- 1 - !" #$%% "" &%' ( ! " # #" $%&$'((& ( )(*+ , ## - )(*+ "" # ,. ! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # /%! # # " ,+&,+' " %'',+* # //++$ %+/(+++$ '0 # " # # " 1 " $ 2345 655732829 :; <=2 >?95@24< 649 6A679 96<29 ,+&,+' B6CC29 34 D%'',+* :; <=2 $99E 3C< 2CC3D4C "?952 63F=?7 =272346G<27 72G27729 <D 6C H<=2 73:?46EI GD7 C=D7<! <=2 6BB2EE64<$ FE63@64< 3C :2GD72 <=3C D?7< C22J345 24=64F2@24< DG FD@B24C6<3D4 , 732GG6F<CE269345<DG3E345DGFE63@B2<3<3D4672 <=6<D4'+&,+/6<6:D?<++B@<=2FE63@64<A6C <7682E345 34 6 2@BD DDG64 "22B :267345 25D$ %&$'((& A3<= D<=27 83EE6527C 649 <=2 72CBD4924< D - 3 - :2345 <=2 973827 DG C639 "22B 97D82 <=2 C6@2 A3<= =35= CB22964934676C=649425E3524<@6442764996C=29<D6 2E2F<73F BDE2 649 <=2 82=3FE2 <?7429 <?7<E29 34 <=2 6573F?E<?72 G32E9 ?2 <D <=2 C639 6FF3924< <=2 FE63@64< C?C<6342957328D?C649@?E<3BE234>?732C=234>?732C=682 72C?E<29 34 B27@6424< B67<36E 93C6:3E3<; 649 C6@2 =6C 6GG2F<29 =3C G?<?72 2674345 F6B6F3<; =2 FE63@64< FD4<24929 <=6< =2 =68345 C?GG2729 <=2 34>?732C 3C 24<3<E29 GD7FD@B24C6<3D4G7D@<=272CBD4924<C % 267429 FD?4C2E 6BB267345 GD7 <=2 6BB2EE64<$ FE63@64< AD?E9 FD4<249 <=6< 6< <=2 <3@2 DG 6FF3924< <=2 652 DG <=2 FE63@64< A6C + ;267C 649 9D345 6573F?E<?72 AD7J 649 =2 A6C 2674345 @D72 <=64 C(+++$ B27 @D4<= =2FE63@64<=69 C?C<63429 F?<E6F276<29 AD?49C D827 735=< 2;2:7DA 649 GD72=269 A3<= C?CB2F<29 G76F<?72 DG E2G< A73C< E2G< 64JE2 649 E2G< G2@?7 649 FE63@64< A6C C?:>2F<29 <D 7693DED53F6E 2K6@346<3D4 649 3< A6C GD?49 <=6< <=2 FE63@64< C?C<63429 34<27 <7DF=64<273F G76F<?72 DG E2G< G2@?7 649 G76F<?72 DG E2G< 6FF2<6:6E2@ G76F<?72 DG - 4 - 93C<6E%79DGC=6G<DG?E46G76F<?72DG?E46C<;ED39B7DF2CC 64993C<6E249DG7693?CG76F<?72DG93C<6E%79DGC=6G<DG E2G< G3:?E6 A3<= CDG< <3CC?2 34>?7; 2 G?7<=27 FD4<24929 <=6< <=2 FD@B24C6<3D4 6A67929 :; <=2 73:?46E <DA679C B634 649 C?GG27345 EDCC DG G?<?72 34FD@2 EDCC DG 34FD@2 9?7345 E639 ?B B273D9 649 D<=27 =269C 672 D4 <=2 EDA27 C3922G?7<=27FD4<24929<=6<<=2DF<D7$,A=D=6C 3CC?29 93C6:3E3<; F27<3G3F6<2 $ K' 649 =6C 6CC2CC29 B27@6424<B67<36E93C6:3E3<;6</(0<D<=2A=DE2:D9;:?< <=2 73:?46E =6C <6J24 (0 D4E; A=3F= 3C D4 <=2 EDA27 C392 2 G?7<=27 C?:@3<C <=6< <=2 FE63@64< :2345 6573F?E<?73C< =6C 6GG2F<29 =3C G?<?72 2674345 F6B6F3<; 649 FD4C3927345 <=2 C6@2 <=2 FD@B24C6<3D4 6A67929 :; <=2 73:?46E ?4927 6EE =269C 672 D4 <=2 EDA27 C392 24F2 C22JC GD7 24=64F2@24< DG FD@B24C6<3D4 :; 6EEDA345 <=2 6BB26E E267429 FD?4C2E 6BB267345 GD7 <=2 72CBD4924< D,$ 4C?764F2 D@B64; FD4<24929 <=6< <=2 FD@B24C6<3D4 6A67929 :; <=2 73:?46E 3C 692L?6<2 - 5 - FD4C3927345<=265234FD@264968DF6<3D4DG<=2FE63@64< 649 <=272 3C 4D 4229 GD7 64; 34<27G2724F2 :; <=3C D?7< 24F2B76;CGD793C@3CC6EDG6BB26E ( 68345 =2679 E267429 FD?4C2EC <=3C D?7< B27?C29 <=2 3@B?5429 >?95@24< 649 <=2 736E D?7< 2FD79C & =2 96<2 DG <=2 6FF3924< 652 DG <=2 FE63@64< 649E36:3E3<;D4<=2 4C?764F2D@B64;6724D<3493CB?<2 / =2 6BB2EE64<$FE63@64< =6C C?C<63429 <=722 G76F<?72C 333! * =2 9DF<D7$, A=3E2 3CC?345 93C6:3E3<; F27<3G3F6<26<K'=6CC<6<29<=6<6BB2EE64<$FE63@64<=6C - 6 - C?C<63429 /(093C6:3E3<;<D<=2 A=DE2:D9; D4C3927345 <=2 C639 6CB2F< <=2 93C6:3E3<; <6J24 :; <=2 73:?46E 6< (03CD4<=2EDA27C3923<C=D?E9:2<6J246<%+0 ' D 6ECD 34FD@2 <6J24 :; <=2 73:?46E 6< C/+++$ B27 @D4<= 3C D4 <=2 EDA27 C392 C B27 <=2 5?392E342C3CC?29:;GD7<=2B?7BDC2DGC2<<E2@24< DG 93CB?<2C :2GD72 <=2 DJ$96E6<= B72CF73:2 6 4D<3D46E 34FD@2 DG C+,(+$ GD7 <=2 ;267 ,+/ 73:?46E =6C 735=<E; 6BBE329 @?E<3BE327 6< H(I =272GD72 FD4C3927345 <=2C6@2<=2EDCCDGG?<?7234FD@23CF6EF?E6<296C?4927 C+,(+$K,K(K%+0M)*+ + =2 FE63@64< =6C C?C<63429 57328D?C 34>?732C D4C3927345 <=2 C6@2 <=2 6@D?4< 6A67929 :; <=2 73:?46E <DA679C B634 649 C?GG27345 6< C&++++$ 3C D4 <=2EDA27C392649C,++++$<DA679CEDCCDG6@243<32C 3C6ECDD4<=2EDA27C392A=3F=4229C<D:224=64F29<D ),+26F= - 7 - =2 73:?46E =6C 735=<E; 6A67929 6 C?@ DG ) *, + <DA679C @293F6E 2KB24C2C. ) + <DA679CGDD94D?73C=@24<649FD482;64F2.) + 6<<24964< F=6752C. 649 ) + <DA679C G?<?72 @293F6E2KB24C2C , =2 FE63@64< A6C 69@3<<29 34 <=2 =DCB3<6E 649 6983C29 GD7 72C< GD7 @D72 <=64 <AD @D4<=C D4C3927345 <=2C6@2=23C24<3<E29GD7EDCCDG34FD@29?7345E639?B B273D9 GD7 <=722 @D4<=C <=6< 3C )*,+ C+,(+$ K%! % =?C <=2 FE63@64< 3C 24<3<E29 GD7 GDEEDA345 6@D?4<DGFD@B24C6<3D4 - ./0) 1234 /5/60.07849. 6:723/- 1234 /5/60.078 49:)264 DCCDGG?<?7234FD@2 C*'+++$ C((%(++$ , 634649C?GG27345 C&++++$ C/(+++$ % 293F6E2KB24C2C C%/&$ C%/&$ #?<?72@293F6E2KB24C2C C,++++$ C,++++$ ( DA679CEDCCDG6@243<32C C,++++$ C/(+++$ & <<24964<F=6752C C++++$ C++++$ / #DD96494D?73C=@24<. FD482;64F2F=6752C C(+++$ C(+++$ * DCCDG34FD@29?7345 E639?BB273D9 C+++$ C%+/(+$ 4/- &6230.04' ) , , + ) , ,+ ) + ) *+ 39/3;.1.34 ) *+ - 8 - 34F2 A3<=D?< 64; :6C3C <=2 73:?46E =6C 5764<29 34<272C< 6< <=2 76<2 DG *0 B6 <=2 C6@2 3C 729?F29<D&0B6 ( 4<=272C?E<<=26BB26E92C2782C<D:26EEDA29 34$B67<24F2<=2GDEEDA345 3! =26BB26E3C6EEDA2934$B67< 33! =2 6BB2EE64<$FE63@64< 3C 24<3<E29 <D <D<6E FD@B24C6<3D4 DG ) *+ 65634C< C//++$ 6C 6A67929 :; <=2 73:?46E 6ED45 A3<= 34<272C< 6< <=276<2 DG&0 B6 G7D@<=296<2DGB2<3<3D4<3EE3<C92BDC3< 333! =272CBD4924<D,$ 4C?764F2FD@B64;3C 9372F<29 <D 92BDC3< <=2 FD@B24C6<3D4 6@D?4< A3<=34 6 B273D9 DG 235=< A22JC G7D@ <=3C 96; G63E345 A=3F= 3< C=6EE F677; 34<272C<6<<=276<2DG'0B6<3EEB6;@24< - 9 - 38! =2 D7927 DG 92BDC3< 649 72E26C2 34 G68D?7 DG <=2 FE63@64< B6CC29 :; <=2 73:?46E 72@634C?46E<2729 8! =2 253C<7; 3C 9372F<29 <D C249 :6FJ <=2 72FD79C 6ED45 A3<= FDB; DG <=3C >?95@24< <D<=2FD4F27429D?7< 0+ &%%' $ %& .