- 1 - !! "" ""# ! $! %&& "'' ( ) !* ! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " # $ " %% % & '()(* '()(* + ! " # % , ! % $ % (#$ % - - %! - ! # $ **** . % ** ! - % ! **(%*%+ % (*** / - % % - 0 % % %! - 3 - % ! - 1 ! %" 23 4553664789 4:3 823 ;<73:9 ;= 823 647> ?34:@7A B;) C349D:@7A 4E:39 . AD7849 ;= 462@554:A4 F@664A3 46DG4 2@8845D: @98:@E8 464?D:4A@ 23 647> ;= 823 4553664789 <49 4EHD@:3> =;: 823 5D:5;93 ;= E;798:DE8@;7;=3=847G4746;=377@82;:4 :;I3E8F@>3 5:36@C@74:B 7;8@=@E48@;7 >483> .. 23 53E@46 47>EHD@9@8@;7==@E3:249=@J3>823C4:G38F46D3;=823 647> =;: 823 5D:5;93 ;= E;C537948@;7 48 9*** / 53: 4E:323 3=3:37E3;D:837247E3>823E;C537948@;78; 9** / 53: 4E:3 7 47 455346 823 %@:98 55366483 ;D:8 E;C5D83> 823 E;C537948@;7 48 9.)** / 53: 4E:3 ;< 823 4553664789 4:3 933G@7A E;C537948@;7 ;= 9(*** /53:4E:3 - 4 - 34:> 634:73> E;D7936 =;: 823 4553664789 47> 634:73>E;D7936=;:823:395;7>3789 34:73> E;D7936 =;: 823 4553664789 249 :36@3> D5;7 823 ID>AC378 @7 ;***(( * <2@E2 53:84@79 8; 823 377@82;:4 :;I3E8 @7 <2@E2 823 E;C537948@;74<4:>3><49 9(*(. /53:4E:3=;:823 7;8@=@E48@;7;=823B34:..*3249469;564E3>:36@47E3 ;7 823>3E@9@;7 ;=823 ;/;:>@748337E2 ;=82@9 ;D:8 @7 ;***. *K <23:3@7 :36B@7A ;7 823 ID>AC378 54993> @7 ;***(( * 823 E;C537948@;7 E4C3 8; ?3 4<4:>3> 48 9(*(. / 53: 4E:3 =;: 823 647> D7>3: 7;8@=@E48@;7 >483> *(*K..* 4EHD@:3> =;: 823 5D:5;93;=377@82;:4 :;I3E853:84@7@7A8;4:9D:F@664A3 34:73>E;D7936=;:82345536647899D?C@898248 823 94@> C4883: <49 84G37 D5 @7 53E@46 34F3 38@8@;7 #@F@6$@4:B;( **?3=;:3823;70?6353J;D:8 47>@8E4C38;?3>@9C@993>39D?C@898248823 3F@3< 38@8@;7;( *469;E4C38;?3>@9C@993>37E323 - 5 - 5:4B98;466;<823455346?B=@J@7A823C4:G38F46D3;=823 4EHD@:3> 647> @7 4 9DC ;= 9(*(. / 53: 4E:3 <@82 39E4648@;7 ;= )L 53: 477DC 7 8248 5;@78 23 564E3> :36@47E3 ;7 823 >3E@9@;7 ;= 823 ;/;:>@7483 37E2 ;= 82@9 ;D:8 :37>3:3> @7 ;**KK *K 47> ;***. * ( 34:73> E;D7936 45534:@7A =;: :395;7>378 ; ?373=@E@4:B 47> 634:73> >>@8@;746 ;F3:7C378 >F;E483 45534:@7A =;: :395;7>378 ;9 47> >; 7;8 >@95D83 823 =4E8 ;= 37247E3C378 ;= E;C537948@;7 ;= 9(*(. /53:4E:3=;:823647>4EHD@:3>=;:82394C3 5:;I3E8D7>3:7;8@=@E48@;7;=823B34:..* 34:73> E;D79369 =;: 823 :395;7>3789 =D:823: 9D?C@8 8248 823 39E4648@;7 48 )L 53: 477DC @9 ;7 823 2@A23:9@>3-@8282@9823B5:4B8;54999D@84?63;:>3: K 4F@7A 234:> 823 634:73> E;D7936 =;: 823 54:8@39 82@9 ;D:8 53:D93> 823 @C5DA73> ID>AC378 47> ;823:C483:@46564E3>;7:3E;:> - 6 - ) 23 >@9847E3 ?38<337 823 647> 4EHD@:3> @7 823 5:39378E49347>4:9D:F@664A3@9484?;D8/(G@6;C383:9 23 647> 4EHD@:3> @7 823 5:39378 E493 47> @7 823 E493 :36@3>D5;7?B823634:73>E;D7936=;:82345536647894:3 =;:82394C35:;I3E8 . ;79@>3:@7A 823 94C3 823 C4:G38 F46D3 <2@E2 249 ?337 =@J3> @7 ;***(( * 48 9(*(. / 53: 4E:3 :3HD@:39 8; ?3 84G37 <@82 39E4648@;7 23 ;/ ;:>@748337E239;=82@9;D:8@78<;>3E@9@;79:36@3>D5;7 ?B823634:73>E;D7936=;:823455366478924F3E;79@>3:3> 39E4648@;7 48 )L 53: 477DC 7 F@3< ;= 823 94C3 39E4648@;7@98;?384G3748)L53:477DC@78235:39378 E493 469; = 823 39E4648@;7 48 )L 53: 477DC @9 84G37 39E4648@;7 =;: 8<; B34:9 ;7 9(*(. / E;C39 8; 9K). / 37E3 823 4553664789 E64@C4789 4:3 378@863>8;E;C537948@;748 9K). /53:4E:3<@82466 9848D8;:B?373=@89 - 7 - * 7823:39D68823=;66;<@7A " #$ 23455346@9<@82E;98 #$ 23 ID>AC378 47> 4<4:> 54993> ?B 823 @F@6 !D>A3 #:7$ 2@8845D: >483> **** @7 ;. ** 47> 469; 823 ID>AC378 47> 4<4:> 54993> ?B 823 >>@8@;746 @98:@E8 !D>A3 464?D:4A@ >483> **( @7 ; *4:3C;>@=@3> #$ 23 4553664789 4:3 378@863> =;: E;C537948@;7 @7 :3953E8;=647>?34:@7AB;)C349D:@7A4E:39 .AD7849;=462@554:A4F@664A346DG42@8845D: @98:@E8464?D:4A@@749DC;= 9K). /53: 4E:3<@824669848D8;:B?373=@89 #$ 8 @9 C4>3 E634: 8248 823 4553664789 4:3 7;8 378@863>=;:47B@783:398@7:3953E8;=>364B53:@;> ;=.>4B9?3=;:3823%@:9855366483;D:847> ((>4B9?3=;:382@9;D:8 - 8 - #($ @A28 <33G9 8@C3 @9 A:4783> 8; C4G3 A;;> 823 >3=@E@8;D:8=33 #$ :4< 4<4:> ;76B 4=83: 54BC378 ;= >3=@E@8 ;D:8 =33 +, (&&) %" @98;6;.