1=405?62:7?A51>87?D
'
05 87:4;56 05:5;? 7:5 :5=5::5< 41 76 85: 405;: :7?BC5=1:5405 :;C2?79
5 07K5 057:< 405 7:32>5?46 1= 957:?5< A12?659=1:40587:4;56
- 5 -
&
05 =7A4279 >74:;I 1= 405 A765 =1: 405 82:8165 1=<;6816791=4056578857967:5762?<5:%
;
05 7885997?46A97;>7?46 ;? 1 07< =;95< 1' 7?< 405 7885997?46A97;>7?46 ;? 1 07< =;95< 1 2?<5: 5A4;1? 1= A4# A97;>;?3 A1>85?674;1? 1= 6&## 57A0# :5685A4;K59D# =1: 405 <5740 1= 7>7887 1 7?<5887 7A07B?2: 7?< 7:1E;?; 1 7>7E; 07K7?# ;? 7 :17< 4:7==;A7AA;<5?440741AA2::5<1?&747C124' 8>4@76799535<CD405A97;>7?4640741?40567;<<745 @05? 405 <5A5765< 7>7887 7?< 7:1E;?; 7?< 1405: ;?>74561=405K50;A95@5:54:7K59;?3;?405K50;A95C57:;?3 1! 41@7:<6 ;B147 6;<5 7?< <25 41 405 :760 7?<?539;35?4<:;K;?3CD;46<:;K5:#40567;<K50;A95<7605< 41 405 1?A1>;?3 >141:ADA95 C57:;?3 531!'
&# :56294;?3 ;?
405 <5740 1= 7:1E;?; 76 @599 76 7>78877?<405:;<5:1=405>141:ADA95;<:7>7>7?5 25 41 2?4;>59D <5740 1= 405 <5A5765< 85:61?6# 405;:
- 6 -
<585?<5?46 788:17A05< 405
:;C2?79 655B;?3 A1>85?674;1?2?<5:K7:;126057<6
;;
"81? 65:K;A5 1= ?14;A5# 405 :5681?<5?4 1 J ?62:7?A5 1>87?D 78857:5< 40:1230 A12?659 7?< =;956 64745>5?4 1= 1CE5A4;1?6# <5?D;?3 :760 7?< ?539;35?4 <:;K;?3 1= 405 K50;A95 7?< =2:405: 405 735# ;?A1>5 7?< 1AA2874;1? 1= 405 <5A5765< 85:61?6 4 @76 A1?45?<5< 4074405A97;>1=405854;4;1?5:67:55IA566;K57?<4074405 <:;K5: 1=405 K50;A95 <;< ?14 07K57?D K79;<7?< 5==5A4;K5 :;K;?3;A5?6541<:;K5405K50;A95744054;>51=7AA;<5?4 4 @76 685A;=;A799DA1?45?<5<4074 74 4054;>5 1= 7AA;<5?4 405 K50;A95 @76 A7::D;?3 >1:5 87665?35:6 407? 405 85:>;66;C95 A787A;4D 1= L # 05?A5# 05 8:7D5< 41 <;6>;66405854;4;1?+24405:5681?<5?41J1@?5:1= 405 1==5?<;?3 K50;A95 <;< ?14 78857: 7?< 05?A5# 05 @76 897A5<5I87:45C5=1:5405 :;C2?79
;;; +765<281?4058957<;?36#405 :;C2?79=:7>5< 6587:745;66256;?C140405A97;>854;4;1?6#762?<5:%
- 7 -
!" # $
$ $ %&'($) $ ! $ * (+,#'-... $
*$
$ ! /
$ ( 00 0 #! $ 0
" /
$ ( $ (
$
"
$
/
. $
$/
*" /
- $ 1 $/
* !" #
$ $ $ & ! '2! 3
$
! $
0
* (+,#'-... *
$ ( $
*$
$ ! $ ( 00 0 #! $ 0
" /
- 8 -
$ ( $ (
$
"
$
/
. $
$/
*" /
- $ 1 $/4
;K ? 1:<5: 41 8:1K5 405;: A1?45?4;1?6# 405 026C7?<1=7:1E;?;5I7>;?5<0;>659=767?<405@;=5 1= 7>78875I7>;?5<05:659=76'7?<314>7:B5<' <1A2>5?46 ? C5079= 1= 405 :5681?<5?4 1# ;46 2401:;M5<==;A5:@765I7>;?5<76 7?<314>7:B5< <1A2>5?46
K =45:057:;?34057:32>5?461=C1404056;<56# 405 :;C2?797?6@5:5<;66251;?4057==;:>74;K5#;6625 1 ;? 405 ?5374;K5# ;6625 1' ;? 405 7==;:>74;K5# ;6625 1 ;? 405 87:49D 7==;:>74;K5 7?< =;?799D 7@7:<5< A1>85?674;1?;?C140405854;4;1?6762?<5:%
- 9 -
?1'% *+,-./01-2,/3. *+,-./01- /*4-0 1661=<585?<5?AD 6#&'# 5<;A79
I85?656 6#' '1661=A1?61:4;2> 6# 1661=
64745 6&# &2?5:79
I85?656 6&#
6##
?1% *+,-./01-2,/3. *+,-./01- /*4-0 1661=<585?<5?AD 6##' 1661=A1?61:4;2> 6# '1661=
64745 6&# 2?5:79
I85?656 6&#
6##'
K;
05
:;C2?79 =;I5< 405 9;7C;9;4D 1? 405 :5681?<5?4 1 J 1@?5: 1= 405 1==5?<;?3 K50;A95 41 87D A1>85?674;1?7?<5I1?5:745<405;?62:5:=:1>9;7C;9;4D
+5;?3733:;5K5<CD40567>5#405854;4;1?5:6;? 1' 07K5 =;95< 1 7?< 405 854;4;1?5:6 ;? 1 07K5 =;95< 1# 655B;?3 5?07?A5>5?4 1= A1>85?674;1?
- 10 -
7?< 41 7889D 4058:;?A;895 1= F87D 7?< :5A1K5:G 97;< <1@? CD 405 85I 12:4 ;? 405 A765 1= ! "#$%& ' ()(*+
57:?5< A12?659 =1: 405 7885997?46854;4;1?5:6 ;? C140 40565 7885796 07K5 A1?45?<5< 4074 405 :;C2?79 5::5< ;? 5I1?5:74;?3 405 ?62:7?A5 1>87?D =:1> 405 9;7C;9;4D 7?< 87D>5?4 1= A1>85?674;1? 41 405 A97;>7?46 401230 405 K50;A95 @76 ;?62:5< 76 1? 405 <745 1= 405 7AA;<5?4# @;40124 A1?6;<5:;?3 405 8:;?A;8956 97;< <1@? CD 40585I12:4;?405A7651=()(*+?40567;< <5A;6;1?#;4076C55?059<4074405?62:7?A51>87?D;6 9;7C954187D405A1>85?674;1?7>12?441405A97;>7?4674 405 =;:64 ;?647?A5# @;40 9;C5:4D 41 405 ?62:7?A5 1>87?D 41 :5A1K5: 405 67>5 =:1> 405 1@?5: 1= 405 1==5?<;?3 K50;A95;?7AA1:<7?A5@;4097@ 0567;<8:;?A;895@76?14 A1?6;<5:5<;?405;?647?A5A765#05?A5#1?40;661953:12?< 058:7D6=1:;?45:=5:5?A51=40;612:4
'
- 11 -
5 # :5681?<5?4 1 J ?62:7?A5 1>87?D 62881:45< 405 ;>823?5< E2<3>5?4 7?< 7@7:< 87665< CD 405 :;C2?79 =;I;?3 405 9;7C;9;4D 1? :5681?<5?4 17?<8:7D5<=1:<;6>;66791=4057885796
051?9D81;?47:;656=1:A1?6;<5:74;1?;?40565 7885796% N05405: 405 :;C2?79 ;6 E264;=;5< ;? =;I;?3 405 9;7C;9;4D 1? 405 :5681?<5?4 1 405 1@?5: 1= 405 K50;A95 CD 5I1?5:74;?3 405 9;7C;9;4D1=405:5681?<5?41?62:7?A5 1>87?D@0;A0A799=1:;?45:=5:5?A5OP
7K;?3 057:< 405 A12?6596 =1: 405 87:4;56 7?< 1? 85:2679 1= 405 :5A1:<6# 405 7AA;<5?4 :56294;?3 ;? 405 <57401=405<5A5765<85:61?6;6?14;?<;68245
K5?405 H27?42>1=405A1>85?674;1?7@7:<5<CD405 :;C2?79;? =7K12: 1= 405 A97;>7?46 ;? C140 405 854;4;1?6 @76 ?14 ;? <;68245
85:2679 1= 5K;<5?A5 1= 405 :5K5796 4074 1?405<7451=7AA;<5?4405K50;A95@76A7::D;?3>1:5407? - 12 -
85:>;445< ?2>C5: 87665?35:6 6 A7? C5 655? =:1> 405 :5A1:<6 4074 401230 405 85:>;445< ?2>C5: 1= 87665?35:6 ;6 L# C24 74 405 4;>5 1= 7AA;<5?4 >1:5 407? 87665?35:6 @5:5 A7::;5< ;? 405 K50;A95 05 5K;<5?A5 1= 405 7961:5K57964074405A07:3560554076C55?=;95< 737;?64 405 <:;K5: 1= 405 K50;A95 1@?5< CD :5681?<5?4 1 7?< 4074 405 <:;K5: <156 ?14 07K5 7?D K79;< 7?< 5==5A4;K5 :;K;?3 ;A5?65 76 1? 405 <745 1= 405 7AA;<5?4
05 :5681?<5?4 1 07< ?5;405: A1?45645< 405 >7445:
C5=1:5 405 :;C2?79 ?1: 8:1<2A5< 405 :;K;?3 ;A5?65 85:47;?;?341405<:;K5:1=405K50;A954;6A957:=:1>405 5K;<5?A5 1= 405 :5681?<5?4 1 4074# 1? 405 <745 1= 7AA;<5?4 401230 405 K50;A95 @76 A7::D;?3 >1:5 407? 405 85:>;445< ?2>C5: 1=87665?35:67?< 405:5 ;6K;1974;1?1= 40545:>67?<A1?<;4;1?61=405819;AD#C24405819;AD@76 ;?=1:A5
? 405 K;5@ 1= 97@ 97;< <1@? CD 405 1?GC95 28:5>5 12:4 ;?
405 A765 1= ()" (*+ :5=5::5< 41 7?< 7961 ;? 405 A765 ,## & -"
- 13 -
%".# 6;?A5 ;? 405 ;?647?4A765 405 :5681?<5?4 1J ?62:7?A51>87?D7<>;445<A1K5:7351=;?62:7?A541405 K50;A95761?405<7451=7AA;<5?4#405:5681?<5?41 ?62:7?A5 1>87?D ;6 9;7C95 41 87D 405 A1>85?674;1? 41 405 A97;>7?46 74 405 =;:64 ;?647?A5 @;40 9;C5:4D 41 :5A1K5: 40567>5=:1>405:5681?<5?41
' ?K;5@1=4058:;?A;895697;<<1@?CD40585I 12:4;?4057C1K567;<<5A;6;1?6#405:5681?<5?41J ?62:7?A5 1>87?D ;6 9;7C95 41 87D 405 A1>85?674;1? 41 405A97;>7?4674405=;:64;?647?A5#405?;407641:5A1K5:
40567>5=:1>4051@?5:1=4051==5?<;?3K50;A95 5?A5# 405=;?<;?31= :;C2?795I1?5:74;?39;7C;9;4D1=405;?62:5:;6 :5H2;:5<41C5;?=5::5<AA1:<;?39D#@57?6@5:40581;?4 :7;65<;?4057==;:>74;K5 5?A5#405=1991@;?3%
;
05788579=;95<CD854;4;1?5:6A97;>7?46 7:57991@5<;?87:4
2 '
- 14 -
;;
05 ;>823?5< E2<3>5?4 7?< 7@7:< 87665< CD
:;C2?79 0 76 405 854;4;1?5:6 ;? 40565 4@1 7885796 7:5 A1?A5:?5<#;605:5CD>1<;=;5< ;;;
5681?<5?4 1 J ?62:7?A5 1>87?D ;6 <;:5A45< 41 <5816;4 405 A1>85?674;1? 7>12?4 74 405 =;:64 ;?647?A5# @;40;? 7 85:;1< 1= @55B6 =:1> 405 <745 1= :5A5;841=7A18D1=40;6E2<3>5?4 ;K ;C5:4D ;6 :565:K5< 41 405 :5681?<5?4 1 J ?62:7?A5 1>87?D 41 :5A1K5:
405 67>5 =:1> 405 :5681?<5?4 1 J 1@?5:1=405K50;A95 K 5?< 405 :;79 12:4 :5A1:<6 41 405 A1?A5:?5<12:4
3&
5$6 $
3&
5%$
!6 $ + ;641%91%'
%