- 1 - ! "# $"%"" && '&( ) ! "# $!%& ' () * + ) $!%& ) !& $!%& * ) ) !!) Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $!%& ' (, ))) *, * + * && * $ %$&$&# * & ) * $&-$& # * &) ** .) % " /01 233425 01 67 8/4 3520980::1 09 ;#& 6409< 2<<=04>4? 67 8/4 @A?<B498 29? ?4C=44 ?284? &-& 32114? 67 8/4 ??080;925 0>05 A?<4 0@2723A=2(:;=1/;=8D8/4=025;A=8E+?01B01109<8/41A08 ;: 8/4 3520980::1 F/0C/ 01 C;9:0=B4? 67 8/4 @A?<B498 29? ?4C=44?284?%&&#32114?09;&;98/4 :054 ;: 8/4 ??5 490;= 0>05 A?<4 ??5 0@2723A=2(:;=1/;=8D8/4*0=1833455284;A=8E+ - 3 - /41A0801:054?678/43520980::1:;=?4C52=280;9 32=8080;929?1432=2843;114110;9144G09<8/40="8/1/2=4 098/41A083=;34=87214;:8/43520980::1018/288/4529? 642=09< 7; B421A=09< 2C=41 <A9821 108A284? 28 2B6/23A= 0552<4 H 018 )0@23A= F21 3A=C/214? 67 2552332 2>A82332 ;90 29? 2552332 2884?0984=B1;:?44?;:1254?284?&&#% /288/4 120?34=1;91/2??0>0?4?8/43=;34=870984=B1;:F/0C/29 4I8498 ;: ! 2C=41 <A9821 F21 255;884? 8; 8/4 1/2=4 ;: 2552332;904>4=109C48/49/4/216449093;114110;9 29? 49@;7B498 ;: 8/4 12B4 25;9< F08/ 8/4 3520980::1 21 @;098 :2B057 3=;34=87 2552332 ;90 32114? 2F27 ;9 &&&&#542>09< 64/09?A1/052 /01 F0:4 3520980:: ; 1;9$2=21/A=2B$3520980::;29??2A</84=1$/2992FF2$ 3520980:: ; 29? =2GG2$?4:49?298 ; /28 3520980::1 9;80C4? 2552332 ;90 /2? 2554<4?57 1;5? 8/4 3=;34=87 09 :2>;A= ;: ?4:49?298 ; A9?4= ?44? ;: 1254 ?284? !&### /4 120? ?44? ;: 1254 01 >;0? /4 3520980::1 233=;2C/4??4:49?298;2742=5284=A3;9/01?49025 - 4 - 8/47 /2>4 :054? 2 1A08 :;= 32=8080;9 29? 3;114110;9 ;: 8/4 1A083=;34=87 4:49?298 ; =4B2094? 261498 29? F21 352C4?4I$32=84 " 4:49?298 ; /21 C;984984? 8/28 8/4 1A08 ;: 8/43520980::101:2514:=0>;5;A129??4904?8/41A08;:8/4 3520980::1 8 01 C;984984? 8/28 ;=0<092557 ;94 29<2FF2 F0:4 ;: 0??2332 ;52129<0 F21 8/4 ;F94= ;: 8/4 529? 642=09<7; 1/4?04?;9&&#%&29?2134=8/4 055 ?284? &#-& 4I4CA84? 67 /4= 09 :2>;A= ;: /4= 1;91$09$52F A9?2332 A=A32?2332 05>290 8/40= 92B41 F4=44984=4?098;098/4=4>49A4=4C;=?1/4120?34=1;91 1;5? 8/4 529? 09 :2>;A= ;: 2552332 2>A82332 ;90 29? 2552332 /29926212332 2884? 09 84=B1 ;: =4<0184=4? 1254 ?284? &&#% /28 09 8/4 32=8080;9 4::4C84? 648F449 8/4B 4184=9 3;=80;9 B421A=09< ! 2C=41 29? <A9821F21255;884?8/41/2=4;: 25523322>A82332;90 211AC//4F218/4261;5A84;F94=;:8/43=;34=87/2>09< - 5 - 2CHA0=4?8/412B4;A8;:/01;F942=909<1;5?8/412B4 :2>;A= ;: ?4:49?298 ; 09 84=B1 ;: ?44? ;: 1254 ?284? !&###:;=>25A26541254C;910?4=280;9/28?4:49?298 ;098A=91;5?8/4120?3=;34=8709:2>;A=;:?4:49?298 ; 0984=B1;:=4<0184=4??44?;:1254?284?&&-&& /28 8/4 3520980::1 29? ?4:49?298 ; /2>4 9; 1/2=4 =0</8 80854 ;>4= 8/4 1A08 3=;34=87 49C4 1;A</8 :;= ?01B01125 ! /4=025;A=8:=2B4?8/4:;55;F09<011A41:;= 081C;910?4=280;9, ! ! " # - 6 - 9 233=4C0280;9 ;: 8/4 4>0?49C4 291F4=4? 011A4 ;1 8; " 09 8/4 94<280>4 29? C;914HA49857 ?01B0114? 8/4 1A08 )409< 2<<=04>4? 3520980::1 3=4:4==4? 8/4 =4<A52= 233425 09 ;& 64:;=4 8/4 *0=18 33455284;A=8/4:;55;F09<3;0981F4=4:=2B4?678/4 *0=1833455284;A=8, $ " ! $" % ! & # - 9 =4$C;910?4=280;9 ;: 8/4 4>0?49C4 8/4 *0=18 33455284 ;A=8 291F4=4? 8/4 3;098 ;1 8; 09 8/4 2::0=B280>4 3;098 ;" 09 8/4 94<280>4 29? C;914HA49857 ?01B0114?8/4233425C;9:0=B09<8/4@A?<B49829??4C=44 32114?678/4=025;A=8 - 7 - % 42=94? C;A9145 23342=09< :;= 8/4 3520980::1$ 2334552981 82G09< 8/01 ;A=8 8/=;A</ 8/4 =4C;=?1 1A6B081 8/28 8/4 2CHA01080;9 ;: 8/4 3=;34=87 67 2552332 2>A82332;90F21251;?A48;8/4C;98=06A80;9B2?467 8/4 3520980:: ; /01 F0:4 21 1AC/ /4 ?0? 9;8 /2>4 297 4IC5A10>4=0</8;>4=8/43=;34=8709C48/43=;34=87F21 2CHA0=4?676;8/ 25523322>A82332;9029?A1/052$8/4 3520980:: ; 8/;A</ 8/4?44? ;: 1254 F21 B2?4 ;957 09 8/4 92B4 ;: 2552332 2>A82332 ;90 8/4 3520980::1 251; /2>4 1/2=4 =0</8 80854 09 8/4 3=;34=87 F/0C/ C;A5? 9;8 /2>4644925049284?F08/;A88/40=C;91498/4=4:;=41/4 1A6B081 8/28 1A618298025 HA4180;9 ;: 52F =2014? 09 8/4 B2884==4HA0=41C;910?4=280;9 # 9 8/4 ;8/4= /29? 542=94? C;A9145 23342=09< :;= =413;9?498 ;1 29? 1A6B08 8/28 2?B0884?57 8/4 3=;34=87 F21 3A=C/214? 09 84=B1 ;: ?44? ;: 1254 ?284? &&#% 67 2552332 2>A82332 ;90 29? 2552332 2882?29?8/4=4019;4>0?49C4;9=4C;=?8;1/;F8/288/4 3=;34=87 F21 3A=C/214? 408/4= 67 8/4 C;98=06A80;9 ;: - 8 - 3520980:: ; ;= :=;B 297 @;098 :2B057 =41;A=C41 /4=4:;=4 8/47 1A6B08 8/28 8/4 3=;34=87 01 8/4 261;5A84 3=;34=87 ;: 2552332 2>A82332 ;90 29? /4 /2? 4>4=7 =0</8 8; 25049284 8/4 12B4 /28 8/4 =025 ;A=8 29? 8/4 *0=18 33455284 ;A=8 /2>4 C;BB0884? 9; 4==;= 9; 1A618298025HA4180;9;:52FF;A5?2=014:;=C;910?4=280;9 & 42=?4=A14?8/4=4C;=?1 /4=4 01 9; ?013A84 ;: 8/4 :2C8 8/28 8/4 1A08 3=;34=87 :;=B4? 32=8 ;: 52=<4= 4I8498 ;: & 2C=41 <A9821F/0C/F213A=C/214?67 25523322>A82332;90 29?/299262123322884?0984=B1;:?44?;:1254?284? &&#% /288/4120?34=1;91/2?8/4=42:84=?0>0?4? 8/43=;34=87648F4498/4B145>4142C/6409<4980854?:;=! 2C=41<A982142C/;8/09<01352C4?;9=4C;=?8;1/;F 8/28 8/4 120? 3=;34=87 F21 2CHA0=4? 67 2552332 2>A82332 ;90 :=;B 297 ;: 8/4 1;A=C41 408/4= :=;B 8/4 C;98=06A80;9;:3520980::; ;=:=;B297;8/4=@;098:2B057 :A9?1 - 9 - /4 =025 ;A=8 29? 8/4 *0=18 33455284 ;A=8 82G09< 9;84 ;: 8/414 2134C81 ;:B2884= /2>4 C;B48; 8/4 C;9C5A10;9 8/28 8/4 3=;34=87 F21 8/4 145:$2CHA0=4? 261;5A843=;34=87;:120? 25523322>A82332;9029?/4 /2>09</2?4>4=7=0</88;?425F08/8/412B4092B2994= /4354214?98/426149C4;:297B284=0254>0?49C46409< 352C4? ;9=4C;=?8; 1/;F 8/42CHA01080;9;:3=;34=87F21 :=;B29?;A8;:8/4@;098:2B057;::A9?1;=:=;B297;8/4= B4B64=1C;98=06A809<8;8/412B4/4=025;A=829?8/4 *0=18 33455284 ;A=8 /2>4 C;BB0884? 9; 4==;= 09 ?01B01109<8/41A08;:8/43520980::1 ; 1A618298025 HA4180;9 ;: 52F F;A5? 2=014 :;= C;910?4=280;9CC;=?09<5712B401 *+ '""( % #