- 1 - ! " #$ % %!$$ &$' ! " # # " # # " $ " # # " $" %& '( ) " #) # " %& '( Digitally signed by THEJAS KUMAR N Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " #) # " * )$) $+ " )& ,! , - , # ./012314.0 3445 678193: ;7. <=3 >3</</713. 014 ./ 01?01?7840 /.040. 678193: ;7. .39>71431<9 <7 $ =0230>>30.34/1>3.971 =3 7.43. 40<34 >09934 @5 <=3 .: 31/7. /2/: '84?3 014 3A@3. /B050>8. /1 7-") 2/43 113C8.3 /9 60::34 /1<7 D839</71 /1 <=/9 ,./<3</</71719323.0:?.781490993<78</1<=33A7.0148A 7;,./<3</</71 $ =39=7.<;06<90.3<=393# - 3 - 13 0A0E9=/ 4/34 /1 0 704 .0;;/6 66/431< 71 () 71<314/1?<=0<<=350.3<=3 3?0:.3>.3931<0</239 7; <=3 43630934 <=3 6:0/A01<9 ;/:34 0 6:0/A >3</</71 /1 7-") 6:0/A/1? 67A>3190</71 =35 A043 <=3 7F13.7;<=3 0.014<=3198.0163 7A>01509.39>71431<9 ;<3.<=3/99801637;<=317</63<=3198.0163 7A>015;/:340 F./<<319<0<3A31<0149>36/;/60::5671<31434<=0<<=3 0.F09 ?7/1?F05<77;09<014=/<<=39<0</7134.0/:3.=35;/:3401 /A>:304/1?0>>:/60</71<7/A>:304713. 01<79= "77=/409 013671<314/1?<=0<=/910A3F099=7F10906689347/1 <=3 014 6=0.?3 9=33< =3 90A3 F09 7@B36<34 @5 <=3 6:0/A01<9=3./@810:4/9A/9934<=30>>:/60</71143.<=393 6/.68A9<01639 <=3 198.0163 7A>015 =09 ;/:34 <=3 ,./< 3</</71 ) 78193: ;7. <=3 .39>36</23 >0.</39 8.?34 9323.0: 671<31</719 78193: ./012314.0 3445 98@A/<9 <=0< <=3 6=0.?3 9=33<F09;/:340?0/19<<=3>.7>7934/A:304/1?0>>:/601<09F3:: 09 <=3 4./23. 7; <=3 /198.34 0. 3163 <=3 198.0163 7A>015 F09 B89</;/34 /1 A0E/1? 01 /A>:304/1? 0>>:/60</71 78193:>:0634.3:/016371<=3436/9/71/1 - 4 - /1 ./ 01?01?7840 /.040. 678193: ;7. <=3 6:0/A01<9 B89</;/34<=3.3B36</717;<=30>>:/60</71 3C< =3 98@A/<9 <=0< <=3 6:0/A01<9 0.3 <=3 /1A0<39 7; <=3 0. 014 <=35 0.3 <=/.4 >0.</39 3 98@A/<9 <=0< <=3 >.7>7934/A>:304/1?0>>:/601</917<01363990.5>0.<5 ;8.<=3. 98@A/99/71 /9 A043 <=0< <=3 198.0163 7A>015 =04 93<<:34 <=3 4/9>8<3 F/<= <=3 6:0/A01<9 =3 198.0163 7A>015 F09 0F0.3 7; <=3 ;06< <=0< 01 81/198.34 <.0/:3. F09 >0.E34 /1 <=3 A/44:3 7; <=3 .704 439>/<3 <=3 90/4 ;06<<=3198.0163 7A>015=0467A3;7.F0.401493<<:34<=3 A0<<3. F/<= <=3 6:0/A01<9 3163 <=3 198.0163 7A>015 60117</A>:304<=37F13.7;<=3.0/:3.0<<=/9B816<8.3 78193:23=3A31<:5671<31434<=0</</9<=36=7/637;<=3 6:0/A01<9 <7 /A>:304 014 A0E3 .39>71431< 09 0 >0.<5 <7 <=3 >.76334/1?9 3 98@A/<9 <=0< <=/9 78.< =04 9>36/;/60::5 4/.36<34<=3./0: 78.<<74/9>7937;<=36:0/A>3</</71F/<=/1 <=.33A71<=9 - 5 - 09<:5 =3 98@A/<9 <=0< <=3 6093 /9 93<47F1 ;7. 0.?8A31<9@3;7.3<=3./@810: 78193:<=3.3;7.398@A/<9<=0< <=3,./<3</</71A05@34/9A/9934 30.4<=30.?8A31<9014>3.8934<=3,./<>0>3.9 F/<=60.3 ( =3 9/A>:3 >7/1< <=0< .3D8/.39 6719/43.0</71 /9 F=3<=3. <=3 ./@810: /9 B89</;/34 /1 .3B36</1? <=3 /A>:304/1? 0>>:/60</71 - =3/9983;0::9F/<=/1010..7F67A>099014.3:0<39 <7 <=3 .3B36</71 7; <=3 >:30 <=0< <=3 <.0/:3. F09 >0.E34 =0>=0G0.4:571<=3.7049/43F/<=78<0159/?10:97./14/60<7.9 9=7F/1? 0 :06E 7; 608</71 7 @3 >.36/93 <=3 198.0163 7A>015=049>36/;/60::5671<31434<=0<F/<=78<06</20</1?<=3 =0G0.4 :/?=<9 7. 015 7<=3. /14/60<7.9 <=3 <.0/:3. F09 >0.E34 0:71?<=3.7049/43/14/60</1?060.3:3990>>.706= =3./@810:=09.3B36<34<=30>>:/60</7171<=.336781<9# =36:0/A>3</</71F/::@34/9A/9934;7.171 B7/143. 7; 1363990.5 >0.</39 /; <=3 <.0/:3. 4./23."7F13./90<;08:<;7.<=3066/431< - 6 - =3 6:0/A >3</</71 F/:: @3 4/9A/9934 /; <=3 43630934 F09 0 B7/1< <7.<;3097. /1 <=3 /16/431< $ ; <=3.3 /9 671<./@8<7.5 13?:/?3163 <=3 198.0163 7A>015 /9 :/0@:3 <7 >05 <=3 67A>3190</71 =3.309719099/?134;7.<=3.3B36</710.381<310@:3=3 .30971/90>>0.31<=3198.0163 7A>015/1<3149<7/A>:304 <=3 7F13. 7; <=3 .0/:3. 71 <=3 97:3 ?.7814 <=0< <=3 :06E 7; 608</71F0932/431<09<=3.0/:3.F09>0.E3471<=39/437;<=3 .704 F/<=78< 015 /14/60<7.9 7. =0G0.4 :/?=<9 /231 <=3 6/.68A9<016397;<=3810<<31434<.0/:3.71<=39=78:43.7;<=3 .704 F/<=78< =0G0.4 :/?=<9 <=3 >.393163 7; <=3 /A>:304/1? 0>>:/601< /9 /A>3.0</23 =3 7.43. >09934 @5 <=3 ./@810: /9 :/0@:3<7@393<09/43667.4/1?:5/</993<09/43 =3 ,./< 7; 3.</7.0./ /9 7.43.34 =3 7.43. 40<34 >09934@5<=3.: 31/7. /2/:'84?30143A@3. /B050>8. /1 7-") 2/43 113C8.3 /9 D809=34=3/A>:304/1?0>>:/60</71/90::7F34=3./0: 78.< /94/.36<34<74/9>7937;<=36093093C>34/</789:509>799/@:3 - 7 - F/<=/10178<3.:/A/<7;;/23A71<=9;.7A<=3.363/><7;63.</;/34 67>57;<=/97.43. H 398:<01<:5<=3,./<3</</71/9 !" () &%!$$' % /9<7# :7#