- 1 - !! "#$ #%%&' ( #%%)&' #%%&' !"# ! $ % & & '($()* + Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - && & & & + & & )!( & **(*( && *! (*$ & (*, ) ( - ( & # #%%)&' & .& & % $* & & - 3 - ! & '()* & + && & && + & & )!( & **(*( && *! (*$ & (*, )( - ( & # .& & (((*(! & & & % - 4 - % /& *$# % /& 01233144256701819502:1381;1881-601712331247<195= 2==891:1- <> 601 ?@-=A156 B; CB5:9C69B5 25- B8-18 B5 715615C1-261-**(*(9534B! (*$B5 601;941B;--969B52497689C625-1779B57@-=125- 31C924 @-=1 028D2- 32771- 2=29576 2CC@71- B7 25-(;B8601B;;15C173@59702<41@5-181C69B5(*,B; 601 5-925 1524 B-1 ;B8 70B86 EF 25- 1C69B57 ) ( 25- - 8 D ( B; 81:1569B5 B; B88@369B5 C6 # ;B8 70B86 E C6F 601> 281 62G15 @3 6B=16018;B8CB579-18269B5 ( 01 825G B; 601 3286917 95 601 8924 B@86 D944 <1 CB579-181-015C1;B860;B8CB5:15915C1 +,-./0102-/.1-.+-.1345-+ 697601C271B;60138B71C@69B560266012CC@71-B7 25- ( D181 DB8G95= 27 5CBA1 2H ;;9C187 26 142=2:9 25- 9?2>23@8281731C69:14>697;@8601876261-6026601 CBA34295256 02- 5B6 ;941- 5CBA1 2H 16@857 ;B8 601 ;9525C924>128(**6B(*"B579-1895=6015B5,;9495=B; - 5 - 601 729- 5CBA1 2H 16@857 601 2CC@71- B 02- 977@1- 5B69C17 6B 601 CBA34295256 25- 7B@=06 ;B8 097 1H3425269B5;B802:95=5B6;941-6015CBA1 2H16@857 ! 6 97 76261- 6026 3@87@256 6B 601 729- 5B69C17 601 CBA3429525625-(02-2338B2C01-2CC@71-B25- B;;181-601981H3425269B5;B85B602:95=;941-6015CBA1 2H16@8578142695=6B BD1:18601729-B;;18D27 5B6 2CC1361- 25- 96 D27 -981C61- 601 CBA34295256 25- (6B7@<A96601-BC@A1567@86018969776261-6026 2CC@71- B 76261- 6B 02:1 -1A25-1- 2 7@A B; 7!***** , 27 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 6B -B 7BA1 B;;9C924 ;2:B@8 01 CBA34295256 -972=811- 6B 32> 7@C0 2 0@=1 2AB@5625-6015 96D2781-@C1-6B7("**** ,2;618 51=B69269B5 " 6 97 ;@86018 76261- 6026 601 CBA34295256 <195= @50233> 2<B@6601729--1:14B3A15625--1C9-1-6B2338B2C0 95602681=28-CCB8-95=4>01D15624B5=D960097;8915- 25-2338B2C01-601;;9C12615=24@8@25-95;B8A1- 601A 81=28-95= 601 -1A25- B; 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 <> 2CC@71- B 7 318 601 -981C69B5 977@1- <> 601 8173B5-156 ' 01 2C61- 2CCB8-95=4> 6 97 ;@86018 - 6 - 76261- 6026 2CC@71- B( 02- 95;B8A1- 601 CBA34295256 6026 01 DB@4- 715- 2CC@71- B 6B 097 B;;9C1 25- -981C61- 09A 6B 32> 601 2AB@56 B; 7("**** , 6B 2CC@71-BCCB8-95=4>2CC@71-B76261-6B02:1 2338B2C01-95097C4959C25-9568B-@C1-09A714;6026 01 D27 7156 <> 2CC@71- B( ( 2;618 02:95= CB5;98A1- 6026 2CC@71- B D27 7156 <> 09A 01 D27 025-95=B:186012AB@566B2CC@71-B26602669A1 2CC@71-BD2723381015-1-<>6018173B5-156' 25- 2;618 CB5-@C695= 601 95:1769=269B5 7@<A9661- 601 C028=170116 $ 5 B8-18 6B 38B:1 601 C271 B; 601 38B71C@69B5 601 38B71C@69B5 1H2A951- * D96517717 27 6B * 25-=B6A28G1-#"-BC@A156727H76B#"25-247B 9-1569;91- ! A2618924 B<?1C67 27 7 6B ! A2618924 B<?1C67 27 7 6B ! 5 601 B6018025-6012CC@71-=B61H2A951-;B@8D9651771727 6B ! 25- 247B =B6 A28G1- -BC@A1567 27 H76B 01 8924B@862;61823381C92695=<B60B824 25- -BC@A15628> 1:9-15C1 B5 81CB8- 81CB8-1- 601 CB5:9C69B5B;2CC@71-B725-(;B8601B;;15C1776261- - 7 - ) 128- 89 025G28 1=-1 412851- CB@5714 ;B8 601 2331442567 25- 89 11415-82 @5-1 412851- 31C924 8B71C@6B8;B88173B5-15695<B606012331247 6976017@<A9779B5B;412851-CB@5714;B86012331442567 6026 601 ?@-=A156 B; CB5:9C69B5 25- B8-18 B5 715615C1 32771- 2=29576 2CC@71- B7 25- ( 281 318:1871 B8 188B51B@7 0181;B8160172A197492<416B<1716279-1 # 697;@860187@<A9661-602660138B71C@69B5027;2941-6B 38B:1601-1A25-25-2CC13625C1B;9441=24=8269;9C269B5 <> 601 2CC@71- 181 2C695= B5 601 76261A156 B; 601 2CC@71-B6018173B5-156'C255B69A349C261601 2331442567 95 601 2<B:1 729- C271 01 8924 B@86 D960B@623381C92695=601;2C6738B3184>25-815-181-601 CB5:9C69B5D09C097@57@762952<41@5-1860142D * 6 97 ;@86018 7@<A9661- 6026 601 38B71C@69B5 027 5B6 1762<49701-60151H@7<16D1152CC@71-B725-(D960 2CC@71- B @86018 601 38B71C@69B5 027 5B6 1762<49701-6026<B606012CC@71-02:171562CC@71-B 6BCB441C66012441=1-9441=24=8269;9C269B5;8BA 097 2731C6 97 C8@C924 6B 601 C271 B; 601 38B71C@69B5 B6 1762<497095=601814269B57093B;2CC@71-B725-(D960 - 8 - 2CC@71- B 96714; 97 601 =8B@5- 6B -97C28- 601 ;2C6 B; -1A25-95=9441=24=8269;9C269B5 01729-2731C6B@=066B 02:1<115CB579-181-<>601 8924B@86D0941CB579-1895= 6011:9-15C1 697;@860187@<A9661-602660B@=0601CBA3429525676261- 95 097 1:9-15C1 6026 2CC@71- B7 25- ( 02:1 A2-1 71:1824 30B51 C2447 25- -1A25-1- 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 ;8BA09A601389A28>1:9-15C149G1$0275B6<115 38B:1-952CCB8-25C1D96060142D 011:9-15C1B; DB@4- 95-9C261 6026 601 8173B5-156 ' 027 5B6 CB441C61-601A1AB8>C28-95097381715C125-01;@86018 -13B7176026D016018601A1AB8>C28-D2760181B85B6 D275B62D2816B09AB81B:186010270:24@1B;601 AB<94130B510275B6<11571C@81-D09C0979A3B862566B 27C1862956012@601569C96>B;601729-AB<941573961B; 6097 42C@52 601 8924 B@86 38BC11-1- 6B 815-18 601 CB5:9C69B5D09C097188B51B@725-@57@762952<41 ( 6 97 ;@86018 7@<A9661- 6026 601 8924 B@86 B@=06 5B6 6B 02:1CB579-181-60181A29595=141C68B59C1:9-15C125-967 CB561567 BD1:18 601 8924 B@86 CB579-181- 601 729- 1:9-15C125-2C61-@3B57@C0141C68B59C1:9-15C1D09C0 - 9 - 97 CB56828> 6B 601 42D 8142695= 6B 601 2-A9779<9496> B; 141C68B59C 1:9-15C1 :15 277@A95= 6026 601 2441=1- CB5:187269B57 02- 62G15 342C1 <16D115 601 3286917 5BD018195601729-CB5:187269B57601-1A25-B;9441=24 =8269;9C269B5DB@4-62G15342C1 697;@860187@<A9661-602660B@=060138B71C@69B56891- 6B 1762<4970 602627 601 DB8GB; D27 315-95= D960 2CC@71-B277@C001-1A25-1-9441=24=8269;9C269B5 601 1:9-15C1 B; 7 ( 25- C41284> 95-9C2617 6026 2CC@71-B725-(D1815B638171562660173B6D0181 6012441=1-95C9-15602-62G15342C1 ! 6 97 ;@86018 7@<A9661- 6026 6B 815-18 CB5:9C69B5 ;B8 601 B;;15C1 @5-18 1C69B5 ) B; 601 C6 -1A25- 25- 2CC13625C1 B; 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 <> 601 @<49C 18:256 A@76 <1 1762<49701- <> 601 38B71C@69B5 BD1:18 601 8924 B@86 CBAA9661- 2 =82:1 188B8 95 2889:95= 26 2 CB5C4@79B560262CC@71-B725-(281014-=@946>B;601 B;;15C17 76261- 7@382 95 601 2<715C1 B; 38B318 38BB; 0181;B81601CB5:9C69B597815-181-@5?@769;92<4115C1 9697492<416B<1716279-12G95=7@C07@<A9779B57601 412851-CB@5714;B82331442567382>76B244BD6012331247 - 10 - " 5 7@33B86 B; 097 7@<A9779B57 601 412851- CB@5714 ;B8 233144256781491-B5601;B44BD95=?@-=A1567% 825525: 7 ( 1182?@662: 76261<>B:6B; 1409( 1182?@662: 76261B:6B; B;1409 ! 02562AA2: 76261B; 1425=252! 02562AA2: 76261B; 1425=252! " 2=62895=0: 76261B;@5?2<" $ 26>25282>252 @860> : 7 97689C6 5731C6B8 B; B49C16261B;5-08282-170I25B6018$ ) 9?2>2G@A28: 76261B; 2A942-@) 15G262 @<<282B : 7 6261 8138171561- <> 5731C6B8B;B49C1 # @82?24: 762611409-A959768269B5# * 2524242AB-282609: 76261B;2028270682* 1152 D B 24D256 1AG1 : 7 6261 B; 2028270682 ( 2A82G2708B82: 76261B;@5?2<( 27D25695=0: 76261B;@5?2< 1 WP.NO.24119/2022 dated 22.04.2024 2 2023 SCC Online SC 280 3 (2023) 4 SCC 731 4 (2022) 2 SCC 574 5 2023 SCC Online 320 6 (2015) 10 SCC 152 7 (2021) 3 SCC 687 8 (2006) 13 SCC 305 9 (1979) 4 SCC 725 10 (1979) 4 SCC 526 11 (2005) 5 SCC 21 12 (1972) 3 SCC 652 13 (1973) 3 SCC 657 - 11 - ! 6261B; 285262G2: 7 25@A25602920! " 8925?@5260: 7 016261<> 285262G225-B87" $ 01A2 24927 01A 025-82 : 7 6261 B; &6628 82-170$ ) 2492A: 76261B;9A2C02482-170) 6261B; 18242: 7B02AA1-B@702- # 82-113 @A28: 76261B;026697=280# (* 97082: 7(* ( 98970 2<@ : 7 BC095 9=0 B@86 B; 18242( (( 0@7024C025- 270D256 29GD2- : 7 6261 B; 2028270682(( ( @?9697D27: 76261B;772A( (! 24>25 @A28 B=B9 : 70@6B70 =590B689 25- 25B6018(! (" A65962B5G28: 702G@562429782(" ($ 2A2332AA952<02:9: 76261B; 285262G2($ 14 LAWS (KAR) 2006 3 129 15 WP No. 10027/2022 dated 16/11/2022 16 2022 SCC Online SC 991 17 (1973) 2 SCC 808 18 (2016) 14 SCC 318 19 (2023) 5 SCC 350 20 2021 SCC Online Del 82 21 (2009) 3 SCC 779 22 2018 SCC Online Bom 1073 23 (2013) 12 SCC 406 24 (2011) 2 SCC 532 25 2014 (123) RD 855 - 12 - () 6261B; 285262G2: 7028260025-82() ( @5?2<82B: 76261B;2028270682( (# <<27: 76261B; 18242(# * 897025025-18: 76261B;1409* 2982G270 9D289: 76261B; ( 28A95-18G2@8: 76261B;@5?2<( &A1702694: 76261B; 285262G2 ! 8?@5 25-9682B 0B6G28 : 7 294270 @702A82B B8256>24! " 5:28 : 7 27011825-B60187" $ 9417095G28282-G28: 76261B;2028270682$ ) 2A170 0161: 76261B;2-0>282-170) 2A95=0: 7B42A95=0 # 25?2>7950 2A82B 02:25 : 7 2662682> @42<82B 024G125-87# !* 961709502: 76261B;&662882-17025-25B6018!* 26 CRL.A. No. 2612/2010 dated 20/02/2021 27 CRL.A.No.223/1999 decided on 11/12/2001 28 (2002) 10 SCC 371 29 (2001) 10 SCC 103 30 (2016) 3 SCC 108 31 2022 SCC Online SC 966 32 (2020) 8 SCC 811 33 CRL.A.No.2760/2012 dated 21.07.2022 34 (2020) 7 SCC 1 35 (2014) 10 SCC 473 36 (2011) 4 SCC 143 37 ILR (2010) M.P 1633 38 1985 SCC Supl. 41 39 (2015) 3 SCC 123 - 13 - ! 70242602B59: 7@8=170B59! !( ?2>@362: 7!( $ 18 CB5682 8911415-82 @5-1 412851- 31C924 8B71C@6B8 23312895= B5 <1024; B; 027 :101A1564> ?@769;91-601?@-=A156B;CB5:9C69B5815-181-<>601 8924 B@8625-01;@860187@<A9661-602660138B71C@69B5027 38B:1- 601 C271 B; -1A25- 25- 2CC13625C1 B; 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 <> 601 2CC@71- 01 1:9-15C1 B; 7 ( 25-2818141:2566B?@769;>60172A1 01 8924B@86 2;61802:95=CB579-181-6011:9-15C1B;60171D96517717 2889:1-262CB5C4@79B56026601-1A25-25-2CC13625C1 027<11538B:1- ) 697;@860187@<A9661-602660B@=07BA1B;;9C924D96517717 2662C01- 6B 601 5CBA1 2H 13286A156 02:1 6@851- 0B769419581731C6B;6019-15696>B;:B9C172A34178142695= 6B 601 729- 682572C69B5 6026 A2> 5B6 <1 79=59;9C256 27 60181281B6018;B8A7B;1:9-15C1D09C07@33B8676026601 40 (2019) 8 SCC 1 41 2023 SCC Online CHH 3959 42 2022 SCC Online Del 3549 - 14 - 2CC@71- B7 25- ( 02:1 -1A25-1- 601 2AB@56 ;8BA 601CBA34295256279441=24=8269;9C269B5 697;@860187@<A9661-60266011H3186D0B971H2A951-27 (027CB5-@C61-261766B-1618A951601:182C96>B; 601:B9C172A34178142695=6B601CB5:187269B57602602- 62G15 342C1 <16D115 601 CBA34295256 25- 601 2CC@71- 01729-(0277@<A9661-2813B8627318H#*7 318 601 729- 813B86 96 97 38B:1- 6026 601 2CC@71- 02- -1A25-1-9441=24=8269;9C269B5;8BA601CBA34295256 # 697;@860187@<A9661-6026601315-15C>B;DB8G8142695= 6B 601 CBA34295256 027 247B <115 1762<49701- <> 601 38B71C@69B5 01 729- 315-15C> B; DB8G 96714; DB@4- 95-9C261 6026 601 2CC@71- B -1A25-1- 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5;8BA6B-B7BA1B;;9C924;2:B@8 (* 6 97 ;@86018 7@<A9661- 6026 601 614130B59C CB5:187269B57 602602-62G15342C1<16D1156013286917DB@4-95-9C261 6026 601 2CC@71- B7 25- ( ?B9564> 25- 71:18244> -1A25-1-6019441=24=8269;9C269B5;8BA6B-B7BA1 B;;9C924;2:B@8 - 15 - ( 697;@860187@<A9661-6026601 8924B@86027CB579-181- 601 729- 2731C6 25- 81CB8-1- 601 CB5:9C69B5 D09C0 97 2338B38926125-?@769;92<41 0181;B8195618;1815C1DB@4- 5B6 <1 289715 2:95= 729- 60@7 601 412851- 31C924 8B71C@6B8;B86018173B5-156,382>76B-97A977601 2331247 (( 01412851-31C9248B71C@6B8;B86018173B5-156,95 7@33B86B;0977@<A9779B502781491-B5601?@-=A156B; 601B5J<41@381A1B@8695601C271B; !"! ( 2:95= 0128- 601 412851- CB@5714 ;B8 601 81731C69:1 3286917 25- 247B 318@71- 601 ;95-95=7 B; 601 8924 B@86 6013B9567D09C0DB@4-28971;B8A>CB579-18269B5281% 43 (2023) 4 SCC 731 - 16 - (! 1;B812-:18695=6B601;2C67B;601C27196978141:2566B 81;18 601 41=24 38B3B7969B5 B; 601 42D 24B5= D960 601 38B:979B57B;601C6 01C028=170116027<115429- 2=295766012331442567;B8601B;;15C173@59702<41@5-18 1C69B57)(-8 D(B;C6 (" 56097CB561H696978141:2566B81;186B1C69B5)B;601 C6812-727@5-18% !"#$ #$%# &#'()*$+ ) ,-.'*% /#&($) .#*$+.&*.#0$%& '% ( ' ' ) ( ' ' - 17 - ) ( * ' ' + $ ,+ $%- ' ' ' ' $ .$%& ' /01 2 '/31 $ 404 $ ,+ $%- '% ( + !5 ! 5 ! 5 ' ! 5 ' ' - 18 - ) ) ( ' $6 5 C281;@4 812-95= B; 601 2<B:1 729- 38B:979B5 96 A2G1796C41286026601-1A25-;B89441=24=8269;9C269B525- 2CC13625C1 60181B; 97 * 6B CB57696@61 25 B;;15C1@5-181C69B5)B;601C6 ($ 56097CB561H696978141:2566B81;186B601?@-=A156B; 601 B5/<41 @381A1 B@86 95 601 C271 B; "1" 76261-7@382 601 B5/<41 @381A1 B@86 014- 95 3282=8230 B() 27 @5-18% !#$ #' 7 8 9$: ;(0$ <7=<8 !#$. 0 # ' * 0 # - 19 - 2 $ $ 9 ' $>$0 $0 &$3$ $>$? 9$9.$ 7$. ' $ + ' ' $ (,+$3= @8' ' 3 ,+$3= $ ' ' A $ - 20 - $ . $ > 0 #$ 0 (((( ' $ 8$. 0 B & ' 0 # 0 ((( ( &$. ' 0 B & $3 $ & 2 0 B $5 - 21 - 2 $. 2 + ' ' $A * ! 9$9.$ 7$. ' $ + ' ' $ (,+$3= @8' ' 3 ,+$3= $ ' ' A $ - 20 - $ . $ > 0 #$ 0 (((( ' $ 8$. 0 B & ' 0 # 0 ((( ( &$. ' 0 B & $3 $ & 2 0 B $5 - 21 - 2 $. 2 + ' ' $A * ! 5 "0 $C$$C$D2'BB0E@ >#B876 A $9 3 &' 2 $ E 3 &' * $& 2 ' ' $5 () 5C281;@4812-95=B;6012<B:1729-?@-=A15696A2G17 96 C4128 6026 6B CB57696@61 25 B;;15C1 @5-18 1C69B5 ) B; - 22 - 601 C6 60181 A@76 <1 2 -1A25- ;B8 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 25- 601 72A1 027 6B <1 2CC1361- <> 601 @<49C 18:256 5C1 601 2CC13625C1 97 38B:1- 3817@A369B5@5-181C69B5(*B;601C6DB@4-28971 ( 2:95=CB579-181-6013895C93417429--BD5<>601B5/<41 @381A1B@86956012<B:1?@-=A1565BD96978141:256 6B CB579-18 601 1:9-15C1 B; A2618924 D96517717 5 6097 81=28- 601 38B71C@69B5 027 81491- B5 601 1:9-15C1 B; 7(25-D0B281CB579-181-27A2618924D96517717 6B60195C9-156CCB8-95=6B01-9-5B67@<A96601 5CBA1 2H 16@857 ;B8 601 >128 (** 6944 (*" 1 ;@86018 2-A9661- 6026 3@87@256 6B 601 5B69C17 B; 601 5CBA1 2H 13286A156 01 02- 2338B2C01- 2CC@71- B25-81K@1761-09A6B-B601511-;@4 (# @86018 76261- 95 097 1:9-15C1 6026 601 2CC@71- B 76261- 6B 02:1 -1A25-1- 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 B; 7!***** ,0BD1:1896D2781-@C1-6B7("**** , 2;61851=B69269B56B-B7BA1B;;9C924;2:B@86B09A ;@86018 -13B717 6026 2CC@71- B( CB562C61- 09A B:18 601 30B51 25- -981C61- 09A 6B 32> 601 2AB@56 B; 7("**** , 6B 601 3187B5 D0BA 01 DB@4- 715- - 23 - BD1:18 95 601 A12569A1 02- CB562C61- 601 8173B5-156 ' 25- 95;B8A1- 601A 2<B@6 601 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5D09C0D27<195=-1A25-1-<>6012CC@71- * 1 ;@86018 -13B71- 95 097 1:9-15C1 6026 27 318 601 -981C69B5 B; 601 8173B5-156 ' 01 2C61- 25- 2CCB8-95=4> 2CC@71- B D27 2881761- 01 B:18244 1:9-15C1 B; DB@4- 95-9C261 6026 01 027 7@33B861- 601 C271 B; 601 38B71C@69B5 6026 01 02- 81C19:1- 25 95768@C69B5 ;8BA 2CC@71- B( 6026 01 70B@4- 32> 601 2AB@56B;7("**** ,6B2CC@71-BBD1:1827 601 38B71C@69B5 027 ;2941- 6B 1762<4970 6026 60181 D27 2 -1A25-A2-1<>2CC@71-B6B-B7BA1B;;9C924;2:B@8 6B 601 1:9-15C1 B; 97 5B6 8141:256 25- 601 8924 B@86 B@=06 6B 02:1 23381C9261- 601 1:9-15C1 B; 38B3184><1;B8196CB@4-02:12889:1-262CB5C4@79B5 6026 6012CC@71- 281;B@5- =@946> B; 601 B;;15C17 76261- 7@382 781=28-76011:9-15C1B;(97CB5C1851-0176261- 6B02:12CCBA32591-25-2338B2C01-6012CC@71- B26142=2:96B=16C4289;9C269B59581731C6B;5B69C17 977@1-<>09ACCB8-95=6B09A01D273817156D0152 - 24 - -1A25- B; 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 D27 A2-1 <> 2CC@71- B BD1:18 95 601 C8B77,1H2A95269B5 01 02- 2-A9661- 6026 01 D27 1568@761- D960 601 DB8G B; 7@<A96695= 601 5CBA1 2H 16@857 B5 <1024; B; 7 CB@4- <1 7115 ;8BA 097 1:9-15C1 6026 7BB5 2;618 601 95C9-156 01 81A2951- @55B69C1- 25- -9- 5B6 95;B8A 601 729-;2C66B601CB5C1851-2@60B896>697;@860185B69C1- 6026 01 D27 5B6 3817156 27 B5 601 -261 B; 601 2441=1- 95C9-156 D09C0 02- 62G15 342C1 95 601 C4959C B; 0181;B81 097 1:9-15C1 95 81731C6 B; -1A25- 25- 2CC13625C1 B; 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 DB@4- 5B6 342> 25> 39:B624 8B41 95 6097 C271 25- 097 1:9-15C1 DB@4- 5B6 9573981 25> CB5;9-15C1 0181;B81 95 A> CB579-181- B3959B56011:9-15C1B;6097D965177975B6<1491:2<41 ( 011:9-15C1B;D0B97601702-BDD9651776B601 95C9-156 DB@4- 95-9C261 6026 60181 D27 5B -1A25- B; 9441=24=8269;9C269B5<>2CC@71-BBD1:18D27 025-95= B:18 601 2AB@56 B; 7("**** , 6B 2CC@71- B26602669A16012CC@71-BD2723381015-1-<> 6018173B5-156,5CB5?B956812-95=B;6011:9-15C1 B;(25-96C25<195;1881-602660138B71C@69B5 - 25 - 027 ;2941- 6B 1762<4970 601 -1A25- 25- 2CC13625C1 B; 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 <> 2CC@71- B7 25- ( 01 8924 B@86B@=066B 02:123381C9261-6011:9-15C1957@C02 A25518<1;B812889:95=262CB5C4@79B560266012CC@71- 281;B@5-=@946>B;B;;15C13@59702<41@5-181C69B5)B; 601C6 7 81=28-7 601 141C68B59C 1:9-15C17 281 CB5C1851- 601 38B71C@69B5 6891- 6B CB5:95C1 601 B@86 6026 601 CB5:187269B57 <16D115 25- D960 B6018 2CC@71- D181 81CB8-1- 95 $ D09C0 D27 38B-@C1- <> 25-60172A1D27719L1-@5-186016823A202L28D09C0 97A28G1-27H( 0B@=07@33B861-601C271 B; 601 38B71C@69B5 95 81731C6 B; 601 729- A202L28 601 1:9-15C1B;725-DB@4-C41284>95-9C2616026<B60 60171 D96517717 02:1 5B6 7115 601 81AB:24 B; 601 A1AB8> C28- ;8BA 601 729- $ @86018 96 DB@4- 95-9C2616026601>02:15B60128-601CB5:187269B57729- 6B02:1<11568257;1881-6B601BA32C697C7;B870B86 MJ 5 601 2<715C1 B; CB441C695= 601 C1869;9C261 27 81K@981-@5-181C69B5$",B;6015-925:9-15C1C66B 38B:1 601 141C68B59C 1:9-15C1 95 81731C6 B; 601 A1AB8> - 26 - C28- 96 97 @572;1 6B 814> B5 601 1:9-15C1 B; 601 729- 141C68B59C -1:9C1 0B@=0 601 38B71C@69B5 027 6891- 6B 9A38177601B@866026601CB5:187269B57602602-62G15 342C1<16D1156013286917D18168257;1881-6B7D09C0 281 9-1569;91- 27 7 ) 25- # 27 601 389A28> 1:9-15C196714;38B:1-6B<1@52CC1362<4160181A29595= 3B869B57B@=065B66B02:1<115CB579-181-<>601 8924 B@86 BD1:18 601 8924 B@86 =8B774> CBAA9661- 25 188B8 95 CB579-1895= 601 729- 1:9-15C1 0181;B81 601 ;95-95=7 B; 601 8924 B@86 95 81731C6 B; 601 141C68B59C 1:9-15C1 95 A> CB579-181- :91D 97 B33B71- 6B 601 716641-3895C9341B;42D ! 5609781=28-96978141:2566B81;186B601?@-=A156B; 601 B5/<41 @381A1 B@86 95 601 C271 B; 0&C:&F0.CA G&>G&EA&D&C$H&&G&F?I@&9G&E3A&@J,&CHEG0 76261- 3282=8230 B$ B; 601 729- ?@-=A156 D09C0812-727@5-18% 2. ' ' $ & $ - 27 - * $ 9 ' $ H - 0 @ ' 0 > & + 9G ' ' $ $ & ' ' $& ' $ ' $ 0 2 ' & 3$D$$3$J$9 "(BB0#;(B< 0(#;(B<0(;(B< 0(@K0B76$5 " 5812-95=B;6012<B:1729-?@-=A15696A2G1796C4128 6026 D015 601 CB5:187269B5 97 5B6 38B:1- 608B@=0 95-1315-156D96517717814>95=B57@C0CB5:187269B525- - 28 - 815-1895=601CB5:9C69B5DB@4-<1@5?@769;92<415C196 97;B@5-602660181975BA26189246BCB551C66012CC@71- D960 601 C89A1 815-1895= 601 CB5:9C69B5B5 601 <2797 B; 95:249- 1:9-15C1 C1862954> DB@4- 412- 6B 25BA24> 0181;B81 2A B; 601 CB579-181- B3959B5 6026 601 38B71C@69B5 027 ;2941- 6B 38B:1 601 C271 2=29576 601 2CC@71-1:15B5601141C68B59C1:9-15C1697511-4177 6B72>60266013187B57D0B2CK@29561-D960601:B9C1B; 2CC@71- B7 25- ( 02:1 <115 1H2A951- 95 6097 C271 25-601>02:16@851-0B7694125-5B67@33B861-601C271 B;60138B71C@69B5 $ 01 1:9-15C1 B;( 277@A17 =812618 79=59;9C25C1 27 2CC@71- B D27 DB8G95= D960 09A 27 25 B;;9C1 <B> CCB8-95=6B09A51960182CC@71-B5B82CC@71-B( 02773BG15D96009A81=28-95=715-95=B;2CC@71-B 6B 6B CB441C6 601 9441=24 =8269;9C269B5 5 ;2C6 01 -13B717950971:9-15C160260102-71562CC@71-B6B CB441C6 601 AB51> 6B -13B796 601 72A1 956B 601 <25G 6B A2G1B5495132>A156B;2881287B;95CBA162HB; :15 B5 25> 76816C0 B; 601 9A2=95269B5 96 CB@4- <1 95;1881- 6026 601 38B71C@69B5 027 @66184> ;2941- 6B - 29 - 1762<4970 6026 601 38B71C@69B5 027 38B:1- 601 C271 <1>B5- 2 8127B52<41 -B@<6 81=28-95= 601 =@946 B; 601 2CC@71-9581731C6B;601B;;15C1776261-7@382 ) 781=28-76017@<A9779B5B;412851-31C9248B71C@6B8 23312895=B5<1024;B;8173B5-156'01A2954>81491- B5 601 ?@-=A156 B; 601 B5/<41 @381A1 B@86 95 601 C271B;C,,G&:HI&76261-7@382D018195601B5/<41 @381A1B@86014-60269;601CBA342952566@851-0B76941 B8 027 -91- B8 D27 @52:2942<41 6B 416 95 097 1:9-15C1 -@895=68924-1A25-B;9441=24=8269;9C269B5C25<138B:1- <>416695=956011:9-15C1B;25>B6018D965177D0BC25 2=295 416 95 1:9-15C1 196018 B8244> B8 <> -BC@A15628> 1:9-15C1 B8 601 38B71C@69B5 C25 38B:1 601 C271 <> C98C@A762569241:9-15C1 01729--9C6@AB;601B5/<41 @381A1B@8695A>CB579-181-:91D975B623349C2<41 6B601C271 0181;B81601814925C1342C1-<>601412851- 31C924 8B71C@6B8 ;B8 8173B5-156 ' C255B6 <1 7@762951- 560149=06B;601B<718:269B57A2-12<B:138BC11-6B 257D18 601 3B9567 D09C0 28971 ;B8 A> CB579-18269B5 27 @5-18%, - 30 - B956B9 5601M1=269:1J B956B99 5601M1=269:1J B956B999 5601M1=269:1J B956B9: 5601M;;98A269:1J # CCB8-95=4>38BC11-6B3277601;B44BD95=%, 9 0189A9524331247281244BD1- 99 01 ?@-=A156 B; CB5:9C69B5 25- B8-18 B5 715615C1 -261- **(*( 32771- 95 34B*! (*$<>601--969B524 97689C6 25- 1779B57 @-=1 25- 31C924 @-=1028D2-97716279-1 999 01 2331442567 2CC@71- B7 25- ( 281 2CK@9661- ;B8 601 B;;15C17 3@59702<41 @5-18 1C69B5 (*, B; 25- 1C69B57 ) ( - 8 D ( B; 601 81:1569B5 B; B88@369B5C6# 9: 294<B5-71H1C@61-9;25>7625-C25C1441- 5( & ' $ &976B%#4B%