- 1 - !" ! # $$ # $%$ ! & ! " # $% #&" ' !" " " ! ($)* ! $# # ( ! + ! &" ( ' , - Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )- " & + !" & &" -(( + " " & + # # .! & & .! & &" $ #.! & &" /01233425016054789:/434:0:0;<4=>520?2<:144@0<A 6;=/0A/4=>;?34<12:0;<840<A2AA=04B4789:/4CD7A?4<: 2<72E2=772:473211470<;-(( 89 :/4 770:0;<25 4<0;= 0B05 &D7A4 2<7 4?84= 0C2923D=6;=1/;=:F =08D<25G /4 2334552<: 60547 2 >520? 34:0:0;< D<74= 4>:0;< (( ;6 :/4 ;:;= 4/0>541 >: * 846;=4 :/4 =08D<25144@0<A>;?34<12:0;<6;=:/42>>074<:250<CD=041 1D664=4789/0?0<2=;272>>074<:72:47-E/4< - 3 - /4E213=;>4470<A;<:/4?;:;=>9>54842=0<A;$ )) 6=;? !/2=2:2A0 :; 0C293D= 7D4 :; =21/ 2<7 <4A50A4<: 7=0B0<A 89 :/4 7=0B4= ;6 :/4 5;==9 842=0<A =4A01:=2:0;< ;($)* /4 2334552<: E21 1/06:47 :; :/4 /;130:25 2<7 3=;B0747 E0:/ :=42:?4<: : E21 2B4==47 :/2: 7D4 :; :/4 2>>074<: :/4 >520?2<: 1D1:20<47 34=?2<4<: 70128050:9 /4<>4 1;DA/: 6;= >;?34<12:0;< /4 =413;<74<: ; H <1D=2<>4 ;?32<9;33;147:/4>520?34:0:0;<8974<90<A:/42A4 0<>;?4 2<7 70128050:9 1D664=47 89 :/4 >520?2<: : E21 2B4==47 :/2: :/4 2>>074<: /21 ;>>D==47 7D4 :; :/4 <4A50A4<>4 ;6 :/4 =074= ;6 :/4 ?;:;=>9>54 2<7 :/4 =413;<74<:840<A:/40<1D=4=;6:/45;==901<;:4<:0:547:; 329 2<9 >;?34<12:0;< 2<7 1;DA/: 6;= 701?01125 ;6 :/4 >520?34:0:0;< - /4 =08D<25 6=2?47 :/4 011D41 2<7 =4>;=747 :/4 4B074<>4 ;6 :/4 32=:041 /4 34:0:0;<4= 4I2?0<47 21 + 2<7 0< 1D33;=: ;6 /01 >214 :E; ;>:;=1 E4=4 4I2?0<4721+1-2<72<7A;:?2=@477;>D?4<:121 - 4 - I1 :; - /4 =413;<74<:1 707 <;: 277D>4 2<9 4B074<>4 2<7 E0:/ >;<14<: A;: ?2=@47 >;39 ;6 :/4 <1D=2<>4;50>921 I 6:4=/42=0<A8;:/32=:041:/4 =08D<25890:1CD7A?4<:2<72E2=772:47/21 2E2=747:;:25>;?34<12:0;<;6 1*AA=04B47 89:/412?4>520?2<:010<:/01233425 42=<47 >;D<145 ?: 2:<2 /0B29;A0?2:/ 23342=0<A6;=:/42334552<:1D8?0:1:/2::/4 =08D<25/21 >;??0::47 2 A=2B4 4==;= 0< 2114110<A :/4 0<>;?4 ;6 :/4 34:0:0;<4= 2: 1( 34= ?;<:/ E0:/;D: 233=4>02:0<A :/462>::/2:/4E21E;=@0<A21221;<2<7E2142=<0<A ?;=4 :/2< 1 34= ?;<:/ : 01 1D8?0::47 :/2: :/4 =08D<25/2121141147:/470128050:9;6:/434:0:0;<4=2: JE/0>/01>;<:=2=9:;:/44B074<>4;6:/4 ;>:;=12<7 :/4 0128050:9 4=:060>2:4 3=;7D>47 4<>4 1/4 144@1 =4211411?4<:;6:/412?42134=:/44B074<>4;<=4>;=7 :016D=:/4=1D8?0::47:/2::/4 =08D<25D<74=:/4/4271;6 320< 2<7 1D664=0<A1 5;11 ;6 2?4<0:041 0< 5064 2<7 5;11 ;6 0<>;?47D=0<A5207D334=0;72<7;:/4=/42712=4251;;< - 5 - :/45;E4=10744<>41/4144@1:;255;E:/423342589 233=;3=02:459?;70690<A:/40?3DA<472E2=7 =0 2/D5 1:D=4 542=<47 >;D<145 23342=0<A 6;= :/4 =413;<74<: H <1D=2<>4 ;?32<91D33;=:1 :/4 0?3DA<47CD7A?4<: 2<7 2E2=7;6 :/4 =08D<252<71D8?0:1:/2::/44B074<>4;6+1-2<7 7;41 <;: 0<70>2:4 2<9 70128050:9 1D664=47 89 :/4 2334552<: =41D5:0<A 0< =47D>:0;< ;6 0<>;?4 2<7 /4<>4 :/4 =08D<25 /21=0A/:5921141147:/470128050:92:JE/0>/7;41<;: >2556;=2<90<:4=64=4<>4:016D=:/4=1D8?0::47:/2::/4 >520?2<:/21<;:3=;7D>472<94B074<>4E0:/=4A2=7:;:/4 0<>;?4 /4<>4 :/4 =08D<25 /21 21141147 :/4 0<>;?4 2: 1(34=?;<:/2<7:/2::/42E2=7;6:/4 =08D<25 D<74= ;:/4= /4271 251; 7;41 <;: =4KD0=4 2<9 4</2<>4?4<:4<>4/4144@1:;701?011:/4233425 ( 2B0<A/42=7:/42=AD?4<:1;6542=<47>;D<145 6;= :/4 2334552<:>520?2<: 2<7 542=<47 >;D<145 6;= :/4 <1D=2<>4 ;?32<9 E4 /2B4 ?4:0>D5;D159 34=D147 :/4 ?2:4=025;<=4>;=7 - 6 - ) /4;<593;0<::/2:2=01416;=;D=>;<1074=2:0;< 0<:/0123342501# :012<D<7013D:4762>::/2:0<:/4=;27:=2660> 2>>074<: 72:47 - :/4 2334552<:>520?2<: /21 1D1:20<47 A=04B;D1 0<CD=041 ; 1D81:2<:02:4 :/4 0<CD=041 2<7 :/4 70128050:9 1D664=47 89 :/4 2334552<: /4 277D>47 4B074<>4;6+1-2<7E/;/2B421141147:/470128050:9 2<72=4;30<47:/2::/4B010;<;6:/42334552<:0<=0A/:494 0170?0<01/4789-:;-J2<72>>;=70<A5921141147:/4 70128050:90?052=59+/21743;147:/2::/46=2>:D=4;6 :/:;;://21=41D5:470<70660>D5:90<3=;<;D<>0<A:/4E;=71 2<7 /4 /21 21141147 :/4 70128050:9 6=;? H J ;<1074=0<A:/412?4:/4 =08D<2521141147:/43/910>25 70128050:9 2: J 2<7 2114110<A 0<>;?4 2: 1( 34= ?;<:/ /21 2E2=747 :;:25 >;?34<12:0;< ;6 1* 25;<A E0:/ 0<:4=41: 2: :/4 =2:4 ;6 (J 34= 2<<D? - 7 - ;<1074=0<A :/4 ;=25 4B074<>4 ;6 +1 - 2<7 2<7 @4430<A 0< B04E :/2: :/4=4 01 <; >;<:=2=9 4B074<>4 ;< =4>;=7 :;7013D:4:/4 12?4 E4 =4211411 :/4 70128050:9 2: JE/0>/E;D57?44::/44<71;6CD1:0>4 * 7?0::4759 2334552<: /21 <;: 3=;7D>47 2<9 4B074<>4 E0:/ =4A2=7 :; :/4 0<>;?4 ;<1074=0<A :/4 <;:0;<25 0<>;?4 >/2=: 3=432=47 89 :/4 2=<2:2@2 :2:4 4A25 4=B0>41 D:/;=0:9 6;= :/4 2>>074<: ;6 :/4 942= E4=4211411:/4<;:0;<250<>;?4;6:/4>520?2<:2: 134=?;<:/6;=:/43D=3;14;674:4=?0<2:0;<;6 >;?34<12:0;<7?0::4759:/474>42147E212A4728;D: 942=12::/4:0?4;62>>074<:/4<>4:/4 =08D<25/21 =0A/:592335047:/4233=;3=02:4?D5:03504=;6FG /D1:/4 >;?34<12:0;< D<74=:/4 /427;6 5;11;6 6D:D=4 0< 0<>;?4 ;<2>>;D<:;670128050:901>25>D52:4721 1II JIL 1* ;<14KD4<:59:/45;11;60<>;?47D=0<A5207D3 34=0;701=4>25>D52:4721 1IL 1( - 8 - /4 =08D<25 /21 >;??0::47 2< 4==;= 0< 2E2=70<A?42A4=>;?34<12:0;<;6 1D<74=:/4 /427 ;6 320< 2<7 1D664=0<A 2<7 ?42A4= >;?34<12:0;< D<74=:/4/427;65;11;642=<0<A7D=0<A5207D334=0;72<7 5;11;62?4<0:0412<72::4<72<>42<7>;<B492<>4>/2=A41 2@0<A<;:4;6:/40<CD=0411D1:20<472<770128050:91D664=47 89 :/4 2334552<: E4 2=4 ;6 :/4 B04E :/2: :/4 12?4 01 =4KD0=47:;844</2<>473=;34=59>>;=70<A59E42E2=7 320< 2<7 1D664=0<A 2 1D? ;6 1:;E2=71 5;11;6 2?4<0:04121D?;6 1(2<7:;E2=71>;<B492<>4 <;D=01/?4<: 2<7 2::4<72<:G1 >/2=A41 2 1D? ;6 1(012E2=747 /4 >;?34<12:0;< 2E2=747 2: 1 6;= ?470>254I34<14189:/4 =08D<2501CD1:2<73=;34=E/0>/ 7;41<;:>2556;=2<90<:4=64=4<>489:/01;D=: - < 255 :/4 2334552<: 01 4<:0:547 6;= ?;706047 >;?34<12:0;<21D<74=# - 9 - '()*+,-'.*(/0. ,-'.*(/0. (,1./ 20<2<71D664=0<A 1 470>254I34<141 1 ;E2=7134=?2<4<:70128050:9 1* ;11 ;6 0<>;?4 7D=0<A 5207 D3 34=0;7 1( ;<B492<>4 <;D=01/?4<: 2<7 2::4<72<:G1>/2=A41 1( ;11;62?4<0:041 1( /(2 *""3 4112E2=789:/4 =08D<25 1* .4(.+','./ *"5"3 <:/4=41D5::/46;55;E0<A# 0 /423342501 00 /4 CD7A?4<: 2<7 2E2=7 321147 89 :/4 =08D<2501/4=489?;706047 000 /42334552<:014<:0:547:;:/4>;?34<12:0;< ;6 1"" 21 2A20<1: 1* 2E2=747 89 :/4 =08D<25 25;<A E0:/ (J 0<:4=41:34=2<<D?6=;?:/472:4;634:0:0;< :055=4250M2:0;<;64<:0=4>;?34<12:0;<2?;D<: - 10 - 4I>5D70<A 0<:4=41: 6;= :/4 745294734=0;7 ;6 7291 0< 6050<A :/4 233425 21 34= ;=74= 72:47- 0B J;6:/44</2<>47>;?34<12:0;<1/25584 @43: 0< 743;10: 0< 2<9 <2:0;<250M47 82<@ 0< :/4<2?4;6>520?2<:6;=234=0;7;6942=1 ;E4B4= :/4 >520?2<: E;D57 84 4<:0:547 :; 7=2E34=0;70>250<:4=41: B 0A/: E44@1. :0?4 01 A=2<:47 6;= :/4 <1D=2<>4 ;?32<9 :; 743;10: :/4 8252<>4 >;?34<12:0;<2?;D<: B0 4A01:=9 01 70=4>:47 :; =4:D=< 255 :/4 =4>;=71 :; :/4>;<>4=<47 =08D<25 )3 6$7 $ )3 6%$ !7 $ ! 01:;#5;#- #