- 1 - ! "# $" % "" " &'&()*'& )) + !" # $ $ "%! # $ &' $ & $ ( ( "&% !%!& "%)& !%! $ $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ $$ "%" ! !&% $ !%! $ ( *+ *+ ,- .-/0/012-3 4-025 /,- 67789-: 02 30;- 1"&% !%!& 1< 8269650 1=07- /6/012 .-2:025 02 1"%)& !%! 12/,-<0=-1</,-::0/0126=09/307/62: -990129183/6:50390//0256/,136.833-509/-3-:<13 /,- 1<<-27-9 .8209,64=- 82:-3 -7/0129 "%" ! 62: !&%1<,636/0>6>6>662,0/6!%!<139,13/**09 4-<13-/,09183/9--?0255362/1<460=82:-3-7/012& 1<,636/0>66563?836?9,662,0/6!%! ! -63: 30 382?8;63 ;63582:6.6 =-632-: 71829-= <13 /,-.-/0/012-3 62:30 1.6=?309,266:6@ =-632-:05,183/ 1@-32;-2/=-6:-3<13/,-3-9.12:-2/ /6/--389-:/,-;6/-306=9123-713: - 3 - 2 @0-A 1< /,- 30@6= 712/-2/0129 835-: 4> /,- =-632-:71829-=9<1341/,/,-.63/0-9/,-.102//,6/A18=: 6309-<13;>71290:-36/01209 B >629A-3/1/,-641@-.102/0902 <13 /,-<1==1A025 & 20/06==>("C;1/,-31</,-:-7-69-:=1:5-: <039/02<13;6/012656029/82?21A2.-391299/6/025/,6/12 /,-:6/-1<0270:-2/12%&"!!%!&:-7-69-:,69512- 18/1</,-,189-82:-3/,-.3-/-D/1<629A-302526/83-E9 76==48/9,-,6:21/3-/832-:/1/,-,189--@-26</-3=6/- 02 /,- 205,/ ,- 67789-: 4-025 /,- ,89462: 1< /,- :-7-69-:-2F803-:6418/,-3A,-3-6418/98/,1A-@-3 12 /,-2-D/:6>,-3:-6:41:> A69<182: 2-63 6 7626= ,-3-<13-9,-989.-7/-:<18=.=6>12/,-.63/1<82?21A2 .-39129 02 7689025 /,- :-6/, 1< /,- :-7-69-: 62: /,89 - 4 - 3-F8-9/-: /,- 1=07- /1 3-509/-3 /,- 769- 62: 02@-9/056/- /,- ;6//-3 7713:025=> $ 76;- /1 4- 3-509/-3-: 62: 02@-9/056/012A6982:-3/6?-2 ,- 7,635-9,--/ 76;- /1 4- <0=-: 656029/ /,- .-/0/012-369/,-91=-67789-:6==-5025/,6/12/,-:6/-1< 0270:-2/A,-2/,-:-7-69-:3-/832-:/1/,-,189-=6/-02 /,-205,/6/""%%.;,-F8-9/012-:/,-:-7-69-:6418/ ,-3 A,-3-6418/9 62: ,- A69 8.9-/ 69 9,- A69 12 /,- .,12- -@-3> /0;- 62: /,-3-4> 9;1/,-3-: ,-3 A0/, 6 .0==1A 69 6 3-98=/ 1< A,07, 9,- :0-: 6/-3 ,- 90=-2/=> 9,0</-:/,-:-6:41:>18/1</,-311;62:/,3-A0/2-636 7626= A,07, A69 <182: 12 /,- 2-D/ :6> ;132025 ,-3-<13-0/09/,-712/-2/0121</,-.319-78/012/,6//,- 67789-:09/,-68/,131</,-730;- ) /0943185,//1/,-21/07-1</,-183//,6//,- 0270:-2/ ,6: 177833-: 12 /,- 02/-3@-2025 205,/ 1< %& % "!!%!& ,- 67789-: A69 6..3-,-2:-: 12 ""%)!%! /099/6/-:/,6/020/06==>/,-43602;6..025 A69:12-4>/,-2@-9/056/025 <<07-3A0/,/,-.-3;099012 - 5 - 1< /,- =-632-: 6509/36/- 12 /,3-- :0<<-3-2/ 989.-7/9 027=8:025 /,- .-/0/012-3 ,- 1.02012 -D.3-99-: 4> /,- -D.-3/09/,6//,-626=>90962:-@6=86/0121</,-1=> 36; 3-@-6=-:21905291<:-7-./01212/,-0998-93-=6/-:/1/,- 730;- 82:-3 02@-9/056/012 A,07, 02:076/-9 /,- .-/0/012-3 A69 21/ :-7-./0@- <13 /,- 3-=-@62/ F8-9/0129 69?-: /1 /,-; G / 09 9/6/-: /,6/ 65602 /,- 43602 ;6..025 <13 /,-.-/0/012-3A69:12-6=125A0/,/A11/,-3989.-7/94> /,- 2@-9/056/025 <<07-3 12 %%)!%! 62: 69 .-3 /,- 1.02012 1< /,- -D.-3/ /,- .-/0/012-3 ,69 82-63/,-: /,- 0270:-2//,6//,-:-7-69-:,6:3-/832-:/1,189-6/ % 62: ,- -2F803-: ,-3 6418/ ,-3 A,-3-6418/9 /,-3- A69 ,-6/-: -D7,625- 1< A13:9 4-/A--2 ,89462: 62: A0<- A,07,=-:/,-.-/0/012-3/19;1/,-3,-3A0/,6.0==1A62: =6/-3A36..025/,-:-6:41:>0264=62?-/62:,0:0250/02 67626=,-3-6</-3,-3-/832-:/1/,-,189-696213;6= .-3912/09/,-3-<13-/,-712/-2/0121</,-.319-78/012 /,6//,-.-/0/012-309/,-68/,131</,-730;- - 6 - 9.-3/,-769-;6:-4>/,-.319-78/012/,-3- 63-21->-A0/2-99-9/1/,-0270:-2/D7-.//,-.0==1A960: /1 4- <182: 2-63 /,- 489, 21 1/,-3 02730;026/025 ;6/-306=9 63- 9-0H-: 6/ /,- 029/627- 1< /,- .-/0/012-3 319-78/012 70/-: 69 ;62> 69 A0/2-99-9 ,- 19/ 13/-;-.13/9,1A9/,-7689-1<:-6/,:8-/169.,>D06 :8- /1 9;1/,-3025 ,- 9-712: 43602 ;6..025 A69 :12- 12 %%)!%! 6</-3 /,- .319-78/012 <60=-: 02 /,- <039/43602;6..025/-9//,6/A69:12-12!%"!%! 6</-3 /,- .319-78/012 <60=-: 02 /,- <039/43602;6..025/-9//,6/A69:12-12!%"!%! / 09 12=> /,-3-6</-3 /,- .-/0/012-3 A69 633-9/-: 12 ""%)!%! ' 027- /,-3- 63- 21 ->-A0/2-99-9 /1 /,- 0270:-2/21362>1/,-302730;026/025;6/-306=96@60=64=-12 3-713: -D7-./ 43602 ;6..025 /-9/ 3-.13/ 4> /,- -D.-3/9 /,-3-09217,627-1</6;.-3025A0/,62>1</,-A0/2-99-9 ,-.319-78/012762@-3>A-==6::87--@0:-27-0298..13/ 1<0/9712/-2/0124>-D6;02025/,-1<<0706=A0/2-9962:6=91 70378;9/62/06=A0/2-99-92:-3987,70378;9/627-96; 1< /,- 1.02012 /,6/ /,- .-/0/012-3 09 21/ 3-F803-: /1 4- - 7 - :-/602-: 02 789/1:> <13 62> .83.19- 7713:025=> 629A-3/,-641@-.102/02/,-6<<03;6/0@-62:.317--:/1 .699/,-<1==1A025 0 ,-.-/0/01209 00 ,-.-/0/012-30913:-3-:/14--2=635-:12460= 02 30;- 1"&% !%!& 1< 8269650 1=07- /6/012 12 14/602025/,-412:02698;1<9!%%%%% 8.--9A1 6?,9 12=> A0/, /A1 983-/0-9 <13 /,- =0?-98; /1 /,- 96/09<67/012 1< /,- I8309:07/0126= 183/ 984I-7/ /1 /,- <1==1A025712:0/0129 6 ,- .-/0/012-3 9,6== 21/ 71;;0/ 62> 90;0=631<<-27-A,0=-12460= 4 ,- .-/0/012-3 9,6== 21/ /,3-6/-2 13 /6;.-3A0/,/,-.319-78/012A0/2-99-9 7 ,- .-/0/012-3 9,6== 6..-63 4-<13- /,- 183/6962:A,-23-F803-: - 8 - < 02 769- /,- .-/0/012-3 @01=6/-9 62> 1< /,- 712:0/0129 69 9/6/-: 641@- /,- .319-78/012 A0== 4- 6/ =04-3/>/1;1@-/,-306=183/9--?0257627-==6/0121<460= 2<83209,025/,-983-/0-94>/,-.-/0/012-3/,-306= 183/ 09 6/ =04-3/> /1 :03-7/ /,- 2@-9/056/025 <<07-3 /1 @-30<> /,- 7133-7/2-99 1< /,- 6::3-99 62: 68/,-2/070/> 1< /,-:178;-2/9<83209,-:4>/,-.-/0/012-362:/,-983-/0-9 62:63-.13/;6>4-76==-:<1302/,6/3-563:A,07,09/1 4- 984;0//-: 4> /,- 2@-9/056/025 <<07-3 A0/,02 :6>9 ,-306=183/1296/09<67/012;6>.317--:/1677-.//,- 983-/0-9<13/,-.83.19-1<3-=-69025/,-.-/0/012-312460= ,* &"") % 09/1"=1""