- 1 - ! "# $"%"" && '&(&) * !"# $ %& ' " !"# !"# Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "( !"# $ ) ** ) *+ ) ), **+* # * ) ) , ) **+*+ ) ) )) -) ) ) - & % " ./ 0/1/2032456320 7/8294./:;<=.35/<561 4/>6614./5;84:<6:/<4?82?6 ">/35;<829 *+ 3=</5 9;2435 3</ 7/16</ 4.85 6;<4 399<8/@/0 7? A;09>/24 320 0/=<// 034/0 **+*+ :355/0 82 6# *624./18B/61/286< 8@8B;09/320) - 3 - 829359;<; C.8=. 85 =6218<>/0 7? 4./ A;09>/24 320 0/=<//034/0**+*:355/0826 *+624./ 18B/6100848623B854<8=4320/558625;09/38=.;< 84482934820.32;< * ./376@/5;8416<:3<4848625/:3<34/:655/55862 8518B/07?:B38248115C.63</4./=.8B0</2610/1/203246 =624/208294.344./5;845=./0;B/:<6:/<48/5=62585482961 4.<//B320/0:<6:/<48/532062/.6;5/:<6:/<4?7/829A6824 13>8B? 32=/54<3B :<6:/<48/5 3=D;8</0 7? 4./ 0/1/20324 6 4.<6;9. .85 32=/546<5 ./ :B38248115 320 4./ 0/1/2032457/8294./A682413>8B?>/>7/<53<//2484B/016< /D;3B 5.3</ <89.4 484B/ 320 824/</54 82 4./ :<6:/<4? ./ 0/1/2032467/8293008=4/046730@8=/5.302/9B/=4/0 4./ :B38248115 320 4./8< >64./< C.6 3</ 16<=/0 46 43E/ 5./B4/< 82 4./8< >34/<23B 9<320:3</245F .6;5/ ./ 0/1/20324 6 C84.6;4 4./</ 7/829 32? B/93B 6< 13>8B? 2/=/5584?56B04./5;84:<6:/<48/5./0/1/203245646 7/829 4./ 30A682829 B3206C2/<5 61 4./ 5;84 :<6:/<48/5 43E82930@32439/614./584;348628BB/93BB?674382/04.<// - 4 - </9854/</00//056153B/82</5:/=4614/>6614./5;84 :<6:/<48/5 ./ 0/1/20324 6 C84.6;4 .3@829 32? /G=B;58@/<89.46@/<4./5;84:<6:/<4?3B8/234/084/>6 460/:<8@/4./B/9848>34/<89.45614./:B38248115/2=/4./ 5;8416<=32=/BB3486261*0//056153B/034/0**#* /G/=;4/0 7? 4./ 0/1/20324 6 82 13@6;< 61 0/1/20324 646682</5:/=46184/>6614./5;84:<6:/<4? * ./ 0/1/203245 6 46 18B/0 4./ C<844/2 5434/>/240/2?8294./:B38243@/<>/24532030>844/04./ </B348625.8:7/4C//24./:B382481153200/1/2032464 85 =624/24/0 4.34 0/1/20324 6 56B0 4/> 6 61 4./ 5;84:<6:/<48/5824./8<13@6;<824/<>561*0//056153B/ 034/0 **#* 16< 3 @3B;37B/ 53B/ =62580/<34862 ./ 0/1/20324 6 56B0 4./ 53>/ 46 >//4 .85 13>8B? B/93B 2//05 ./ 0/1/203245 6 46 3</ 4./ 7623!180/ :;<=.35/<5./0/1/203246857/8294./&3<43614./ A682413>8B?:<6:/<4?C35C/BBC84.82.85B/93B3;4.6<84?46 5/BB4./:<6:/<4?/2=/56;9.416<085>8553B615;84 - 5 - * ./<83B 6;<41<3>/04./16BB6C829855;/5320 300848623B16<845=62580/<34862! ! ! " #!" ! $ ! % $ & ' " ! " ! " "% $ ! (") ! ! * ! !% $ "% + % , -!" % .% //0112((34(// $ 5 " " ! !% - 6 - *" ./ >64./< 614./ :B38248115 /G3>82/035 320 /G.8784/0 58G 06=;>/245 35 G 46 G( ./ 0/1/203245 6 320 /G3>82/0 4./>5/B@/5 35 46320/G.8784/006=;>/24535G46./ <83B 6;<4 62 3::</=834862 61 /@80/2=/ 320 >34/<83B 62 </=6<05 325C/</0 855;/5 6 46 ( 82 4./ 3118<>348@/ 320 855;/5 6 320 300848623B 855;/ 6 82 4./ 2/9348@/320=625/D;/24B?0/=<//04./5;8435:<3?/016< *( /829 399<8/@/0 4./ 53>/ 4./ 0/1/203245 6320"18B/0/9;B3<::/3B826 *+./ )8<54::/BB34/ 6;<4.351<3>/04./16BB6C829:6824516<845 =62580/<34862! 6 7! 5 " " 8 " 5 ! ! !% $! ! 25% % - 7 - * ./ )8<54 ::/BB34/ 6;<4 62 </!3::</=834862 61 /@80/2=/320>34/<83B62</=6<0325C/</04./:682456 320824./2/9348@/320=625/D;/24B?:3<4B?3BB6C/04./ 3::/3B>6081?8294./A;09>/243200/=<//:355/07?4./ <83B 6;<4464.//G4/244.344./0//06153B//G/=;4/07? 0/1/20324 6 82 13@6;< 61 0/1/203245 6 320 62 ** 82 </5:/=4 61 4/> 6 61 4./ 5;84 :<6:/<4? 5.6C2 82 =./0;B/! 35 7820829 46 4./ /G4/24 61 <0 5.3</610/1/2032463204./538053B/0//05C/</264 7820829 46 4./ /G4/24 61 <0 5.3</ 61 4./ :B38248115 320 =6218<>4./</54614./A;09>/243200/=<//:355/07?4./ <83B 6;<4/829399<8/@/04./:</5/243::/3B *# /3<2/0 =6;25/B 16< 4./ 3::/BB324 <8 <;2E;>3<>3<39;203::3</84/<348294./9<6;205824./ >/>6<320;> 61 3::/3B 5;7>844/0 4.34 /G=/:4 3BB/9829 4.34 0/1/20324 6 7/829 3008=4/0 46 730 @8=/5 26 /@80/2=/ 85 B/0 / 5;7>845 4.34 4./ :B38248115 3B629 C84. 4./8<>64./<.300/5/<4/04./0/1/20324646>//4.85 - 8 - 2/=/55848/5 ./ .30 26 6:4862 7;4 46 3B8/234/ 4./ 5;84 :<6:/<4? ./</16</ 4./ 3B8/234862 85 16< 4./ 13>8B? 2/=/55848/5 ./ 7;<0/2 61 :<6@829 4./ 13>8B? 2/=/5584? C35624./:B38248115./0/1/2032467/8294./&3<43 614./A682413>8B?.30/@/<?<89.4465/BB4./:<6:/<4?/ 1;<4./<5;7>8454.344./5/35:/=45614./>344/<.3@/264 7//2=62580/</07?4./<83B 6;<43204./)8<54::/BB34/ 6;<498@829<85/465;75432483BD;/5486261B3C *+ /3<0/<;5/04./</=6<05 * ./ 13=45 23<<34/ 376@/ 06 264 </D;8</ </84/<34862 0>844/0B? 3BB 4./ 5;84 :<6:/<48/5 82=B;0829 84/> 6 61 4./ 5;84 :<6:/<48/5 3</ 4./ A6824 13>8B? 32=/54<3B :<6:/<4? ./ 0/1/20324 6 ! 134./< 61 :B38248115.3556B04/>6614./5=./0;B/:<6:/<48/582 13@6;<610/1/2032456320824/<>5610//0561 53B/034/0**#*/B/@32446</1/</=4862614./ <3251/<61<6:/<4?=4C.8=.</30535;20/<! - 9 - 9( $$/6 " 5 : 5 5 " " ! " " -! ! " ; ' '" " ! !' 5 ! ! " " ' '" ! 4 85 </B/@324 3B56 46 </1/< 3<3 6 61 ;BB3-5820;B3C54/084862C.8=.</30535;20/<! 5 ' ) ! " ' " " ! ! -! " ! ! 5 " -!"# ! " < "< " #!" ! ! " 5! ! " ! 6" " - 10 - " " 5 )5 " ! ! " 55 ! " " ! < ! ! " 5 5 5 ! 5! ! ! 5 " 2= 5 5! " " 5 " ! "> .;5 4./:;<=.35/<5 613 A6824:<6:/<4?C6;B0 7//2484B/0=B38>5.3</562B?464.//G4/24614./5.3</61 4./ @/206< C.6 C35 3 >/>7/< 61 4./ A6824 13>8B? ./ 7;<0/261:<6@8294./13>8B?2/=/5584?85624./:;<=.35/< ./</16</ 26 5;75432483B D;/54862 61 B3C C6;B0 3<85/ 16< =62580/<34862 4 4.85 A;2=4;</ B/3<2/0 =6;25/B 16< 4./ 3::/BB32455;7>8454.34582=/4./13>8B?.3564./<B320/0 :<6:/<48/5 34 4./ 48>/ 61 08@85862 320 3BB64>/24 61 4./ 5.3</54./</5:620/245!:B382481157/08</=4/0463BB644./ 5.3</ 61 4./ :B38248115 82 B320 ?6 46 3@680 32? 1<39>/2434862 - 11 - ./53805;7>8558628543E/262</=6<0 " .8B/ 0<3C829 ;: 61 4./ )823B /=<// 320 30A;54829 4./ /D;848/5 4./ B320 :;<=.35/0 7? 4./ 3::/BB3245464.//G4/24614./5.3</614./0/1/203246 >3? 7/ 3BB644/0 5;7A/=4 46 64./< </D;8</>/245 82 4/> 6614./5;845=./0;B/:<6:/<48/5 ( 84. 4./ 376@/ 675/<@34862 4./ 3::/3B 85 +( '"") % & 8546B6 &