Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46513 (KAR)
GHALEPPA AND ANR v. THE TELANGANA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT
MFA/200856/2023 · 2025-02-03
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46513 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46513 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""
#
$! $! !!%%&
' ( )
! "" #
$
%
&
$'!$(
! & ( %
&
$ !)$(
!* * # &( * ! $
" ! !*
! '! " #
$ '
'!*
! !$
#
$ $* '! +
! * ,
! * '! -
$*"
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.03 17:26:53 - 0800
- 2 -
! .!' !'
'$ &
.!' !' ( /012 32240/5/6 78 9:/ ;<62=/19 316 3>346 01 !$
?# 78 9:/ 66@ /10?4 050@ '<62/ 316 '!* 0634 316 ! 39 0634 639/6 # 9:/ A/9090?1/4B 34/ 7/C?4/ 9:0B ?<49 01 3AA/3@ B//D012 /1:31E/=/19?C9:/E?=A/1B390?1
:/A/9090?1/4B34/9:/C39:/4316=?9:/4?C9:/ 6/E/3B/6F 31;//5D<=341 3937?<9# 3= 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=34 316 :0B E?>?4D/4 $0;383D<=34>/4/4/9<41012C4?=9:/04>?4D39!3:01643 316 !3:01643 ?=A318 !<120 109 ?1 9:/04 !?9?4E8E@/ 7/34012 ?)# +G 9:/ <B ?>1/6 78 9:/ 4/BA?16/19 7/34012 +H# E3=/ 01 1/2@02/19 =311/431663B:/632301B99:/=?9?4E8E@/B34/B<@9 9:/6/E/3B/6F 31;//5D<=34>:?>3BA0@@0?1406/460/6 399:/BA?9:/406/43@B?B<EE<=7/69?9:/01;<40/B@39/4 E3B/ E3=/ 9? 7/ 4/20B9/4/6 78 ;<40B60E90?13@ A?@0E/ 316
- 3 -
<@90=39/@83E:342/B://9>3BC0@/632301B99:/<B6405/4 :/ A/9090?1/4B >:? 34/ 9:/ A34/19B ?C 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F
31;//5D<=34:35/3AA4?3E:/69:/407<13@B//D012;<B9 E?=A/1B390?1 9 >3B B939/6 9:39 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F
31;//5D<=34 >3B 3 7402:9 B9<6/19 :3B E?=A@/9/6 :0B 60A@?=3 316 >?4D012 3B AA4/190E/ 4301// 316 /341012 34?<16BA/4=?19:
# :/ 4/BA?16/19 3AA/34/6 9:4?<2: 09B E?<1B/@ 316 6/10/6 9:/ A/9090?1 35/4=/19B 9 >3B E?19/16/69:399:/3EE06/19>3B6</9?9:/1/2@02/1E/?C 9:/ 406/4 ?C 9:/ =?9?4E8E@/ $0;383D<=34 316 9:/8 >/4/ 4/9<41012 3C9/4 9:/ 102:9 6<98 316 3B B<E: 9:/8 >/4/ 64?>B8 :/8 :35/ 3@B? E?19/16/6 9:39 9:/4/ 0B E?19407<9?48 1/2@02/1E/ 3B B<E: 9:/ B3=/ 1//6B 9? 7/ 6/9/4=01/6 :/ 407<13@ C43=/6 3AA4?A4039/ 0BB</B :/ A/9090?1/4
? >3B /I3=01/6 3B " 31?9:/4 >091/BB >3B/I3=01/63B " 316I 9?+>/4/=34D/601 /506/1E/
? /506/1E/ >3B @/6 ?1 7/:3@C ?C 9:/ 4/BA?16/19
- 4 -
:/ 407<13@ 3C9/4 :/34012 9:/ 342<=/19B 3>346/6 3 E?=A/1B390?1 ?C B+ <16/4 9:/ C?@@?>012:/36B
@ ?
/36B ?=A/1B390?1 >346/6
?>346B@?BB?C6/A/16/1E8 B+
?>346B@?BB?C*0@03@E?1B?490<= B # ?>346B9431BA?49390?1?C6/36 7?68C<1/43@316?7B/J<0/B E/4/=?18/IA/1B/B B
?93@ B+
/012 32240/5/6 78 9:/ J<319<= ?C 9:/ E?=A/1B390?1 9:/ A/9090?1/4B 34/ 7/C?4/ 9:0B ?<49 01 3AA/3@ :/ @/341/6 E?<1B/@ 3AA/34012 C?4 9:/ A/9090?1/4B B<7=09B 9:39 9:/ 407<13@ :3B E?1B06/4/6 9:/ 01E?=/ ?C 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=34 39 B A/4 =?19: 7<9 01 C3E9 9:/ I B:?>/6 3 B90A/16 ?C B+ A/4 =?19: / B<7=09B 9:39 0C 9:/ B90A/16
- 5 -
/341/6 78 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=34 6<4012 :0B 3AA4/190E/60120BB+/506/19@83C9/4E?=A@/90?1 ?C 9:/ 94301012 :/ >?<@6 /3B0@8 /341 B A/4 =?19: / 7/012 32/6 37?<9 8/34B :36 7402:9 A4?BA/E9B3169:/E/490C0E39/BA4?6<E/6789:/A/9090?1/4B >/4/ 1?939 3@@ E?1B06/4/678 9:/407<13@:/4/C?4/ :/ E?19/16B 9:39 9:/ 01E?=/ ?C 9:/
6/E/3B/6 F
31;//5D<=34:3B9?7/3BB/BB/6A4?A/4@8789:0B?<49 /4 E?1943 9:/ @/341/6 E?<1B/@ 3AA/34012 C?4 9:/ 4/BA?16/19 >?<@6 B<7=09 9:39 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F
31;//5D<=34 >3B ?1@8 3 94301// 316 9:/ /341012 3B ?1 9:/ 639/ ?C 9:/ 3EE06/19 :3B 7//1 E?1B06/4/6 78 9:/ 407<13@ 316 3AA4?A4039/ E?=A/1B390?1 :3B 7//1 3BB/BB/6 / B<7=09B 9:39 9:/4/ 0B 1? 1/E/BB098 ?C 318 /1:31E/=/19 + :/ C3E9 9:39 9:/4/ >3B 31 3EE06/19 015?@5012 9:/ <B ?>1/6 78 4/BA?16/19 F ?4A?4390?1 316 9:/ =?9?4E8E@/ ?1 >:0E: 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=34 >3B A0@@0?1 406/4 0B 1?9 01 60BA<9/ 506/19@8 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F
31;//5D<=34 :36 1? 4?@/ 9? A@38 01 E?19407<9012 318
- 6 -
1/2@02/1E/ :/4/C?4/ 9:/ E?19/190?1 ?C 9:/ 4/BA?16/19 9:39 9:/4/ >3B E?19407<9?48 1/2@02/1E/ :3B 7//1 402:9@8 4/;/E9/6789:/407<13@:/
E/490C0E39/A4?6<E/639 I + >?<@6 B:?> 9:/ 639/ ?C 7049: ?C 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F
31;//5D<=34 3B ++ :/ 3EE06/19 :35012 ?EE<44/6 ?1 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=34 >3B 32/6 8/34B =?19:B :/4/C?4/ 9:/ 407<13@ 36?A90129:/=<@90A@0/4?CE311?97/C3<@9/6>09:
:/9/B90=?18?C9:/ " F!3@@0D34;<1B:?>B 9:39 :/ 0B 3 B<A/450B?4 01 3B:>31943? /E:10E3@ 316 4301012 *?<16390?1 :4?<2: 9:/ B306 *?<16390?1 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=34 >3B 6/A<9/6 9?
!3:01643 3B313AA4/190E/94301//<16/49:/
390?13@=A@?8370@098 1:31E/=/19 !0BB0?1 / B939/B 9:39 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F
31;//5D<=34 >3B 2/99012 B90A/16 ?C B+ A/4 =?19: :/ I 0B 9:/ B90A/16 B@0A C?4 9:/ =?19: ?C /E/=7/4 F + 9 B:?>B 3 9?93@ /=?@<=/19 ?C B+31636/6<E90?1?CB+9?>346BE319//1 E:342/B:/4/C?4//506/19@89:/407<13@/44/60193D012 9:/01E?=/39B A/4=?19:
- 7 -
:/I 9?316I 9?+>?<@6B:?> 9:39 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=34 :36 E?=A@/9/6 0A@?=3 01 ?=A<9/4 E0/1E/ 316 1201//4012 01 C04B9 E@3BB :/ =34DB E346 39 I B:?>B 9:/ B3=/ A349 C4?=9:0B:/:363EJ<04/6E/49301?9:/4J<3@0C0E390?1019:/ C0/@6?CBE0/1E/3B=387/C?<16C4?=IB 316 / :36 3@B? A3490E0A39/6 01 B/5/43@ BE0/1E/ /5/19B >:0E:6/A0E9:0BD//1019/4/B93169:/A<4B<09C?43EJ<04012 7/99/4 BD0@@B :/ A4?50B0?13@
390?13@ 436/ /490C0E39/ 39 I + 01 9:/ C0/@6 ?C @/E940E031 0B 3@B? 31 0160E390?1 ?C 9:/B3=/ 90B>?49:9?1?9/9:399:/4/34/1?8346B90EDB 9? 3BB/BB 3 A4?737@/ 01E?=/ ?C 3 8?<12 7<66012 316 BD0@@/6/19:<B03B91/CC?49B:?<@6:35/7//1=36/789:/ 407<13@9?3BB/BB9:/A4?737@/01E?=/?C9:/6/E/3B/6F
31;//5D<=34 3C9/4 :/ E?=A@/9/B :0B 94301012 3B 3 3AA4/190E/ 01 !3:01643 316 !3:01643 " 01 :0B 9/B90=?18 :3B B939/6 9:39 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=34 >?<@6:35//341/637?<9#9?@3D:BA/4311<=3C9/4 :0B B<EE/BBC<@ 94301012 / 7/012 9:/ B<A/450B?4 01
- 8 -
3B:>31943? /E:10E3@ 316 4301012 *?<16390?1 @?E39/6 39 <1/:3B9:4?>1B?=/@02:9?19:/C<9<4/A4?BA/E9<B?C 9:/6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=3419:/ E4?BB/I3=01390?1 /IE/A9B<22/B90129:399:/6/E/3B/6F 31;//5D<=34>3B 1?9 /341012 B+ 1?9:012 0B /@0E09/6 37?<9 9:/ C<9<4/A4?BA/E9BB939/678:0=01:0B3CC063509 # ?1B06/40129:/9/B90=?103@B?C9:/6/E/3B/6F
31;//5D<=343169:/9/B90=?18?C9:/ " 090B/506/19 9:39 9:/ 6/E/3B/6 F 31;//5D<=34 >?<@6 :35/ /341/6 3 >32/B ?C B 9? B## A/4 =?19: 6/A/16012<A?1:0BBD0@@B??D0129?9:/9/B90=?103@B316 9://19:<B03B=?C9:/6/E/3B/6F 31;//5D<=3409E317/ B3C/@8B3069:39:0B010903@3AA?019=/19>?<@6:35/C/9E:/6 31/341012?CB A/4=?19:/5/1>:/13BB/BB/6 >09:=?6/439//IA/E9390?1B :/4/C?4/ 9:/ :3B 9? 7/ E3@E<@39/6 78 366012 K ?C B 9?>346B C<9<4/ A4?BA/E9B/1E/&B LB(I I IKM
786/6<E9012K9?>346B:0B A/4B?13@/IA/1B/B
- 9 -
1 366090?1 9? 9:/ 37?5/ E?=A/1B390?1 9:/ A/9090?1/4B34//1909@/6 C?4 E?=A/1B390?1 ?C 9?>346B
9?>346B 316
9?>346B 3B:/@6789:/?1-7@/ <A4/=/?<4901 9:/ E3B/ ?C !" #" $ %&:/E?=A/1B390?17/0126/9/4=01/63C9/4 + 8/34B ?C 9:/ B306 ;<62=/19 K C?4 /3E: ?C 9:/ # 8/34B A/40?6 :3B 9? 7/ 366/6 :/4/C?4/ 9:/ A/9090?1/4B 34//1909@/6C?4E?=A/1B390?13B7/@?>
@ ? /36B ?=A/1B390?1 >346/6 789:0B?<49
?BB?C6/A/16/1E8 B
?5/3163CC/E90?1 B # *<1/43@/IA/1B/B B+
?BB?CB939/ B+
?93@ /BB>346/6789:/ 407<13@ B# B+
?93@/1:31E/=/19 B #
- 10 -
*?49:/3C?4/B3064/3B?1B9:/3AA/3@6/B/45/B 9?7/3@@?>/63169:/C?@@?>012?46/40BA3BB/6G
:/3AA/3@0B3@@?>/601A349
:/3AA/@@3190B/1909@/6C?43B<=?CB # 01366090?19?>:39:3B7//13>346/6789:/407<13@ 3@?12>09:019/4/B9399:/439/?CKA3C4?=639/ ?CA/9090?190@@9:/639/?C6/A?B09
/B9 ?C 9:/ ?46/4 A3BB/6 78 9:/ 407<13@ 4/2346012 6/A?B09/9E4/=301<13@9/4/6
6 &
$! ( $
)'' 0B9
? @
? )