- 1 - !"#$ %#& ## # '(')*+,(' ** - !" # "$ % " & "" '(') !"*"# & +( & "! %#+ &! # " ' ' ! ( ' & "$ # " & && " '!# '!# !# !'# & Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " !"# " & & * & % ," * ! ," * # -./012.2.34./5.61789012.2.341: ;<<=/173=471: 1<2.34+(35"-;:;2.9;;>;:.?=:;?/-;;4-.2; /11?.4> :1>=6;: 8;.6 53: 2-1 35514<1/ 0=4./-;861 =471: 1<2.34/ '!# '!# !# ;47 !'# 35 "-;:;2.9; 9;9;;4-.2; -1>./2352-10:3/1<=2.34<;/1.48:.15./2-;2 2-1 <3@06;.4;42A/ /./21: ;47 -1: -=/8;47 B1:1 -;C.4> ; /2:;.417@;:.2;6:16;2.34/-.02./;661>172-;22-18:32-1: 35 ;<<=/17 3 -;7 .421:C1417 .4 2-1 /;.7 73@1/2.< 7./<3:7.4;4;221@0223:1<34<.612-17.551:14<1/812B114 2-1@ -1 71<1;/17 4;@169 D;6;47;: ./ /;.7 23 -;C1 811434.4.@.<;621:@/B.2-2-1<3@06;.4;42A/5;@.69;47 - 3 - B;/.42-1-;8.2355:1E=142690.<?.4>E=;::16/B.2-2-1@ -1 0:3/1<=2.34 5=:2-1: ;661>1/ 2-;2 ;<<=/17 3 B-3 B;/ 4=:/.4> ;4.@3/.29 ;>;.4/2 2-1<3@06;.4;42A/ 8:32-1: .46;B 71C163017 ; >:=7>1 ;47 34 '' ;2 ;83=2 0@<3@@.2217-./@=:71: -3=>- 2-1 <:.@1 B;/ .4.2.;669 :1>./21:17 ;>;.4/2 =4?43B4 01:/34/ 7=:.4> 2-1 <3=:/1 35 .4C1/2.>;2.34 2-1 4C1/2.>;2.4> 55.<1: 8;/17 34 2-1 /2;21@142/ 35 % ;47 % 832- C1473:/ B-3 ;:1 /2;217 23 -;C1 B.241//17 2-1 3<<=::14<1 ;::;.>417 ;<<=/173;472-10:1/142012.2.341:;/;<<=/173/ ;47 :1/01<2.C169 -1 /2;21@142/ 35 2-1/1 B.241//1/ :1C1;62-;22-19-;7;661>1769/114;<<=/173.456.<2.4> @=62.061/2;8.4F=:.1/342-171<1;/17;472-1:1;521:2-1 0:1/142 012.2.341: !;<<=/17 3# /2;88.4> 2-1 71<1;/17 B-14 -1 -;7 5;6614 23 2-1 >:3=47 4 <3@0612.34 35 .4C1/2.>;2.34<-;:>1/-112<;@123815.617.@06.<;2.4>2-1 0:1/142012.2.341:53:2-135514<10=4./-;861=471:1<2.34 !#352-1"-;:;2.9;9;9;;4-.2; - 4 - + 1;:417 <3=4/16 ;001;:.4> 53: 2-1 012.2.341: B3=67C1-1@14269<3421472-;22-1142.:1<;/1;>;.4/22-1 012.2.341:./;:1/=62355;6/1.@06.<;2.341B3=67/=8@.2 2-;22-1<-;:>1/-112@;21:.;6/1C14.5;<<10217.42-1.: 142.:129 73 432 7./<63/1 ;49 @32.C1 ;22:.8=217 23 2-1 012.2.341:2./=:>172-;22-1:1;:143;661>;2.34/350:.3: 14@.293:;493C1:2;<2<3441<2.4>2-1012.2.341:B.2-2-1 71<1;/17 1G<102 53: 2-1 8;67 /2;21@142 35 2-1 /3<;6617 191B.241//1/ B-3/1 /2;21@142/ 432;869 -;C1 8114 :1<3:717 ;521: ;4 =41G06;.417 716;9 1;:417 <3=4/16 B3=67 5=:2-1: /=8@.2 2-;2 .4 2-1 ;8/14<1 35 ; 1/2 7142.5.<;2.34 ;:;71 B-.<- ;//=@1/ /.>4.5.<;42 .@03:2;4<1B-1:12-1;<<=/17B1:14320:1C.3=/69?43B4 23 2-1 B.241//1/ 2-1 .4C1/2.>;2.34 ./ :1471:17 5=47;@142;6697151<2.C11B3=67;6/31@0-;/.H12-;22-1 012.2.341:./;5;@.69@;4-;C.4>710147142/23/=003:2 ;47 -;/ 8114 .4 F=7.<.;6 <=/2379 /.4<1 ' %.2- 2-1 .4C1/2.>;2.34 43B <3@06121 ;47 2-1 <-;:>1 /-112 ;6:1;795.617<342.4=17.4<;:<1:;2.34352-1012.2.341:.2./ - 5 - <34214717 B3=67 /1:C1 43 5=:2-1: 0=:03/1 ;47 B3=67 ;@3=42 23 ;4 =4B;::;4217 710:.C;2.34 35 -./ 6.81:29 >=;:;42117=471::2.<61352-134/2.2=2.343547.; ' 61;:417 .>- 3=:2 3C1:4@142 61;71: -;/ 3003/17 2-1 012.2.34 <342147.4> 2-;2 2-1 <-;:>1 /-112 @;21:.;6/ <61;:69 7./<63/1 2-1 ;<2.C1 0;:2.<.0;2.34 35 2-1 012.2.341: .4 2-1 -3@.<.7;6 ;//;=62 151::.4>232-1/2;21@142/35%;47%61;:417 /=8@.2/ 2-;2 832- B.241//1/ -;C1 <;21>3:.<;669 71/<:.8172-13C1:2;<2352-1012.2.341:2./;661>172-;2 ;521:;<<=/173.456.<217;:3=47/2;8.4F=:.1/342-1 71<1;/17 2-1 012.2.341: 233 /2;8817 2-1 71<1;/17 B-14 -15166342-1>:3=472-1:189/-;:.4>;<3@@34.42142.34 .4 2-1 <3@@.//.34 35 2-1 @=:71: 2 ./ 5=:2-1: /=8@.2217 2-;2832-2-1B1;034/;661>1769=/17892-1;<<=/17-;C1 8114 :1<3C1:17 ;2 2-1.: .4/2;4<1 14<1 .2 ./ =:>17 2-;2 2-1 4;2=:1 ;47 >:;C.29 35 2-1 35514<1 <3=0617 B.2- 2-1 /01<.5.<:361;22:.8=217232-1012.2.341:7./142.261/-.@23 ;49:16.15;22-.//2;>1 - 6 - -;C1 <;:15=669 <34/.71:17 2-1 :.C;6 /=8@.//.34/ ;47 01:=/17 2-1 <-;:>1 /-112 @;21:.;6/ 06;<1734:1<3:7 ) -1 @;21:.;6 <3661<217 7=:.4> .4C1/2.>;2.34 7./<63/1/ 2-;2 2-1 012.2.341: !;<<=/17 3# -;7 ;<<3@0;4.17 ;<<=/17 3 23 2-1 /<141 35 35514<1 -1 /2;21@142/ 35 2B3 .4710147142 191B.241//1/% ;47 %/01<.5.<;66971/<:.812-1:36106;917891;<-352-1 ;<<=/17 <<3:7.4> 23 2-1/1 B.241//1/ ;<<=/17 3 .4.2.;669 ;//;=6217 2-1 71<1;/17 B.2- ; ?4.51 ;47 .456.<217 @=62.061/2;8.4F=:.1/%-142-171<1;/17516673B4342-1 >:3=47 2-1 0:1/142 012.2.341: ./ /2;217 23 -;C1 /2;8817 -.@ 5=:2-1: -10:3/1<=2.34 ;6/3 :16.1/ =034 2-1 ;661>17 :1<3C1:9 35 2-1 B1;034/ =/17 .4 2-1 <3@@.//.34 35 35514<1;22-1.4/2;4<135832-;<<=/17 ( 2 2-./ /2;>1 2-1 @;21:.;6/ <3661<217 7=:.4> .4C1/2.>;2.34 .5 2;?14 ;2 2-1.: 5;<1 C;6=1 0:.@; 5;<.1 .47.<;21 2-1 0;:2.<.0;2.34 35 2-1 012.2.341: ;634> B.2- - 7 - ;<<=/17 3 .4 2-1 -3@.<.7;6 ;<2 -1 /01<.5.< :361 ;22:.8=217 23 2-1 012.2.341: 2-1 >:;C.29 35 2-1 35514<1 0=4./-;861 =471: 1<2.34 !# 35 2-1 "-;:;2.9; 9;9; ;4-.2; ;47 2-1 :1<3C1:9 35 2-1 B1;034 ;:1 ;66 :161C;42 <.:<=@/2;4<1/ 2-;2 <;4432 81 .>43:17 ;2 2-./ /2;>1%-12-1:2-1012.2.341:B;/;<2=;6690:1/142;22-1 /<141 B-12-1: -1 /-;:17 ; <3@@34 .42142.34 B.2- ;<<=/17 3 ;47 B-12-1: -1 .47117 .456.<217 ;49 /2;8 .4F=:.1/ 34 2-1 71<1;/17 ;:1 ;66 @;221:/ 2-;2 :1E=.:1 712;.6171G;@.4;2.347=:.4>2-1<3=:/1352:.;6-1/1;:1 E=1/2.34/ 35 5;<2 2-;2 <;4 81 ;7F=7.<;217 3469 ;521: ;00:1<.;2.34 35 2-1 1C.714<1 ;77=<17 89 2-1 0:3/1<=2.34 ;4771514<1 ;C.4>:1>;:7232-1>:;C.29352-135514<12-1 4;2=:1 35 2-1 ;661>;2.34/ ;47 2-1 /01<.5.< 3C1:2 ;<2 ;22:.8=217232-1012.2.341:2-./3=:2./352-1<34/.71:17 C.1B 2-;2 2-./ ./ 432 ; 5.2 <;/1 23 1G1:<./1 7./<:12.34 .4 5;C3=: 35 2-1 012.2.341: 53: >:;42 35 8;.6 -1 061; 35 0:3634>17 .4<;:<1:;2.34 2-3=>- ; :161C;42 5;<23: <;4432 - 8 - 89 .2/165 3=2B1.>- 2-1 /1:.3=/ ;661>;2.34/ /=003:217 89 0:.@; 5;<.1 @;21:.;6 .4 ; <;/1 .4C36C.4> 2-1 35514<1 35 @=:71: <<3:7.4>69B.2-3=21G0:1//.4>;4930.4.3434 2-1@1:.2/352-1<;/12-./3=:25.47/43>:3=4723>:;42 ;49 .47=6>14<1 23 2-1 012.2.341: -1 <:.@.4;6 012.2.34 ./ 2-1:153:17./@.//17 3B1C1: <34/.71:.4> 2-;2 832- ;<<=/17 ;:1 .4 F=7.<.;6 <=/2379 2-1 61;:417 :.;6 3=:2 ./ 7.:1<217 23 1G017.212-12:.;6;47<34<6=712-1/;@1;22-11;:6.1/2.4 ;<<3:7;4<1B.2-6;B .+ ' ##* & ./2363