Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46525 (KAR)
VEERANAGOUDA v. PARAMESHWAR AND ANR
MFA/200289/2023 · 2025-02-27
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46525 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46525 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""
#$ $
%%
&' ( )
!! " #
$
! %
! !! &
'
( !! " #
' &)
**&&*
! %$
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
'
!+* #!$ '
%
'
(
%
! !!&&! !, &!,
(
(
' -!! % . -+ % !&. ' '
( %
/
(
(
$ # /
(
($ 0123 450 6012703 89:7-06 ;92 450 1<<066174 173 450 6012703 89:7-06 ;92 450 20-<973074 9& & 0=7> 1>>2=0?03 @A 450 B:3>C074 173 1D123 =7 9!, &!, 31403 ! !!&&! @A 450 6012703
33=4=9716 =-42=84 173 0--=97- (:3>0 173 0C@02
=B1A1<:21 450 <04=4=9702 =- @0;920 45=- 9:24 -00E=7> 0751780C074 9; 450 89C<07-14=97 =7 20-<084 9; 450 31C1>0- 81:-03 49 450 ?05=860
- 3 -
* 50 ;184:16 C142=F 9; 450 81-0 =- 4514 97 +,&!, 450 <04=4=9702 D5=60 50 D1- <298003=7> 49D123- 9E1<:21 ;29C 5=- ?=661>0 =7 5=- 12 @012=7> 0>9
+! 450 32=?02 9; 450 218492 81C0 ;29C 450 9<<9-=40 -=30 173 31-5 49 450 12 20-:64=7> =7 17 188=3074 50 12 9; 450 <04=4=9702 -:-41=703 31C1>0-
89C<61=74 81C0 49 @0 20>=-40203 =7 2=C0 9!+&!, 97 450 70F4 31A 9; 450 188=3074 173 :64=C1406A 450 8512>0 -5004 D1- ;=603 1>1=7-4 32=?02 9; 450 218492 50 <04=4=9702 499E 5=- ?05=860 49 (1?16= :49C9@=60- 2=?140 =C=403 450 1:4592=G03 301602 173 20<1=202 7E16 2913 :@@166= 50 301602 =--:03 1 20<1=2 0-4=C140 9; - =780 450 89-4 9; 450 20<1=2 D1- 501?A 450 <04=4=9702 3=3 794 >04 =4 20<1=203 5020;920 50 1<<2918503 450 2=@:716 -00E=7> 450 -1=3 -:C 9; - 1- 31C1>0-
7 1<<0121780 450 20-<973074 9! 459:>5 307=03 4514 45020 D1- 17A 70>6=>0780 97 450 <124 9; 450 32=?02 9; 450 218492 13C=4403 4514 45020 D1- 17 188=3074 @:4 50 1660>03 4514 450 188=3074 D1- 3:0 49 450 70>6=>0780
- 4 -
9; 450 12 32=?02 0 897407303 4514 =; 50 =- 5063 6=1@60 ;92 450 89C<07-14=97 450 -1C0 51- 49 @0 ;1-40703 :<97 450 20-<973074 9& =7 ?=0D 9; 89742184 9; <96=8A
50 20-<973074 9& =7 =4- D2=4407 -4140C074 20=4021403 450 8974074=97- 9; 450 20-<973074 9!
173 16-9 897407303 4514 450 89C<07-14=97 861=C03 =- 5=>56A 0F92@=4174 =C1>=712A 173 :74071@60 =7 61D 50 32=?02 9; 450 218492 D1- 794 51?=7> 1 ?16=3 32=?=7> 6=807-0 - -:85 =4 =- 794 6=1@60 49 <1A 450 89C<07-14=97
7 450 @1-=- 9; 450 1@9?0 8974074=97- 450 2=@:716 ;21C03 1<<29<2=140 =--:0- 50 <04=4=9702 D1- 0F1C=703 1- %! 173 970 D=470-- D1- 0F1C=703 1- %& 173 F! 49 ! D020 C12E03 =7 450 0?=30780 50 9;;=8=16 9; 450 20-<973074 9& 0F1C=703 =4- 9;;=8=16 1- %! 173 970 398:C074 D1- C12E03 1- F! + ;402 5012=7> 450 12>:C074- 9; @945 -=30- 450 2=@:716 1D12303 1 89C<07-14=97 9;
-!! D=45 =74020-4 49 @0 <1=3 @A 450 20-<973074 9& 49 450 <04=4=9702
- 5 -
0=7> 1>>2=0?03 @A 450 -1C0 450 <04=4=9702 51- 1<<2918503 45=- 9:24 8974073=7> 4514 30-<=40 45020 @0=7> 17 0-4=C140 ;92 - 173 -:85 0-4=C140 51?=7> @007 <29?03 @A 0F1C=7=7> 450 %& 450 2=@:716 ;1=603 49 1<<208=140 450 -1C0 173 49 1D123 1 -:C 9; - 1- 861=C03 4 =- 897407303 4514 450 2=@:716 02203 =7 20B084=7> 450 F, D5=85 =- 450 0-4=C140 =--:03 @A 450 %&
,
450 6012703 89:7-06 1<<012=7> ;92 450 20-<973074 9& 8974073- 4514 450 <04=4=9702 -=C<6A -41403 4514 450 ?05=860 D1- 41E07 49 (1?16= :49C9@=60- 2=?140 =C=403 450 1:4592=G03 301602 173 20<1=202 7E16 2913 :@@166= 173 50 3=3 794 >04 450 ?05=860 20<1=203 50 <04=4=9702 513 794 <293:803 89<A 9; 450 <96=8A 9; 5=- ?05=860 173 16-9 4514 450 <04=4=9702 513 794 -<074 17A 1C9:74 49D123- 450 20<1=2- 4 =- 897407303 4514 =7 450 1@-0780 9; -:85 0--074=16 0?=30780 450 2=@:716 206=03 97 450 ?16:14=97 9; 450 ?05=860 C074=9703 =7 450 <96=80 C151G12 173 51- 1D12303 1 -:C 9;
-!! D5=85 =- <29<02 173 8922084
- 6 -
! <02:-16 9; 450 0?=30780 97 208923 D9:63 -59D 4514 450 <04=4=9702 =7 5=- 40-4=C97A @0;920 450 2=@:716 51- -41403 4514 1;402 450 188=3074 50 60;4 5=- 12 14 (1?16= :49C9@=60- 2=?140 =C=403 450 1:4592=G03 301602 173 20<1=202 7E16 2913 :@@166= 50 301602 51?0 =--:03 1 20<1=2 0-4=C140 9; - 173 -=780 450 89-4 9; 450 20<1=2 =- 501?A 50 3=3 794 >04 450 ?05=860 20<1=203
!!
4 =- <024=7074 49 7940 4514 450 <04=4=9702 51- 794 <293:803 17A 94502 C1402=16 ;92 51?=7> -<074 - 49D123- 450 20<1=2- 7 17A D1A 450 <04=4=9702 51- 794 -<074 1 -:C 9; - -=780 =4 =- 976A 17 0-4=C140 7 450 829--0F1C=714=97 9; 450 %! 7945=7> =- 06=8=403 @A 450 =7-:21780 89C<17A 49 -59D D514 =- 450 ?16:14=97 9; 450 ?05=860
!& 50 %& D59 =- 450 171>02 9; 450 (1?16= :49C9@=60- 2=?140 =C=403 450 1:4592=G03 301602 173 20<1=202 7E16 2913 :@@166= 51- -41403 4514 50 51- =--:03 450 0-4=C140 1- <02 F, 173 4514 450 <04=4=9702 51- 41E07 1D1A 450 12 7 450 829--0F1C=714=97 =4 =-
- 7 -
06=8=403 4514 50 39 794 E79D 1- 49 D504502 450 <04=4=9702 51- 861=C03 450 89C<07-14=97 ;29C 5=- 9D7 =7-:202 4 =- 16-9 -:>>0-403 4514 450 20<1=2- D020 794 0;;08403 @A (1?16= :49C9@=60- 2=?140 =C=403 450 1:4592=G03 301602 173 20<1=202 7E16 2913 :@@166= 49 450 -1=3 12
!* 7 @0=7> H:02=03 @A 45=- 9:24 49 450 6012703 89:7-06 1<<012=7> ;92 450 <04=4=9702 50 -:@C=4- 4514 50 51- -963 450 ?05=860 ;92 1 -:C 9; - 1- 1 -821< 5:- =4 =- 0?=3074 4514 =7 17A 8=28:C-41780 450 ?05=860 D1- 794 20<1=203 9209?02 ;29C F D5=85 =- IJ 0>=-402 F42184 9; 450
9; 450 ?05=860 -59D 4514 =4 D1- <:2851-03 =7 849@02 &!* 50 188=3074 51- 988:2203 97 +,&!, 5:- =4 =- 0?=3074 4514 450 ?05=860 513 2:7 ;92 70126A
A012- 5020;920 450 -:2?0A 9; 450 31C1>0- 988:2203 49 450 ?05=860 =7 450 188=3074 D1- 7080--12A 7 94502 D923- 450 0-4=C140 14 F, D9:63 =786:30 166 459-0 31C1>0- D5=85 513 988:2203 0?07 <2=92 49 450 188=3074 16-9
- 8 -
!
9C=7> 49 450 =C<:>703 B:3>C074 =4 =- 0?=3074 4514 450 2=@:716 513 7945=7> 1?1=61@60 97 208923 0F80<4 450 0-4=C140 <293:803 @A 450 <04=4=9702 14 F, @?=9:-6A 450 <04=4=9702 513 794 -<074 1 -=7>60 2:<00 ;92 450 20<1=2 9; 450 ?05=860 7 4514 8=28:C-41780 450 2=@:716 -H:1206A 206=03 97 450 ?16:14=97 9; 450 074=20 12 D5=85 =- 1?1=61@60 =7 450 <96=80 <1<02- 50 <29<024A -0=G:20 C0C9 14 F D9:63 -59D 4514 450 ?16:14=97 9; 450 12 D1- C130 14 -! F80<4 45=- 398:C074 45020 =- 7945=7> 97 208923 49 -59D 450 ?16:0 9; 450 ?05=860 5020 =- 7945=7> 97 208923 49 -59D D514 D1- 450 ?16:0 9; 450 ?05=860 0?07 =CC03=1406A <2=92 49 450 188=3074
! 7302 450-0 8=28:C-41780- 450 2=@:716 =- B:-4=;=03 =7 206A=7> 97 450 -0=G:20 C0C9 D5=85 89741=7- 450 ?16:14=97 9; 450 <29<024A %507 450 0-4=C140 D5=85 =- 794 -:<<92403 @A 1 <20?=9:- -:2?0A @A 1 -:2?0A92 92 ?16:1492 9; 450 ?05=860 =4 89741=7 166 94502 31C1>0- 49 450 ?05=860 D5=85 C=>54 51?0 988:2203 0?07 <2=92 49 450 188=3074
- 9 -
! 7302 450-0 8=28:C-41780- 450 0-4=C140 817794 @0 1 398:C074 D5=85 89220846A 30<=84 450 31C1>0- D5=85 513 988:2203 =7 450 188=3074 9209?02 450 <04=4=9702 51- 859-07 794 49 184 :<97 450 0-4=C140 173 49 >04 450 ?05=860 20<1=203
!+ 7302 450-0 8=28:C-41780- 79 ;1:64 817 @0 ;9:73 D=45 450 2=@:716 =7 1D123=7> 1 -:C 9;
-!! 49D123- 450 31C1>0- 49 450 ?05=860 5=- 1-<084 =- 794 3=-<:403 @A 450 20-<973074 9& K =7-:21780 89C<17A 0780 450 1<<016 =- @020;4 9; 17A C02=4- 88923=7>6A 450 ;9669D=7>)
50 1<<016 =- 3=-C=--03
3 &$ ( $
(( =-4 9 ! 6 9 +