Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 4623 (PNJ)
SHAM LAL ALIAS SHYAM LAL v. STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS
RFA/1031/2025 · 2026-02-12
Harkesh Manuja
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 4623 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 4623 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
RFA No.1031 of 2025
!" #$ " 6 6 6 6 $999 $999 $999 $999:::: &) #+(+!,"% &'' &( $" &/ 5 !"+$! . +! "% &(($2 .00$ . $;=$# $;=$# $;=$# $;=$# ?@ ) ;=;<9;9< '& 7% +!&#" "$1 025 (O&M)
$ $ $ $ &" $# &" $# &" $# &" $# 6 6 6 6 &/*'"&-./$0&" $ "% &'' ((&!" &)* +!,(&-./$0&" &!.
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
9 9 9 9;;;;99999;9 9;9 9;9 9;9EEEE '' ((&!" '' ((&!" '' ((&!" '' ((&!" '$!. !" '$!. !" '$!. !" '$!. !"7777 8888 '$!. !"$ 2+"% &" #$ '$!. !"$9C 0$!.$!&"+$! $# . (&) $# E .&) ."$"% '$!. !" $!9E;F9;9 #$ "% '& "+ &!. #$ "% & $ $*" *##+0+ !" 0&* - "% &5 ,"% &'' &(+ 0$!.$! . !, %& 1 !(&+."$"% 2& ..&"
" +0" *., - &,& 7$%& $* "B8-2% 1)"% # !0 ' "+"+ 1 ) +! 9;9< & $! + .&" . $%&(+8
"+"+$! MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.18 09:30 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
RFA No.1031 of 2025
' # .*!. FG0"B8#+( . ?9@ + 0$5' ! &"+$! 2 $ 99C9 7 + / !* "&" $ &,& 7 !$"+#+0&"+$! .&" FG0"-#$ "% +"):
%& 1)"% &!.0H ?=@ & '$!. !"$ 0$5' + .+!6% 0$ . .& $2! 2& 5&. &00$ . ?G@ ,, =$#"% FG &'' ((&!"$2! . 7=:;8-% 2& $ CF"% %& $*" $ $# $5%+5 !" )&" $G 6%& &$9G;7 *0%- "% &!. 025 (O&M)
0"+$! =;>=$#"% &!.0 .&""% +! "&!0 $#"% &'' ((&!"2 + #() "&"+!,- "% .+ '*" 2+"% ' 0" "$ "% &0H*+ . (&! +,%& 9 + 2& 8 &!. 9G; 7= + $# /+((&, /+!&,& - &.1& " 7$%&(+8 % &0H*+ +"+$! +! "% &" .;9;;&!.;;<9;;
"% '*1(+0'* '$ !&5 ()#$ ""+ -#$(($2 .1)&!2& .*!. 0H*+ +"+$!$(( 0"$ 7#$ %$ "A"% & . $! "% 3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% $2& 0$ . ."$1 $2! "$"% 6%& &$ 99C97:98&!.9G 2! +!'$ +$!$#<C9G"% %& - $ .+!,() ,, + / ."% $#-"% &'' ((&!" $* G0"- "&"+!,"% +!"%&""% / .CF"% %& +!6%& &$99C9 $2! "$"% I" !"$#C= . %&
" $# 6%& & $99C9 7:98 2& /+. ,+ " . &( . ..&" . G= &!0"+$! .$!9;;< ;7=:;82& / $(.1)"% &'' &!. 0H*+ +"+$! $(( 0"$ 0$5 0H*+ +"+$!0"-FG7#$ %$ "A"
"2& .+ 5+ . (&" "$ "% &''$ "+$!5 !" (&!. '& 0 ( #$ 5+!, '& " $# 6%& +,%& ; + 2& 8 ' "&+!+!, "$ & " $E- % +( 6%& & - + " "% ' !" 0& 0$55 !0 . /+ + * .*!. 0"+$! G>E$#"
""+!,*'$# +. !"+&( 1&! "& 0"+$!$#"% FG0"'&
"% B8$!;9;F9;
"% ) & 9;;E:;- 2% +! ' +/ "% I" !"$#CF"% %& +!"% (& 9G;7=:;82+"%"% &'' ((&!"1 + -"% .+ 1* 5 !"$#0$5' ! &"+ $*,%" # !0 *!. 0"+$! =; / !* !" + 2 !$"0$ 0"& " C97:98-2% & +!6%& &$9 %& % &'' ((&!"&( $'( &. ."% & '* 0%& . 1) ' +/&" '$!. .=;<#$(($2+!,1)5*"&"+ "2& &( $'( &. ."%&"!$'& " ' ((&!""$' +/&" '$!.
!"$ $55+"" . +(( ,&(+") 2%+( 5&4+ 2
"A"%
" $# %& & $ "% + " +0" /+. $#"%
"&" - & . +/&" (&!. 1 +!, &"+$! =;> & "% $9G; ."%&" !. !"
"&"+$! & "$# $& &4+!, MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.18 09:30 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
RFA No.1031 of 2025
.+ 1* 5 !"$# ' +/&" '$!. ?<@ !
"%&" & ' "% $!2& . "+((9; $# '& " $# 6%& 0$55+"" . 1) " 0$5' ! &"+$!+! !*51 ?E@ % .+ 5+ .
"% &'' ((&!"C(&!.$2 1 !' # . ?@ %& '&' 1$$4& 2 5&. $!1 %&(#$ ?F@ ' FE:F7I
:= '$ +$!$#C=
"% / !* "& &,& 7 CF"% %& $*"$ '$!. !" $ 7I
:98
"+! &'' ((&!" "$ ' 025 (O&M)
$#0$5' ! &"+$!& ,& . '& "$# . !"$ !"% $"% -"% "&!."&4 !$!1 % / !* 0$ . +! "% #$ 5 $# ;:9-' +/&" '$!. !"$2 %& & $9G; 7=:;8- & *0% "% "% &!. 0H*+ +"+$! $(( 0"$ +!#&/$* $#' +/&" '$!. !" % ( & ! . # !0 $* " /+. % # !0 ' "+"+$! ' # $2! +!,&,, + / ."% $#-"% %&/ % & . ( & ! . 0$*! ( #$ 2 ((& 0$ . $#"% 0& 7 8 (#$#"% &'' ((&!"C(&!.$2! ' * &( $# "% 0$ . %$2 "%& =8&!.:97I
:G8-"% &'' C= . %& $#6%& &$ 99C97
"&" $#/+((&, /+!&,& -&.1& 7$%&(+8&" /+. ,+ " . &(
"$#6%& &$99C97:982& $:&+ +!,% #$(($2 . 1) !" +! !"()-!$ %& $*"$#6%& & '$!. !"$$2 / -"% / $#6%& &$9G;7=:;8+!#&/$* %&(#$#' +/&" '$!. !"$2 $# 3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% ) & E 2& 0$ . .& $2! +!'$ + % 2& !$ +(( ,&(+") $ ' / 0"$ 2%+( 5&4+!, .+ 1* 5 !" $2+"% ' 0""$"% &+.4%& /+. +" 2& . .&" . ;=;<9;9 . &"
"% +! "&!0 $#
" -"% ' !" ,*(& + "'' &(% $ "% '& "+ &!. ,$! "% $*,% #+!. *1 "&!0 +!"% *15+ +$
"%&" +! "% 3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% ) '' ((&!"2& 0$ . ."$1 $2! 97:98&!.9G;7=:;8' "&+!+!, 1& "$E- % +(6%& & -+ " &( .
..&" .=;<7I
: & $(.1)"% &'' ((&!"+!#&/$* !" ) $# 5*"&"+$! 1& . "% *' $9G;7=:;82& / $(.1)" / !* &*"%$ +"+ 2%+( 0& )+!,$ 3 * $# 2& E: +$! +") !" $# %& & 9;9<-
"% &(%& % "% +$! ) & ! +! +!,"$ + " +0" :8- * $# *'$! )"% ,$*" MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.18 09:30 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
RFA No.1031 of 2025
!" + +! "% '$!. !"$ ;8& 2 ((-"%$* &'' ((&!" +"% #&/$* $# '$! $9G;7=:;8-! ' $.*0 &!.' $ %+5# $5"% &' '( &2& $*,%" $5 '& " $# 6% &,&+! !$ .$0*5 $ % . '$ ( /&!"+!"%+
"%+ '* 0 '* 0 2& '* 0 # $5 9;E &5$ (&!. '* 0 5*"& &!) '* 0 *( &5! 025 (O&M)
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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
RFA No.1031 of 2025
$ 6%& %)& 5+!$ 0$5 %&/ ?@ ! / '* 0%& 5&. 1 ' "&+!+!, "$ "% 6%& & -+ " +0" 2%+( !$!: *+"+! $!1 %&(#$#"% 9;;:;9- 9;;E: 0$ . .1 +!,0 ?@ !"% 2 $!, %&/+!, (+ . *'$! !# &"" " .0$'+ $ ' $/ .$! 0$ . ?;@ $ 0$ . .+!"% ' "&+!+!, "$ "% 6%& & -+ " +0" $2! +! '$ &"% - '$!. !" + '* 0%& 025 (O&M)
$9G;%&/ !$" !&!)5*"&"+$! %& & &$9G;% #$* /+ 2&$#(& %)&5&($!=;</+. & +4& +!$ &""%&""+5 "+ 2 $!,"$ *,, $5' ! &"+$!H*&6%& & &$9G=" %&/ . '$ +!,#&( ()L ! /+ 2 $# &#$ &+.- $!0 '$ 1) %+5 # $5 "% &'' ((&!" &1$
"% / !* "&" $# /+((&, +0"&,& 7$%&(+8-"% ( &
"+!,"% &'' ((&!"5 ()#$ "% % &'' ((&!"#$ "% 0$ 0"+$!$# :; &!. 9;:9- 2% +! ' 0$: %& +!6%& &$9G;7=:; !"% %*51( $'+!+$!$#"%+ $* " 0$ . . "%&" "% 3&5&1&!.+ ' !#&0"- "% ( & ! . # !0 $ $# ( /&!"3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% ) $ .& I
:="$I
:F $ $/ - '$!. !" $ !$2% 3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% ) & FE:
"% / !* "&" $# /+((&, 0"&,& 7$%&(+8-2% +! +$! $# C= . %& $# 6%& & !. !" $ %+5 (# 2%+( ()+! . CF"% %& # $5 "% &'' ((&! &"+$!+!"% !&5 $#5)%&,+!,% #(&!.2& '* 0%& .1)5)#&"% # $ +4&$9E<+!5)!&5 "%$*,%2 *,, ""%&"&5!$" !"+"( ."$, "& ="+ &( $#* "% 2 $!,"$ *,, ""% '$!. !" $- #&+( . "$ ' $/ & 1$*" %& +! 6%& & $9G; 7=:
/+!&,& - &.1& " $E- % ( & ! . # !0 $* "2 !"2 $ & $!"%&"!$ ##$ "2& / 5& $#3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% ) & E: '$!. !" $ 2& %$2! "$ ;8 * "-"% ( & !
. # !0 $* "2 ' $.*0 . $! 0$ . 2 !$" "$ $* " #&+( . "$ &'' 0+&" "%&" " ) & FE:F"$9;:92 .* 2% .+ '*" . "% / !* !" :F7I
:=8&!.:97I /+!&,& - &.1& " $E- % +!"% &'' ((&!"2& 0$ . ."$ $ 99C9 7:98 &!. 9G; 7=: )+!, *'$! "% &#$ &+. 3&5&1&! (&!" $*" $# 6%& & $99C9 7: 5 ,%#$ # $5 2&
"&!)
""%&" &!) :;8 % +( $!, 5&. :-
"$ 1 2 !"
"$ 1
" "% .*() !" +
:G8 % +(
"$1 ;8 &1&!.+ 98 MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.18 09:30 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
RFA No.1031 of 2025
%* - +! *0% .$0*5 !"$#"+"( 7=:;8-2& .+ 1 !*51 -2+"%$*" ?@ 00 &'' &(+ &(($2 . # !0 $* " ( & $#0$5' 7=:;8 ' "&+!+!, % +(6%& & - ?9@ (( 1 1 1 1 *& ) *& ) *& ) *& )9 9 9 9----9; 9; 9; 9;9999 "+4 J% J% 025 (O&M)
% 0+ 0*5 "&!0 - '$!. !" $ +"( H*&%+ $2! %+'$ '$ +$ + 1* .0$5' ! &"+$!& &,&+! " *""% 1 +!,&!) +,%"-"+"( $ +!" 00$ .+!,()-+!/+ 2$#"% &#$ & .&!."% +5'*,! .2& ..&" . * "+ % 1) "& +. % &'' ( ' ! &"+$!1 +!,$2! +!'$ + +!, "$ "% / !* "&" $# /+(( -+ " +0"&,& 7$%&(+8$! ((' !.+!,&''(+0&"+$!7 8-+#&!)- % 7 7 7 7 9E 9E 9E 9E % "% ' &4+!,C & $! . C % "% '$ "&1( C $ %&/+!, #&+( . "$ ' $.*0 & +$!$/ &!)'& "$#6%& &$9
""% &0H*+ +"+$!$#"% &+.4%& +!" ""% +! &+.. "&+( ..+ 0* +$!-"% '
" .;=;<9;9<'& .1)"% ( & ! ((&!"C(&!.$2! + % (. !"+"( . +$!$#C= . %& +!6%& &$9 /+((&, /+!&,& - &.1& " $E $!&00$*!"$#+" &0H*+ +"+$! - %&((&( $ "&!..+ '$ .$# 6 8 6 8 6 8 6 8 C$ C$ 6 &!) $9G; %& & !" & ! . .#$ $9G; E- MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.18 09:30 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment