Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43592 (KAR)

VAISHALI BABSHETTE v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/201606/2025 · 2025-11-25

Sachin Shankar Magadum

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# $"%"" " &' &() &(( * !" # $ % &'' ( &'' '!" ' ( '(' & !" # $)( & * (( & % Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( & ! & $ % ! & $ % + " &" &) )(& & ( " " & ( & && ,!$% " " & ( & ( ( - () '(( $ - () '((% ./012345 /4010123 16 78 .99:645 2 61604;13<.= 644>13?@:.6A13?2B/;2944513?6132" ".;1613? 2:0 2B ;1C4 2" " 2B 15.; 2C43 2<194 0.0123 16015.;B2;0A42BB43946/:316A.7<4:354;4901236,! " " ;4.5 =10A 490123 2B 351.3 43.< 254!"/43513?230A4B1<42B55<1D1<):5?4.35 )(&15.; A4 ?160 2B 0A4 =;10043 92C/<.130 <25?45 78 ;46/2354302=A2160A45.:?A04;13<.=.?.1360A4; A:67.35 A4; 13<.=6 .35 0A4 /;46430 /40101234; 16 0A.0 - 3 - .B04; A4; C.;;1.?4 23 """ 6A4 =.6 <22>45 .B04; 23<8B2;.7;14B/4;125.3592:<5<4.5./4.94B:<C.;10.<<1B4 C4;4<8 B2; .72:0 0=2 84.;6 A4;4.B04; .992;513? 02 ;46/2354302A4;A:67.35.3513<.=674?.3.7:613? A4; B;4@:430<8 0.:3013? A4; 23 0A4 ?;2:35 0A.0 6A4 =.6 ;4/4.045<8 B.<<13? 1<< .35 6:7E49045 A4; 02 923013:2:6 A.;.66C430 .35 02;0:;4 A4 A.6 B:;0A4; .<<4?45 0A.0 546/1040A41304;D4301232BA4;C20A4;0A41<<0;4.0C43078 A4;A:67.35.3513<.=6923013:45.350A.00A48.7:645 A4; 13 B1<0A8 <.3?:.?4 A4 /;46430 /40101234; =A2 16 .;;.845 .6 .99:645 2 .35 16 0A4 C.;;145 61604;13<.= 2B ;46/235430 2 A.6 .<62 7443 1C/<19.045 B2; 0A4 .<<4?45 2BB43946 /:316A.7<4 :354; 4901236 ,! "";4.5=10A4901232B0A4351.3 43.<254 4.;34592:364<B2;0A4/40101234;5;.=13?0A4 2:;0F6 .0043012302 0A4 9A.;?46A440 C.04;1.<6 92304356 0A.00A4/40101234;16.C.;;14561604;13<.=;461513?13A4; 2=3 C.0;1C231.< A2C4 .35 5246 320 6A.;4 . 92CC23 A2:64A2<5 =10A ;46/235430 2 3 0A4 .764394 2B .38 - 4 - /;1C. B.914 C.04;1.< .00;17:013? 6/491B19 2D4;0 .906 02 0A4 /40101234; 10 16 .;?:45 0A.0 923013:.0123 2B 9;1C13.< /;2944513?6 =2:<5 .C2:30 02 .3 .7:64 2B /;29466 4B4;;13? 02 0A4 92C/<.130 .D4;C4306 <4.;345 92:364< 6:7C106 0A.0 0A4 .<<4?.01236 .?.1360 0A4 /40101234; .;4 D.?:4 6=44/13? .35 2C317:6 13 3.0:;4 54D215 2B .38 /.;019:<.;6 ;4?.;513? .906 9236010:013? 9;:4<08 A4;4B2;4 13 0A41304;460 2BE:60194 <4.;345 92:364<644>6 @:.6A13? 2B/;2944513?61362B.;.60A4/40101234;1692394;345 4; 9230;. <4.;345 1?A 2:;0 2D4;3C430 <4.54; 6:7C106 0A.0 0A4 C.04;1.<6 /<.945 78 0A4 3D4601?.013? BB194;5169<2646:BB191430?;2:35602/;29445 .?.1360 0A4 /40101234; A4;413 .35 0A.0 0A16 16 320 . 9.64 =A4;4 0A4 4G0;.2;513.;8 E:;165190123 2B 0A16 2:;0 :354; 490123 ! 2B 0A4 A.;.018. .?.;1> :;.>6A. .3A10. "2:?A0027413D2>4502@:.6A0A4/;2944513?6.00A4 0A;46A2<5 4.;345 92:364< .//4.;13? B2; ;46/235430 2 92C/<.13.30A.6.;?:45130A46.C4D4134B4;;13? - 5 - 02 0A4 60.04C4306 ;492;545 78 0A4 3D4601?.013? BB194; 6A4 92304356 0A.0 0A4;4 16 .54@:.04 C.04;1.< 02 /;29445 4D43.?.13600A4/40101234; 61604;13<.=.350A4;4B2;40A4 /;46430/40101235246320C4;109236154;.0123 A162:;0 A.69.;4B:<<8 A4.;50A46:7C1661236 2B 0A4 <4.;345 92:364< .//4.;13? B2; .<< /.;0146 .35 A.6 C4019:<2:6<8 4G.C1345 0A4 92C/<.130 9A.;?46A440 .35 0A4.992C/.3813?C.04;1.< <0A2:?A 0A4 92C/<.130 9230.136 . /.6613? ;4B4;4394 .<<4?13? 0A.0 0A4 /40101234; .<62 1<<0;4.045 ;46/23543026:9A.<<4?.01236.;43410A4;6/491B1932; 6://2;045 78 /;49164 1360.3946 2B 9;:4<08 .00;17:0.7<4 02 0A4 /40101234; A4 04;C H;4<.01D4 2B 0A4 A:67.35I 299:;;13?13490123,!2B0A4 16:352:7045<87;2.5 .35 139<:546 0A4 /40101234; 2=4D4; 0A4 C4;4 B.90 0A.0 0A4 /40101234; 16 0A4 61604; 2B .99:645 2 9.3320 78 1064<B B:;316A . 6:BB191430 7.616 02 /;2649:04 A4; B2; 0A4 2BB43942B9;:4<08:354;490123,!A162:;0A.623 64D4;.< 299.61236 4392:304;45 9.646 =A4;413 - 6 - 92C/<.13.306 =A1<4 3.;;.013? C.;10.< 51692;5 0435 02 4G.??4;.04.35135169;1C13.04<81C/<19.0464D4;.<;4<.01D46 2B 0A4 A:67.35 (4;4 7.<5 2C317:6 .<<4?.01236 .?.1360 ;4<.01D46 9.3320 E:601B8 6:7E49013? 0A4C 02 9;1C13.< /;2649:0123:3<466./;1C.B.9149.64B2:3545236/491B19 C.04;1.<1654C2360;.045 ! 30A4/;464309.640A4/40101234;16.C.;;145 61604;13<.= =A2 .5C10045<8 ;461546 13 A4; 2=3 C.0;1C231.< A2C4 3 0A16 7.9>5;2/ 10 7492C46 /.;019:<.;<8 349466.;8 02 69;:013164 0A4 9A.;?46A440 C.04;1.<02.694;0.13=A40A4;.3813?;4514302B0A42BB4394 :354; 490123 ,! 16 C.54 2:0 .?.1360 A4; A2:?A 9;:4<08 C.8 74 /A8619.< 2; C430.< 0A4 B.90 0A.0 0A4 /40101234; ;461546 64/.;.04<8 .35 5246 320 6A.;4 . 92CC23 A2:64A2<5 =10A ;46/235430 2 C.>46 10 <466 /;27.7<4 0A.0 6A4 92:<5 A.D4 6:7E49045 ;46/235430 2 020A4>1352B=1<<B:<9235:9092304C/<.045:354;490123 ,!2B A44G/;466123H=1<<B:<9235:90I349466.;1<8 1C/<146 54<174;.04 276013.04 74A.D12:; 9.:613? 9;:4<08 - 7 - .35 0A4;4B2;4 1392;/2;.046 C436 ;4. .6 .3 4664301.< 92C/23430 3<466 0A4 92C/<.130 2; 0A4 9A.;?46A440 5169<26466/491B19.906C.31B46013?6:9A130430123.<9;:4<08 ;4<.01D469.332074C49A.319.<<86:7E4904502/;2649:0123 , .D13? 4G.C1345 0A4 C.04;1.<6 23 ;492;5 =10A 0A4 .72D4 /;1391/<46 13 C135 0A16 2:;0 B1356 0A.0 ./.;0 B;2C 0A4 ?434;.< 2C317:6 .<<4?.0123 ;4B4;;45 02 4.;<14; 0A4;416326:760.301D4C.04;1.<13519.013?0A4/40101234;F6 13D2<D4C430 13 .38 .90 2B 9;:4<080 16.<62 61?31B19.30 02 3204 0A.0 135169;1C13.04<8 6:7E49013? . C.;;145 =2C.3 <1D13? 13 A4; 2=3 C.0;1C231.< A2C4 02 . <23?5;.=3 9;1C13.< 0;1.< =10A2:0 .54@:.04 C.04;1.< ;46:<06 13 3445<466A.;.66C430.35A:C1<1.0123.0A4;C.;10.<A2C4 =A19A .66:C4 /.;019:<.; 6436101D108 13 0A4 92304G0 2B 0A4 351.3 6291.< B.7;19 A4 /;2649:0123 2B 0A4 /40101234; 7.645236:9A;4C204.35:36:760.301.045.<<4?.0123613 0A4 9236154;45 2/13123 2B 0A16 2:;0 .C2:306 02 . 9<4.; .7:64 2B <4?.< /;29466 A4 ;492;5 5169<2646 0A.0 ;46/235430 2 A.6 :3B2;0:3.04<8 1C/<19.045 0A4 - 8 - /40101234; 546/104 0A4 <.004; 320 ;461513? :354; 0A4 6.C4 ;22B 2; A.D13? .38 /;2G1C108 43.7<13? 92CC166123 2B 0A4 .<<4?45.906 " A4 23F7<4 :/;4C4 2:;0 13 . 9.043. 2B 549161236 A.6 ;4/4.045<8 9.:012345 0A.0 ;4<.01D46 2B 0A4 A:67.356A2:<532074.;;.845.6.99:645230A460;43?0A 2B 2C317:6 .<<4?.01236 :3<466 6/491B19 2D4;0 .906 9236010:013? 0A4 2BB4394 .;4 9<4.;<8 C.54 2:0 //<813? 0A464=4<<6400<45/;1391/<46020A4/;464309.640A162:;0 16 6.016B145 0A.0 0A4 C.04;1.< 23 ;492;5 5246 320 =.;;.30 923013:.0123 2B /;2944513?6 .?.1360 0A4 /40101234; 992;513?<802/;4D430.7:642B/;29466.3502649:;40A4 43562BE:601940A162:;016139<1345024G4;916413A4;430 E:;165190123 :354; 490123 ! 2B 0A4 A.;.018. .?.;1> :;.>6A..3A10." &2; 0A4 B2;4?213? ;4.6236 0A4 B2<<2=13? 2;54; 16/.6645 - 9 - 1A4/401012316 11 A4 /43513? /;2944513?6 13 2" " .;1613? 2:0 2B ;1C4 2" " 2B 15.; 2C43 2<194 0.0123 160;190 15.; B2; 0A4 2BB43946 /:316A.7<4 :354; 4901236,!"";4.5=10A4901232B0A4 /43513? 74B2;4 0A4 2:;0 2B 0A4 5510123.< 1D1< ):5?4 .35 )(& 15.; .;4A4;478 @:.6A45 1362B.; .6 0A4/40101234;1692394;345 +) &""( % )