Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 46516 (KAR)

MANJUNATH v. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER/COMPETENT AND ORS

MFA/202027/2024 · 2025-11-25

H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" # $%# $% %! ## &' ( ! "#$ $ %&'( ) " %$#(($ Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # %&'( * # #+ ,,' ) ) ) ((#$ (( ! ) ) - ! ) . . - 3 - % . /01 233425 01 60547 8974: 14;<0=9 #+; =6 </4 :>0<:2<0=9297=9;0502<0=9;<,,'6=:1/=:<?</4;<- ;/25549@09@ </4 A87@B49< 297 2C2:7 72<47 (( 321147 >D </4 770<0=925 01<:0;< 87@4 0A2D238:2 09 :>0<:2<0=9 3350;2<0=9 =#$ (( C/4:4>D </4 2C2:7 321147 >D :413=9749< =# :>0<:2<=:";8B"438<D =BB0110=94: /21 >449 ;=960:B47 >D 701B01109@ </4 23350;2<0=9 42:947 ;=89145 6=: </4 23345529< 18>B0<<47 </2<</45297=6</423345529<C212;E80:47>D</42<0=925 0@/C2D 8</=:0<D =6 9702 8:1829< <= C/0;/ </4 2C2:7 C21321147=9('((@@:04F47>D</4E829<8B=6 ;=B34912<0=9 2C2:747 >D </4 ;=B34<49< 28</=:0<D </4 23345529< /21 1=8@/< 6=: :4"74<4:B092<0=9 297 49/29;4B49<>D09F=G09@ 4;<0=91#&297'=6</4 2<0=9250@/C2D1;<,&' - 4 - # /4 :>0<:25 :0>8925 ;=B3:0109@ =6 2 1=54 :>0<:2<=: 233=09<47 >D </4 49<:25 =F4:9B49< /2F09@ 49<:81<4709<=:464:49;43:=;44747<=3211</40B38@947 2:>0<:25 2C2:7 =9 #((( :4"74<4:B0909@ 297 49/29;09@</4B2:G4<F2584=6</418>A4;<5297>45=9@09@ <= </4 23345529< =C4F4: 9=< >409@ 12<016047 >D </4 2B=89< 1= 74<4:B0947 >D </4 :>0<:2<=: </4 23345529< 233:=2;/47 </4 A8:0170;<0=925 =8:< 8974: 4;<0=9 #$ =6 ;< D </4 0B38@947 A87@B49< 297 =:74: 72<47 ((</4:025=8:<3:=;44747<=701B011</4said 23350;2<0=960547>D</423345529<409@2@@:04F47>D</4 12B4</423345529<01>46=:4</01=8:< $ /4 B209 ;=9<49<0=9 :20147 >D </4 542:947 ;=89145 6=: </4 23345529< 01 </2< </4 0B38@947 A87@B49< 297=:74:321147>D</4:025=8:<019=<=95D;=9<:2:D<= </43:=F010=91;=9<2094709 4;<0=9#$=6</4;<>8<</4 12B401251=;=9<:2:D<=</474;010=9=6</434H=8:<09 ;214=6 - 5 - ! 4251=;=9<4974709 :4134;<=6E829<8B=6;=B34912<0=92C2:747 & 4</2<210<B2D9=C</4E841<0=901</2<the 34H=8:<09;214=6 183:21<:8;G7=C9 4;<0=9 # =6 </4 2<0=925 0@/C2D1 ;< ,&' 9 </4 10B052: 50941 ;=91074:09@ </01 2134;< =6 </4 01184 09 =((, ( </01 =8:< 255=C47 </4 233425 F074 0<1 A87@B49<72<47((>D14<<09@21074</4A87@B49< 297=:74:321147>D</4:>0<:25:0>8925297:4B0<<47</4 B2<<4: >2;G <= </4 438<D =BB0110=94: 6=: 6:41/ :4";=91074:2<0=9 ' 9F04C=6</42>=F4C432116=55=C09@ 0 /423342501/4:4>D ""# 00 /4 0B38@947 A87@B49< 297 =:74: 72<47 (( 321147 >D </4 770<0=925 01<:0;< 87@4 0A2D238:2 09 :>0<:2<0=9 3350;2<0=9 =#$ (( 297 </4 :>0<:25 2C2:7 72<47 #((( 321147 >D :413=9749< - 6 - =# :>0<:2<=:";8B"438<D=BB0110=94:2:4 14<21074 000 2<<4: 01 :4B0<<47 >2;G <= :413=9749< =#" :>0<:2<=:";8B"438<D =BB0110=94: 6=: :4" ;=91074:2<0=9 26:41/ 09 2;;=:729;4 C0</ 52C >42:09@ 09 B097 </4 =>14:F2<0=91 B274 09 </01 =:74: C0</09 2 34:0=7 =6 10H B=9</1 6:=B </4 72<4=6:4;403<=6</4;=3D=6</01=:74: 0F 55 :0F25 ;=9<49<0=91 =6 </4 32:<04:1 2:4 G43< =349 F /01=8:</219=<4H3:4114729D=3090=9=9</4 B4:0<1=6</4;214 F0 9F04C=6</4=:74:72<47&(&321147>D </01=8:<09;214:413=9749<=#49/29;41</4 ;=B34912<0=9 </4 ;520B29< 01 9=< 49<0<547 6=: 09<4:41< =9 </4 49/29;47 ;=B34912<0=9 6=: </4 7452D4734:0=7=6&,72D10960509@</4233425 )* &#' % )* & %! ' % 01<= 5=#$