Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43618 (KAR)
CHETAN v. SANTOSH AND ANR
MFA/201999/2022 · 2025-11-04
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43618 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43618 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $ %
%%
&"' (
! "# $%% &
'
(#
) *
"#
++
###
! "# $%
&%
+ ,
###"
'
++
-(&' +%
%% + % ## %
+
+
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( #
% %
+ +. %
+
*
%%
+
/
/ 0%
$
123 455647 23 82769 4:42;3< <16 =9:>6;< 4;9 4?4@994<69##5433692;A( #BC<16 992<2A;47 6;2A@ 2D27=9:6 4;9+294@ 4;9 294@ &8A@ 31A@< E<16 <@2B=;47F' 366G2;: 6;14;H6>6;< A8 <16 HA>56;34<2A;
16 2;I=@69 H742>4;< 4:69 ) C64@3 >6< ?2<1 4HH296;< A; # #-# 82769 H742> 56<2<2A; B68A@6 <16 <@2B=;47 366G2;: HA>56;34<2A; A8 3(##### 16 <@2B=;4748<6@HA;3296@2;:<166;<2@66D296;H6A;@6HA@9143 4?4@969 4 3=> A8 3)((( 47A;: ?2<1 2;<6@63< 4< <16 @4<6A8)J56@4;;=>8@A><1694<6A856<2<2A;<277<1694<6 A8@6472K4<2A;::@26D69BC<163429=9:>6;<4;94?4@9<16 H742>4;< 143 5@686@@69 <16 5@636;< 455647 4;9 HA;<6;969 <14< <16 H742>4;< ?43 52772A; @296@ 4;9 16 H4; 5@AH669
- 3 -
4:42;3< 4;C A8 <16 IA2;< <A@<8643A@3 HA;<@2B=<69 8A@ <16 4HH296;<16;H682;92;:A8<16<@2B=;47<14<BA<1<16D612H76 14D6HA;<@2B=<698A@<1634294HH296;<2;<16@4<2AA8 #/ # 4;9 <14< @635A;96;< A3 4;9 4@6 724B76 <A 54C #J A8 <16 HA>56;34<2A; 4>A=;< 23 <A B6 >A928269 16 H742>4;< 143 3=886@69 1649 2;I=@C B=< <16 <@2B=;47 143 ;A< 455@6H24<69<1684H<35@A56@7C4;9:@4;<69>64:6@4>A=;<3 <23473A3<4<69<14<<164>A=;<3:@4;<69=;96@A<16@16493 4@6 A; 7A?6@ 3296 4;9 @6L=63<69 8A@ 6;14;H6>6;< A8 <16 HA>56;34<2A;
( 64@9 <16 4@:=>6;<3 A8 764@;69 HA=;3673 8@A> BA<1329634;956@=369<16@6HA@93
" 16 H742>4;< ?43 <16 52772A; @296@ A8 >A<A@HCH76 B64@2;:@6:23<@4<2A;A( )4;9>6<?2<14HH296;< ?16; <16 3429 D612H76 943169 4:42;3< 4;A<16@ >A<A@HCH76 B64@2;: @6:23<@4<2A; A( - 16 H14@:63166< 23 827694:42;3<BA<1<16D612H7634;92<?431679<14<<16@623 HA>5A32<6;6:72:6;H6A8BA<1329632;<16@4<2AA8 #/ #16 H742>4;<82769H742>56<2<2A;4:42;3<<16A?;6@4;9;3=@6@A8
- 4 -
<16 >A<A@HCH76 B64@2;: @6:23<@4<2A; A( ) 26 @635A;96;<A34;916H742>4;<143;A<2>5764969<16 A?;6@ 4;9 ;3=@6@ A8 <16 >A<A@HCH76 B64@2;: @6:23<@4<2A;
A( - 16 <@2B=;47 92@6H<69 <16 @635A;96;< A3 4;9 <A 54C A;7C #J A8 <16 HA>56;34<2A; 2; 84H< <16H742>4;<23<1652772A;@296@4;916234<72B6@<C<AH742> <16##JHA>56;34<2A;4:42;3<4;CA8<16IA2;<<A@<8643A@3 16;H6 <16 @635A;96;< A3 4;9 B62;: <16 A?;6@ 4;9 ;3=@6@A8>A<A@HCH76B64@2;:@6:23<@4<2A;A( ) 4@6 92@6H<69 <A 54C <16 6;<2@6 HA>56;34<2A; 4>A=;< 4;9 74<6@ <16C H4; @6HAD6@ #J A8 <16 HA>56;34<2A; 4>A=;< 8@A> <16 A?;6@ 4;9 2;3=@6@ A8 <16 >A<A@HCH76 B64@2;:
@6:23<@4<2A;A( -BC9=65@AH633A874?
16H742>4;<3=3<42;698@4H<=@6A8@2:1<<6>5A@47 54@26<47BA;66M<@49=@4716>A<A>4 ?2<1>A336886H<4356@ M% <16 9234B272<C H6@<282H4<6 < ?43 233=69 BC AD6@;>6;< A8 ;924 2;23<@C A8 AH247 =3<2H6 4;9 >5A?6@>6;<
654@<>6;<A86>5A?6@>6;<A856@3A;3?2<1 9234B272<263;<1634299234B272<CH6@<282H4<6<169234B272<C?43 433633694< J68=@<16@3<4<69<14<<16@6?438@4H<=@6
- 5 -
A83G=77BA;64;976493<A7AHA>A<A@A79234B272<C16<@2B=;47 HA;3296@2;:<1684H<<14<<169234B272<C?43;A<43363369BC <16 6=@A7A:23< 143 <4G6; 9234B272<C 4< #J <A <16 ?1A76 BA9C2;3<649A8 J
) A;3296@2;:<16;4<=@6A82;I=@263<123A=@<82;93 2<@643A;4B76<A<4G6<169234B272<C4<(#J<A<16?1A76BA9C < 23 3<4<69 <14< <16 H742>4;< ?43 9A2;: >27G D6;92;:
B=32;6334;964@;2;:43=>A83)### 56@>A;<1=<16 143;A<5@A9=H694;C2;HA>65@AA8A8<1634>62;H6<16 H742>4;<>6<?2<14HH296;<2;<16C64@#4356@<16H14@< 5@654@69 BC <16 4@;4<4G4 6:47 6@D2H63 =<1A@2<C 123 2;HA>6 23 <A B6 <4G6; 4< 3- # 6;H6 <16 7A33 A8 8=<=@62;HA>6?A=79B643=;96@/
3- # ...(#JN3-)"##
- 16H742>4;<?4349>2<<692;<16A352<478A@ 94C362;H=@@693--( <A?4@93>692H476M56;363 16 <@2B=;47 143 4?4@969 4 3=> A8 3--( <A?4@93 >692H47 6M56;363 ?12H1 ;6693 ;A 2;<6@86@6;H6 A;3296@2;:
<16 4:6 A8 <16 H742>4;< ;4<=@6 A8 2;I=@263 3=3<42;69 4;9 A<16@@676D4;<84H<3<123A=@<82;932<@643A;4B76<A4?4@94
- 6 -
3=>A83- ### <A?4@93542;4;93=886@2;:3(#### <A?4@937A33A84>6;2<263
=6<A<162;I=@26316>2:1<14D6 ;A<4<<6;9694;C?A@G8A@4<7643<32M>A;<136;H643=> A8 3-# ## &3- # . ) >A;<13' 23 4?4@969=;96@ <16 1649 A8 7A33 A8 2;HA>6 9=@2;: 7429 =5 56@2A9 3=> A8 3(#### 23 4?4@969 <A?4@93 6M<@4 ;A=@231>6;< <@4;35A@<4<2A; 4;9 4<<6;94;< H14@:63 6;H6 <16 <A<47 HA>56;34<2A;?A=79B643=;96@/
) *+,-./0*1-+231 /412
A33A88=<=@664@;2;:3 3-)"##
692H476M56;363 3--( ( %42;4;93=886@2;:3 3- ###
" A33A84>6;2<263 3(####
A33 A8 2;HA>6 9=@2;: 7429 =5 56@2A9&3- # .)>A;<13' 3-# ## ) @4;35A@<4<2A; 6M<@4 ;A=@231>6;< 4;9 4<<6;94;< H14@:63 3(####
2+) -5
657
64@;69 HA=;367 8A@ <16 @635A;96;< A ;3=@4H;6HA>54;C3=B>2<3<14< #JA8<16HA>56;34<2A; 4>A=;<4?4@969BC<16<@2B=;47143B66;47@649C965A32<69
HHA@92;:7C<168A77A?2;:/
- 7 -
&2' 1645564723477A?692;54@<,
&22' 16 H742>4;< 23 6;<2<76 <A <A<47 HA>56;34<2A; A8 3")( 47A;: ?2<1 2;<6@63< 4< <16 @4<6 A8 )J 56@ 4;;=> 8@A> <16 94<6 A8 56<2<2A;<277<1694<6A8@6472K4<2A;434:42;3<43=> A83)((( 4?4@969BC<16<@2B=;47,
&222' 16@635A;96;<A;3=@4;H6HA>54;C 23 92@6H<69 <A 54C <16 6;<2@6 HA>56;34<2A; 4>A=;< 4;92<H4;@6HAD6@ #JA8<16HA>56;34<2A;4>A=;< 8@A> <16 A?;6@ 4;9 ;3=@6@ A8 <16 >A<A@HCH76 B64@2;: @6:23<@4<2A;
A( - BC 9=6 5@AH633A874?,
&2D' 16@635A;96;<A2;3=@4;H6HA>54;C 23 92@6H<69 <A 965A32< <16 <A<47 HA>56;34<2A; 47A;: ?2<12;<6@63<?2<12;456@2A9A8A;6>A;<18@A><16 94<6A8<123A@96@,
&D'
; 3=H1 965A32< <16 H742>4;< 23 56@>2<<69 <A ?2<19@4? <16 6;<2@6 HA>56;34<2A; 4>A=;<47A;:?2<12;<6@63<4HH@=69<16@6A;
,7 &% ' $
23<A/7A/