Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43653 (KAR)

HEJIBAI W/O BHALA NAIK v. DHARMANNA S/O LINGANNA RATHOD

RSA/200029/2014 · 2025-10-28

Sachin Shankar Magadum

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #$%$$ && '%( ) !" # $ " $ % & "!""!"' & "!!"' $ & !(!!"' & & "!"! & % # ) Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ & !("!! $ * $ &+ $%, - &# *%$ - &# ./ 0123456/7 122/18 49 :; 3./ 2814634<< =.5 49 1>>?4/@/7:;?/@/?9185<AB7>C/631677/0?//?/67/?/7:; 3./ ?418 5B?3 167 749C49918 5< 3./ 9B43 :; 3./ $4?93 22/8813/5B?346 5"!!"' ! $5? 3./ 91D/ 5< 056@/64/60/ 3./ 21?34/9 1?/ ?/</??/735192/?3./4??16D:/<5?/3./?4185B?3 ' $10398/1746>353./019/1?/19B67/? E ./ 2814634<< 469343B3/7 1 9B43 46 5"!"! 9//D46> 1 7/0?// 5< 2/?C16/63 46AB603456 94C284043/? 1>14693 3./ 7/</67163 ./ 2814634<< 0814C/7 35 :/ 3./ 1:958B3/ 5=6/? 167 46 81=<B8 2599/99456 5< 8167 :/1?46>;5FFC/19B?46>)10?/9'>B6319943B13/7 - 3 - 13 .166B? @4881>/ .5?12B? 18BD 3 =19 ./? 92/04<40 019/3.139./.17184/613/716/G3/635<'10?/9!>B6319 943B13/7 35=1?79 3./ 65?3./?6 25?3456 5< ./? .58746> 46 <1@5B?5<56/46>1?1A3.?5B>.1?/>493/?/7918/7//7167 .17 ?/3146/7 3./ ?/C14646> /G3/63 5< ! 10?/9 !' >B6319 35=1?79 3./ 95B3./?6 947/ ./ 7/</67163 :/46> 3./ 17A54646>5=6/?5<8167:/1?46>;5FF1C/19B?46>) 10?/9 ! >B6319 188/>/78; 931?3/7 463/?</?46> =43. ./? 2/10/<B8 2599/99456 167 /6A5;C/63 5< 3./ ?/3146/7 25?3456 /60/ 3./ 2814634<< =19 05693?146/7 35 469343B3/ 3./ 2?/9/63 9B43 9//D46> 2?53/03456 5< ./? 2599/99456 2?57B046> 1856> =43. 3./ 281463 1 9D/30.C12 467401346> 3./?/8134@/850134565<./?1673./7/</67163+92?52/?34/9 ./ 7/</67163 B256 9/?@40/ 5< 9BCC569 /63/?/7 122/1?160/ 167 <48/7 1 =?433/6 9313/C/63 013/>5?40188; 7/6;46> 3./ 1@/?C/639 C17/ 46 3./ 281463 / 7492B3/7 3./ 47/6343; 167 /G3/63 5< 3./ 9B43 2?52/?3; 167188/>/73.133./2814634<<.17653122?510./73./5B?3 =43. 08/16 .1679 3 =19 0563/67/7 3.13 3./ :5B671?4/9 - 4 - <B?649./7:;3./2814634<<=/?/4605??/031673.139./=19 653 3./ 5=6/? 5< ) 10?/9 ' >B6319 19 0814C/7 6 3./ :19495<3./?4@1828/1746>93./21?34/9=/?/?/8/>13/735 3?418358/175?18167750BC/631?;/@47/60/469B225?35< 3./4??/92/034@/0814C9 ) ./ ?418 5B?3 B256 122?/0413456 5< 3./ /@47/60/ 56 ?/05?7 169=/?/7 99B/ 5" 46 3./ 1<<4?C134@/ .58746> 3.13 3./ 2814634<< .17 9B00/99<B88; 2?5@/7 ./? 81=<B8 2599/99456 167 /6A5;C/63 5< 3./ 9B43 2?52/?3; 99B/ 5! ?/81346> 35 188/>/7 463/?</?/60/ =19 1895 169=/?/7 46 3./ 1<<4?C134@/ 167 0569/HB/638; 3./ ?4185B?37/0?//73./9B43?/93?14646>3./7/</67163<?5C 463/?</?46>=43.3./2814634<<+92599/99456 ( >>?4/@/7:;3./9147AB7>C/631677/0?//3./ 7/</67163 2?/</??/7 16 122/18 46 5"!!"' ./ $4?93 22/8813/ 5B?3 56 1 ?/122?14918 5< 3./ 5?18 167 750BC/631?; /@47/60/ <5B67 3.13 0/?3146 17C4994569 /84043/7 <?5C 3./ 2814634<< 7B?46> 0?599/G1C4613456 4674013/7 3.13 9./ =19 653 46 2599/99456 5< 3./ 9B43 - 5 - 2?52/?3;19563./713/5<<4846>5<3./9B43 /8;46>B256 3./9/ 17C4994569 3./ 22/8813/ 5B?3 ?/@/?9/7 3./ <46746>95<3./?4185B?31670569/HB/638;749C499/73./ 2814634<<+99B43 ./ 8/1?6/7 05B69/8 <5? 3./ 2814634<<122/88163 ?/43/?1346> 3./ >?5B679 B?>/7 46 3./ C/C5?167BC 5< 122/18@/./C/638;0563/67/73.133./188/>/717C4994569 /G3?103/7460?599/G1C4613456016653:/?/1746495813456 5?3?/13/719<1318353./2814634<<+9019/3491?>B/73.13 3.//G1C4613456460.4/<5<3./7/</67163.4C9/8<05631469 C13/?418 17C4994569 10D65=8/7>46> 3./ 2814634<<+9 2599/99456 167 9B0. 17C4994569 5B>.3 35 2?/@148 5@/? 93?1; 9313/C/639 /84043/7 46 0?599/G1C4613456 5B69/8 <B?3./? 9B:C433/7 3.13 3./ ?/@/6B/ ?/05?79 167 3./ ?/>493/?/7 918/ 7//7 2?57B0/7 :; 3./ 2814634<< 08/1?8; /931:849. 3.13 1<3/? 9/8846> ' 10?/9 ! >B6319 9./ 056346B/7 35 .587 ! 10?/9 !' >B6319 943B13/7 56 3./ 95B3./?6 947/ :/;567 3./ 193I%/93 181 3./?/:; 7/C5693?1346> 056346B5B9 2599/99456 3 49 3./?/<5?/ - 6 - 0563/67/7 3.13 3./ ?/@/?918 5< 3./ 7/0?// :; 3./ $4?93 22/8813/5B?3492/?@/?9/167B69B931461:8/4681= F 3./ 8/1?6/7 05B69/8 <5? 3./ 7/</67163?/92567/639B225?3/73./<46746>9167?/19569 ?/05?7/7 :; 3./ $4?93 22/8813/ 5B?3 / 0563/67/73.13 3./ 17C4994569 /84043/7 46 3./ 0?599/G1C4613456 5< 3./ 2814634<< >5 35 3./ ?553 5< 3./ C133/? 167 560/ 43 49 /931:849./73.133./2814634<<=19653462599/994565<3./ 9B43 2?52/?3; 19 56 3./ 713/ 5< 3./ 9B43 3./ @/?; <5B6713456 5< 16 46AB603456 9B43 0588129/9 /60/ 3./ 749C499185<3./9B43:;3./22/8813/5B?31005?746>35 .4C=1??163965463/?</?/60/ " 1@46>./1?73./8/1?6/705B69/8122/1?46><5? :53.947/9138/6>3.167562/?B9185<3./28/1746>95?18 /@47/60/ 167 750BC/631?; C13/?4189 2810/7 56 ?/05?7 3.495B?32?50//7935/G1C46/=./3./?3./<46746>95<3./ $4?9322/8813/5B?30188<5?463/?</?/60/469/0567122/18 - 7 - "" .49 5B?3 :; 5?7/? 713/7 ")"!!" .19 17C433/7 3./ 9/0567 122/18 56 3./ <5885=46> 9B:93163418 HB/9345695<81= +,-+,./,012/30/14,1+45637/1+,548/ "! ./2814634<<133./34C/5<469343B346>3./9B43 .19<B?649./719D/30.C127/240346>3./?/8134@/85013456 167/G3/635<3./2?52/?34/9./87:;:53.3./2814634<<167 3./ 7/</67163 2/?B918 5< 3./ 9147 9D/30. ?/@/189 3.13 3./816795<3./2814634<<1673./7/</671631?/05634>B5B9 1675<94C481?/G3/639943B13/717A54646>/10.53./?./ 9D/30. <B?3./? 7490859/9 3.13 :53. 2?52/?34/9 84/ 56 /43./? 947/ 5< 1 181 ?B6646> 193I%/93 =.40. <5?C9 1 613B?18 - 8 - 7/C1?01346> </13B?/ :/3=//6 3./ 65?3./?6 167 95B3./?6 25?345695<3./4??/92/034@/.58746>9 "' 6 /G1C4646> 3./ 9D/30. 43 49 /@47/63 3.13 56 3./65?3./?6947/5<3./181:53.21?34/95?4>46188;./87 816795<122?5G4C13/8;/HB18/G3/63=.48/3./7/</67163+9 65?3./?6 25?3456 C/19B?/7 ' 10?/9 !! >B6319 3./ 2814634<<+9 65?3./?6 25?3456 C/19B?/7 ' 10?/9 ! >B6319 ./ 2814634<< .19 013/>5?40188; 199/?3/7 3.13 9./ 9587 3.49 65?3./?6 25?3456 5< ' 10?/9 ! >B6319 35 56/ 46>1?1A 3.?5B>.1?/>493/?/7918/7//7 "E ./2?/9/637492B3/3./?/<5?/49056<46/7568; 353./95B3./?625?34565<;5FF=./?/463./2814634<< 0814C9 35 .1@/ ?/3146/7 16 /G3/63 5< ! 10?/9 !' >B6319 =.48/3./7/</67163+9?/3146/7816746;5FF1563./ =/93/?6947/C/19B?/9!10?/9!>B6319197/846/13/746 3./2814634<<+99D/30. " 83.5B>. 3./ 7/</67163 46 .49 =?433/6 9313/C/63 .19 <5?C188; 7/64/7 3./ 05??/036/99 5< 3./ - 9 - 9D/30.<B?649./7:;3./2814634<<9B0.7/6418?/C1469:187 167 B69B225?3/7 :; 16; 05B63/?9D/30. 5? 9B:931634@/ 750BC/631?; /@47/60/ ./ 7/</67163 .19 6/43./? 2?57B0/7 1 C12 <?5C 16; 05C2/3/63 1B3.5?43; 65? <B?649./7 16; C13/?418 21?340B81?9 35 7492B3/ 3./ :5B671?4/9 5? ?/8134@/ 2594345646> 9.5=6 46 3./ 2814634<<+9 9D/30. ") 6 3./ 1:9/60/ 5< 9B0. /@47/60/ 3.49 5B?3 <46793.133./2814634<<+97/846/134565<3./2?52/?3;?/C1469 B60563?5@/?3/7 ./7/</67163+9 C/?/ 188/>13456 3.13 3./ 9D/30. 49 4605??/03 016653 46 81= 7492810/ 3./ 2814634<<+9 0569493/631679B225?3/7@/?9456569/HB/638;B67/?3./ >/6/?18 ?B8/ /C:574/7 46 /03456 ""E 88B93?13456 > 5< 3./67416@47/60/031617@/?9/46</?/60/6/0/991?48; 1?49/91>146933./7/</67163<5?.49<148B?/352?57B0/3./ :/93 1@1481:8/ /@47/60/ 61C/8; 1 05B63/?9D/30. 5? 8167 ?/05?793.1305B87.1@/7492?5@/73./2814634<<+9@/?9456 "( 6 3./ 0563?1?; 3./ 2814634<< .19 2?57B0/7 ?/841:8/ 750BC/631?; /@47/60/ 4608B746> 3./ ?/>493/?/7 - 10 - 918/7//7=.40.653568;/931:849./93./<1035<184/613456 5<125?34565<./?816735=1?793./65?3./?6947/:B31895 7/C5693?13/9 ./? 056346B/7 5=6/?9.42 167 ?/3/63456 5< 3./?/C14646> ! 10?/9 !'>B6319 56 3./ 95B3./?6 947/5< 3./ 181 ./ ?/043189 46 3./ 918/ 7//7 3./C9/8@/9 ?/05>64J/ 3./ ?/947B18 .58746> 5< 3./ 2814634<< 3./?/:; 05??5:5?1346> ./? @/?9456 .B9 3./ 2814634<< .19 91349<1035?48; 9.5=6 3.?5B>. 2?4C1?; 750BC/631?; /@47/60/3.139./74765321?3=43../?/634?/.58746>167 ./? 3438/ 167 2599/99456 5@/? 3./ ?/3146/7 /G3/63 ?/C146 463103 " ./?/@/6B/ ?/05?79 2?57B0/7 167C1?D/719 G.4:439 ! 35 167 F 35 ") <B?3./? <5?34<; 3./ 2814634<<+9 019/ ./9/ 750BC/639 0569493/638; ?/05?7 3./ 2814634<<+95=6/?9.425@/?;5FFC/19B?46>)10?/9' >B63194635318@/61<3/?3./918/5<125?345646<1@5B?5< 46>1?1A 3./ CB313456 /63?4/9 167 ?/05?75<?4>.39 /G3?1039056346B/35?/<8/033./2814634<<+961C/46?/92/03 5<3./?/3146/7!10?/9!'>B6319 - 11 - "F ./ 7/</67163 .19 653 2?57B0/7 16; 0563?1 ?/@/6B/ ?/05?79 35 7/C5693?13/ 3.13 3./ 2814634<< .19 74@/93/7./?9/8<5<./?/634?//G3/635?3.133./?/C14646> 25?3456 .19 C/?>/7 =43. 3./ 7/</67163+9 .58746> G0/23 <5? 1 @1>B/ 7/6418 46 3./ =?433/6 9313/C/63 3./?/ 49 65 9B:931634@/0.188/6>/353./2814634<<+93438/63./1:9/60/ 5< 16; ?4@18 750BC/631?; /@47/60/ 3./ ?/@/6B/ /63?4/9 2?57B0/7 :; 3./ 2814634<< 01??; 2?/9BC234@/ @18B/ 5< 05??/036/99 B67/? /03456 "'' 5< 3./ #1?6131D1 167 /@/6B/ 03 167 CB93 3./?/<5?/ :/ >4@/6 7B/ /@47/6341?;=/4>.3 ! ./05?/0563?5@/?9;.5=/@/?0/63/?91?5B67 3./188/>/717C4994569133?4:B3/7353./2814634<<7B?46>./? 0?599/G1C4613456 :; 3./ 7/</67163+9 05B69/8 167 3./ @58B631?;17C4994569C17/:;3./7/</67163.4C9/8<46.49 /G1C4613456460.4/< =.48/ 7/25946> 46 9B225?3 5< .49 7/</60/ ./ $4?93 22/8813/ 5B?3 =.48/ ?/@/?946> 3./ =/88?/1956/7 7/0?// 5< 3./ ?418 5B?3 .19 ?/84/7 958/8; - 12 - B256495813/725?345695<3./2814634<<+90?599/G1C4613456 05693?B46>3./C1917C499456917@/?9/35./?2599/99456 !" .495B?3<46793.139B0.16122?510.=43.5B3 1 .5849340 ?/1746> 5< 3./ 7/25943456 C1; 653 :/ 8/>188; 95B67 ./ 2?460428/ 49 =/889/338/7 3.13 1 9313/C/63 46 0?599/G1C4613456 CB93 :/ ?/17 46 056AB603456 =43. 3./ /G1C4613456460.4/< 167 9B??5B6746> /@47/60/ 35 190/?3146 439 3?B/ 4C25?3 ./ $4?93 22/8813/ 5B?3 .5=/@/? 122/1?9 35 .1@/ 2810/7 B67B/ /C2.1949 56 9/8/034@/ /G0/?239 749?/>1?746> :53. 3./ 0563/G3 167 3./ 05??5:5?134@/5?18167750BC/631?;/@47/60/177B0/7:; 3./2814634<< !! ./?/<5?/ :/<5?/ /G1C4646> =./3./? 3./ <46746>9 5< 3./ $4?93 22/8813/ 5B?3 1?/ 9B931461:8/ 3.49 5B?37//C943122?52?413/35/G3?1033./2?/049/25?34569 5< 3./ 2814634<<+9 0?599/G1C4613456 ?/84/7 B256 :; 3./ 22/8813/ 5B?3 19 17C4994569 <5?C46> 3./ :1949 <5? ?/@/?9185<3./7/0?// - 13 - !" # $%&' () "* +, -'&# .%/ 01 201 # (345 6 #0'# $ ! "* +, !7 89 :;'1 <&"6 =7 ( # * '* >*(> !"# !' ./ 7/</67163+9 93167 46 /G1C4613456460.4/< 1321?1>?12.5E4918950?B0418./?/<5?/3./91C/1895 6//7935://G3?103/7005?746>8;3./91C/49/G3?103/7 =.40.?/17919B67/? ! "# $ $ % &%''() ! * * &%''( $ ! &%''() $ - 14 - !E ./ 7/</67163+9 9313/C/63 46 .49 /G1C4613456 460.4/<3.13K./.19653/60?510./7L49653C/?/8;19/8< 9/?@46> 7/6418 167 :B3 16 B6/HB4@5018 16 K17C499456L =43.46 3./ C/1646> 5< /034569 "( 35 !' 5< 3./ @47/60/ 036K17C499456L4681=4919313/C/639B>>/9346>16 46</?/60/ 19 35 1 <103 46 499B/ 167 5?7461?48; 52/?13/9 1>146933./ C1D/?+9 5=6 463/?/933 7/?4@/9 439 2?5:134@/ <5?0/653<?5C3./9313/C/63439/8<:B3<?5C4390569493/60; =43. 3./ 9B??5B6746> 04?0BC93160/9 167 3./ 84D/84.557 5< 4393?B3.19=/4>./7563./2?/2567/?160/5<2?5:1:48434/9 9/8</G0B82135?; 199/?3456 9B0. 19 K .1@/ 653 /60?510./7L3./?/<5?//6A5;3.//@47/6341?;=/4>.33.13 3./9313B3/1005?793517C4994569 ! 67/? /034569 "" 167 "! 5< 3./ @47/60/ 03 3./ :B?7/6 5< 2?5@46> /60?510.C/63 84/9 B256 3./ 7/</67163/92/04188;=./63./<10384/9=43.46.4992/0418 D65=8/7>/ B67/? /03456 ") ./ 7/</67163 .5=/@/? .19<148/7357490.1?>/3.49:B?7/6:;=43..58746>3./@/?; - 15 - /@47/60/ 3.13 05B87 .1@/ 05608B94@/8; 9B225?3/7 .49 28/1 61C/8; 1 C/19B?/C/63 9D/30. 05CC499456 ?/25?3 5? ?/@/6B/ /G3?1039 6 9B0. 04?0BC93160/9 3./ ?B8/ 5< 17@/?9/46</?/60/560/1>14652/?13/91>14693.4CB67/? /03456""E88B93?13456 > !) 6 3./ 53./? .167 3./ 188/>/7 17C4994569 /84043/7<?5C3./2814634<<7B?46>0?599/G1C4613456=.40. 3./ $4?93 22/8813/ 5B?3 .19 ?/84/7 B256 016653 :/ @4/=/7 46 495813456 5? 35?6 5B3 5< 0563/G3 ./ 9/338/7 25943456 46 81= 49 3.13 /@47/6341?; 17C4994569 1?/ 653 05608B94@/ 2?55< 5< 3./ <1039 17C433/7 /03456 '" 167 CB93:/?/17191=.58/1856>=43.3.//G1C461345646 0.4/< 167 750BC/631?; ?/05?7 93?1; 1C:4>B5B9 5? 21?34188;/G3?103/7169=/?21?340B81?8;46?/81345635C4G/7 HB/934569 5< 2599/99456 /G3/63 5? :5B671?; 016653 5B3=/4>. 05>/63 750BC/631?; /@47/60/ 167 0569493/63 :5B671?4/9 !( %./6 3./ 2814634<<+9 3438/ 750BC/639 ?/@/6B/ /63?4/9 167 7/846/13456 9D/30. 188 25463 35 056346B/7 - 16 - 2599/99456 5@/? 3./ 95B3./?6 ?/3146/7 25?3456 3./ 2?/2567/?160/ 5< 2?5:1:48434/9 ./1@48; 34839 46 ./? <1@5B? ./ 2814634<<+9 @/?9456 49 0569493/63 05??5:5?13/7 167 9B225?3/7 :; C13/?418 /@47/60/ =./?/19 3./ 7/</67163+9 019/ ?/939 568; 56 5?18 7/64189 7/@547 5< 05??5:5?13456 ./?/<5?/3./22/8813/5B?3+9?/@/?9182?/C49/7958/8; 56 495813/7 17C4994569 =.48/ 4>65?46> 3./ 0BCB8134@/ 750BC/631?; /@47/60/ 167 3./ 2?460428/ 5< 2?/2567/?163 2?5:1:4843;016653:/9B93146/74681= ! 6@4/=5<3./1:5@/7490B994563.495B?3495< 3./ 056947/?/7 5246456 3.13 3./ 9B:93163418 HB/934569 5< 81=59"167!7/9/?@/35:/169=/?/7463./6/>134@/ ./ <46746>9 ?/05?7/7 :; 3./ ?418 5B?3 1?/ :19/7 56 2?52/? 122?/0413456 5< /@47/60/ =./?/19 3./ $4?93 22/8813/ 5B?3 .19 C4974?/03/7 439/8< :; >4@46> B67B/ =/4>.3 35 1 </= 93?1; 169=/?9 46 0?599/G1C4613456 167 5@/?855D46> 3./ :?517/? /@47/6341?; :18160/ ./ 2814634<< .19 9B00/99<B88; 7/C5693?13/7 ./? 5=6/?9.42 167 81=<B8 2599/99456 3.?5B>. ?/@/6B/ ?/05?79 3438/ 7//79 167 - 17 - 7/846/13456 5< :5B671?4/9 228;46> 3./ 3./5?; 5< 2?/2567/?160/ 5< 2?5:1:48434/9 3./ /@47/60/ 56 ?/05?7 B6C4931D1:8;254639353./2814634<<+9056346B/72599/99456 5@/? 3./ 9B43 2?52/?3; 167 3./ 7/</67163+9 463/?</?/60/ 3./?/46604@487492B3/93./5B?3+9319D49357/3/?C46/ =.40. 21?3;+9 @/?9456 49 C5?/ 2?5:1:8/ 653 =.40. 56/ 49 2?5@/7 :/;567 ?/19561:8/ 75B:3 6 3.49 05C21?134@/ 9018/ 3./ 2814634<<+9 019/ <5?34<4/7 :; 750BC/631?; /@47/60/ 167 05??5:5?13/7 :; 0569493/63 :5B671?; 7/90?4234569 08/1?8; 5B3=/4>.9 3./ 7/</67163+9 B69B:93163413/7 7/64189 ./ 950188/7 17C4994569 133?4:B3/7353./2814634<<460?599/G1C46134561?/6/43./? 08/1?65?B6/HB4@50185616;C13/?418<1031673./?/<5?/ 653<131835./?019/ !F $5?3./<5?/>546>?/195691677490B9945693.49 5B?32199/93./<5885=46> 4 ./ />B81?/056722/1849./?/:;1885=/7 - 18 - 44 ./ AB7>C/63 167 7/0?// 713/7 "!""!"' 2199/7 46 5"!!"' :; 3./ 8/1?6/7 /645?4@48&B7>/.5?12B?499/31947/ 444 569/HB/638; 3./ AB7>C/63 167 7/0?// 713/7 !(!!"'2199/7465"!"! :;3./ 4@48 &B7>/ &B645? 4@49456 .5?12B? 49 ?/935?/71671<<4?C/7 4@ 63./?/9B833./2814634<<49./8735:/4681=<B8 2599/99456 5< 3./ 9B43 90./7B8/ 2?52/?3; 167 3./ 46AB603456 >?163/7 :; 3./ ?418 5B?3 ?/93?14646> 3./ 7/</67163 <?5C 463/?</?46> =43. ./?2599/99456931679056<4?C/7 @ 88 2/6746> 463/?850B35?; 122840134569 4< 16; 93167749259/75< -9 '$$( % 4935'85"