Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46508 (KAR)
HANAMANTHAGOWDA S/O MAHADEVAPPAGOWDA BIRADAR v. NANDA W/O RAJSHEKHAR BYAKOD AND ORS
WP/200003/2021 · 2025-01-07
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46508 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46508 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%""
&% '(
! "
#
$%&"'"
(
)
"
$%&"'"
&*
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
$%&"'"
+
$%&"'"
, +-
"
,
((# ,
,
'&""('"*
,
""*('"&
. $
"%('"*$('
'+"(('"*
+
. $
,
/0
1
23 4567897:: 78 ;""*('"& ;8 923 :753 ;: 923 387;< 7=75 >?@3 68? , 6A6=686 6@3B6?7 7A C3:;<3 927A ;><9 D265538@78@ 68 ;<?3< ?693? '&""('"* CE
- 3 -
B27D2 923 ;><9 7F4;>8?3? 68 6@<33F389 ;: A653 68? <3:3<<3? 79 9; 923 A>C$<3@7A9<6< :;< ?393<F78697;8 ;: ?>9E 68? 438659E ( 23 A>79 78 ;""*('"& B6A :753? :;< A43D7:7D 43<:;<F68D3 ;: 68 6@<33F389 ;: A653 ?693? '#'('"
23 A>79 B6A D;893A93? CE 923 ?3:38?689A B2; ?3873? 923 3G3D>97;8 ;: 6@<33F389 ;: A653 23 A>79 B6A A39 ?;B8 :;< 9<765 68? 923 4567897:: B6A 3G6F783? 6A
" 238 23 9<73? 9; F6<H 923 6@<33F389 ;: A653 6A 68 3G27C79 923 A6F3 B6A ;44;A3? CE 923 ?3:38?689A ;8 923 @<;>8? 9269 A>::7D7389 A96F4 ?>9E B6A 8;9 467? 923<3;8 23 <765 ;><9 43<>A3? 923 ?;D>F389 68? 235? 9269 923 4;AA3AA7;8 ;: 923 A>79 4<;43<9E B6A ?357=3<3? 9; 923 4567897:: >8?3< 6@<33F389 ;: A653 68? 923<3:;<3 923 4567897:: B6A C;>8? 9; 46E 923 A96F4 ?>9E 6A 4<3AD<7C3? >8?3< <97D53 3!7! ;: 923 6<8696H6 96F4 D9
"*# :;< A2;<9 /923 D9 ;:
"*#0! ;B3=3< 923 4567897::
26? 467? 78A>::7D7389 A96F4 ?>9E 923<3;8 68? 923<3:;<3 7F4;>8?3? 923 ?;D>F389 78 3G3<D7A3 ;: 79A 4;B3< >8?3< 3D97;8
;:
- 4 -
923 D9 ;:
"*# 68? <3:3<<3? 923 ?;D>F389 9; 923 A>C$ <3@7A9<6< :;< ?393<F78697;8 ;: ?>9E 68? 438659E 378@ 6@@<73=3? CE 923 A67? ;<?3< 923 4567897:: 7A C3:;<3 927A ;><9
36<83? D;>8A35 :;< 923 4567897::
D;8938?3? 9269 78 =73B ;: 923 I>?@F389 ;: 923 43G ;><9 78 923 D6A3 ;:
<34;<93? 78 79 7A 8;9 83D3AA6<E 9269 438659E 69 938 97F3A 923 ?>9E 26A 9; C3 7F4;A3? 3 A>CF79A 9269 923 4567897:: 7A 3897953? 9; @; C3:;<3 923 34>9E ;FF7AA7;83< 68? A33H :;< <3:>8? ;: 923 438659E 23<3:;<3 23 D;8938?A 9269 923 43G ;><9 96H78@ 789; D;8A7?3<697;8 923 6C;=3 4<;=7A7;8 78 56B :;< <3:>8? 26? 235? 9269 D;553D978@ 68 3J>65 6F;>89 ;: A96F4 ?>9E 6A 438659E B;>5? C3 A>::7D7389 D;F45768D3 78A936? ;: <353@6978@ 923 46<973A C3:;<3 923 34>9E ;FF7AA7;83< :;< <3:>8? ;: 923 438659E + 23 536<83? ??797;865 ;=3<8F389 ?=;D693 ;8 923 ;923< 268? D;8938?3?
9269 923 56B F68?693A 9269 923 4567897::
A2;>5? 46E 923 438659E 69 938 97F3A 923 ?>9E
- 5 -
68? 6:93< 46EF389 ;: A>D2 438659E 79 7A :;< 923 4567897:: 9; 644<;6D2 923 34>9E ;FF7AA7;83< A33H78@ :;< <3:>8? ;: 923 438659E 467? 3 A>CF79A 9269 923 34>9E ;FF7AA7;83< 78 3G3<D7A3 ;: 27A ?7AD<397;8 B;>5? ?393<F783 B269 7A 923 6F;>89 576C53 9; C3 <3:>8?3? 9; 923 4567897:: 23<3:;<3 23 D;8938?A 9269 923 4567897:: D688;9 6=;7? 46E78@ 923 ?>9E 68? 438659E 6A 4<3AD<7C3? >8?3< 56B
26=3 D;8A7?3<3? 923 A>CF7AA7;8A F6?3 CE 923 536<83? D;>8A35 :;< 923 439797;83<4567897:: 68? 536<83? ??797;865 ;=3<8F389 ?=;D693 64436<78@ :;< <3A4;8?389 ;+ & 238 68 78A>::7D73895E A96F43? ?;D>F389 7A 4<;?>D3? C3:;<3 68 >92;<79E ;< 6 ;><9 6>92;<7K3? 9; <3D37=3 3=7?38D3 923 ;><9 26A 8; ;923< ;497;8 9268 9;
7F4;>8? 923 ?;D>F389 68? ?7<3D9 D;553D97;8 ;: ?3:7D79 A96F4 ?>9E 68? 438659E 8D3 923 ?>9E 68? 438659E 7A D;553D93? 79 7A 65B6EA ;438 :;< 923 46<9E 9; 6445E C3:;<3 923 D;8D3<83? 34>9E ;FF7AA7;83< >8?3< 3D97;8 % ;:
- 6 -
923 D9 ;:
"*# :;< <3:>8? ;: 923 438659E 3D97;8 % ;: 923 D9 ;:
"*# 4<;=7?3A 9269 923 34>9E ;FF7AA7;83< F6E 7F4;A3 438659E ;: 6 A>F ;:
<>433A 68? <3:>8? 923 3GD3AA 23<3:;<3 92;>@2 923<3 7A 6 4<;D3?><3 4<3AD<7C3? >8?3< 923 D9 ;:
"*# :;< 46EF389 68? <3:>8? ;: 923 438659E A78D3 79 7A A>CF7993? CE 923 536<83? D;>8A35 :;< 923 439797;83< 9269 923 439797;83< B;>5? 46E >4 923 ?3:7D79 A96F4 ?>9E 68? 68 3J>65 6F;>89 ;: A96F4 ?>9E 9;B6<?A 438659E 7893<3A9 ;: I>A97D3 B;>5? C3 F39 CE 43<F79978@ 923 4567897:: 9; 46E ?3:7D79 A96F4 ?>9E 6A B355 6A 68 3J>65 6F;>89 ;: A96F4 ?>9E 6A 438659E B792;>9 ?<7=78@ 923 439797;83< 9; @; C3:;<3 923 34>9E ;FF7AA7;83< A33H78@ :;< <3:>8? 27A B;>5? 65A; 96H3 A>::7D7389 D6<3 ;: 923 7893<3A9 ;: 923 <3=38>3
8 9269 =73B ;: 923 F6993< 927A ;><9 4<;D33?A 9; 46AA 923 :;55;B78@
7! 23 <79 39797;8 7A
77!
23 7F4>@83? ;<?3< 46AA3? CE 923 <765 ;><9 7F4;>8?78@ 923 A653 6@<33F389 ?693? - 7 -
'#'('" 7A >4 235? ;B3=3< 923 4567897:: 7A 43<F7993? 9; 46E 923 ?3:7D79 A96F4 ?>9E ;8 923 A653 6@<33F389 6A 4<3AD<7C3? >8?3< 56B 6A ;8 923 ?693 ;: 923 6@<33F389 68? 65A; 68 3J>65 6F;>89 ;: A96F4 ?>9E 46E6C53 6A 438659E 777! 4;8 46EF389 ;: A>D2 ?3:7D79 A96F4 ?>9E 68? 438659E 923 <765 ;><9 A2655 <3D37=3 923 ?;D>F389 78 3=7?38D3 68? 4<;D33? 78 6DD;<?68D3 B792 56B
7=! 23 4567897:: A2655 8;9 C3 3897953? 9; A33H :;< 68E <3:>8? C3:;<3 923 34>9E ;FF7AA7;83<
)'
&"(
"
7A9 ;
" 5 ; &