- 1 - !! ""# "$%&! ! '! &(#&#& )##* ! ! " ! "# ! $ % & % " % "'''( %) %$! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * % $$" $$% % +! * '$$$'$, - #$'$#) ! ) ! % % % ./ * + + 0 " + 0 ! 123234516 37 819461 2:37 4;62 711<35= 94>>4?35= 61>3197+ ! " # $%&'(') * $%) ( ( + + %, - 3 - $ :1@A71492:1B123234516372:A2:1:ACD4351C A7 A ;5346 >16< 35 617B45C152 4 9A@246E 35 2:1 E1A6 (($ A5C ?46<1C 946 $" E1A67 23>> :37 7;7B157345 35 2:1 E1A6 $' ?32:4;2 A5E 8>1F37: :A2 35 2:1 E1A6 $' 617B45C152 4A>>1=1C>E94;5CF37ABB64B63A2345499;5C7 242:12;51497(#,("#352:17A>17C1BA62F15249 2:1 9A@246E ?:3@: 617;>21C 35 35323A2345 49 2:1 C4F1723@ 15G;36E A=A3572 A>> 2:1 1FB>4E117 ?46<35= 35 2:1 7A3C C1BA62F152 123234516 ?A7 451 AF45=72 2:1F 5 2:1 C4F1723@ 35G;36E B123234516 ?A7 94;5C =;3>2E 49 2:1 @:A6=17 49 F37ABB64B63A2345 A5C :1 ?A7 :1>C 24 81 51=>3=152 A5C C161>3@2345 49 :37 C;2E 617;>235= 35 F37ABB64B63A2345 49 2:1 9;5C7 @A;735= >477 24 2:1 617B45C152 9A@246E :161A9216 A 5423@1 @AF1 24 81 377;1C 45 $,'$'$$ 8E 2:1 617B45C152 4 9A@246E C37F37735= 2:1 B123234516 964F :37 716H3@17 A5C A>74 C1@>3535= :3F A5E 935A5@3A> 81519327 A63735= 4;2 49 :37 716H3@17 135= A==631H1C B123234516 6A371C A C37B;21 ;5C161@2345492:1A65A2A<A44B16A23H14@132317 - 4 - @2 (( I:16135A9216 6191661C 24 A7 .2:1 @2/ 946 861H32EJ 819461 2:1 77372A52 1=3726A6 49 44B16A23H1 4@312317 3DAEB;6A :1 77372A52 1=3726A6 49 4 4B16A23H14@3123173DAEB;6A8E46C16CA21C$('$'$# 712A73C12:146C1649C37F377A>BA771C8E2:1617B45C152 4 A5C C361@21C 2:1 617B45C152 24 @4573C16 2:1 B123234516 24 81 @45235;1C 35 716H3@1 8E =3H35= A>> 2:1 81519327 135= A==631H1C 2:1 617B45C152 B6191661C A5 ABB1A> 819461 2:1 A65A2A<A BB1>>A21 638;5A> 35 44B BB1A> 4#$'$$ :1 638;5A> 8E 46C16 CA21C '$$$'$, A>>4?1C 2:1 7A3C ABB1A> 712 A73C1 2:1 46C16 BA771C8E2:11B;2E1=3726A64944B16A23H1 4@312317 A5C61FA5C1C2:1FA22169469617:@4573C16A2345964F2:1 72A=1 49 1H3C15@1 8E A9946C35= 61A745A8>1 4BB462;532E 24 2:1BA623172372:3746C16?:3@:37B;235G;172345352:37 B1232345 # 1A651C@4;571>9462:1B1232345167;8F3272:A2 2:1 46C16 49 61FA5C 37 ;57;72A35A8>1 35A7F;@: A7 2:1 1B;2E1=3726A635:3746C16BA771C;5C161@234549 - 5 - 2:1@2:A7F123@;>4;7>EABB61@3A21CA>>2:11H3C15@1 A5C 45>E 2:161A9216 :A7 @4F1 24 2:1 @45@>;7345 49 B123234516 8135= 3554@152 49 2:1 @:A6=17 >1H1>>1C A5C :A7 B64@11C1C 24 712 A73C1 2:1 46C16 49 C37F377A> BA771C 8E 2:1 617B45C152 4 1 7;8F327 2:A2 ?:15 2:1 1B;2E 1=3726A6 ?:4 37 2:1 9A@2 935C35= A;2:4632E :A7 @4F1 24 2:1 C1935321 @45@>;7345 2:1 638;5A> @4;>C 542 :AH1 352169161C ?32: 2:1 7A3C 46C16 61FA5C35= 2:1 FA2216 946 9617:@4573C16A2345 15@1711<7946A>>4?35=2:1B1232345 , 1A651C@4;571>ABB1A635=946617B45C152 4 45 2:1 42:16:A5C 7;8F327 2:A2 2:1 B16;7A> 492:146C16 BA771C8E2:11B;2E1=3726A64944B16A23H1 4@312317 35C3@A217 2:A2 2:161 37 54 ABB>3@A2345 49 F35C 54 ABB61@3A2345499A@27A5C1H3C15@1492:1@A71 17;8F327 2:A22:146C1637451?32:4;2A5E61A745?:3@::A78115 63=:2>E 2A<15 5421 49 8E 2:1 638;5A> 617;>235= 35 712235= A73C1 2:1 7AF1 A5C 61FA5C35= 2:1 FA2216 1 7;8F327 2:A2 35 A5E @A71 2:1 FA2216 37 45>E 61FA5C1C 946 9617: @4573C16A2345 A5C 54 B61D;C3@1 ?3>> 81 @A;71C 24 2:1 - 6 - B123234516 A7 :1 :A7 A5 4BB462;532E 24 B;2 9462: :37 @A71 1991@23H1>E 15@1711<7946C37F377A>492:1B1232345 1A6C16;71C2:161@46C7 " >>1=A234549 F37ABB64B63A2345 49 9;5C7 >1H1>>1C A=A3572 2:1 B123234516 A5C 42:167 37 24 2:1 2;51 49 7(#,("#C4F1723@15G;36E:A78115@45C;@21C 1KAF3535=2:1?325177174581:A>949842:2:1C1>35G;152 1FB>4E117 A7 ?1>> A7 2:1 FA5A=1F152 7 FA5E A7 # C4@;F1527 :AH1 8115 1K:38321C A7 K7 24 # 1>35G;152 1FB>4E117 :AH1 1KAF351C A5C B64C;@1C C4@;F1527A2K724 BB61@3A2345 49 2:1 FA2216 8E 2:1 1B;2E 1=3726A64944B16A23H14@312317;5C161@2345492:1 @2 4;=:2 24 :AH1 8115 7B1@393@A>>E ACH16235= 24 2:1 A94617A3C FA2163A> 1H3C15@1 B>A@1C 45 61@46C 4?1H16 BA=1#(492:1?632B1232345?:3@:37ABA62492:146C16 BA771C 8E 2:1 1B;2E 1=3726A6 35C3@A217 2:A2 :1 :A7 F161>E =>4771C 4H16 2:1 FA2216 ?32:4;2 ACH16235= 24 A5E - 7 - 7B1@393@@4521523457462:1@:A6=17462:11H3C15@1>1C8E 2:1BA62317352:1C4F1723@15G;36E46?32:61=A6C242:1 @45@>;7345 A663H1C 35 2:1 C4F1723@ 15G;36E K@1B2 1KB617735= :37 4B35345 A7 24 ?:4 4;=:2 24 :AH1 8115 617B45738>12:11B;2E1=3726A64944B16A23H14@312317 :A75132:16ACH1621C242:1@6;K492:1FA2216546242:1 377;1746@:A6=17352:1@45264H167E :1 638;5A> 2A<35= 5421 49 2:171 A7B1@27 49 2:1 FA2216 A5C 1K26A@235= 2:1 46C16 49 2:1 1B;2E 1=3726A6 49 44B16A23H1 4@312317 35 " A2 BA6A=6AB:7 $, A5C $ 49 327 46C16 :A7 @4F1 24 2:1 @45@>;73452:A22:1?:4>1ABB64A@:AC4B21C8E2:11B;2E 1=3726A649 44B16A23H1 4@312317 37 451 @4526A6E24 2:1 7122>1CB473234549>A?352:A22:11B;2E1=3726A68135= 2:1 4;62 49 61@46C :A7 542 ACH1621C 24 2:1 A>>1=A23457 @4;5216A>>1=A23457A5C2:11H3C15@1>12358E2:1BA62317 819461 :1 @4F35= 24 2:1 @45@>;7345 @@46C35=>E :A7 712 A73C1 :37 46C16 A5C FA2216 37 61FA5C1C 8A@< 946 9617: @4573C16A2345 - 8 - ( 5 B16;7A> 49 2:1 61@46C7 A5C :1A635= 2:1 @4;571>492:1BA623172:374;62C4542935CA5E61A74524 352169161 ?32: 2:1 46C16 49 2:1 A65A2A<A BB1>>A21 638;5A> 5 A5E 1H152 842: 2:1 B123234516 A5C 2:1 617B45C1527 :AH1 4BB462;532E 24 B617152 2:136 @A71 1991@23H1>E 819461 2:1 1=3726A6 5 2:A2 H31? 49 2:1 FA221654=64;5C7A61FAC14;29463521691615@11232345 37 35@1 2:1 FA2216 37 49 2:1 E1A6 $'$ 2:1 1B;2E 1=3726A6 49 44B16A23H1 4@312317 7:A>> C37B471 49 2:1 FA22161KB1C3234;7>E?32:35A54;216>3F3249('CAE7964F 2:1CA214961@13B2492:1@1623931C@4BE492:3746C16 #+, )&#& * (" * 372 4+> 4+$# +