- 1 - ! "# $! % &!$! % &!"&# " ! !$$ '#( ) !" # $ !" % &'($ &') Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * +" , $$ # -.--($ $ $.. " % &'( % &'(' * + #/ ' , # # .+, # # " (-- $( ) " % # - 0 # # 1 #" % # # # " 2 " 2 " " - 3 - & + 2 " , 345 677869 :;<8= 8>?4@; .+, @A ?38 @?@= 834>985>?)((+38=84;6A?8==8A8==8<?@65B?38>?CA@= 53@=?, 365 D88; A498< DE ?38 >964F6;?5 >36998;G4;G ?38 H:<GF8;? 6;< 6I6=< <6?8< ( 76558< DE ?38 8;4@=4J49":<G8K3@=67:=4;$( ) #6>?5 G4J4;G =458 ?@ ?38 A494;G @A ?38 677869 D=48A9E 5?6?8< 6=8 ?36? @; (. I38; ?38 <8>8658< 6=4E6776 I65 7=@>88<4;G ?@I6=<5 :;656G4 @; 345 F@?@=>E>98 D86=4;G =8G45?=6?4@; @---( ;86= 656;67:=DE7655=@6<;86=6??4;6F6;4494996??36? ?4F869@==ED86=4;G=8G45?=6?4@; @-.--($I34>3 I65D84;G<=4J8;4;6=6536;<;8G94G8;?F6;;8=<6538< 6G64;5??38<8>8658<56=85:9?@A?386A@=8564<6>>4<8;? ?38 <8>8658< 5:5?64;8< G=48J@:5 4;H:=485 6;< 5:>>:FD8< ?@?384;H:=485 - 4 - 38 >964F6;?5 A498< 6 78?4?4@; :;<8= 8>?4@; @A ?38 >? 588L4;G >@F78;56?4@; A@= ?38 <86?3 @A ?38 <8>8658<69@;GI4?34;?8=85? $ 7@; 58=J4>8 @A ;@?4>8 ?38 =857@;<8;? @ 67786=8< ?3=@:G3 >@:;589 6;< A498< I=4??8; 5?6?8F8;? <8;E4;G ?38 6J8=F8;?5 F6<8 4; ?38 >964F 78?4?4@; 38 =857@;<8;? @<8574?858=J4>8@A;@?4>8<4<;@?67786= D8A@=8?38=4D:;696;<I65796>8<8M-76=?8 ' ; ?38 D6545 @A ?38 7986<4;G5 @A ?38 76=?485 ?38 964F5=4D:;69A=6F8<?38455:856;<?38=86A?8==8>@=<8< ?38 8J4<8;>8 38 =4D:;69 DE 4F7:G;8< H:<GF8;? 6;< 6I6=<36576=?9E699@I8<?38>964F78?4?4@;6;<389<?36? ?38 >964F6;?5 6=8 8;?4?98< ?@ 6 >@F78;56?4@; @A 5(( -69@;GI4?34;?8=85?6??38=6?8@A076 6;< <4=8>?8< ?38 ;5:=6;>8 @F76;E ?@ <87@54? ?38 >@F78;56?4@; 6F@:;? 69@;G I4?3 4;?8=85? 84;G 6GG=48J8<?387=858;?677869365D88;A498< - 5 - 38986=;8<>@:;589A@=?38>964F6;?5365=6458<?38 A@99@I4;G>@;?8;?4@;5 6, #4=5?9E ?38 >964F6;?5 6558=? ?36? ?38 <8>8658< I65 6G8<6D@:?E86=56??38?4F8@A?386>>4<8;?6;<36< 4;>@F8 @A 5 - 78= <6E DE I@=L4;G 65 F65@; @I8J8= ?38 655855F8;? @A F@;?39E 4;>@F8 @A ?38 <8>8658< 6?5( - DE ?38 =4D:;69 45 :;H:5?4A48< 6;< 8==@;8@:5 D, 8>@;<9E 65 78= ?38 96I 964< <@I; DE ?38 @;CD98 :7=8F8 @:=? 4; ?38 >658 @A ! *$"!!+ ! , 4; >6585 I38=8 ?38 <8>8658< I65 589A- 8F79@E8<@==8>84J8<6A4M8<5696=E6;6<<4?4@;@A$0@A ?38 85?6D94538< 4;>@F8 ?@I6=<5 BA:?:=8 7=@578>?5C 45 I6==6;?8< I38; ?38 <8>8658< I65 D89@I ?38 6G8 @A $ E86=5 38 564< 7=4;>4798 53699 D8 677948< ?@ ?38 7=858;? >658 - 6 - >, 65?9E >@;54<8=4;G ?38 6G8 6;< 6J@>6?4@; @A ?38 <8>8658< ?38 @J8=699 >@F78;56?4@; 6I6=<8< DE ?38 =4D:;69454;6<8N:6?86;<@;?389@I8=54<8 4?3 ?38 6D@J8 >@;?8;?4@;5 ?38 986=;8< >@:;589 5@:G3??@699@I?38677869 . ; ?38 @?38= 36;< ?38 986=;8< >@:;589 A@= ?38 ;5:=6;>8 @F76;E 365 =6458< ?38 A@99@I4;G >@:;?8=- >@;?8;?4@;5 6, #4=5?9E 69?3@:G3 ?38 >964F6;?5 >964F ?36? ?38 <8>8658<I6586=;4;G5 -78=<6E?38E36J8A6498< ?@ 5:D5?6;?46?8 ?384= >964F I4?3 5:77@=?4;G <@>:F8;?5 @;58N:8;?9E ?38 =4D:;69 365 >@==8>?9E 6558558< ?38 4;>@F8@A?38<8>8658<;@?4@;699E D, 8>@;<9E 54;>8 ?38 >964F6;?5 36J8 ;@? 85?6D94538< ?38 4;>@F8 @A ?38 <8>8658< ?38E 6=8 ;@? 8;?4?98< A@= >@F78;56?4@;?@I6=<5BA:?:=87=@578>?5C >, 34=<9E @; 677=8>46?4@; @A @=69 6;< <@>:F8;?6=E 8J4<8;>8 6;< >@;54<8=4;G ?38 6G8 6;< 6J@>6?4@; @A ?38 - 7 - <8>8658< ?38 @J8=699 >@F78;56?4@; 6I6=<8< DE ?38 =4D:;6945H:5?6;<=865@;6D98 4?3 ?38 6D@J8 >@;?8;?4@;5 ?38 986=;8< >@:;589 5@:G3??@<45F455?38677869 ( 86=< ?38 986=;8< >@:;589 A@= ?38 76=?485 6;< 78=:58<?38H:<GF8;?6;<6I6=<@A?38=4D:;69 ) ? 45 ;@? 4; <457:?8 ?36? 6=4E6776 <48< 4; ?38 =@6< ?=6AA4> 6>>4<8;? @>>:==8< @; (. <:8 ?@ =653 6;< ;8G94G8;?<=4J4;G@A?38@AA8;<4;GJ834>98DE4?5<=4J8= 38 >964F6;?5 >964F ?36? <8>8658< I65 86=;4;G 5 - 78= <6E D:? A6498< ?@ 7=@<:>8 5:77@=?4;G <@>:F8;?5?@5:D5?6;?46?8?384=>964F;?386D58;>8@A 7=@@A@A4;>@F8?38;@?4@;694;>@F8365?@D86558558< >>@=<4;G?@?38G:4<894;85455:8<DE?386=;6?6L6?6?8 8G698=J4>85:?3@=4?EA@=6>>4<8;?5@>>:==8<4;?38E86= .?38;@?4@;694;>@F8@A?38<8>8658<53699D8?6L8; 6?5' -7F@?386A@=8564<4;>@F8$0365?@ - 8 - D86<<8<@;6>>@:;?@AA:?:=87=@578>?54;J48I@A?3896I 964<<@I;DE?38@;5?4?:?4@;8;>3@A?38:7=8F8@:=? 4; -$" !. +5:7=6, 3:5?38 F@;?39E 4;>@F8 >@F85?@5$' -4;>8?38=86=8$<878;<8;?5?38 =4D:;69 365 =4G3?9E <8<:>?8< $?3 @A ?38 4;>@F8 @A ?38 <8>8658< ?@I6=<5 78=5@;69 8M78;585 6;< =8F64;4;G 6F@:;?365?@D8?6L8;65345>@;?=4D:?4@;?@?38A6F49E 38<8>8658<I656G8<6D@:?E86=56??38?4F8@A?38 6>>4<8;?6;<F:9?47948=67794>6D98?@3456G8G=@:745BC 3:5 ?38 >964F6;?5 6=8 8;?4?98< ?@ >@F78;56?4@; @A / 0 +5$'OOO $, @; 6>>@:;? @A B9@55@A<878;<8;>EC ;6<<4?4@;?38>964F6;?458;?4?98<A@=>@F78;56?4@; @A/0:;<8=?38386<@AB9@55@A85?6?8C 38 >@F78;56?4@; 6I6=<8< DE ?38 =4D:;69 :;<8= @?38=386<545H:5?6;<=865@;6D98 - 9 - 3:5 ?38 >964F6;?5 6=8 8;?4?98< ?@ ?38 A@99@I4;G >@F78;56?4@; 1234/56748493: 973:346359/ 184674 '/( @55@A<878;<8;>E $ #:;8=698M78;585 ' @55@A85?6?8 ' @55@A>@;5@=?4:F?@ 78?4?4@;8=5+$$O$, . 65; $ ;?38=85:9??38A@99@I4;G@=<8=4576558< 6, 38677869455;;<397425:6 D, 38H:<GF8;?@A?38964F5=4D:;6945F@<4A48< >, 38>964F6;?56=88;?4?98<?@6?@?69>@F78;56?4@;@A / 0656G64;5?5(( -6I6=<8< DE?38=4D:;69 <, 38 ;5:=6;>8 @F76;E 45 <4=8>?8< ?@ <87@54? ?38 >@F78;56?4@;6F@:;?69@;GI4?34;?8=85?6?076 - 10 - A=@F ?38 <6?8 @A A494;G @A ?38 >964F 78?4?4@; ?499 ?38 <6?8@A=8694P6?4@;I4?34;678=4@<@A54MI88L5A=@F ?38<6?8@A=8>847?@A6>@7E@A?345H:<GF8;? 8, 38 677@=?4@;F8;? <87@54? 6;< =898658 @A 6F@:;? 53699 D8 F6<8 4; 6>>@=<6;>8 I4?3 ?38 ?8=F5 @A ?38 6I6=<@A?38=4D:;69 A, ;J48I@A?38@=<8=<6?8<$'76558<DE?345 @:=? ?38 >964F6;?5 6=8 ;@? 8;?4?98< A@= 4;?8=85? @; ?388;36;>8<>@F78;56?4@;A@=?38<896E8<78=4@<@A <6E54;A494;G?38677869 !90 '$!( & !90 '"&# "( & 45? @9 @