- 1 - ! "!#!! ! $%&$'$ '' ( !"#$ % & ' ( !"#$ ( !"$ # !"#$ % & () ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( *!&'( &' *$$ ##$ ( ! &! ( ') #+ & '$& $ ' ( ( ( ! & ( ' ( (( #&'",&',&',&'$,$&',$-. $ &'&!'( & ( ' ,", ( / #! &/ ' 001223456 71849 3::;61< -6# 34< + 84 =8>1 -$ -. 32?1=8 -28:1 5358-4 4-@ 014<849 84 01:832 361 & ' -$ -4 5A1 .821 -. 5A1 213=41< <<858-432 1668-46 ;<91 (365 =3:? 01:832 -;=5! 35 8B3C30;=3 &84!:A3=91 -. <<858-432 865=8:5 34< 1668-46 ;<91 8B3C30;=3' =198651=1< .-= 5A1 - 3 - -..14:160;486A3721;4<1= 1:58-46#&'",&',&' ,&' $, $&' =13< @85A 1:58-4 ,$ -. A3=358C3 C3C3 34A853 $ D.-= 6A-=5 E5A1 $FG 34< ;4<1= 1:58-4 &'&H3' -. :A1<;21< 36516 34< :A1<;21< =8716 &=1H1458-4 -. 5=-:85816' >14<>145 :5$D.-=6A-=5E5A1 &':5FG3=1611?849 .-=9=345-.7382 13=< =8 A8H3434< 355346A1558 213=41< :-;4612 .-= 5A13001223456 34< =8 3>3<3= A3A37;<<84 213=41< 89A -;=5 -H1=4>145 213<1= .-= =160-4<145 - I 5351 160-4<145 - 5A-;9A 61=H1< A36 =1>3841< ;4!=10=161451< 1=;61< 5A1 >351=8326 -4 =1:-=< 4 H81@ -. 5A1 =8H32 :-451458-46 ;=91< 7C 5A1 213=41<:-;4612.-=7-5A5A103=58165A10-8455A35@-;2< 3=861.-=>C:-468<1=358-486 !"#"$% - 4 - C346@1=5-5A137-H10-84586845A1EF.-= 5A1.-22-@849 * 160-4<145-.821<5A1.8=6584.-=>358-4@85A 32?1=8 0-28:1 3938465 3::;61< -6 5- + 32219849 :->>8668-4 -. 5A1 -..14:16 0;486A3721 ;4<1= 1:58-46 #&' ",&' ,&' ,&' $, $&' =13< @85A 1:58-4,$-. $34<;4<1= 1:58-4&'&H3'-. 5A1 &':5 A1(:3>15-71=198651=1<34< 84H16589358-4@36;4<1=53?14.51=84H16589358-4:A3=91 6A115:3>15-71.821<39384653::;61<-65-+.-=5A1 37-H1 638< -..14:16 -2;>4 -+ -. 5A1 :A3=91 6A115 <86:2-616 5A35 5A1 3::;61< .-=>1< 3 9349 5- :3;61 4;8634:1 5- 5A1 <1:1361< 34< A86 .3>82C >1>71=6 1H14 @A14A1=1J;1651<5A1>4-55-:3;6184:-4H14814:134< 4-5 5- 51361 34< A3=366 5A1 .1>321 >1>71=6 5A1C @1=1 4-5A11<8495-5A163>1 A13::;61<A3H1:-4608=1<5- :3;61 5A1 <135A -. 5A1 <1:1361< 4 ,$$ 84 5A1 13=2C>-=484935#$$3>3::;61<-6#34<+:3>1 - 5 - 413=5A16:141-.-::;==14:134<2351=-5A1=3::;61<A3H1 326- B-841< 5A1> 84:1 5A1 <1:1361< @36 0366849 5A=-;9A 5A1 6:141 -. -::;==14:1 3.51= 35514<849 5A1 435;=1F6:3225A13::;61<A3H108:?1<;0J;3==12@85AA8> 1:1361< 01251< 65-41 3938465 3::;61< -6 34< * 5- 63H1A8628.134<5A13::;61<.-=>8495A1>612H16845-34 ;423@.;23661>72C3553:?1<5A1<1:1361<::;61<- 3663;251< @85A 3K1 3::;61< -6 34< @85A :2;76 3::;61< -6* @85A =-< 3::;61< -6 # 34< + ?8:?1< @85A219663=16;25-.@A8:AA16;653841<.353284B;=816 H14 3.51= :3;6849 .3532 84B;=816 5- 5A1 <1:1361< 5A1 3::;61< :3>1 5- A86 A-;61 34< 3663;251< !" ! 5A1 .35A1= -. 5A1 <1:1361< 34< !, ! 5A1 @8.1 -. 5A1 84.-=>34534<:3;61<84B;=816 5865A1:-451458-4-.5A10=-61:;58-45A355A1 84:8<145 @36 @8541661< 7C 5A1 1C1@85416616 A1 32219358-46>3<1393846513:A-.5A13::;61<84:2;<8495A1 3001223456 3=1 61=8-;6 84 435;=1 A1 :-451458-4 -. 5A1 213=41< :-;4612 .-= 5A1 3001223456 86 5A35 5A1 3001223456 - 6 - A3H14-5;61<34C@130-47;5-42C?8:?1<5A1<1:1361< :344-5 71 3 9=-;4< 5- 1423=91 5A1> -4 7382 36 601:8.8: 32219358-463=1>3<15A355A1=1@36:-4608=3:C34<5A1 3::;61<A3H1.-=>1<34;423@.;23661>72C71.-=1:3;6849 <135A-.5A1<1:1361< # A1 .3:56 43==351< 37-H1 <86:2-61 5A35 85 86 3 0=1023441<>;=<1=:3;61<7C;6849<13<2C@130-466 01= 0-65>-=51> =10-=5 5A1 <1:1361< A3< 6;653841< .-;= 1K51=432 84B;=816 34< 5A1 <135A @36 <;1 5- A1>-==A391 34<A13<84B;=8166;653841<03=5.=->5A356!"34< ,A3H1326-6;653841<84B;=816 A15=83271.-=15A1 =832 -;=5 A36 4-5 C15 719;4 4 5A1 >13458>1 8. 5A161 30012234563=11423=91<-473825A1=1@822715A=1355-5A1 >351=832@85416616 @A-3=15-711K3>841<-471A32.-. 5A10=-61:;58-4 + 3?849 845- :-468<1=358-4 5A1 435;=1 34< 61=8-;64166 -. 5A1 -..14:16 34< 5A1 -H1=5 3:5 :->>8551< 7C 5A1 3001223456 71849 03=5 -. :-4608=3:C 34< 326- 84 - 7 - :3;6849 5A1 <135A -. 5A1 <1:1361< 34< 3663;25849 5A1 84B;=1<1C1@854166163>-.5A1-0848-45A355A1C3=14-5 1458521<.-=9=345-.73824H81@-.5A137-H1346@1= 5A137-H10-845845A1E419358H1F34<0=-:11<5-03665A1 .-22-@849 A1=8>84320013286 )% $!!' # 865- 2-,