- 1 - ! "#! $! % &!$!! % &! ! !$$ '() *+ ! !$$ ,, * + ! " #$ % " & &" '$ & Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ' % " % & '"( " & )* $ % ! " +' ! % &' % $+"# & % ) ,,* + " #$ % " & &" '+ & " ' % % ! " - 3 - % & '"( " & * ' , &"'! " +' ! ( -! .! % & ' $+"# % & $##" / 0! 1! % ) %& 2 2 3 % 3 % & 23 % ! 4565789-::5-;6.5<=>96$"-=1 ++" .? 745 ::5;;-=7 =6@A-=05 9B:-=? -=1 .? 745 -::5;;-=76"0;-<B-=76 0-;;<=> <= C@567<9= 745 D@1>B5=7 -=1 -8-A1 1-751 ' <= - 4 - 9$+"# :-6651 .? 745 A<=0<:-; 5=<9A <E<; %@1>5 -=1 -;-.@A->< 9= 745 >A9@=1 9F C@-=7@B 9F 09B:5=6-7<9= .? 745 =6@A-=05 9B:-=? -6 5G9A.<7-=7 -=1.?7450;-<B-=76-6<=-15C@-75 45 1-75 9F -00<15=7 <=E9;E5B5=7 9F 745 E54<0;5 <=D@A? 6@FF5A51 .? 745 0;-<B-=76"-::5;;-=76 -=1 ;<-.<;<7? 79 :-? 09B:5=6-7<9= -A5 =97 <= 1<6:@75, 745 9=;? 1<6:@75<68<74A5>-A179C@-=7@B9F09B:5=6-7<9=6:5A 745=6@A-=05 9B:-=?74509B:5=6-7<9=-8-A151.?745 A<.@=-; <6 5G9A.<7-=7 -=1 A5C@<A56 A51@07<9= -=1 -6 :5A 745-::5;;-=7"0;-<B-=774509B:5=6-7<9=-8-A151.?745 A<.@=-; <6 <=-15C@-75 09B:-A51 79 745 <=D@A? 6@FF5A51 84<044-6 A56@;751 <= H 1<6-.<;<7? -=1 <= 745 75574 9F 5E<15=05 .? 745 19079A -6 745 6-B5 4-6 .55= 67-751 -6 1<6-.<;<7?-7((H ' 5-A1 A< -E5=1A- 511? ;5-A=51 09@=65; -::5-A<=> F9A 745 -::5;;-=7 <= 9$" -=1 A< ->-A-D -7<; ;5-A=51 09@=65; -::5-A<=> F9A 745 -::5;;-=7<=9++" - 5 - # A< -=E5=1A- 511? ;5-A=51 09@=65; -::5-A<=> F9A 745 -::5;;-=7 8<74 -;; 745 E545B5=05 6@.B<7751 74-7 745 A<.@=-; 9@>47 79 4-E5 7-I5= 745 1<6-.<;<7? -7 ''H.5<=> "'A1 9F (H <=675-19F+H -6 4-6.55=7-I5=.?745A<.@=-;-=1<=675-19F7-I<=>745 <=09B5 -7 745 A-75 9F 6#+"-6 F<G51 .? 745 5>-; 5AE<056@749A<7?F9A745?5-A6-B54-6.55=7-I5= -6 6(" :5A B9=74 9 -;69 745 <=09B5 -8-A151 @=15A-;;74545-165G05:7B51<0-;5G:5=656A5C@<A56A5 1575AB<=-7<9=-=169@>4779-;;98745-::5-;-=1A51@05 74509B:5=6-7<9= 5F@7<=>7456@.B<66<9=69F745;5-A=5109@=65; F9A 745 -::5;;-=7 <= 9$" 745 ;5-A=51 09@=65; -::5-A<=> F9A 745 0;-<B-=7"-::5;;-=7/6 <= 9++"8<74-;;E545B5=056@.B<775174-7<=745 :A565=05 9F 5E<15=05 .? 745 19079A 67-7<=> 74-7 ((H 1<6-.<;<7? 6@FF5A51 .? 745 -::5;;-=7 -;69 45 8-6 <B:-7<5=7 F9A09=6<15A-.;5:5A<919F7<B545A<.@=-;9@>47794-E5 7-I5=1<6-.<;<7?-7H<=675-19F+H45<=D@A518-6 - 6 - ->51 ## ?5-A6 -7 745 7<B5 9F -00<15=7 -=1 :A91@051 745 <=09B505A7<F<0-759F4<689AI58-689AI<=>-6-67-FF =@A65<=%-?-15E-96:<7-;-;-.@A-><-=1-;695G-B<=51 745 19079A &' 55A564 -7<; -A1<9;9><67 %-?-15E- 96:<7-; -;-.@A->< 849 09=F<AB51 74-7 745 -::5;;-=7"0;-<B-=7 8-6 89AI<=> -6 - B-;5 67-FF =@A65 <= %-?-15E- 96:<7-; -;-.@A->< 6<=05 + 79 $' -=1 >577<=> - 6@B 9F 6'" :5A B9=74 -6 - 6-;-A? 45 A<.@=-; 4-6 F-<;51 79 09=6<15A 745 09=1<7<9= 9F 745 -::5;;-=7 -6 45 8-6 09=F<=51 79 .51 <= E<589F1<6-.<;<7?6@FF5A511@579<=D@A<564519079A& 4-6 67-751 .5F9A5 745 9@A7 A5>-A1<=> 745 :-7457<0 09=1<7<9=@=15A84<04745-::5;;-=7"0;-<B-=7<6@=15A>9<=> -=1745849;5.91?1<6-.<;<7?<6-7((H45-::5;;-=74-6 6@FF5A51 65E5A5 45-1 <=D@A? 1@5 79 84<04 745A5 <6 =9 B9E5B5=7 <= 4-=16-6 85;; -6;5>6 58-69= 7@.5F9A F551<=> 7A-0459679B? 7@.5 F9A .A5-74<=> -=1 15:5=1<=> 9=9745A6F9A-;;745-07<E<7<56A5C@<A51F9A4<6;<E<=>45 <=D@A51 8-6 -= <B:-7<5=7 9F # 1-?6 = 745 75574 9F - 7 - 74565 5E<15=056 745 A<.@=-; 4-6 7-I5= 745 <=09B5 :A9:5A;? 4985E5A =97 -1151 @7@A5 A96:507@6 <= 75AB6 9F 745 ;-8 ;-<1 198= .? 745 9=/.;5 :5G 9@A7 <= 9-;6974509B:5=6-7<9=-8-A151@=15A-;;745 45-165G05:7B51<0-;5G:5=656-A59=745;985A6<15-=1 745 6-B5 A5C@<A56 A51575AB<=-7<9= -=1 A509=6<15A-7<9= -=1 -009A1<=>;? 69@>47 79 -;;98 745 -::5-; F<;51 .? 745 0;-<B-=7"-::5;;-=7 -=1 1<6B<66 745 -::5-; F<;51 .? 745 =6@A-=05 9B:-=? 0-;;<=> <= C@567<9= 745 C@-=7@B 9F 09B:5=6-7<9= $ -E<=>45-A1745;5-A=5109@=65;-::5-A<=>F9A 745 :-A7<56 :5A@651 .974 745 -::5-; :-:5A6, 745 9=;? C@567<9=74-7-A<65F9A9@A09=6<15A-7<9=<6 &45745A74509B:5=6-7<9=-8-A151 .? 745 A<.@=-; .5F<7 8<74<= 745 5G:A566<9=D@6709B:5=6-7<9=<F745 -=685A <6 9745A8<65 845745A 745 6-B5 A5C@<A56 -=? <=75AF5A5=05 -7 7454-=169F74<609@A7J 1 +!$ $ - 8 - + @A-=685A79745-.9E5:9<=79F09=6<15A-7<9= <6K:-A7;?<=-FF<AB-7<E5/F9A745F9;;98<=>2 -./0/ 7 <6 =97 <= 1<6:@75 74-7 745 0;-<B-=7"-::5;;-=7 4-6 6@FF5A51 745 45-1 <=D@A? 84<04 4-6 A56@;751 <= 1<6-.<;<7? 009A1<=> 79 19079A & 745 1<6-.<;<7? <6 -7 ((H 79 745 849;5 .91? 5 4-6 67-751 A5>-A1<=> 745 09=1<7<9=-=1:A565=767-7@69F745-::5;;-=7"0;-<B-=774-7 45<609=F<=5179.51-=1;<E<=>-E5>57-7<E5;<F5-=1745A5 <6=9B9E5B5=76<=4-=16-685;;-6;5>65<69:5=<=> 4<6 5?56 6:9=7-=59@6;? 45 8-6 9= 7@.5 F9A F551<=> 7A-0459679B?7@.5F9A.A5-74<=>-=115:5=1<=>9=9745A6 F9A-;;745-07<E<7<56A5C@<A51F9A4<6;<E<=>-=145A5C@<A5- 09=67-=7 -775=1-=7 45 -::5;;-=7 =6@A-=05 9B:-=? 4-6 =97 :;-051 -=? 09@=75A 5E<15=05 79 1<60A51<7 745 5E<15=05 9F 745 19079A 9 -;69 745 09=1<7<9= 9F 745 -::5;;-=7"0;-<B-=7<7<69=A509A174-77450;-<B-=7<=D@A51 F<;51745:57<7<9=74A9@>44<6=5G7FA<5=1-645<6=97<=- :96<7<9= 79 B9E5 -=1 09=F<=51 79 .51 45 6-;-A? - 9 - 05A7<F<0-75:A91@051.5F9A5745A<.@=-;0;5-A;?6498674-7 458-6>577<=>-6-;-A?9F6'"-667<:5=1<-A?-=1 -F75A151@07<=>6798-A16<=09B57-G458-6>577<=> 6(":5AB9=74 (459=3.;5:5G 9@A7<= !"#$%&'$() #* $% ' ))+&'$,# -.'$/ - !#% '$% '$ !"#& 4-609=6<15A517450-65845A5<=7451<6-.<;<7?6@FF5A51.? 745 -::5;;-=7 8-6 -7 $(H -E<=> 09=6<15A51 745 -E90-7<9= 9F 745 -::5;;-=7 745A5<= 45;1 74-7 749@>4 745 1<6-.<;<7? 6@FF5A51 -7 $(H 6-B5 -B9@=76 79 ;966 9F 5-A=<=>0-:-0<7?-7 H -=1 4-E<=> 09=6<15A51 745F-07 74-7 745 -::5;;-=7 745A5<= 8-6 15:5=15=7 F9A 5-04 -07<E<7<56 9F 4<6 ;<F5 9= 745 9745A6 -=1 4-E<=> 09=6<15A51 7456-B5-8-A15109B:5=6-7<9=798-A16-775=1-=7794<6 A567 9F ;<F5 7-I<=> 745 A5B@=5A-7<9= 9F 6" :5A B9=74 <5 6$" :5A ?5-A -=1 09=6<15A<=> 745 B@;7<:;<5A09AA56:9=1<=>79745->59F745<=D@A51-8-A151 797-;09B:5=6-7<9=9F6" 9-;697459=3.;5 2 (2022) 15 SCC 620 - 10 - :5G 9@A7 -7 -A->A-:4 9( 9F 745 6-<1 0-65 4-6 09=6<15A51 79 -8-A1 - 6@B 9F 6'" 798-A16 @7@A5 51<0-; G:5=656 09=6<15A<=> 745 ->5 9F 745 -::5;;-=7 745A5<= -=1 -1151 F@7@A5 :A96:507@6 79 745 <=09B5-69=7451-759F-00<15=7=E<589F745;-8;-<1 198= .? 745 9=/.;5 :5G 9@A7 745 09B:5=6-7<9= -8-A151.?745A<.@=-;A5C@<A56A51575AB<=-7<9=-=1A5 09=6<15A-7<9= 774<667->5745;5-A=5109@=65;-::5-A<=>F9A 745-::5;;-=7=6@A-=05 9B:-=?4-66@.B<775174-7<= E<589F7-I<=>H1<6-.<;<7?745-::5;;-=7<6=975=7<7;51 F9A;9669F<=09B51@A<=>;-<1@::5A<91-685;;-6;9669F -B5=<7<56 9 F-A -6 6@.B<66<9= A5>-A1<=> =9= 5=7<7;5B5=79F09B:5=6-7<9=F9A745;9669F<=09B51@A<=> ;-<1 @: :5A<91 85 F<=1 F9A05 <= 745 09=75=7<9= 9F 745 ;5-A=51 09@=65; F9A 745 -::5;;-=7 L =6@A-=05 9B:-=? 009A1<=>;? 85 4-E5 =97 -8-A151 -=? 5=4-=051 09B:5=6-7<9= @=15A 745 6-<1 45-1 749@>4 745 A<.@=-; - 11 - 4-6 -8-A151 6" @=15A 745 6-<1 45-1 -=1 85 4-E5=9709=6<15A517456-B584<;5A51575AB<=-7<9= 985E5A 798-A16 ;966 9F -B5=<7<56 <6 09=05A=51 745 -::5;;-=7 <6 ->51 ## ?5-A6 745 -B5=<7<56 -A5 -8-A151 F9A 745 1<609BF9A7 9F ;<F5 45 -::5;;-=7 <6 09=F<=51 79 .51 F9A 745 A567 9F 4<6 ;<F5 -=1 4-6 79 ;<E5 - E5>57-7<E5 ;<F5 &<74 -;; 1<FF<0@;7<56 <= F@7@A509=F<=<=> 79 .51B-?A56@;7<=.5169A56-=19745A<=F507<9=654-679 ;<E58<74-;;749651<609BF9A76-=1;9674<609BF9A7-.;5;<F5 =745650<A0@B67-=05645<65=7<7;51F9A;9669F-B5=<7<56 009A1<=>;? 85 -8-A1 6 @=15A 745 6-<1 45-1 A5D507<=> 745 09=75=7<9= 9F ;5-A=51 09@=65; -::5-A<=> F9A 745-::5;;-=7=6@A-=05 9B:-=? 9=6<15A<=> 745 -6:507 9F :-<= -=1 6@FF5A<=> <=D@A518-6<=:-7<5=7F9A#1-?6-=1=98F9AA5679F4<6 ;<F5.51A<115=1@57974565E5A5<=D@A<566@FF5A5145=05 <7<6-::A9:A<-7579-8-A16"798-A16K:-<=-=1 6@FF5A<=>/ - 12 - ' 98 09B<=> 79 745 -6:507 9F @7@A5 775=1-=7 4-A>56 <7 <6 -::A9:A<-75 79 -8-A1 6#" F9A -= -775=1-=709=6<15A<=>745567<B-75:-?9F6":5A B9=74-=1-::;?<=>-::A9:A<-75B@;7<:;<5A-7K#/ # 9=6<15A<=>7451<6-.<;<7?9F745<=D@A51-7H -=1 -11<=> H 798-A16 F@7@A5 :A96:507@6 -=1 -::;?<=> -::A9:A<-75 B@;7<:;<5A -7 K#/ 745 K 966 9F @7@A5 -A=<=> -:-0<7?/ 89@;1 09B56 79 6$" -6 ->-<=67 6'#"-8-A151.?745A<.@=-; 4@6 <= -;; 745 -::5;;-=7"0;-<B-=7 <= 9++" <6 5=7<7;51 F9A - A5-6656651 09B:5=6-7<9=-6F9;;9862 9669FF@7@A5<=09B5 (MHGG#! $" @7@A5B51<0-;5G:5=1<7@A5 7-I<=> <=79 09=6<15A-7<9= 745->59F745-::5;;-=7-6 ##?5-A6! " ' @7@A5775=1-=704-A>56 GG#! #" - 13 - # -<=-=16@FF5A<=>6 " 775=1-=704-A>56F991 -=109=E5?-=0504-A>56 -I<=><=7909=6<15A-7<9= 9F745F-0774-7458-6-= <=:-7<5=7F9A797-;;?# 1-?69=E-A<9@6900-6<9=6! " $ 9669F-B5=<7<56 " + 51<0-;G:5=1<7@A5 '" * 009A1<=>;? 745 -::5;;-=7 <6 5=7<7;51 79 - 6@B 9F /* -6 ->-<=67 6#" -8-A151 .? 745A<.@=-; $ 9A 745 F9;;98<=> A5-69=6 85 :A90551 79 :-66 745F9;;98<=>2 ORDER <! 45-::5-;F<;51.?745=6@A-=05 9B:-=? <6% )- ))#% <<! 45 -::5-; F<;51 .? 745 -::5;;-=7"0;-<B-=7 <645A5.?'00 *#% $.'&! - 14 - <<<! 45D@1>B5=7-=1-8-A11-751' <= 9$+"# :-6651 .? 745 A<=0<:-; 5=<9A <E<; %@1>5 -=1 -;-.@A-><<645A5.?B91<F<51 <E! 45 -::5;;-=7 <6 5=7<7;5 F9A - 6@B 9F 6((" 84<04 64-;; 0-AA? <=75A567 -7 745 A-75 9F $H :5A -==@B FA9B 745 :57<7<9=7<;;A5-;<N-7<9= E! 45 -B9@=7 <= 15:96<7 .? 745 -::5;;-=7 =6@A-=05 9B:-=? <= 9$" 64-;; .5 7A-=6B<7751 79 74509=05A=51A<.@=-;F9A1<6.@A65B5=7 E<! 45 -::5;;-=7 L =6@A-=05 9B:-=? 64-;; 15:96<7 .-;-=05 -B9@=7 A51575AB<=51 09B:5=6-7<9= -;9=> 8<74 -00A@51 <=75A567 67-751.5F9A574509=05A=51A<.@=-; 8<74<=-:5A<919F6<G855I6FA9B7451-75 9FA505<:79F09:?9F74<69A15A E<<! :9= 15:96<7 9F 745 -B9@=7 -6 67-751 745A<.@=-;<645A5.?<61<A5075179 <=E567 H 9F 745 -B9@=7 <= -= <=75A567 .5-A<=> <G51 5:96<7 9F -=? -7<9=-;<N51 - 15 - -=I F9A - :5A<91 9F 74A55 ?5-A6 8<74 - A5=58-;0;-@659F-=9745A78975AB6 E<<<! 45.-=I64-;;=97:5AB<7-=?;9-=9=745 6-<1 -B9@=7 <= 15:96<7 8<749@7 -= 9A15A FA9B74509=05A=51A<.@=-;" 9@A7 <G! 9A-=?F@7@A55G<>5=0<56<F745-B9@=7<= 15:96<7 A5C@<A51 79 .5 8<741A-8= 745 A<.@=-;64-;;09=6<15A7456-<15G<>5=0?9= 745.-6<69FB-75A<-;:A91@051-774-77<B5 -=1:-66 -::A9:A<-75 9A15A6 -6 :5A 745 <76 8<619B-::;?<=><76D@1<0<9@6B<=1 G! 45 -;-=05 9F H -B9@=7 8<74 -00A@51 <=75A567 64-;; .5 A5;5-651 <= F-E9@A 9F -::5;;-=7@:9=:A9:5A<15=7<F<0-7<9= G<! 99A15A-6790967 !1* '$!!) & !1* ') & " <6792 ;92#" 2%