- 1 - !" # $!%!&!! !!&& '() *+ !!&& '() !!% '() * + !" ! # $%&%' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ! ! # $%&%)'( * &'"('+ ( ,) +&& '"'(('+ ('(('+ ((,('% * + !% ! - 3 - # $%&%' ( ! ! # $%&%)'( * &'"('+ ( ,) +&& '"'(('+ ('(('+ '('- !!% * + !%' ! # - 4 - $%&%'( ( ! ! # $%&%'( * )'(('(% ( -(( +'& ,-'''$ . (/ $ '('- '"'(('+ ! ! 0 - 5 - % ! 0 12341 516 785569 :; <:;56= >29 8=7:;;:2? @:51 516 A2?;6?5 2> <689?6= A23?;6< >29 516 B895:6; :5 :; 58C6? 3B >29>:?8<=:;B2;8< ( 16 9:D3?8< B8;;6= 8 A2772? 29=69 :? 2;((,('% 8?= '('- 2(''+-+('% :; >:<6= DE 516 8?= 92D 2('''"'('+ :; >:<6= DE 516 A<8:78?5 848:?;5 516 F3=476?5 8?= 8@89= =856='"'(('+B8;;6=DE516==:5:2?8<6?:29 :G:< 3=46 8?= 8<8D3984: :? 2' 2> ('- @16968; 2(''+-&('+ :; >:<6= DE 516 848:?;5516F3=476?58?=8@89=:? 2((,('% )16A92;;2DF6A529:? 92D 2('''"'('+$ A<8:78?5 ;5856= 5185 ;16 @8; 8 A22<:6 8?= @8; 689?:?4 ;+'''$ B69 72?51* 516 8AA:=6?5 2AA3996= :? 516 E689 (') D35 516 9:D3?8< 18; 58C6? 169 :?A276 2?<E 85 ;"'''$ B69 72?51* ;16 @8; 846= -% E689; 8?= ;16 - 6 - 8<;296H3:96>3539676=:A8<6IB6?;6;2>;'()''$8?= 516:?5696;5:;52D66?18?A6=52(/ - 689?6= A23?;6< >29 516 8BB6<<8?5 :? 2(''+-+('+ $ 29B2985:2? ;5856= 5185 516 2A529 8;;6;;6= 516 =:;8D:<:5E 85 )(&+/ ; 516 A<8:78?5 <2;5 >23956651516=:;8D:<:5E8;;6;;6=DE5162A529:;2?516 1:4169;:=616<2;;2>56651@:<<?25A83;68?E1:?=98?A6 :? @29C:?4 D35 516 9:D3?8< 18; @92?4<E A2?;:=696= 516 =:;8D:<:5E 85 / 1696>296 96H36;56= 52 ;65 8;:=6 516 ;8:=F3=476?5 % 689=516894376?5;2>D251;:=6; " * ;B69516@23?=A695:>:A856516A<8:78?5;3;58:?6= G3<;:2? 2> )( 8?=- 8?= 8D98;:2? )I( A7 J A1:?16 6I87:?6= 516 =2A529 8?= 16 ;5856= 5185 516 :?F39E ;3;58:?6= DE 516 A<8:78?5 :; 49:6G23; :? ?85396 8?= ;16 18;8?=:D3<89=6G:85:2?@1:<62B6?:?48?=A<2;:?42>F8@ 7:;;:?4 2> ) )( - -( 56651 B<8436 8?= A8<A3<3; - 7 - 7:<= 4:?4:G8< :?><87785:2? 8?= 6?<894676?5 51696 @8; 56?=69?6;; 2> D251 9:415 8?= <6>5 8?= 513; 16 8;;6;;6=516=:;8D:<:5E85)(&+/689?6=A23?;6<>29516 29B2985:2? 78:?<E A2?56?=6= 5185 516 <2;; 2> 56651 @:<< ?25:?569>696@:51169@29C358=7:556=<E;16;3;58:?6= <2;; 2> 56651 8?= 516 =:;8D:<:5E 8;;6;;6= DE 516 =2A529 :; )(&+/169:D3?8<18;9:415<E58C6?)9=2>516;876 8; / 1:; 2395 >:?=; ?2 968;2? 52 :?569>696 @:51 516 =:;8D:<:5E8;;6;;6=DE5169:D3?8< , 16 A<8:78?5 765 @:51 8? 8AA:=6?5 2? ('(')12341A<8:78?5;5856=5185;16@8;689?:?4 ;+'''$ B69 72?51 ;16 >8:<6= 52 B92G6 169 :?A276 6?A68;B6951643:=6<:?6;2>51689?858C85856648< 69G:A6; 35129:5E 51:; 2395 >:?=; :5 968;2?8D<6 52 58C6 169:?A27685;,'''$B6972?511673<5:B<:692>- 8=2B56=DE5169:D3?8<:;F3;58?=B92B69 13;516<2;;2>>35396:?A276A276;52;,'''I (I-I/K;(+)"'$ - 8 - & 9:D3?8< 18; 8@89=6= 8 ;37 2> ;(%'''$ 52@89=; B8:? 8?= ;3>>69:?4 8?= ;%'''$ 52@89=; <2;; 2>876?:5:6;1:; 2395>:?=;?2968;2?52:?569>696@:51 516;876 + 395169 51:; 2395 >:?=; :5 968;2?8D<6 52 498?5 8? 8723?5 2> ;%'''$ >29 598?;B29585:2? 6I598 ?239:;176?58?=8556?=8?5A18946; ' 6?A6516A<8:78?5:;6?5:5<6=>2951672=:>:6= A27B6?;85:2?3?=69=:>>696?5168=;8;D6<2@! 8:?8?=;3>>69:?4 ;(%'''$ 2;;2>>35396:?A276 ;(+)"'$ 98?;B29585:2? 6I598 ?239:;176?5 8?=8556?=8?5A18946; ;%'''$ 2;;2>876?:5:6; ;%'''$ 258< 6;;!8@89=6=DE9:D3?8< ?18?A676?5 ;&-)"'$ ;%'''$ ,--- $ 13; 516 8BB6<<8?5 :; 6?5:5<6= >29 6?18?A6= A27B6?;85:2? 2> ;)))"'$ @:51 :?5696;5 85 "/ B69 8??37 8?= 51696>296516 A92;; 2DF6A5:2? =6;69G6; 52 D6 8<<2@6=:?B895 - 9 - * ? G:6@ 2> 6?18?A676?5 78=6 :? 92D 2('''"'('+51:;8BB68<=6;69G6;52D6=:;7:;;6= ( * 1:; 8BB68< :; >:<6= DE 516 29B2985:2? 848:?;5 516 F3=476?58?=8@89=:? 2((,('%;585:?45185516 A<8:78?5 18; ;3;58:?6= ;:7B<6 :?F39:6; 6 18; ?25 6I87:?6= 516 =2A529 8?= 513; 8;;6;;:?4 516 =:;8D:<:5E =26;?2589:;6 ) 2?;:=69:?4516?853962>:?F39:6;5169:D3?8< 18;498?56=B92B69A27B6?;85:2?2>;)''''$8?=51:; 2395=26;?25>:?=8?E968;2?52:?569>696@:51516;876 6?A65168BB68<=6;69G6;52D6=:;7:;;6= - ?51696;3<5516>2<<2@:?429=69:;B8;;6=! : 92D 2('''"'('+>:<6=DE516A<8:78?5 :; 8<<2@6= :? B895 16 A92;; 2DF6A529$A<8:78?5 :; 6?5:5<6= >296?18?A6=A27B6?;85:2?2>;)))"'$@:51:?5696;585 "/ B69 8??37 >927 516 =856 2> B65:5:2? 5:<< 516 =856 2> - 10 - 968<:;85:2? 2@6G69 8; B69 516 29=69; 2? ('( =856= )'(('(% 516 A92;; 2DF6A529 :; ?25 6?5:5<6= >29 :?5696;5 >29 516 =6<8E6= B69:2= 2> -, =8E; :? >:<:?4 516 A92;;2DF6A5:2? :: 2?;6H36?5<E 2(''+-+('+ >:<6= DE 516 29B2985:2? =:;B35:?4 516 H38?537 :; 1696DE =:;7:;;6= ::: 16 8BB6<<8?5$ 29B2985:2? :? 2(''+-+('+ :; =:96A56= 52 =6B2;:5 516 6?18?A6= A27B6?;85:2? 2> ;)))"'$ 8<2?4 @:51 :?5696;5 @:51:? 2?672?51>927516=8562>51:;F3=476?5 :G ?;3A1=6B2;:5516A92;;2DF6A529:;B697:556= 52@:51=98@5166?5:968723?58<2?4@:51:?5696;58AA936= 2?:5 G 2(''+-&('+>:<6=DE516 29B2985:2?:; 8<;2=:;7:;;6= ,.* '&!! ) % :;5 2!< 2!)(