Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43692 (KAR)
BHAGYASHREE v. SAGAR NAVTAKE
MFA/201327/2021 · 2025-10-28
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43692 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43692 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $% #
$% "%&"
##
'( )
!"#
$ % &
"#
!#"
$ % ' &
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( (
!)%!& ( (
(
!#)#! (
!#!) ( (
(
!##
( * (
+
(
,
,
&% %,
&
-./011203./4-252/634784-296:;<2=40=::2>522 :042: !#)#! 10//2: .= 7!#!) ?@ 4-2 3205=2: 5.=>.103 6:;2 (0<.3@ 7654 030?650;. %-252.=084255282552:470/*4-2(0<.3@7654+&A-252.=4-2 124.4.7=8.32:?@4-252/17=:2=46=:252>4.7=!"%!&%.0&' %.?&784-2.=:6055.0;2>4%875/-754*4-2>4+&A0/ 0337A2: ?@ :.//73B.=; -./ <055.0;2 A.4- 0112330=4
- 3 -
125875<2: 7= !# #!C 2.=; 0;;5.2B2: ?@ 4-2 /0<2 4-20112330=4A.82-0/>7<261A.4-4-2152/2=4011203
205:4-205;6<2=4784-23205=2:>76=/23875 4-20112330=4=/1.42780112050=>24-576;-4-2>76=/23 4-2 52/17=:2=4 -0/ =74 465=2: 61 256/2: 4-2 7503 0=:
:7>6<2=405@ 2B.:2=>2 8754->7<.=; 7= 4-2 5.03 7654 52>75:/0=:03/75232B0=4<0425.03/7=52>75:
" -2 80>4/ 78 4-2 >0/2 052 4-04 4-2 <055.0;2 78 4-2 0112330=4 0=: 52/17=:2=4 A0/ /732<=.D2: 7= !# #!C 0/ 125 4-2 >6/47</ 152B0.3.=; 0<7=; .=:6/ 04 650;7: E 0<F-0=:. ./4 0;03F74 8425 4-2 <055.0;24-252/17=:2=4477F4-20112330=447-./-76/2 04 0465 A-252.= -2 037=; A.4- <2<?25/ 78 4-2 80<.3@ 477F >052 78 4-2 0112330=4 0=: 452042: -25 0/ 4-2.5 7A= :06;-425 A.4- 37B2 0=: 0882>4.7= 84257=2<7=4-78 4-2 <055.0;2 4-2 ?2-0B.765 78 4-2 0112330=4 A0/ =74 =75<03 0=: /-2 :.: =74 64425 0 /.=;32 A75: 47 -./ 1052=4/ 7=3@ ?2>06/24-252/17=:2=4A0/>7<10504.B23@5.>-0=:-2./ 4-27=3@/7=.=4-280<.3@-20112330=4-0:0=.=42=4.7=
- 4 -
473.B2030B./-3.82/4@320=:/-2:.:=74A0=4.=4258252=>2 78 0=@7=2 .= -25 125/7=03 0=: <055.2: 3.82 (.=033@ /-2 :2<0=:2: /2105042 -76/2 857< 4-2 1052=4/ 78 4-2 52/17=:2=4 2=>2 4-2 52/17=:2=4 <7B2: 47 /2105042 -76/2 04 030?650;. 4.33 4-2 :042 78 /210504.7= = 4-2 :2<0=:780112330=44-28.5/40==.B25/05@78<055.0;2A0/ >232?5042: .= 230;0B. -2 0112330=4 A0/ 0>4.=; 3.F2 >7<<.44.=;/6.>.:2.=4-2<7=4-7863@#!-25208425 .= 4-2 <7=4- 78 >47?25 #! /-2 A2=4 47 -25 1052=403 -76/2 875 8.5/4 :23.B25@ ?0?@ ?7@ A0/ ?75= 47 4-2 0112330=4 .= -25 A2:37>F A.4- 4-2 52/17=:2=4 ?64 4-2 0112330=4 :.: =74 52465= 47 4-2 <045.<7=.03 -76/2 -2 /6?92>42: 4-2 52/17=:2=4 47 <2=403 0=: 1-@/.>03 -050//<2=4 0/ >7=42=:2: .= 4-2 124.4.7= -2528752 4-2 52/17=:2=4A0/>7=/450.=2:478.324-2124.4.7=875:.B75>2 G =/1.4278/25B.>278=74.>24-20112330=4?2.=; 4-2 52/17=:2=4 :.: =74 011205 ?28752 4-2 (0<.3@ 7654 7A2B25 /6?/2E62=43@ A-2= 4-2 >0/2 A0/ 17/42: 875 8654-252B.:2=>2784-252/17=:2=4124.4.7=250/!4-2
- 5 -
0112330=4A.820112052:4-576;-4-2>76=/230=:8.32:-25 7?92>4.7=/ ?@ :2=@.=; 4-2 124.4.7= 0B25<2=4/ 0=: /-2 0332;2: <2=403 0=: 1-@/.>03 -050//<2=4 47 -25 ?@ 4-2 52/17=:2=4 0=: -./ 1052=4/ 47 -25 -2 /76;-4 875 >7<12=/0475@ >7/4 78 /###### 0=: 4-2 .=425.< <0.=42=0=>2 78 /##### 125 <7=4- 875 -25/238 0=:
875 -25 =2A3@ ?75= ?0?@ 0=: 4-252?@ 4-2 0112330=4A.82 150@2:875:./<.//03784-2124.4.7=
= 75:25 47 157B2 4-2 >0/2 4-2 52/17=:2=4124.4.7=25 ;74 2H0<.=2: -.</238 0/ !
0=: ;74<05F2:4-522:7>6<2=4/04H/!47"=4-274-25 -0=:.=/1.42788.3.=;7?92>4.7=4-20112330=4A.82-0/=74 >-7/2=470::6>20=@2B.:2=>27=-25?2-0388425>37/.=; 784-22B.:2=>278?74-4-21054.2/4-23205=2:>76=/23875 ?74-4-21054.2/:.:=74>-77/2471648754-4-2.505;6<2=4 0=:-2=>27=4-2?0/./784-22B.:2=>20=:4-2<0425.03 8754->7<.=; 7= 52>75: 4-2 (0<.3@ 7654 >0<2 47 4-2 >7=>36/.7= 4-04 4-2 0112330=4A.82 -050//2: 4-2 52/17=:2=4-6/?0=:1-@/.>033@0=:<2=4033@0=::2/2542:
- 6 -
4-2 52/17=:2=4-6/?0=: 875 0 >7=4.=676/ 125.7: 78 <752 4-0= @205/ A.4-764 520/7=0?32 >06/2 >>75:.=;3@ 4-2 (0<.3@ 7654 :2>522: 4-2 124.4.7= 6=:25 4-2 .<16;=2: 96:;<2=40=::2>522
7A4-217.=4875765>7=/.:2504.7=./I
C -2 3205=2: >76=/23 875 4-2 0112330=4A.82 -0/ /6?<.442:4-04 857<4-2 124.4.7= 0B25<2=4 .4/238 4-252./ =7>7=4.=676/125.7:78@205/780332;2::2/254.7=?@4-2 52/17=:2=4-6/?0=: (654-25 4-252 ./ =7 1-@/.>03 0=: <2=403-050//<2=4<242:764?@4-252/17=:2=4-6/?0=:
875 ;50=4.=;:.B75>2 0=: 4-2(0<.3@ 7654 -0/ >7<<.442: 0=25575.=0337A.=;4-2124.4.7=2=>2-2-0/150@2:47 0337A4-2011203
- 7 -
=1256/03784-245.03765452>75:/.4A763: ?2>32054-04084250112050=>2784-20112330=4/-2?2.=; 4-2 52/17=:2=4 ?28752 4-2 (0<.3@ 7654 0=: 8.3.=; 78 7?92>4.7=/ 4-2 (0<.3@ 7654 .=/420: 78 17/4.=; 4-2 >0/2 875 >7=>.3.04.7= 78 4-2 1054.2/ 75 528255.=; 4-2 <04425 47 <2:.04.7= 875 >7=>.3.04.7= 157>22:2: 47 52>75: 8654-25 2B.:2=>278!2=>2=77117546=.4@A0/;.B2=474-2 1054.2/87552>7=>.3.04.7=75/24432<2=4784-2<04425B2= .= 4-2 011203 7= -0=: 4-76;- 4-2 <04425 ./ 5282552: 47 <2:.04.7=875/24432<2=4?74-4-21054.2/80.32:47011205 -2528752 7= 4-./ ;576=: 03/7 0= 7117546=.4@ A763: ?2 ;.B2= 47 4-2 1054.2/ 875 52>7=>.3.04.7= .8 0=@ 78 4-2.5 <055.0;2 75 47 2H13752 4-2 17//.?.3.4@ 78 /24432<2=4 ?24A22=4-2< ) (654-25<752 0/ /6?<.442: ?@ 4-2 3205=2: >76=/23 875 4-2 0112330=4 4-2 75:25 /-224 78 4-2 (0<.3@ 7654 A763: >32053@ 52B203 4-04 4-2 (0<.3@ 7654 477F 61 4-2 <04425 -655.2:3@ A.4-764 ;.B.=; /688.>.2=4 7117546=.4@ 474-20112330=4A.82/-2?2.=;4-252/17=:2=4470::6>2
- 8 -
-252B.:2=>20=:4-252?@17/42:4-2<0442587505;6<2=4/ 857< #C#)#! 47 !"#)#! = !"#)#! 2B2= 4-76;- ?74- 4-2 1054.2/ 0=: 4-2.5 >76=/23 A252 0?/2=4 A.4-764 ;50=4.=; 4.<2 875 05;6<2=4/ 4-2 05;6<2=4 78 ?74- 4-2 1054.2/ A0/ 40F2= 0/ =74 0::52//2: 0=: 17/42: 4-2 <04425 875 96:;<2=4 47 !#)#! 0=: 10//2: 4-2 .<16;=2:96:;<2=47=4-2/0<2:0@.27=!#)#! -./A763:03/752B2034-044-2(0<.3@7654-0/80.32:47 ;50=4/688.>.2=47117546=.4@474-20112330=4A.82470::6>2 -25 2B.:2=>2 2B2= 4-76;- /-2 >7=42/42: 4-2 <04425 ?@ 8.3.=; 7?92>4.7=/ 2=>2 A2 052 78 4-2 >7=/.:252: B.2A 4-04 4-2 .<16;=2: 96:;<2=4 0=: :2>522 78 4-2 (0<.3@ 7654 ./ 3.0?32 47 ?2 /24 0/.:2 0=: 4-2 <04425 /-033 ?2 52<.442:?0>F474-245.037654875>7=/.:25.=;0852/-?@ ;.B.=; 520/7=0?32 7117546=.4.2/ 47 ?74- 4-2 1054.2/ 47 0::6>24-2.52B.:2=>2.84-2@/7.=42=:2=>24-2011203 :2/25B2/47?20337A2:0=:52<0=:2: !# >>75:.=;3@ 0=/A25.=; 4-2 0?7B2 17.=4 .= 4-2 088.5<04.B2A2157>22:4710//4-287337A.=;I
- 9 -
%0& -2011203./-252?@0337A2:0=:52<0=:2:
%?& 7=/2E62=43@ 4-2 96:;<2=4 0=: :2>522 :042: !#)#!
.= 7!#!) 78 4-2 3205=2: 5.=>.103 6:;2 (0<.3@ 7654 030?650;../-252?@/240/.:2 %>& -2<04425./52<0=:2:474-245.037654875 >7=/.:25.=; 4-2 <04425 0852/- ;.B.=; /688.>.2=40=:520/7=0?327117546=.4@47?74- 4-2 1054.2/ 47 0::6>2 4-2.5 2B.:2=>2 0=:
157>22: A.4- 4-2 <04425 .= 0>>75:0=>2 A.4- 30A A.4-764 .=8362=>2: ?@ 0=@ 78 4-2 7?/25B04.7=/784-./7654 %:& 7=/.:25.=; 4-2 0;2 78 ?74-4-2 1054.2/0=:
4-04 4-2 124.4.7= ./ 875 :.B75>2 ?74- 4-2 1054.2/ /-033 0//./4 4-2 (0<.3@ 7654 47 :./17/2 78 4-2 <04425 0/ 2H12:.4.76/3@ 0/ 17//.?32 A.4-764 0/F.=; 875 0=@ 8654-25 0:9765=<2=4 *+ '# ( %
*+ '"%&"( %
./47!37 C