- 1 - !" #$#% &'$!' (!!) ! " # $ $ % $ &'# % &()*#'# + % &()*#'# ® Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $$$ , &()*#'# ( % $$ &()*'- ! $#+. $%(" $ * / $ $ " $ $ '-#'' + & $ "$ $ ###' &$$#$+ $ 0 - 3 - !0 " 123234516 37 8 94:85 ;1<45=35= 24 >?1@A<1@ 63;1 >4::A532B ?1 ?87 8CC<31@ D46 2?1 C472 4D 5=8598@3 46E1682 =868E?1@F( 5=8598@315216355@38<AE ?161 37 54 61716G82345 C64G3@1@ 35 2?1 783@ 5=8598@3 1521652?1=64A5@2?82G16BD19C472786161716G1@ D46>?1@A<1@63;1>85@3@8217352?11523615@328<AE35 617C1>2 4D 5=8598@3 46E167 2?1 C123234516 :8@1 61C617152823457 24 2?1 617C45@1527 24 61>4573@16 2?1 61716G82345C4<3>B?178:1?87542;115>4573@161@;B 2?1 2821 ==631G1@ ;B 2?1 78:1 2?1 C123234516 ?87 C61D1661@2?379632C1232345 2 37 7A;:3221@ 2?82 C4<3>B 4D 61716G82345 8@4C21@ ;B 2?1 2821 D46 5=8598@3 46E167 37 35 >45268G1523454D2?1C4<3>B4D2?128218@4C21@61=86@35= 2?1 >3G3< C4727 2 37 7A;:3221@ 2?82 2?1 61716G823457 861 542=3G15D46 5=8598@346E167 87 >4521:C<821@ 352?1 6472168@4C21@24D3<<2?1>3G3<C4727352?128212378<74 - 4 - 7A;:3221@2?822?161716G82345C4<3>B8@4C21@;B2?12821 61=86@35= 5=8598@3 46E167 G34<8217 2?1 >457232A23458< :85@82152?1783@=64A5@3237C68B1@2?82423D3>82345 @821@ '-#'' ! 551HA61& 24 2?1 9632 C1232345" ;B 9?3>? 8CC<3>823457 861 35G321@ D46 2?1 C472 4D 5=8598@3 46E16782G8634A7 5=8598@3152167352?15@328<AE;1 712873@12378<74C68B1@2?828@361>2345:8B;1377A1@ 24 2?1 617C45@1527 24 >4573@16 2?1 61IA172 4D 2?1 C123234516 35 1H215@35= ;12216 61716G82345 D46 2?1 >?1@A<1@63;17 + <18651@ @@323458< @G4>821 15168< :2 6>?858 39863 8CC18635= D46 617C45@152 47# 24 + 7A;:327 2?82 C64G3@35= 61716G82345 37 2?1 C6164=823G1 4D 2?1 2821 ?1 DA62?16 7A;:327 2?82 2?1 C4724D 5=8598@346E1673785?454686BC47285@5428 >3G3<C472D462?826187452?16472168CC<3>8;<124>3G3<C472 375428CC<31@24 5=8598@346E1672378<74>45215@1@ 2?82 32 37 542 87 3D 2?1 2821 ?87 542 C64G3@1@ D46 61716G82345 9?3<1 71<1>235= 2?1 5=8598@3 46E167 ;A2 - 5 - ?87 28E15 8 @1>37345 24 C64G3@1 61716G82345 24 >?1@A<1@ 8721785@ >?1@A<1@ 63;17 >4::A532317 ;871@ 452?136 C4CA<82345 72615=2? 35 2?1617C1>23G1 5=8598@3 152167 2 37 7A;:3221@ 2?82 9?161 2?1 C4CA<82345 4D >?1@A<1@ 8721737:4612?85'J358C8623>A<86>152162?1C47237 61716G1@D468>?1@A<1@8721>85@3@8213:3<86<B9?15 2?1C4CA<823454D>?1@A<1@63;137:4612?85'J3585B 5=8598@3152162?1783@C4723761716G1@D46>?1@A<1@ 63;1>85@3@8212377A;:3221@2?82352?13572852>871 2?161861G16BD19C167457;1<45=35=24>?1@A<1@63;135 =868E?1@8&( 5=8598@3 15216 $46 2?82 618745 2?1 78:13754261716G1@D46>?1@A<1@63;12377A;:3221@ 2?82 2?1 C123234516 8D216 618<3K35= 2?82 7?1 :8B 542 ;1 :16324634A7 154A=? 24 =12 61>6A321@ ?87 :8@1 61C61715282345785@6A7?1@24D3<12?135728529632C1232345 52?1783@=64A5@73237C68B1@2?822?19632C1232345:8B ;1@37:3771@ IA8<32B 37 8 DA5@8:1528< C635>3C<1 4D 2?1 457232A2345 ?1 2821 7?4A<@ 542 @15B 24 85B C16745 - 6 - 1IA8<32B ;1D461 2?1 <89 85@ 2?1 1IA8< C6421>2345 4D <897 5D462A5821<B :461 4D215 2?85 542 @37>63:3582345 ;871@ 45 ;362? ?87 ;115 C862 4D 4A6 >A<2A61 4 4G16>4:1 2?1 78:1 24 C64G3@1 85 1IA8< 72862 35 <3D1 85@ 1IA8< 4CC462A532BD468<<>323K15724618>?2?136DA<<C4215238<2?1 >45>1C2 4D C6421>23G1 @37>63:3582345 D35@7 8 C<8>1 35 4A6 457232A2345 1716G82345 37 C862 4D 32 ?1 CA6C471 4D C6421>23G1 @37>63:3582345 46 61716G82345 37 24 >A61 2?1 @378;3<32B 2?82 8 C16745 37 7A;L1>21@ 24 ;1>8A71 4D 2?1 =64AC ?1 ;1<45=7 ?1 2821 9?3<1 C64G3@35= D46 61716G82345 ?87 24 E11C 2?37 D8>246 35 :35@ ?1 4;L1>2 7?4A<@ ;1 24 >A61 2?1 @378;3<32B 85@ ;635= 8;4A2 1IA8<32B 8:45=72 2?1 >323K157 85@ 32 7?4A<@ 542 ;1 ;871@ 45G421 ;85E C4<323>7 ;B 8CC18735= 2?1 5A:163>8<<B 72645= =64AC ?1 C4CA<82345 4D 8 C8623>A<86 >4::A532B 35 8 C8623>A<86 8618 :8B5428<98B7 ;1 2?163=?28CC648>? 24@1216:351 2?161716G82345242?82>4::A532B3:3<86<B1>454:3>46 C4<323>8< ;8>E986@5177 8<451 :8B 8<74 542 ;1 2?1 63=?2 >6321638 45 8<< 4>>873457 ?1 IA172345 61IA361@ 24 ;1 - 7 - 8579161@ 37 9?12?16 8 C16745 ;1<45=35= 24 8 C8623>A<86 >4::A532B 46 =64AC 37 7A;L1>21@ 24 @37>63:3582345 D64: 2?174>312B467A;L1>21@24>162835@378;3<32B352?174>312B ;1>8A71?1;1<45=7242?82C8623>A<86=64AC46>4::A532B 9?3>??87C61G1521@?3:D64:?8G35=851IA8<7286235<3D1 85@@1531@4D1IA8<4CC462A532B24618>??37DA<<C4215238< 878>323K15 ( 491G16 2?1 @1216:3582345 4D 2?171 D8>2467 37 ;172 <1D224 2?1 937@4: 4D2?1<1=37<82461H1>A23G1 87 2?1 >871 :8B ;1 85@ 2?1 4A627 7?4A<@ ;1 61<A>2852 24 35216D161 35 2?1 78:1 A5<177 32 37 7?495 2?82 2?1 <1=37<8234537A<268G36A72?1C64G373454D2?1457232A234546 35>8714D1H1>A23G146@16@1<1=821@<1=37<823452?178:1 37G34<8235=2?1C64G3734574D2?1457232A2345462?17282A21 87 2?1 >871 :8B ;1 5 2?1 3572852 >871 2?1 C64G373457 61<8235=248CC4352:1524D 5=8598@346E16761G18<2?82 2?1783@C47237?454686BC47285@5428>3G3<C472 - 8 - * $46 2?82 618745 2?1 2821 ?87 >45><A@1@ 2?82 61716G823457 24 2?1 783@ C472 >85542 ;1 8>>46@1@ 87 C16 2?1647216D4<<491@D462?1>3G3<C472 / 5 2?1 3572852 5423D3>82345 2?82 37 A5@16 >?8<<15=1 2?1 61<1G852 C64G37345 61=86@35= 2?1 78:1 9?3>?37358558@8618@787D4<<49785@3261D<1>279?82 ?87;1157A::863K1@8;4G1 !"#$% &!"' & !"# ( )# )*+,-. !/ 0 /% 12 / % 0/!3! ! /%0/!3! ! 4567 8 9: 5 ! / 4;. 5 ! < => !/?! "' !/! :@ 8 9:3 < =>0&AB7!%C5#D !" !EF!;.' G # 0H => 8 9:*% !& !" C ;&( +!I ) ?1:18535=4D8D461:1523451@><8A71:8E1732 ><186 2?82 C472 4D 2?1 5=8598@3 46E16 37 8 ?454686B - 9 - C472 85@ 2?1 C16745 71<1>21@ 93<< ;1 C83@ 8 ?4546863A: 85@3754215232<1@2478<86B - 18651@ @@323458< @G4>821 15168< 7A;:327 2?822?1 5=8598@3152167861>61821@932?85352152345 4DC64G3@35=>861D462?1>?3<@6154D2?1G3<<8=185@328<74 8>27 87 8 @8B >861 >15216 D46 2?1 >?3<@615 4D 2?1 G3<<8=1 9?1615A263234A7D44@37D1@242?1E3@785@;873>1@A>82345 373:C8621@242?1:28<74D8>3<328217;42?2?1C8615274D 2?1E3@72482215@946E@A635=2?1@8B23:13@7;1<45= 24 @3DD16152 >4::A532317 ;135= 24=12?16 32 8<74 D472167 1IA8<32B 85@ ?1<C7 24 168@3>821 @37>63:3582345 ;871@ 45 >4::A532B 2 37 7A;:3221@ 2?82 5=8598@3 46E16 37 61IA361@24357C361>45D3@15>14D8<<2?1G3<<8=16785@>861 D468<<2?1E3@736617C1>23G14D2?1>4::A532B85@8C16745 37>?471528E35=8<<2?171D8>24673524>4573@1682345 #' 16A78< 4D 2?1 3:CA=51@ 5423D3>82345 :8E17 32 ><186 2?82 2?1 C472 4D 5=8598@3 46E16 37 8 ?454686B C47285@323754261IA361@D462?1282124D4<<492?178:1 647216 2?82 37 D4<<491@ 35 617C1>2 4D 2?1 >3G3< C472 - 10 - 61=86@35= C64G3@35= 61716G823457 ?1 783@ C4<3>B 4D 2?1 2821 37 542 35 G34<82345 4D 2?1 C64G373457 4D 2?1 457232A23454685B7282A215@162?1783@>36>A:7285>17 32 ?87 24 ;1 >45><A@1@ 2?82 2?1 63=?27 4D 2?1 C123234516 ?8G1542;115G34<821@;B2?13:CA=51@5423D3>82345 ## 2375422?1>8714D2?1C1232345162?827?1?87 542 ;115 C16:3221@ 24 8CC<B D46 2?1 C472 4D 5=8598@3 46E16 ?1 >85542 @1:85@ 2?1 783@ C472 ?87 24 ;1 51>177863<B 61716G1@ D46 2?1 >?1@A<1@ 63;1 5 2?1 3572852 >871 32 37 8 15168< 1632 C472 85@ 2?1 C123234516 >85 8<74 C8623>3C821 35 2?1 71<1>2345 C64>177 85@ 617C45@1527861;4A5@2471<1>2?163D7?137D4A5@24;1 2?1:472:16324634A78:45=8<<2?18CC<3>8527 # 75463=?274D2?1C123234516?87;115G34<821@ 2?19632C123234537?161;B #+ 1=3726B 37 @361>21@ 24 612A65 ;8>E 2?1 463=358< 61>46@77A;:3221@;B2?1617C45@152&2821 - 11 - # 5 G319 4D @37:3778< 4D 2?1 9632 C1232345 4#'(@417 542 7A6G3G1 D46 >4573@1682345 85@ 2?1 78:1378>>46@35=<B@37:3771@ !*+ (') $ #/